This dialect that speaks the Greek Makedonians in the borders of Bulgaria-Fyrom why the Archetyps words are in Greek(I only Speak for Greek edition as Kilkis-Serres-Kastoria because the Fyrom Edition Transformed Twice)the Structure of Syntax is Similar to Greek.There are more Pro-Homeric &Homeric words to exceed even the Greek language.Except the ARCHETYPS WORDS-ProHomeric-Homeric- There are at least 20% Greek words.Because mostly of uneducated People Spoken and didn't knows the Truth
My opinion is that ,Slav it means=Deaf,first gave this Explain the Germans Tribes for the People who can communicate and don't understand.Something similar To Bar-bar-ric used by greeks for foreign tribes.I think the History that Proven these tribes nothing contributated to mankind except few examples.
It is not a Macedonian dialect. It is a slavic dilalect (probably Bulgarian) which was spoken by Slavs that populate the region of Macedonian after the 7th century AD.
Why is so difficult for you guys to comprehend that???
@ydra1821 The language is Macedonian, the dialect is from Kukush (Kilkis), Macedonian language and bulgarian language are 2 differente languages, but they are similar because the are from group of south slavic languages.
@ydra1821 Don't get me wrong, do you know what is the meaning of word "slav"? It's mean man who spread word of God,because"Slovo"means word(in old slavic language) medieval time,in the Balcan region every Christian was a slav:) that was a culture... So in culture view Macedonains are slavic, but in national view they are Macedonians.Do you understand my friend?:)
@46denari Yes, I do understand. However, my opinion regarding the meaning (not etymological) of slavic culture is slightly different than the general "every christian was a slav". I won't insist though because you were very polite with me. Just, if it matters, I believe that Macedonian nationality is strongly related with the nature of the modern Macedonian language and this classifies it within the slavic-derived culture and population.
maqedonia Illyrian Territory aleksander) King agron) Pyrrhus of Epirus) Teuta princes) arkili) Skenderbeg Ali Pasha) ismail Qemali) all these are Illyrians long live UNITED STATES OF ALBANIA!
Мисля, че който чуе този диалект, в него няма да остане и капка съмнение, че македонския език е диалект на българския. Много по-красиво звучи македонският диалект без гроните си сръбски думи и окончания!
First Macedonian king who participated in the Olympic games was Alexander the Philellin.150 years before Alexander the great. Now this language in the video is an old Bulgarian dialect and not Macedonian.
Greek was introduced (enforced) in Aegean Macedonia through schools. That's why the so called "Macedonian Greek dialect" is IDENTICAL with the standard demotiki. All other native Greek areas have their own specific dialects.
And what does Aristotle has to do with the modern Macedonian dialects? Or modern Greek dialects, for that matter? Or with the forced assimilation that Greek state imposed on the native ethnic Macedonians in Greece?
Νot actually. Macedonian Greek is not identical with the standard Greek.Greek was introduced through schools only in the slavic-speaking villages of Florina, Pella, Kastoria etc. Search Macedonian dialect of Greek.
I tried Wikipedia, the Article named: Ancient Greek dialects. There are seven named: Doric, Aeolic, Attic, NorthWest, Acadian, Ionic and Achaean. Macedonian is not among them. Look at the map. Macedonia, Illyrian and Thracian are separate langauges. :-)
No man. How Macedonian could be a separate language, since no elements of this language variety have been found?? ;) Not of Illyrian either.Thracian was not Greek, we know that from the thracian inscriptions.But we know nothing about Mac. & Illyr. ;-)
It is true that we don't know enough about the Ancient Macedonian. But that goes both ways. The Greek claim that it was a Greek dialect is also unsubstantiated. The fact that Greeks called them barbaroi (foreing language speakers) suggest that the Ancient Macedonian language was foreign to them.
It was not Greeks, but only Demosthenes that called Macedonians barbaroi. And Demos. was not an historian but a rhetor, that is a kind of lawyer. But I can't see what these things have to do with the modern times and the present linguistic situation ....
It was not only Demostenes. When Alexander I wanted to participate in the Olympic games, they rejected him as a king of barbarians. He managed to convince them (bribe) that although his people are barbarians, he is of hellenic origin.
Alexander I was not rejected at all.Anyone who wanted to participate had to convince the judges, he was Greek.Alex. had to do the same.You mean the Macedonians participated the Olympics bcoz they bribed?You admire your 'ancestors' so much :):)
When Alexander I, Alexander of Macedon's great-grandfather, tried to enter the Olympic games, he was rejeced, since he was a Macedonian king, and Greeks considered Macedonians to be non-Hellenic barbarians. He needed to come up with a mythologic story (and some money too) to convince them that although he is a king of barbarians, he himself is a Hellene.
actually there's no macedonian dialect of greek. if you have a look at linguistic maps of greece, the region of macedonia is not included.
today the greek language spoken in macedonia is not different from standard greek. just a slight slavic accent. they speak standard greek because the greek language was introduced artificially through schools.
