Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (236)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • his voice is just amazing, simply put. I'd be challenged if someone asked me to find a better voice, because i don't think there are any. He sings straight to the heart and his voice could move mountains.

  • Talent like Josh's should be given the opportunity to shine. So many talented people out there go unnoticed. If you think youve got what it takes to be a star enter in one of the MakeAStar contests. It's easy, you just go to the website, upload your video and wait for people vote. You win $100 if enough people vote for you.

  • JOSH, I was watching the AI show, and I believe nobody in that show have the powerful and amazing voice that your have. Your voice is unique.

  • Wife is a big x factor fan, as for myself, wasnt very interested till I heard this very unique voice coming from the tv, of course it was Krajcik. It just blew me away!! I agree with u ffemt8, others do have same type or similar style voices, but Krajciks voice is LEGENDARY!!!! Hope someone gives him a shot, he deserves it!!! Leave the burritos to someone else.

  • I think Nicole is one of the coolest chicks on the face of this earth

  • the best! I Like

  • listen to this then listen to the original version by the beatles josh killed it

  • Josh take Jenny Lute from the Wet Darlings on your tour and rock the world together, your're fantastic, brilliant!!!!!

  • JOSH you are my star! I will hopefully the 1st one will stand in front of the music store in Prague who will buy your CD! you are great!

  • NAILED!

    

  • This song is really beautiful, and Josh did his usual wonderful job!

  • lots of times the person who doesn't win a public competition comes out much better than the won who wins, because they don't have to be under a unnegociated contract.... Just think about Jackie Evanco ( however you spell it), Jennifer Hudson, etc...

  • Wonderful and different voice, amazing !

  • I like this....very nice control

  • Josh is amazing and he didnt have to win 1st place to be the winner he is. I would definately go see him, and Im 57 years old, hes the best.

  • JOSH IS AMAZING, AND I WILL BE THE FIRST ONE TO BUY ALL OF HIS ALBUMS, I CAN HARDLY WAIT TILL HE PUTS ONE OUT, HE IS MICHAEL MCDONALD AND JOE COCKER ROLLED INTO ONE, HE'S ONE HOT MF!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!­!! I'D DO HIM, AND TWICE ON SUNDAY....AWESOME TALENT....HELLUVA VOICE!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • He sings from the heart that has endur so much. talent is when you sing and someone else feels everyword and that my friends is what he does.

  • his voice is so amazing !! i close my eyes and listen to him, i agree his voice is one of a kind and he should have won:) but he will go far and be great at whatever will come !!!!!

  • Comment removed

  • @missmoney1996 have you ever listen Joe Cocker version?It's awesome!

  • @EsttevanRaul Sorry, that was my idiotic sister. I personally love the beatles but she literally has no (decent) taste in music

  • @missmoney1996 How could you ever say any song by the Beatles is Boring, Yes Josh nailed it. But the Beatles were the best that ever was.

  • It's okay to come in second.

  • This is amazing. He made a beautiful song even better. I didnt know that was possible.

  • Dear Josh k, if you read this. You know that you were the only good singer on the show. The x factor is simon's show so his no talent trash pile girl won. I do not know one person who liked Simon's pet. JOSH K YOU ARE A TRUE WINNER!!!.

  • VOTE FOR JOSH! TRUE TALENT!

  • wáááááááááááááááá Love this!!! My best singer :). Perfect!

    one girl from Hungary

  • ultimately the best! love you josh!!

  • Love this ^^ :)

  • i feel every word he sings

  • CMON GUYS VOTE FOR JOSH!!!! HOMETOWN HERO!!!! KRAJCICK MAGIC!!!!

  • He's the best on the show and I believe he can win it all.

  • Natural soulful talent

  • I so don't care if he wins. Don't get me wrong, I want him to but as long as he comes out with music is all that matters. I love love love his voice. He is one of a kind and I've loved him since he auditioned. I'm sooooo happy he has made it this far.

  • this guy just sang one of my favorites song of my bery favorite singer george harrison, in my opinion he sang it better than Eric Clapton, this guy rules

  • He's been my favorite since the beginning. I hope he wins and Melanie comes second, Rachel third.

  • JOSH HAS TO WIN HE HAS RAW NATURAL TALENT, AND WE NEED IN THIS SHITTY TIME OF MUSIC !!!!!!!!!!!!!!

    i love ya josh you're amazing!!!

  • He should be the one to win, Melony has a voice i've heard a million times. Josh's voice is legendary.

  • Comment removed

  • @ffemt8 *melanie

    and I totally agree with you

  • Josh will go all the way

  • 11 people are crazy!

  • Hurry Xfactor and finish so we can get some Josh music out there to buy!

  • Diamond of the first water...

  • my heart melted when I heard this. I JUST FELL IN LOVE WITH HIS VOICE!!!!!

