Wow I'm the odd one out. This version is horrible to me. The Donmar Warehouse version is so much better. She's not even trying to sing it like it's meant to be sung. It's not suppose to be pretty. She's trying to change the whole rhythm of the song.
You've got to hear the version in the Donmar Warehouse production available on e-music ...sung with a Glasgow accent, in a new, even harsher translation and scary as hell.
defo the most vicious interpretation of the song and a truely wonderful one! - obviously the contrast between "innocence" of the OV and lyrics is gone. But the English translation is the best I have seen so far and really caught the meaning - except for the last lines which are poorly translated "That'll learn ya!" :(
I like to feel sexy....knowing someone is watching me ..wanting me...turns me on!BADLY! I like to flirt and pose..and sometimes i like to get WILD! how? ..he he..come in video and youll see:-)) maybe u can teach me something..or maybe i will ! come visit me at MeetYourFling * COM my user-id there is dorotea-fvso chat soon on cam :-) qcugqmazqk
I think, it's a nice performance - but since I'm german I see the weaknesses of the translation. Has any of you ever listened to Bea Arthurs version on her Just between friends CD? I liked that one very much.
This was wonderful. I admit I am partial to the Lotte Lenya, it is the version I grew up with. Yeah, nice song for kids. But I love Ford's expressiveness. Although some of it reminds me of a crazy Gloria Swanson at the end of Sunset Boulevard, especially the eyebrows!
Really enjoyed seeing this. I would suggest that anyone who has been properly inspired by Miss Ford to appreciate "Pirate Jenny" also seek Betty Buckley's gut wrenching rendition on her 1996 "Evening at Carnegie Hall" album.
wow, i am amazed by her performance! so far i have not yet listened to many english translations of this song, but this one is the first that seems like a proper translation to me. its either that, or Annes amazing accentuation that makes her performance worthwile.
Great video, good sound quality, and intriguing performance. Wish there were clips of the 1976-77, New York Shakespeare Festival production of "Threepenny..." on YouTube (with Raul Julia as "Macheath"). I have the LP. I'm sure footage exists somewhere of this production but there's no DVD out. Anybody know for sure or not?
How wise you were, to have actually seen this, in-person, back then! Memories like these are priceless and alas, unlike you, I missed it.
Yes, I agree in re the '76 translation and L. Lenya: Even though she originated the role and am sure both Weill and Brecht liked her rendition (?) from a musical-standpoint level it's a bit coarse on my ears
Yeah right, that one's a pretty good version...but no one can express it as powerful and expressive as Hilde did in the 60's. To bad she died, there's no one to replace her conveniently yet =)
This lady (A.K. Ford) does a great job, but she just doesn't seem as loony as a criminally-vindicative "Pirate Jenny" ought to be! :-D Or, maybe, it's just Knef chopping off with the hard Teutonic tongue that makes one feel so adequately convinced. Given the level of über-feminism in modern German Kultur, though, it's only a matter of time before H. K. is surpassed...? Yikes---batten down the hatches!
Interesting thoughts. But I don't believe anyone could ever surpass Hilde. Still today I often sense in productions of almost all german as well as of some international artists how much they took their inspiration from her performances. But none of them has the same range of mimes and gestics or even that ability to connect and change them so accordingly to the themes like Hilde did...her talent was pretty unique I guess.
Actually, I agree with you 100%: Hildegard Knef was an absolute original; a product of her times; I don't think any of the younger female German performers could approximate the kind of cynical rage that can only have been borne out of all that post-war devastation. Americans don't understand this, never having had to thoroughly rebuild hundreds of years of history the way Germany/Europe, and Japan, for instance, have...*not* to say this is *singularly* Knef's forte, but it figures, somewhat
i quite like the crazyness of it. nobody beat marianne faithfull though - legend and a half! theres so many different versions of this song, some are really good.
I think we should remember: 1) Kurt Weil's work was kept alive here in the US while Germany went nuts with the Nazi's; 2) Kurt Weil was so ashamed that when he got here he never spoke another word of German. Considering that he forged a second great career here in NYC, and that Lenya stayed on, I have no trouble hearing Americans singing him in "American". Actually, I find it appropriate.
i think i'm just too used to the original, because although she does it quite well, i'd prefer if she stuck to the original score and didn't talk it so much. that and it's transposed way down.
