The Carnvial Is Over by The Seekers

[75banjoman]

He broke a fundamental rule of music-never play the melody over the top of the vocalist-a professional should know this!

[steveJ1957]

It's a Saturday night here in England.. Snowing... Serious Goosebumps listening to this Wonderfull tune..... BRILLIANT !!! Cheers for uploading ...

[spongebobsquareprick]

Sounds like someone strangling a cat. Dump the fiddler ,cos he ruined that.

[TheShanver]

De tijd staat voor niemand stil,maar ongelooflijk wat een mooie stem.Het lijkt of haar stem met de jaren alleen maar beter en mooier wordt, en dat op die leeftijd.Groeten uit Holland.

[applepie238]

WOW,what a breathtaking performance from judith, the blonde girl singing is a top austrailian but you could see she was IN AWE of judith, because thats how fabulous judith still is.

[jimbo9580]

shoot the fiddler.he is killing this anthem

[eagle1angel]

Kill the fiddle.....

[jake30966]

I have to agree with everyone that that violin is woefull .

[retreat57]

I have loved listening to Judith and the seekers for over 30 years they are awesome and although i find orchestral music enjoyable the two just don't work . Bring back the tambourine and ditch the violin etc, how can we experience her wonderful voice if it is drowned out by a violin, I found the ladies in sparkly dresses a bit over the top Judith is a natural beauty whatever she wears.

[guidozzo1]

Nooo please, the Seekers are fantastic, my all time favourite group, but they don't

deserve to br disturbed by the noise of that fiddle.

[Orangemga1600]

Orchestra over the top...that fiddle is awful...totally out of place with the wonderful vocal from the amazing judith....still good to see the Seekers in 2011!

[lifeisgreat77]

Andre Rieu and the orchestra try to destroy the song.

There are many better versions of this great song.

[kookaburrakookaburra]

The Violinist needed to Hush when Judith was singing this, no respect. Judith's voice is amazing.

[gramule]

@kookaburrakookaburra the fiddler is an egoid disgrace. no respect for/to judith.

[Bigbearbeau]

there's no hippie like and old hippie, she kicks arse!!!!

[enginebelly]

Amazing singing. What a beautiful women. 

[GerryDT]

Excelent!!!!! on  my realy would like to meet list wish list

[moparmtn]

What an priviledge it was for all of them to be singing with Judith......

[Boreas1960]

Totally agree sack the fiddler. Bloody disgrace that Judith is singing in the dark.

Iowa61, Rieu can hardly be credited with 'reuniting' The Seekers. They've been 'reunited' since 1992 and together again since that time, at a pace commensurate with their ages and other commitments.

[VNVgirl]

it's sooooo beautiful ... thank you for this :)

[iowa61]

Sorry gang. I'm greatful for Rieu's intervention to reunite one of the greatest groups of the pop music era. But his production values are products of either incompetence or ego...

[boardey]

To think, that Andre Rieu was in my local city of Manchester the other month. Now he is in my favourite City, with my most loved group. I am still in Manchester, so sad.

[scuzzydirtbag]

Anyone know who the singer in the white gown standing next to Judith is?

[1504trevor]

@scuzzydirtbag The blond is Kalki Schrijvers. She began singing with the choir, but just lately she has been performing more often as one of the soloists of Andre Rieu and his orchestra .

[scuzzydirtbag]

@1504trevor Thanks for identifying the lady. She is quite striking!

[howzitgoin1970]

Good grief, no lights on Judith and the Boys. How bizarre, but I am so grateful for this video capture. Thanks for uploading it! Judith's voice is still so moving.

[grimTales1]

Lovely, it's a shame The Seekers are obscured by the dark though.

[ambtec]

thank you for the post have a look at my andre rieu clips ambtec

[Proculled]

Hmm,Judith and the boys standing in the "dark"and Andre all lit up.Nevertheless thanks a lot.We only miss "I am Australian"now and we can say we were there.