The macedonian dialects of the greek language r spoken by the indigenous greek speaking ppl of Kozani,Grevena,Pieria,Imathia,Thessaloniki,Chalkidiki,Serres,Drama prefectures
Bulgarian dialect - fully understandable by Bulgarians all over Bulgaria.
kkasapa 1 week ago
This dialect that speaks the Greek Makedonians in the borders of Bulgaria-Fyrom why the Archetyps words are in Greek(I only Speak for Greek edition as Kilkis-Serres-Kastoria because the Fyrom Edition Transformed Twice)the Structure of Syntax is Similar to Greek.There are more Pro-Homeric &Homeric words to exceed even the Greek language.Except the ARCHETYPS WORDS-ProHomeric-Homeric- There are at least 20% Greek words.Because mostly of uneducated People Spoken and didn't knows the Truth
pyraixmhs 2 weeks ago
My opinion is that ,Slav it means=Deaf,first gave this Explain the Germans Tribes for the People who can communicate and don't understand.Something similar To Bar-bar-ric used by greeks for foreign tribes.I think the History that Proven these tribes nothing contributated to mankind except few examples.
pyraixmhs 2 weeks ago
БЪЛГАРСКИ!
wursata 1 month ago
Bulgarian
artemis20001000 2 months ago
@artemis20001000 hahaha bulgarian you are crazy tatars
you speak just bad macedonian nothing else
drumercoka 14 minutes ago
Bulgarian(old version).
SuperDetelin 2 months ago
It is not a Macedonian dialect. It is a slavic dilalect (probably Bulgarian) which was spoken by Slavs that populate the region of Macedonian after the 7th century AD.
Why is so difficult for you guys to comprehend that???
ydra1821 5 months ago
@ydra1821 The language is Macedonian, the dialect is from Kukush (Kilkis), Macedonian language and bulgarian language are 2 differente languages, but they are similar because the are from group of south slavic languages.
46denari 3 months ago
@46denari So let me understand better. Macedonians were a south slavic group of people?
ydra1821 3 months ago
@ydra1821 Don't get me wrong, do you know what is the meaning of word "slav"? It's mean man who spread word of God,because"Slovo"means word(in old slavic language) medieval time,in the Balcan region every Christian was a slav:) that was a culture... So in culture view Macedonains are slavic, but in national view they are Macedonians.Do you understand my friend?:)
46denari 3 months ago
@46denari Yes, I do understand. However, my opinion regarding the meaning (not etymological) of slavic culture is slightly different than the general "every christian was a slav". I won't insist though because you were very polite with me. Just, if it matters, I believe that Macedonian nationality is strongly related with the nature of the modern Macedonian language and this classifies it within the slavic-derived culture and population.
ydra1821 3 months ago
@ydra1821 hahaha slavic
fucking gayreeks
macedonian not bulgarian
drumercoka 13 minutes ago
Bitches can't shut the fuck up!!!!!
ΜΑΚΕΔΟΝΙΑ always will be greek place and always it was
I want to tell me someone F.Y.R.O.M. bitche what is the name meaning in their language :
Alexander the grade ( Μεγας αλεξανδρος)
Aristotelis ( Αριστοτελης )
Bergina ( Βεργινα )
Sarisa ( Σαρισα )
Makedonia ( Μακεδονια )
veteranos7 5 months ago
Интересно -
balkan1.blog.bg/politika/2011/06/04/maichiniot-jazik-na-makedoncite.759584
getop34 7 months ago
maqedonia Illyrian Territory aleksander) King agron) Pyrrhus of Epirus) Teuta princes) arkili) Skenderbeg Ali Pasha) ismail Qemali) all these are Illyrians long live UNITED STATES OF ALBANIA!
MrLadrocuori 8 months ago
Мисля, че който чуе този диалект, в него няма да остане и капка съмнение, че македонския език е диалект на българския. Много по-красиво звучи македонският диалект без гроните си сръбски думи и окончания!
Saint80BG 9 months ago
@Saint80BG ajde de a da ne e blgarskiot samo los dijalekt na makedonskiot taka e pravilno zosto se zedovte od nas
drumercoka 12 minutes ago
This has been flagged as spam show
macedonia for the macedonians.... yes!!!! for the greeks not the bulgar slavo gypsies. macedonia is greek so fuck off!!!!!!!!!!
hellenemacedon 1 year ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
This fake Zombie country (small land of) FYROM must return to its owners
ALBANIA, BULGARIA and GREECE
see part 6 with FACTs
FYROmonkey1 1 year ago
..nice video,bulgarian language#1!!!
.
go on!!!
drmack70 1 year ago
Nice video, great idea, beautiful language. Go on. God bless
sakshama 1 year ago
Bravo Stojanov,Pozdrav...
