Response to "IfYourMomWereATaco" more than 33,400 listeners have hear this Marian Anderson performance of "Standchen" but only about 6200 have heard her rendition of "Gretchen am Spinnrade" which they would enjoy - she is accompanied by Franz Rupp who helped her with German pronunciation
Responding to "If your mom were a Taco" you are correct that "Gretchen" is one of Schubert's most famous songs, but not everyone has heard Marian Anderson perform it with Franz Rupp at piano.
Do NOT bother. The very real problems that beset that once fine country is due to the policies which those particular Americans have forced upon this once peaceful and prosperous nation. I refer of course to the very right wing groups and their policies that prevent the best governance and the best performance of the economy. I speak as an American observer and a Liberal Democrat of many years,
Marian Anderson's piano accompanist is Franz Rupp 1901-1992 a Jewish refugee from Nazi Germany who made recordings with violinist Fritz Kreisler 1930s + became Marian Anderson's accompanist 1940 - 1965. He also did a great deal to teach her Schubert songs + the German language + for many years was associated with Curtis Institute of Philadelphia.
If you like this Marian Anderson Schubert performance (as I do) hear her also in the less well-known Gretchen Am Spinnrade -Gretchen at the spinning wheel' based on Goethe's Faust. The "Gretchen' has a remarkable piano accompaniment that mimics the sound of a spinning wheel- one of Schubert's first published works from about 1811 age eleven.
Her enunciation is better than any opera singer I have ever heard, including all the famous greats that spring to mind when you think of opera, male and female.
I had an old Victor LM 98 with Marian Anderson in the 1950s with performances of the Rellstab-Schubert "Standchen" and the Ave Maria based on Walter Scott. These remain my favorites of all Schubert.s great 800 songs
and all classical music. Even Fritz Wunderlich can't match Marian Anderson, and incredible voice and human being, of whom America must always be proud.
Of course you are correct, but the gesture is not without meaning. Australian Prime Minister Kevin Rudd recently apologized for past government's maltreatment of the Aborigines. An apology implies a promise not to sin again.
@zeissghost Do NOT bother. The very real problems that beset that once fine country is due to the policies which those particular Americans have forced upon this once peaceful and prosperous nation. I refer of course to the very right wing groups and their policies that prevent the best governance and the best performance of the economy. I speak as an American observer and a Liberal Democrat of many years,
@zeissghost Do NOT bother. The very real problems that beset that once fine country is due to the policies which those particular Americans have forced upon this once peaceful and prosperous nation. I refer of course to the very right wing groups and their policies that prevent the best governance and the best performance of the economy. I speak as an American observer and a Liberal Democrat of many years,
hearing this makes me think why those white supremacists back then barred her performance due to her race...i mean seriously, had we not find ways to keep record of this awesome performance, we would've missed out on A LOT
My vocal teacher was telling me that this is a song only for male voices and in no case i should never try to sing it ...but i did not obey to his instructions !
How can someone , a woman in our case , ignore the marvellous Standchen of Shubert ? to tell you the truth i take some courage after having listened to this recording ..........
The teacher is a pumpkinhead. Is it a man or a woman? Male idiotic chauvinists abide in "cultural circles"' but there are some foolish women who go blindly after what they were taught by males.
Simply greate
bobon47 3 weeks ago
uberirdisch
dohoang1 1 year ago
so so wonderful, maravilloso, me conmovio profundamente
r7diego 1 year ago 2
Much better than the deutsche,,, somehow sharp and oma
malaisennui 1 year ago
Response to "IfYourMomWereATaco" more than 33,400 listeners have hear this Marian Anderson performance of "Standchen" but only about 6200 have heard her rendition of "Gretchen am Spinnrade" which they would enjoy - she is accompanied by Franz Rupp who helped her with German pronunciation
Lactoris1 1 year ago
Responding to "If your mom were a Taco" you are correct that "Gretchen" is one of Schubert's most famous songs, but not everyone has heard Marian Anderson perform it with Franz Rupp at piano.
Lactoris1 1 year ago
Do NOT bother. The very real problems that beset that once fine country is due to the policies which those particular Americans have forced upon this once peaceful and prosperous nation. I refer of course to the very right wing groups and their policies that prevent the best governance and the best performance of the economy. I speak as an American observer and a Liberal Democrat of many years,
Aled
ifuliki 1 year ago
In C minor.
norisv 1 year ago
beautiful
ladylegolaska 1 year ago
Marian Anderson's piano accompanist is Franz Rupp 1901-1992 a Jewish refugee from Nazi Germany who made recordings with violinist Fritz Kreisler 1930s + became Marian Anderson's accompanist 1940 - 1965. He also did a great deal to teach her Schubert songs + the German language + for many years was associated with Curtis Institute of Philadelphia.