Interesting and good interpretation, but English language is not made for this song/lyrics. She is sometimes a lit bit too theatralic at the end but I like here that there is only a piano. Everybody on utube knows that I prefere the Hildegard Knef interpretation (Hilde´s singing and acting the song but NOT the Big Band in the background).
I must disagree...I believe she got exactly what Kurt Weill was going for in this song. Haunting, dark and sinister. To bring that much emotion to a song while just standing there takes great talent.
I like half of this performance, and the other half I'm not so hot about. I like her singing the verses, but for some reason, the chorus annoys me. Maybe it's just because I'm so used to Lotte Lenya's version(s) of this song.
This woman is BRILLIANT! This is such an incredible, haunting, hair rasing performance. This made me love The Three Penny Opera. I've never seen a good performance of anything from this show until now. This woman is an incredible actress! and singer!
it's probably because most people that have sung from it aren't as brilliant as this woman. I didn't even like this song until I saw/heard her sing it...and now I love it. She really is incredible, isn't she!
This is indeed a good performance of the song. I wish people would give Marc Blitzstein proper credit for the English version of The Threepenny Opera. He did the adaptation of Brecht's play familiar to English-speaking audiences. Some songs (like this one) stayed close to the originals while others differed greatly (especially when they were "cleaned up" for 1950s theatergoers.) Personally I like both versions for different reasons.
She does a nice job, as a concert piece, and has a good voice. But her characterization is not gritty enough (the character in the song is a lowly, abused bar maid). It would be interesting to see her in a full production of "The Threepenny Opera." Thanks for posting.
Fearless & fascinating. Miss Ford is an wonderful actress AND singer. This feels like the interpretation Kurt Weill had in mind when he wrote the song. Bravo.
Now that is very, very well done.
gvanderleun 2 months ago
Less dramatic than Ute Lemper but did a good job on her softly voice, my choice's still Nina Simone.
Candyberry2006 6 months ago in playlist Kurt Weill, Threepenny Opera
Quite good! All the emotion and all the imagination. It had my attention. I had to check that the Black Freighter wasn't docked up in our town!
TuboEspectador 9 months ago
This makes me want to swear appreciatively . Love it.
actclicksmile 11 months ago
i know the versions of lotte lenay, gisela may and sonja kehler, but this version cab compete
gadaichie 1 year ago
i like the dresden dolls / amanda palmers version
black1399 1 year ago 3
Excellent rendition of this song!!! I love the expressions she gave as she sang.
valeriemci1 1 year ago
This is really great, and she's best when she plays it small. nice!
normanthepig 1 year ago
I like nina simone's, its more vulgar and vicious.
fsklrk 1 year ago
she scares me like she has a gremlin in her
jamespriceAK 1 year ago
Anne Kerry Ford sings beautifully. =)~
Persephonie22 1 year ago
Super :P
martha6742 2 years ago
she's pretty good as a singer
biegunkaelo 2 years ago
awesome!
purelyshameless 2 years ago
Wow I'm the odd one out. This version is horrible to me. The Donmar Warehouse version is so much better. She's not even trying to sing it like it's meant to be sung. It's not suppose to be pretty. She's trying to change the whole rhythm of the song.
blackbird107 2 years ago
@blackbird107 no, it's supposed to show frustration and rage. just listen to te lyrics, there is nothing pretty and singable about them.
WhiteDragonTile 1 year ago
Comment removed
winosapien 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
You're not the only one blackbird107. She oscillates between singing it "pretty" and full on camp. Two things one should avoid when singing Weill.
winosapien 1 year ago
Un bel notte vedremo! The arrival of the ship, the distant cannon in the harbor, and what happens this time as her man approaches her abode.
wbeaty 2 years ago
WOW!!!! it's f good
lachorvath 2 years ago
Absolutely love this version. Some versions try to camp it up. I prefer it sung with poison.
bobbyunavailable 2 years ago 20
This has been flagged as spam show
couldn't agree more.
