Added: 3 years ago
From: rumpel287
Views: 57,465
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (209)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • Fantastic Animation, I'm guessinf the yellow lights are Ancient engergy weapons rather than drones. Plus the Aurora class needs to put more money in their shield meter :o)

  • It's cool, but no way we take out an Ancient ship with only rail guns. With a shield up. The amount of drones fired would have destroyed both ships in a minute.

  • This representation is flawed in so many ways... Railguns would never deal with Ancient shields, no effin' way; drones are not "balls", adding some sort of tail to one model and copy+pasting it shouldn't have been a problem; drones fire from a single point on the ship, not from random points on the hull; Ancient battleships were never that bright, another easy-to-do thing you didn't bother to do.

  • were are the beam weapons

  • also y weren't there beam weaponds

  • well who won ?? the rail guns of the Daedalus would not have been stopped by the enemy ( replicator ) shields.. shields are for energy weapons only...but not even with the new Asgard shields and the McKay modification to them would they have stood up to that many drones if they would have even stopped the drones since they are not energy weapons but physical missiles

  • Well Asgards gave their shields first,then at the end they gave the tau'ri weapon tech.

  • set aside the fictional discussion of who would win, the Aurora tactics are all wrong, you do not divide your fire , you concentrate it on one target. Also the Aurora should rotate on its axis to bring more of its turrets to have a clear shot at its target..

  • how did you get the shield effect :o

  • @Johnthepredalien That's actually an easy effect. Just create a sphere, and adjust the shape of it, to encapsulate the 3D model. Set it as transparent, give it a texture, then insert a light at the weapon impact point. After that, it's just scripting the light source to turn on, when you want it to. Takes all of 20 minutes to do, from scratch.

  • Aurora Class drone's wouldda ripped through both Daedalus'

  • While I appreciate the attempt at some fun battle cgi

    This video makes my inner-nerd fucking rage at inaccuracy

  • The Aurora class warship would massacre both Daedalus class ships. Also, the Asgard shields and no beam weapons? How? Why?

  • WTF, all those drones can penetrate the Daedalus and Apollo's shields... and i don't think that many drones would actually fit on Aurora... I admit the Asgard shields are very very powerful but all those drones?? and how the fuck did the Railguns deplete Auroras shields?? They can't even deplete Ori shields... Where are the asgard beam cannons?!

  • Actually, for all of you who say that Asgard shields cannot withstant a drone bombardment, watch the Asuran plot of Stargate Atlantis, where they fight replicators who were able to mimic ancient technology.

    But, more important: Nice piece of work you got there :D

  • nice animation dude, love the particle effects. did you use any other apps like after effects, cause this look pretty good. :) keep it up

  • @YZProfessional no but i use 3ds max

  • I saw similar battles in X3 :D

  • dude u suck!! it takes only a litle more effort to make it look much better, you lazy bastard

  • @gnight51

    do you enjoy criticizing people for their hard work. if its so easy for you, post some videos let us see your "marvelous" works. if you dont then shut up. it have people out there that will make your animations look like shit. 3D is not something you can learn over night. it takes time. dumb bastard.

  • dude okay, rail guns killing an aurora class ancient ship? tari shields holding up against drones!? idk which one is more ridiculously retarded! semi good animation tho...

  • @Xivionv3

    Tauri shields were made by the asgard who were also around during the time of the ancients. That means that the asgard have had 10000 years to make better shields, we never actually saw asgard shields up against drones at any point during the series.

  • @rkb53 while this is true the tauri asgard hybrid sheild are most defnitly not as strong therefore the lieklyness of them holding up against drones for that long and little turrets killing an ancient ship, ancient sheilds are near imentrable from waht i gatherd from all the shows as long as u have power the sheild stays up, asgard sheild do die off even if they have power, the asgard had better hyperdrives. besides they were in a replicator war for most of those 1000 years.

  • Comment removed

  • @Xivionv3 touché, well played.

  • @rkb53 yes it was in may my sins be remembered

  • Comment removed

  • lol, reason for drones is because they slip through shields. Ever see a drone stop on a shield?

    Also, Rail guns are like trying to throw pebbles through a brick wall, doesn't matter what kind of shield you have.