  • if josh doesn't win i kill myself !!!!!!!!!! but first i kill nicole to give him bad songs =/ why didn't she give him songs like this oneeeeee!??!? ohh! soo good T_T

  • @1990milu oh come on...none of that now

  • @MerchantofTarshish pff if you don't like my comment just don't read it and that's it, and if you don't like josh get over it and find something else to watch =S

  • 10 ppl have clearly got wax in their ears or are music deaf..........

  • OMG what a voice, luv this version over original ooo:)

  • All pale in comparison to Josh.

    Freakin awesome. Brilliant. Josh ftw!

  • He reminds me of Joe Cocker a loot. Spectacular!

  • Josh has gone global - people love him, his voice, his passion...he a real guy - down to earth and isn't arrogant about his abilities and talent...you gotta love a guy like this...

  • LOVE HIS VOICE AND TONE!!

  • Whooa, somehow my response to this video was posted on Forever Young,, not sure what happened there. Anyway, Josh, I really liked Elvis's version of this a lot, but you are every bit as great on this one!

  • Josh is an uber masculine hunk and his voice is beautifully raw!!! Said he would win from the first audition.

  • HIS VOICCCCCCE OHHH OH OH HIS VOICE! YES!

  • He rules... so much feeling in his performances.. Reminds me of the intesity of Joe cocker.

  • George Harrison is happy.

  • people not knowing this song just makes me wanna live in another planet....

  • HE IS THE FUCKING MAN! MY FAVORITE PERFORMANCE YET! JOHN, YOURE VOICE IS ORGASMIC

  • he is the best !!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • josh, it's not an option for me either

  • where is the repeat button?

  • I F*ing love josh krajcik!!! 

  • He nailed it. His voice really got down into the "I don't know"s and nailed it!

  • powerful ass voice. i hope he makes it all the way, and then beats out marcus canty in the finale (credit to canty for singing "im singing this song to you", didnt know he know it)

  • I loved the guitar parts. He is an emotional singer. I love his voice and the way he raises it.

  • The crowd just pisses me off!! STFU and let the guy sing.

  • this amazing !!!! i love it!!!!

  • Damn he gave me goosebumps. i love his voice so soulful :). They are all good. I'm glad I'm not a judge LOL

  • a little karaoke from L.A. Reed? HAHAHA...I never heard the Beatles sing it like that before! That was deep, soulful and original!

  • JOSH FOR THE WIN!!!

  • we love Josh!!!

  • easily the best singer on this show

  • i think you he is soooo handsommm

  • Dear Josh, I'm a lesbian. But ... I'm in love with your cute lil smile & your FUCKIN AMAZING voice ...so uh ...will you marry me ?

  • Comment removed

  • Este é o vencedor. 

  • Who is this by.. oh.. THE FREAKING BEATLES.. jeez.

  • WOT IS THE SONG CALLED PLEASE

  • @annaelise14 It's in the title. Something by The Beatles.

    And it's spelled WHAT

  • this was his best performance... He needs to just be on stage an sing.. stop all the props.

    I also sense a bit of arrogance which I dont like! seems like sorta an asshole

  • @Kdential He's not, He's a really really nice guy. He just likes to do things his way. And by him having that way of thinking, it has made him a really awesome guitarist and singer because he knows what he wants in life. Can't wait until after xfactor is over and people can see how awesome he is by doing his own thing and writing his own lyrics. Vote for Josh!

  • @Kdential IMHO, his demeanor doesn't say that at all. There is no arrogance visible to me, just a man confident in his musical ability. You're assuming a lot, and you know what they say about that word, right?

  • On this song he sounds ALOT like eddie vedder.

  • When I hear this guy sing, I swear my I've never heard someone better in my life, he makes something inside me just feel good, and I'm a guy!

  • i know this is a beatles song and all...but this is a lot better than the original!

  • This must be the winner of X Factor !!!!!!!!!

  • whats the name of this song

  • From watching the show, here are my thoughts on the remaining 4. Chris seems to be taking his talents to the limit and most people seem to like him so I think he is going to win it. Can't believe Marcus is at the bottom every week because he along with Melanie are next in line with the crowd. Josh is also a very talented musician as well as a unique singer but I don't like most of his song choices. Josh should sing that first song he song at the auditions that the audience acknowledged him for.

  • @JonnEarl What? You want him to sing it over and over again. Sorta lame, in my opinion, and I do disagree. His song choices were brilliant. Of course, he was constricted by not being able to do his own music, but that was a good decision on his part

  • @juajen2000 Yep, I could listen to it over and over again, and do, But with all of his performances, it's as if we have an album, plus I love his original songs. An artist like Josh doesn't come along that often . A lot of us recognize this and are really enjoying his emergence. I am among millions, you know?

  • kgiu

  • This is a legendary kind of talent, not just some fly by night good singer.