Romanticideitzcoatl 2 years ago 2
Very, very nais.
BruenftigerElch91 2 years ago
Comment removed
Romanticideitzcoatl 2 years ago
Beautiful performance, beautiful actress, beautiful play, beautiful music...
RaimundoGuzman 2 years ago
You should try Betty Buckley's version from her Carnegie Hall concert CD( from 1996 or so). Dark, chilly and dramatic.
UandMeKid 2 years ago
Brilliant! Marvellously scary. Best English version of this song I knew.
topsamite 2 years ago
You've got to hear the version in the Donmar Warehouse production available on e-music ...sung with a Glasgow accent, in a new, even harsher translation and scary as hell.
fringelily 2 years ago
Soooo Goooood.....
Great performance.....
BRAVO
Wesbound1 2 years ago
BRAVO!! BRAVOOO!!!!
MTVoodoo 2 years ago
Wonderful - will look at Nina Simone's version. Love Judy Collins rendition
lazytom1946 2 years ago
Judy Collins' gives me the shivers and scares my kids. It's sooooo evil.
marvy1118 2 years ago
Hers isnt that good.
So dark.
And this one isnt on watchmen nina simones is.
NoMorePigs 2 years ago
I saw Ellen Greene perform this in a NYC production decades ago. I loved it, and her performance became my standard. Ford does a creditable job.
affectivity 2 years ago 2
She performed this how it was meant to be done, and nina's is also good, but kerry hear does this like a pro
waygeta 2 years ago
I prefer Nina Simone's version... majorly.
imaaaaaaaaaaan 2 years ago 2
This was a great Idea to do this song no if we can just get them to remake roots and cast george bush as kunta kente that would be just swell
skie878 2 years ago
i dont remember this on watchmen
Rundleguy 2 years ago
The Black Freighter comic book in Watchmen was named after this song.
thewalkingman 2 years ago
it's on the tales of the black freighter extras thingy which'll be on the dvd ;] if you read the back of the soundtrack's cd you'll see.
invaderGEO 2 years ago
This is a really brilliant performance.
JSWright101 3 years ago
This version seems embarrassing compared to Nina Simone's
embigmoose 3 years ago
defo the most vicious interpretation of the song and a truely wonderful one! - obviously the contrast between "innocence" of the OV and lyrics is gone. But the English translation is the best I have seen so far and really caught the meaning - except for the last lines which are poorly translated "That'll learn ya!" :(
Straaasse 3 years ago
watchmen.. has some sweet references
Ice3461 3 years ago 2
She reminds me of Gloria Swanson a bit. Great performance.
avapepper 3 years ago
this woman has an amazing face... fascinating. i watched this 7 times and every time is good as the last .
inesparis 3 years ago 3
She's good, but...hm, I prefer Ute Lemper singing it.
TheMaryoftheAnn 3 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
I like to feel sexy....knowing someone is watching me ..wanting me...turns me on!BADLY! I like to flirt and pose..and sometimes i like to get WILD! how? ..he he..come in video and youll see:-)) maybe u can teach me something..or maybe i will ! come visit me at MeetYourFling * COM my user-id there is dorotea-fvso chat soon on cam :-) qcugqmazqk
DianzGD 3 years ago
I think, it's a nice performance - but since I'm german I see the weaknesses of the translation. Has any of you ever listened to Bea Arthurs version on her Just between friends CD? I liked that one very much.
googygok 3 years ago
I must agree. I really enjoyed Bea's voice with this song even though she didn't even play that role.
stefanifan2 3 years ago
Nina Simone owns this!!
sailorsdoxy 3 years ago
I wish I could find a version of Nina Simone singing this.
None129 3 years ago 9
it's on the Watchmen soundtrack
OneDeadMFA 3 years ago 2
Comment removed
justconstantine 2 years ago
Well, it's definitely on the Watchmen Soundtrack album!
imaaaaaaaaaaan 2 years ago
This was wonderful. I admit I am partial to the Lotte Lenya, it is the version I grew up with. Yeah, nice song for kids. But I love Ford's expressiveness. Although some of it reminds me of a crazy Gloria Swanson at the end of Sunset Boulevard, especially the eyebrows!