  • the aroras shields arent redy bicose it came from hyperspace and get atacket raigth after

  • asgard shield connat support lot of drone it s imposible

    and machin gun cannot destruct Aurore class his shield is too

    puissant

  • He must have been thinking about Asuran Aurora during the Battle of Asura. Well, sorry to dissapoint you rumpel, lad, but the scene where they took out a few Auroras was only because they caught it with them with shields down. Drones also go through shields like they aren't there. Railguns are also noted to be very weak against shields; which is why they aren't seen using em during the rest of the battle; instead beam weapons were.

  • @masteridiot123 Which makes no sense really. Railguns in Stargate fire many projectiles at very high speed. That should drop the shield very quickly.

  • @masteridiot123 yes indeed, but earth ships were fitted with asgard shields. and drones dont panetrate asgard shields i believe. may be wrong but...

  • @uldos92 Drones can go through Anything. Asgard Shields included. But Asgard Beam technology matches drones if not better. So it'd a evenly played battle.

  • ok failed name cg1 ?? wtf its SG1

  • @hunter4death CGI you goon.

  • hi i just wanted to kno what game you are useing to play this i have been looking all over for 1 like this but never could

  • @suzuka1718 /facepalm its cgi....

  • How do you do this kind of animation?

  • VERY good! The battle itself wouldnt have been the othet way around tho. Realy good work tho

  • cool shield effect :D fucking ey

  • ok now this is cool but could you make a SGU battle that would be freaking awesome!!

  • @Au7stenThe7IsSilent sorry to disappoint you mate, but currently there are no real SGU models available for free...well except for Omnipotent's Destiny. But I don't know if he'll share it.

  • @MrJamesApril no disappoint man idk how it works but there’s a earth ship that was supposed to be in SGU but when Atlantis was canceled by SYFY the SGU story line got modified and the ship got set aside but I have A picture of that ship as my channel background. Check it out and if you want me to send it to you I can. You could make a model of it and use it in a battle or whatever it is you do. Just look and do yr thing man yr good at it. SAVE the stargate Franchise!! Long live the gates.

  • @Au7stenThe7IsSilent well thanks for the confidence but I'm not really good at modelling..could give it a shot tho'...I'll send you contact details via PM

  • the drones are mighter as the railguns of an deadalus class ship :D

  • guys can sb tel me where can i get ship models to that program (i have c4d) and how to create weapons, shields and everything else ? the programme is beyond my possibilities, i cannot understand it without help

  • What the hell? Railguns depleted Aurora Class vessel's shields?

  • @worshippriest its fiction only :) aurora class shield should be strong like a ori ship shield.

  • @worshippriest it makes sense, the Ancients's shields are power by the same source as the drones, so in order to maintain the drones, the shields would be weakened

  • @worshippriest e = mc^2, and m' = m/√(1-v^2/c^3)

    b/c mass equals to soo much energy, it will deplete the shields quickly, and b/c the relativistic mass equation, the high speed projectiles will have more mass

  • @worshippriest Meh, Ancient ships were all sitting more or less dormant for 10 000 years, you'll recall. Maybe the power conduits weren't what they used to be. Or maybe there's a sabateur on board, or they beamed a small explosive into the shield generator room, or beamed the shield generator itself out of the spacecraft. Stargate spacebattles are rarely slugging matches, after all.

  • @worshippriest lol you've never seen the episode of Stargate Atlantis were the railguns were able to nearly cripple a hive ship

  • @worshippriest plus the aurora's rocket's are very powerful, they can easily destroy two deadalus class ship

  • @Molnar1811 The aurora doesn't have rockets dumbass it has DRONES learn your stargate before you TRY to make an intelligent answer

  • @worshippriest it has happend in the show.. the ships name: orion

  • @godisman1234567890 I recall that Hive shot Orion down cause it dinät have shields when orion was shooting drones. It had nothing to do with BC-304 shooting Aurora class ship.

  • @worshippriest Remember Arturus' weapon that was essentially a rail gun that spat out little burst of energy the exact same, but due to the power source the power was dialed up a bit per shot.

  • @worshippriest xd ikr...

  • i made a CGI animation too but i am still working on it becouse its Super hive VS Atlantis

  • @scorp120 could be a replicator.