Belasica11 1 year ago
The title of this video should be " Bulgarian dialect from Kukush".
dgeorgiev 1 year ago
slicen so stumickiot i so mariovskiot jazik
Nikola6676 2 years ago
First Macedonian king who participated in the Olympic games was Alexander the Philellin.150 years before Alexander the great. Now this language in the video is an old Bulgarian dialect and not Macedonian.
Dourios11144 2 years ago
@Dourios11144
and Philhellen means?
gandalFF85 2 years ago
Do you know who is the Argead dynasty? If you know then dont ask me pointless questions. Alexander the Philellin was a Greek.
Dourios11144 2 years ago
Comment removed
vmalexiou 2 years ago
oh my god!!!...
these are bulgarian!!!...macedonian is a greek dialect!!!!
NikiforosZias 2 years ago
Nikifore,
Greek was introduced (enforced) in Aegean Macedonia through schools. That's why the so called "Macedonian Greek dialect" is IDENTICAL with the standard demotiki. All other native Greek areas have their own specific dialects.
GAStojanov 2 years ago
man...
have you ever read an original text of aristotel in your life??.....
NikiforosZias 2 years ago
And what does Aristotle has to do with the modern Macedonian dialects? Or modern Greek dialects, for that matter? Or with the forced assimilation that Greek state imposed on the native ethnic Macedonians in Greece?
GAStojanov 2 years ago
Νot actually. Macedonian Greek is not identical with the standard Greek.Greek was introduced through schools only in the slavic-speaking villages of Florina, Pella, Kastoria etc. Search Macedonian dialect of Greek.
Grkoman 2 years ago
I tried Wikipedia, the Article named: Ancient Greek dialects. There are seven named: Doric, Aeolic, Attic, NorthWest, Acadian, Ionic and Achaean. Macedonian is not among them. Look at the map. Macedonia, Illyrian and Thracian are separate langauges. :-)
GAStojanov 2 years ago
I also tried Wikipedia for the Modern Greek Dialects. Here is the map:
file:Griechisch Isoglosses 1900.png
Macedonian is again not among them. :-)
GAStojanov 2 years ago
No man. How Macedonian could be a separate language, since no elements of this language variety have been found?? ;) Not of Illyrian either.Thracian was not Greek, we know that from the thracian inscriptions.But we know nothing about Mac. & Illyr. ;-)
Grkoman 2 years ago
It is true that we don't know enough about the Ancient Macedonian. But that goes both ways. The Greek claim that it was a Greek dialect is also unsubstantiated. The fact that Greeks called them barbaroi (foreing language speakers) suggest that the Ancient Macedonian language was foreign to them.
GAStojanov 2 years ago
It was not Greeks, but only Demosthenes that called Macedonians barbaroi. And Demos. was not an historian but a rhetor, that is a kind of lawyer. But I can't see what these things have to do with the modern times and the present linguistic situation ....
Grkoman 2 years ago
It was not only Demostenes. When Alexander I wanted to participate in the Olympic games, they rejected him as a king of barbarians. He managed to convince them (bribe) that although his people are barbarians, he is of hellenic origin.
GAStojanov 2 years ago
Alexander I was not rejected at all.Anyone who wanted to participate had to convince the judges, he was Greek.Alex. had to do the same.You mean the Macedonians participated the Olympics bcoz they bribed?You admire your 'ancestors' so much :):)
Grkoman 2 years ago
When Alexander I, Alexander of Macedon's great-grandfather, tried to enter the Olympic games, he was rejeced, since he was a Macedonian king, and Greeks considered Macedonians to be non-Hellenic barbarians. He needed to come up with a mythologic story (and some money too) to convince them that although he is a king of barbarians, he himself is a Hellene.
GAStojanov 2 years ago
actually there's no macedonian dialect of greek. if you have a look at linguistic maps of greece, the region of macedonia is not included.
today the greek language spoken in macedonia is not different from standard greek. just a slight slavic accent. they speak standard greek because the greek language was introduced artificially through schools.
TheAromanian 2 years ago
The macedonian dialects of the greek language r spoken by the indigenous greek speaking ppl of Kozani,Grevena,Pieria,Imathia,Thessaloniki,Chalkidiki,Serres,Drama prefectures
Nocebo21 2 years ago
Comment removed
Nocebo21 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
A small sample from a village near to Veroia
watch?v=JA4J0DJ3x60
Nocebo21 2 years ago
Comment removed
TheAromanian 2 years ago
Deka gi najduvash prikaznite?
Grkoman 2 years ago
Ima mnogu zbirki na prikazni i pesni, pishani i audio zapisi od Egejskite Makedonski Govori.
Ovaa prikazna e od knigata Kukushkiot Govor od Kosta Peev.
GAStojanov 2 years ago
Istina? Ja znam vaa kniga. Jaska imam edna za Ano Kalliniki.
Grkoman 2 years ago
Nice mate Love to listen!!!
Mark3101010100 2 years ago