Lactoris1 1 year ago 4
A goddess. What a marvelous human being, and phenomenal singer. God bless her.
chiaromezzo 1 year ago 3
If you like this Marian Anderson Schubert performance (as I do) hear her also in the less well-known Gretchen Am Spinnrade -Gretchen at the spinning wheel' based on Goethe's Faust. The "Gretchen' has a remarkable piano accompaniment that mimics the sound of a spinning wheel- one of Schubert's first published works from about 1811 age eleven.
Lactoris1 1 year ago
@Lactoris1 I'm not sure where you've been, but Gretchen is one Schubert's most famous songs....
IfYourMomWereATaco 1 year ago
Great, is`nt she?
bobon47 1 year ago
Her enunciation is better than any opera singer I have ever heard, including all the famous greats that spring to mind when you think of opera, male and female.
SoCerebral 1 year ago
Who is the pianist, and what model piano?
Lactoris1 1 year ago
There is a legend that when Roosevelt addressed the DAR, he began: Fellow Immigrants. I love hearing Marian Anderson here!
SSKUTLER 1 year ago
I had an old Victor LM 98 with Marian Anderson in the 1950s with performances of the Rellstab-Schubert "Standchen" and the Ave Maria based on Walter Scott. These remain my favorites of all Schubert.s great 800 songs
and all classical music. Even Fritz Wunderlich can't match Marian Anderson, and incredible voice and human being, of whom America must always be proud.
Lactoris1 1 year ago
A little gem. Thank you.
soyouneedausername 2 years ago
Danke!
austria4you 2 years ago
Every single syllable is a revelation compared to the renditions of some German speaking singers.
This lady's singing is impeccable.
Thank you for posting!
preruminator 2 years ago 5
I am curious -- have the Daughters of the American Revolution ever apologized to Ms Anderson?
lskarin 2 years ago 3
probably not, I'm not too sure though
JadeWeapon 2 years ago
How does one 'apologize' for ignorance, intolerance and racist behavior?
zeissghost 2 years ago 7
Of course you are correct, but the gesture is not without meaning. Australian Prime Minister Kevin Rudd recently apologized for past government's maltreatment of the Aborigines. An apology implies a promise not to sin again.
lskarin 2 years ago
@zeissghost Do NOT bother. The very real problems that beset that once fine country is due to the policies which those particular Americans have forced upon this once peaceful and prosperous nation. I refer of course to the very right wing groups and their policies that prevent the best governance and the best performance of the economy. I speak as an American observer and a Liberal Democrat of many years,
Aled
ifuliki 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@zeissghost Do NOT bother. The very real problems that beset that once fine country is due to the policies which those particular Americans have forced upon this once peaceful and prosperous nation. I refer of course to the very right wing groups and their policies that prevent the best governance and the best performance of the economy. I speak as an American observer and a Liberal Democrat of many years,
Aled
ifuliki 1 year ago
Ms. Anderson finally sang in Constitution Hall at the invitation of an apologetic and more enlightened DAR in 1943.
eyesk8er 2 years ago
Having been given this song to learn, the way that she is so distinct in pronunciation is just amazing. What a professional.
Amiduffer 2 years ago
Absolutely beautiful...
Lovely legato, diction...(although I don't speak German...she's sings so clearly).
Love it...thanks for uploading...where can I get this recording? Can someone tell me please? :)
JenzoCL 2 years ago 3
Her diction is marvellous!
AccidentalTouch 2 years ago
hearing this makes me think why those white supremacists back then barred her performance due to her race...i mean seriously, had we not find ways to keep record of this awesome performance, we would've missed out on A LOT
qzstuffs 3 years ago 2
What a beautiful performance. Who is the pianist? Thanks!
dorabella78 3 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
for get that teacher I am a soprano have sung this many times and gotten amazing compliments.
eze102 3 years ago
Un peu plat, le piano...
Emlomor 3 years ago
This is one of the most elevated and insightful renditions of this sacred lied we have - and there is a lot of competition out there!
Thank you for sharing this.
Adding the text gives you a chance to see how tuned in she was to the poetry.
Absolutely beautiful.
jkircher314 3 years ago 2
Beautiful! A beautiful performance from a beautiful soul.
jimthewriter 3 years ago 2
My vocal teacher was telling me that this is a song only for male voices and in no case i should never try to sing it ...but i did not obey to his instructions !
How can someone , a woman in our case , ignore the marvellous Standchen of Shubert ? to tell you the truth i take some courage after having listened to this recording ..........
Phaidra69 3 years ago 3
The teacher is a pumpkinhead. Is it a man or a woman? Male idiotic chauvinists abide in "cultural circles"' but there are some foolish women who go blindly after what they were taught by males.
Nogah100 3 years ago 2
yeah, me 2!
stirnerin 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
I love it!! But I prefer the version without singing...
LuckyLeny92 3 years ago
WOW!
dozenbeer 3 years ago 3
awsomeeeee!!!!!!
141407078989 3 years ago 4
Blameless and open-hearted interpretation. Much obliged.
bobon47 3 years ago 10