  • this is fucking awesome! how did you do it?

  • Why are they shooting at each other ? isn't that an alteran ship =p

  • @scorp120 Sorry my bad lantean

  • how long did you spend on this? it's just amazing

  • this is rather well done though the Aurora class warship would have destroyed those BC-304's (unless thay had the beam waepons) the simple rail guns these 304's were shooting would never have broken the shields that quickly or really at all....unless of course that one was armor tanked XD jk

  • whats cgi?

  • @namekman01 CGI - Computer Generated Imagery.

  • @BPrice1A i thought that was the program used

    does that mean c4d is the program?

  • @namekman01 Yes c4d is Cinema 4D. That's the program used.

  • LOL at the end u had one of the f-304's just shooting at nothing lol dont quit ur day job

  • what the ...awesome ! its cinema 4d right ? man i so badly wanna have this too ;(

  • really gr8 video !

  • Wow....awesome :D

    I am going to learn this too :)

    Very very well work

  • great work!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • I only miss the stars,, but for the rest you did a pretty epic job there

  • did you make the render?

  • wow, that's actually REALLY good lol

  • I hear batman...

  • I personally think the animations are very good, the weapons fire could stand to have been smaller for the railguns and faster over all, and the lack of sound took away from the quality a bit, and I noticed the weapons fire passed through the sheilds, not impacted on them. Aside from these small things, it was a great video and the detail on the ships was astounding.

  • Very nicely done.

  • AWESOME job :) Well done :) :)

  • it doesnt look real.. but if you were making an animated show.. this is AMAZING..

  • Too much camera shake

  • Very nice job!, one thing though...drones go though shields...

  • amazing!

  • How did you get the shields to render properly? I've been playing with it for awhile now and I can't seem to get it quite right.

  • Batman movie music? :P

  • just one thing there is no tari symbol on the side that is a common misconception.

  • @webduelist It's not really a Tau'ri symbol, it's the symbol of The Point of Origin. You know, where the stargates use reference to? I think it's Earth..... not sure, but the symbol definitely doesn't represent SGC.

    P.S: Yeah, I don't understand why there is a symbol on the side of the ship anyway, there isn't one in the real show. o.O

  • @jfu12450 ya i know its earths point of origin.

  • that was fricken awesome

  • nearly tv quality? its as good as what scifi was showing

  • OMG! That was freakin AWESOME !!!!!

  • @CrazyBrainDead What program did u make that in ????

  • Damn! How did you do that? I got lucky though, so I can create a stone in the grass :-)

    I really would like to know how to create animations like you ...

  • awsome

    

  • guy..buy some hobbys

  • If the Ancient Battleship is launching drones, the Tau'ri vessels should have been toast in short order. I also don't think railguns would put a dent in Ancient shields. Pretty animation, though.

  • Did you make this?

    

  • If they were real drones, they fracking 304's would be fucked in a matter of seconds lol!

  • @MrGibbsOfficial The Ancient ships are what a thousand + years old. In the last few seasons of SG1, the Ori came along with brand new tech, to rival that of Ancients, if not superior. After the asguard Upgrades from the Legacy episode, the Daedalus would have superior shields, so technically two 304's could handle alot of drones. Compare drones to Ori beams, then look at the final SG1 movie. Daedalus takes at least 10-12 Ori beams on all sides with full shields. Drones vs Beams, I say Beams win.

  • @birdman8180 That many Drones would still rip through it in a matter of seconds....

  • @MrGibbsOfficial Life fail, its not real

  • @Aliasify I know it's not real, i'm just stating from the statistics that are available throughout the seires

  • @birdman8180 The fact that drones go through shields is a problem, If I recall right.

  • @017720 drones don't go through shields, otherwise the 2 f-304's would have definitely died in the battle against the replicator's fleet, they got hit by ALOT that battle, you barely see any battle damage on them

  • @birdman8180 they aren't F-304's they are BC-304's, Stargate listing are: X=Experimental (X-301, X-302, X-303, X-304) F= fighter (F-302) BC= Battle Cruiser (BC-303, BC-304)

  • @birdman8180 the Asuran's didn't even use the drones... they only used the drones on the traveler's aurora class, which fired back with drones... they only fired the energy weapons - somewhat big fat yellow lasers the entire time... at the BIG ships... they kinda ignored the little ones...

