超級星光大道 第二季 20071123 一對一pk賽 Part1 08/ 林健輝 流淚手心 曾沛慈 愛上不回家的人1/3

[tcp5359]

好聽啊～

[ispd123]

林健輝 is so strong wow~ i need to learn from him

[maykmyahoo]

Pei Ci you are amazing! You give your best while recuperating from your voice discomfort. Support from Malaysia!

[beibei33]

malaysia boleh !

eric lim boleh!!^^

[frankmu714]

贏全世界...太誇張了，不過我真的有被林健輝電到~唱得很好，­真是永恆經典啊...!!

[fypig]

as long as they were enjoy the process of the competition...i believe through this competition , eric and pets learn alot alot of thing from each other.. eric also given another chance to pk again..

[chin9776]

He was great...

[zkin1988]

i am so proud of him coz i am malaysian too...

malaysia gogogo

[jtml94]

omg!! he just went to taiwan for this competition? i cant believe it! if im not mistaken his the class of 2001 or 2002 when he joined the astro singing competition & his the champion! feel so proud to say tht!

[z7530947]

林健輝+1 讚 曾沛慈 還好

第一次平手就讓我不悅了...

第二次硬加上個1分 打敗林健輝

這就是所謂的專業評審...??

真不知道他們是拿什麼臉,去說自己是最公平最公正最專業的...­在我眼裡就像睜眼說瞎話...一個字 濫

[qoogenius]

吼拜托主办单位根本就是要再拖一集拉。。会赚更多嘛。。 假仙。。很明显的林健辉强多了。。

[wuzhens]

Nothing wrong a profesional "singer" participate a singing competition . that's all your association ideas

[weisenglim]

The issue is more of bias rather than the reason he joined.

The organiser invited him and indeed most PK challengers had albums under their belts. So the issue of joining this contest shouldn't exist.

[kahsoon]

So what he won alot of title? He can't even win 曾沛慈 with her throat problem. I totally agree with the judges, his singing is so bland and robotic.

How can the press thinks 林健輝 is as famous as 萧敬腾? They can't even put them in comparison because 林健輝 is a seasoned artist with few albums while 萧敬腾 is a pub singer? But the biggest difference is 萧敬腾 is a good singer and everyone is waiting anxiously for his album while nobody buy 林健輝's "released" album.

[weisenglim]

If his singing is robotic perfect, 曾沛慈 singing is consistently robotic out of tune.

[fannykok]

are you deaf?

so obvious that Eric is sing much much better than pei ci!

Dun lie to yourself just because u are Pei Ci's fan

[beibei33]

true

face the fact. that's crucial

go lam kin fai!!!

[believek2]

其实我一直都是很支持曾佩慈，但这一集，老实说两人的水准差别实­在太大。

重复看了很多次，林建辉真是唱得比曾佩慈好太多。。。

但因为曾佩慈是最后一个出场，之前又没有人被pk掉，所以最句冠­军相的曾佩慈若被林建辉pk掉就会永远离开星光帮了。

所以。。。

对林建辉确是不公平。。。

[31129]

下個星期五的"超級星光大道

結果還是一樣

林健輝還是沒能打敗曾沛慈

我想您看了一定又會生氣

為了您的健康著想

還是去看台視的"超級偶像"吧

[btmcute]

林健輝比曾沛慈厲害...... you are the best....

i support u, not because u r from malaysia, the main is you are a great singer.

cheers

[angkukubb]

我喜欢pets 从他唱张雨生的没有烟抽的日子开始。。。 她的声音不错听， 可是林的确略胜一筹。。 有一点不公平的感觉。。。pets 哭得原因应该是为了评审们对他的厚爱吧。。 输了不要紧， 最重要是输得漂亮。

[weisenglim]

This isn't going to be fair to other contestants, the one exiting the following weeks, others who came/coming for PKs, and most importantly to the audiences.

After all, things past! Seems like many starting to admire Eric 林健輝 voice.

Going to get his previous albums and up coming ones. :)

[Pokerchee]

评审!!耳聋!耳聋!耳鸣!!

[weisenglim]

Of course I like 曾沛慈 too as she's a strong contestant.

But if the organiser chooses to hold the competition in a 'PK' way, they should do just right that - willing to let go any of the good contestant when a strong PK challenger comes.

The emcee, Momoko Tao keep on saying the competition isn't arranged or fake. Guess they're biting their own words. Never really thought things became so obvious that day. Really disappointed with the show now.

[weisenglim]

Of course I like 曾沛慈 too as she's a strong contestant.

But if the organiser chooses to hold the competition in a 'PK' way, they should do just right that - willing to let go any of the good contestant when a strong PK challenger comes.

The emcee, Momoko Tao keep on saying the competition isn't arranged or fake. Guess they're biting their own words. Never really thought things became so obvious that day. Really disappointed with the show now.

[weisenglim]

Why judges kept 曾沛慈 alive? why 曾沛慈 should have lost:

1) 林健輝: error hardly exists, already of different standard, every aspect singing is just right, not too much not too less.

2) 曾沛慈: singing has many error exists.

3) If feeling is more important than skill:

a) Why not choose contestants with good feeling but lesser skill like John Yuan.

b) Isn't singing competition about all aspects, skill, feeling, note, performance,etc

c) Why 林健輝 won many competitions?

[clevin21]

评审!!耳聋!耳聋!耳鸣!!

[topboi1590]

林建辉在马来西亚也有一首hit song噢。

这首我觉得唱的比王力宏版本的还要好勒@@

[luvcissy]

老鄉

妳這樣說只會害了林健輝惹人討厭...

力宏雖然abc腔很重...但詮釋起來還是感覺比較優^^

[meumeu888]

好聽好聽

[qlu811003]

我怎麼覺得他比曾沛慈厲害......

[tcn1280]

如果以實力,的確,但別忘了,主場優勢,其實輸不一定是輸,以蕭­敬騰為例,只要能上這個舞台就已經是贏家了,我相信還有更多優秀­的歌手,等著被發覺被肯定,為她們加油吧!

[ispd123]

@tcn1280 說得好只要能上這個舞台就已經是贏家了

[danwykl]

the guy is so much better. the girl sure can't loose or else it will be so embarassing for the show! haha