Frissoneuse 3 years ago
Fantastic Performance
Although I prefer 'Hopla' to 'That'll learn ya!'
nubient 4 years ago 2
She's no Nina Simone
streetswell 4 years ago
a master at work!
ilovemess 4 years ago
Those eyes!
JamaQu 4 years ago
Und sie wissen NICHT mit wem sie reden^^
RockyInes 4 years ago
AWESOME!
what a charisma this lady has! let alone her singing-skills.
that is the talent what Brecht/Weill-songs are made for!
purelyshameless 4 years ago
Really enjoyed seeing this. I would suggest that anyone who has been properly inspired by Miss Ford to appreciate "Pirate Jenny" also seek Betty Buckley's gut wrenching rendition on her 1996 "Evening at Carnegie Hall" album.
Rufriben 4 years ago
I just really think this is the quintessential version of this song. It has so much ferocity and depth - what an incredible artist Ms. Ford is!
sheabreaux 4 years ago
if you think this is s great proformance get the cd of pirate jenny song by Nina Simone it will blow your mind!!!!
austinrowteam77 4 years ago
wow, i am amazed by her performance! so far i have not yet listened to many english translations of this song, but this one is the first that seems like a proper translation to me. its either that, or Annes amazing accentuation that makes her performance worthwile.
shaydee0 4 years ago
Great video, good sound quality, and intriguing performance. Wish there were clips of the 1976-77, New York Shakespeare Festival production of "Threepenny..." on YouTube (with Raul Julia as "Macheath"). I have the LP. I'm sure footage exists somewhere of this production but there's no DVD out. Anybody know for sure or not?
Mavarla 4 years ago
I too, have that LP, bought it right after seeing that show in a Wednesday matinee. IIRC, the tickets were $10 each. Amazing how prices have changed.
The translation they used in '76 is my favorite.
Nice performance here. I prefer this (deeper/richer) voice to the definitive Lotte Lenya.
bigapplebucky 4 years ago
How wise you were, to have actually seen this, in-person, back then! Memories like these are priceless and alas, unlike you, I missed it.
Yes, I agree in re the '76 translation and L. Lenya: Even though she originated the role and am sure both Weill and Brecht liked her rendition (?) from a musical-standpoint level it's a bit coarse on my ears
Mavarla 4 years ago
Further thought---might be rude to say this on someone else's video post, but the 1960s Hildegard Knef rendition "auf Deutsch" is the best
Mavarla 4 years ago 3
Yeah right, that one's a pretty good version...but no one can express it as powerful and expressive as Hilde did in the 60's. To bad she died, there's no one to replace her conveniently yet =)
JustPhil22 3 years ago
This lady (A.K. Ford) does a great job, but she just doesn't seem as loony as a criminally-vindicative "Pirate Jenny" ought to be! :-D Or, maybe, it's just Knef chopping off with the hard Teutonic tongue that makes one feel so adequately convinced. Given the level of über-feminism in modern German Kultur, though, it's only a matter of time before H. K. is surpassed...? Yikes---batten down the hatches!
Mavarla 3 years ago
Interesting thoughts. But I don't believe anyone could ever surpass Hilde. Still today I often sense in productions of almost all german as well as of some international artists how much they took their inspiration from her performances. But none of them has the same range of mimes and gestics or even that ability to connect and change them so accordingly to the themes like Hilde did...her talent was pretty unique I guess.
JustPhil22 3 years ago
Actually, I agree with you 100%: Hildegard Knef was an absolute original; a product of her times; I don't think any of the younger female German performers could approximate the kind of cynical rage that can only have been borne out of all that post-war devastation. Americans don't understand this, never having had to thoroughly rebuild hundreds of years of history the way Germany/Europe, and Japan, for instance, have...*not* to say this is *singularly* Knef's forte, but it figures, somewhat
Mavarla 3 years ago
@Mavarla The '76 translation has finally been posted. Search for "NYSF Threepenny Opera - 12 - Pirate Jenny".
bigapplebucky 3 weeks ago
i quite like the crazyness of it. nobody beat marianne faithfull though - legend and a half! theres so many different versions of this song, some are really good.
mynxiemonroe 4 years ago
Eww....don't like this version. I like her performance though... kind-a scary.