  • Yeah man!!

    This is probably one of the best ship's battle I ever seen.

    I would say that is the third o second place, and what I like most was that you made a lantean ship!!!

    Congratulations, and hope see more of your animations!!

  • how u download game?

  • Nicely done surely not the most realistic video when you think about how it was in the series itself. Maybe thats the reason why people think it isn't that good.

    I mean Realguns didn't even penetrated Goa'uld shields and now they shall knock out Ancient shields?

    It's like if a stone age man is trying to destroy a battle tank with small stones and sticks.

    As for the graphics itself awesome work. :)

  • voll geil

  • wie geht der kampf aus??

  • kick ass. but in my opinion the shields should only be seen where an object actually hits them, it looks like the shields are just there and not really responding to the incoming projectiles, as seen in the show

  • If the graphics were just a little bit diffirent, it would be just like in the series!!

    Awesome!

    Subscribed!

    MOAR!

  • Damage needs to be a little better and the hyperspace window

  • nice but I dont think any ship could take sustained drone fire

  • @PraetorianOpti

    you didnt watch the ending of sga season 5 lol

    we will never know if drone fire will effect asguard sheilds

  • Wow, this is really good. You did a great job on the Railgun placements on the Daedalus class ships. There were two problems with the Drones coming from the Aurora though; the Drones are too big, they're just little things. Also, they should be coming from only a few small areas, not all over the ship. However, this is one of the best fight scenes i've ever seen for Stargate that wasn't actually in the show.

  • awesome

  • This is awesome, the only criticism I would make, and it is pretty minor, is the lighting of the weapon effects. The weapon bullet/laser things look like they'd cast light on the ship when they are fired (not familiar with c4d but im sure you can add lights and keyframe their intensity in time with the bullets to fake this effect).

    Very nice, things like this inspire me to get better at cgi!

  • am i wrong or is the brown ship supposed to be the aurora?? :D

  • @magicedaa well one of them

  • AWESOME!!!!!

  • I cant understand people saying this is bad, sure the weapons are a bit "ok need some work here" but i would kill to be able to do shield effects like that, your shields are immense ;) and the hyperspace openings....you are a credit to us Stargate Fans

    <3 Stargate Forever

  • this looks sweet! I love the camera shaking as added effect, models look cool and the graphical effects as well, only thing that looks a bit off is the hyperspace openings (not that those are bad tho, looks cool). also liked how you used the deadalus fly-by just as they have in the series :P

  • This is decent but the only thing wrong with this is the texture of the Ancient vessel. You got some of the coloration right but you need to add a kinda fog grey to the mix.

  • where did you get eh models?

  • Comment removed

  • Just like a real space battle, not stupid shooting or explosion noises..

  • @Gplex Why do you think the producers of shows chose to have sound in their space battles? Because sound is key. Things are relatively boring without sound, and you can do so much with it. And anyway, if you're in the ancient ship you can hear the railguns firing because the sound waves can traverse space.

  • i mean ...make

  • thats great - pls tell me how u name shields ?

  • Dude, this was über. What were they fighting btw? Considering the yellow lights they were firin', I'm guessing that they were ancients.

  • @DHGameStudios my guess is it was the asurians (ancient made replicators that rebeled)

  • Why would an ancient ship attacked the Earth's ships ???

  • @jajabimks it was probably the asurians (ancient made replicators), when they gained the ability to take human form they based their entire tech/culture around the ancients who made them

  • replicators?

  • make more

  • great!

    but why are the ancients battleing the humans?

  • Nice video, nice effects and rendering. The Models are damn awesome, first I tought it would only be Stargate szenes ;)

    I've got a question. How can you tell particels to pass through the shields? Cause I wanna animate a shield with proximal shader and destructor obejcts. But the particles coming form the ship will also get "killed" (From the inside).

    How did you it?

  • nice

  • Good video. However, I'd like to point out that drones can pass through shields. (SG-1 The Lost City Part 2).

  • Not through Asgard Shields!