LittleFrankNFurter 4 years ago
she keeps looking like she forgot the lyrics for two seconds after "and you see me" and that takes away a ton. otherwise good emotion.
Vittorimo 4 years ago
I think we should remember: 1) Kurt Weil's work was kept alive here in the US while Germany went nuts with the Nazi's; 2) Kurt Weil was so ashamed that when he got here he never spoke another word of German. Considering that he forged a second great career here in NYC, and that Lenya stayed on, I have no trouble hearing Americans singing him in "American". Actually, I find it appropriate.
Whatever Anne Kerry Ford is a miracle.
hmshutton 4 years ago
i think i'm just too used to the original, because although she does it quite well, i'd prefer if she stuck to the original score and didn't talk it so much. that and it's transposed way down.
cielomobile 4 years ago
Interesting and good interpretation, but English language is not made for this song/lyrics. She is sometimes a lit bit too theatralic at the end but I like here that there is only a piano. Everybody on utube knows that I prefere the Hildegard Knef interpretation (Hilde´s singing and acting the song but NOT the Big Band in the background).
hoffmann9471 4 years ago
Ute Lemper, she did the best. I don't even know who this woman is. American accents should stay away from German Kurt Weill - It doesn't sound good.
angelovondrez 5 years ago
I must disagree...I believe she got exactly what Kurt Weill was going for in this song. Haunting, dark and sinister. To bring that much emotion to a song while just standing there takes great talent.
schmoodles 5 years ago
I like half of this performance, and the other half I'm not so hot about. I like her singing the verses, but for some reason, the chorus annoys me. Maybe it's just because I'm so used to Lotte Lenya's version(s) of this song.
blackpython 5 years ago
nobody like Nina Simone!!!
dunjica77 5 years ago
I second that! her version makes your skin scrawl.
jacobsimon 4 years ago
This woman is BRILLIANT! This is such an incredible, haunting, hair rasing performance. This made me love The Three Penny Opera. I've never seen a good performance of anything from this show until now. This woman is an incredible actress! and singer!
angryunclemartin 5 years ago
Kurt Weill is a genius, and Anne's voice did it total justice. Her vocal expression is impeccable. I love it!
MissAndyWarhol 5 years ago
WHY wasn't this CD nominated for a Grammy?
ladye8888 5 years ago
WOW! FANTASTIC VOICE! This musical has some AWESOME DARK and SKANKY songs. I don't know why people aren't more head over heels about it.
bingotheraccoon 5 years ago
it's probably because most people that have sung from it aren't as brilliant as this woman. I didn't even like this song until I saw/heard her sing it...and now I love it. She really is incredible, isn't she!
angryunclemartin 5 years ago
SO VERY MUCH!!!
bingotheraccoon 5 years ago
Yeah, Weill's woefully neglected in general, think the tide is turning though.
Weillfanatic 4 years ago
This is indeed a good performance of the song. I wish people would give Marc Blitzstein proper credit for the English version of The Threepenny Opera. He did the adaptation of Brecht's play familiar to English-speaking audiences. Some songs (like this one) stayed close to the originals while others differed greatly (especially when they were "cleaned up" for 1950s theatergoers.) Personally I like both versions for different reasons.
smurfswacker 5 years ago
Ferociously brilliant. She so deeply digs into this song, it's downright hair-raising. I am haunted by this performance....fantastic!
sheabreaux 5 years ago
She does a nice job, as a concert piece, and has a good voice. But her characterization is not gritty enough (the character in the song is a lowly, abused bar maid). It would be interesting to see her in a full production of "The Threepenny Opera." Thanks for posting.
RenzoRienzi 5 years ago
Fearless & fascinating. Miss Ford is an wonderful actress AND singer. This feels like the interpretation Kurt Weill had in mind when he wrote the song. Bravo.
desinga 5 years ago