    In the battle over the replicator homeworld the X-304s are hit by ancient drones and the asgard shields block them....

  • What I don't understand is that the ancients are supposed to be the most advanced race that has ever existed. Than why do the asgard have better weapons, shields, beaming technology? It just doesn't make much sense.

  • @dinowiz90 Actually asgards and the alterans have macthed, they preatty much were "born at same time" as a matter of speaking

  • @arenanet12 No at the start of the atlantis serise it shows Atlantis "1billion years ago" Yet in the last episode of stargate sg1 Thor....i think it was thor mentions that the database they gave the daedalus had their eniter recorded history that had the sum of 100,00 years.....And in the Ark of truth it shows that the Alterans were over 100,00 years old :p

    My theory is the ancients helped the Asgard evolve tecnologically and mentally ^^

    That's just a theory though :p

  • @deathy62 it's a nice theory :P

    I just know that the show rocks ^^

  • @dinowiz90 no they where the best of there time. while the asgard have had 10000 years more time to improve

  • read the damn desciption to see how its made?!!!

    but they are right....ill try the same program same ships etc. but with some extra things

    after i found out how to use the program totally^^

  • Pretty good with the graphics. Weapons and shields are all wrong. If you want to use rail guns fine but use the big guns too (Asgard ray). But I will subscribe expecting a longer and more action packed battle. Make the ships move and suffer. I don;t want to know who is going to win til the ending when one them blows up.

  • wow...those railguns are powerfull, how the hell did they manage to drain that replicator shield so fast? those guns are shit, even against gouald shields.

  • really good :D

  • wow

    respect!

    thumbs up

  • WOW this is really good u should make another 1 but against the wraith also though they never fire drones like that drones come out the top in streams and the 304s would usually fire misles and asgard plasma beams in adition to the rail guns

    also whats this from it looks cool and i wana make a battle

  • nice vid

  • Very Nice! 5*, because you can do something like that and I can't lol xD

    Just like some comments here said, the weapons need to be stronger, shields probably too and the railguns are fired in bursts (normally 6 bullets, 1 - 3 second nothing and then again 6 bullets)

    All after all I really like it!

  • I don´t know why so many people say this is crap. The graphics are amazing. Maybe the weapons should be stronger, but so what? It just looks great.

  • @Soldierlozer THE REASON THE WEAPONS ARENT STRONGER IS BECAUSE OF SHIELDS,AND SCIENTIFICALLY IT WOULD BE A LONG AND DRAWN OUT BATTLE BETWEEN TWO SHIPS OF THIS SIZE AND CALIBRE.

  • omg nearly tv quality

  • @SciFiMoviePro haha

  • @SciFiMoviePro your so right

  • hmans never realy employed railguns against ancient ships, usualy azgard lazers, and you got the firing wrong, the railguns fire on and off, but there are so many that they take turns (in 3's and 4's) and the ancient ships were firing to fast, and they never broadside, i dont know why but anciets never broadside, they alwys steer the ships head on before attacking with drones,they also fire in a big waves, the drones in this were to jerky, ungraceful

  • @OneGoldLion The front of Lantean warships are actually armor plated, so if the shields were lost, the ship would be able to survive a hell of a lot longer facing the fire.

  • they do employ railguns against ancient ships

    during the start of the batttle over asuras(stargate atlantis season 4 episode 11) you can see them firing railguns, both at the beginning and at the end of the battle

    and they do broadside as shown in the battle for asuras

    the rail guns fire however they choose to fire them, they have been fired in short bursts and in long ones

    also asgard and lasers are both s' not z

  • Timofifi ancient ships(2000 meters) are smaller than Wraith hives( 12000 meters) . But you are still right that the x304's railguns couldn't defeat the ancient shields so easily.

  • wrong

    the hive ship is not 12 kilometres long

    hive ships are about 1.5 km and the aurora is slightly shorter

  • The Ancients are one of the most advanced, if not the most advanced races in the Stargate universe. Their drones alone have the capability to pass through shields unaffected, and destroy ships in a matter of seconds. The railguns of a Daedalus-class battlecruiser, or 304, can't even destroy a Wraith hive-ship, which are about the same size as the Aurora-class warships, and they don't even possess shields.