  • This is one of my favorite songs already, but Josh did a great job of performing it. Loved it. I know he will be a big star. One of my favorites from the beginning along with; Rachel, Chris, Marcus, Melanie, Stacy & Leroy.. keep up the good work Josh.

  • this guy is special. i don't care what he looks like, his voice hits my ear like no one else today. he is what's missing from my music collection. today's music needs a voice like this.

  • He has a lot of soul in him.

  • caught between him, Chis Renee,. and Nicole messed up this week with Rachael.

  • @PepperPicaboo i think She needed to go...Nicole did a good thing to put it to a deadlock which sended Rachael home

  • Love him and will buy the cd, but

  • Wow...It's really sad for those of you who don't recognize someone for their God given talent. I would rather hear/see someone singing from their soul than a pretty boy/girl who practices in front of a mirror. I know that's not the reality of the world and that is a shame!! Go Josh

    .......Cheers

  • I have to admit that this guy made a really good version of that grat beatle song.

  • this music is f@#$%¨...! love, love....!

  • Chive ON JOSH!!

  • Wow. very very good version of an amazing song.

  • Chris rene to win .Josh look like a vampire when he sings

  • some haters on here have too much time on their hands. I love Josh...regardless of the outcome of the show, he ought to get signed, and I'll be buying his music.

  • Josh was the clear winner from the day he auditioned. He's had a couple hard genres to deal with this week and last week. But besides that nobody stands up to him.

  • I listened to big bit 12 times on repeat.

    Thumbs up if you want Josh to win! :D

  • Comment removed

  • Is this a beatles song?

    

  • @Draidic - yes

  • @Draidic Yes...yes it is a Beatles song :)

  • that little girl rachel should still be here..but sherzinger didnt have the kohanas to vote off marcus, now i gotta listen to that weasel sing for another week, but for the love of w.e god you beleive in, please please vote for josh, a very talented man with an amazing voice and this could be his last chance to make it big, so dont jew him he deserves it, vote this dude to win!

  • outstanding

  • Wow he gave me the chills, he is my new fave!

  • absolutely amazing

    

  • I think Chris Rene song's lyrics were a little bit too boring.... Where do we go from here repeated and repeated and repeated and repeated....and repeated again and again .Was that really great? ....Did Simon said GENIOUS????? Sorry I don't understand that.

    What I think is Simon wants Chris to take some votes from Josh so Melanie will have more chances. GENIOUS!

  • @mariasegap22 Simon and L.A. are trying to play mind games to discredit Josh so they will be guaranteed one of theirs will win. They really don't give a damn about the performers, it is all about their egos, and they want to win....they are seeing this as a contest between them.

  • now that rachels gone, josh is going to be under constent critisism from simon.

  • @WrathofAqua They will go after Josh with a vengence, so we have to vote with furiosity for him.

  • I never heard this song until that performance, his version is amazing

  • @abmthe3rd How had you never heard this song before?! Were you under a rock? Lol The Beatles!! :)

  • Dude looks like Shrek.

  • @KJVIDS82 really?? i think he's beautiful. mean people suck!!

  • Josh Should Win Melanie Second

  • This dude is a badass. I mean seriously the guy is incredible. VoteVoteVoteVote

  • woody8878, GET OFF MY MAN DI#K. Chris know who and what he is, and hes doing his thing. Get off your knees and wash your face, i know what your about

  • Comment removed

  • Whatever happens in this tv show, I want to buy his CDs/songs right away!! What a voice!!!!!

  • Regarding Cocker similarities, the field where music and musicians are created is well threaded upon after so many years of easy availability to listen and view via radio, TV and now the internet, to find a completely new style and sound, well it can be done but seldom is, but true genius is rare in any field such as a Steve Jobs, Beatles (Lennon / McCartney) etc

  • If we had as many onion fumes in our eyes as Josh has, we would be wide eyed at times and tripping on onion acid too. Melanie is acting too cool, forgeting she was nowhere a month or so ago, time for Josh to take the win based on talent and keeping real to the fact he isnt there yet. Melanie thinks she is Witney or even better than her already. Go Joshua go

  • Krajcik's had it, hands down since he auditioned. Any other result is fickle.

    Most singers pick songs and you wait to hear it and see how you like it. With talent like Josh you HOPE he covers this or that song you know his voice would work with. It's a big difference.

  • Simon get out of the sandpit you are making a mockery of your own show. If it was not for Josh I would have switched off He is a true gentleman and has amazing talent. We are sick of your inappropriate comments grow up

  • @vicpur agreed! it's not about Simon and his giant ego. If Josh goes, we go. Simple as that. Josh is the ONLY reason I watch this show. Never watched it until Josh auditioned.

  • @LolaPolamalu I totally agree. If Josh goes simply because the voting was "disappointing" and people have a gripe with Nicole...then this has ceased to be a talent show and I'm not on board to watch The Simon and Nicole Show. I'll be through with it and will never watch it again.

  • You are magic Krajcik and it's great that the X-factor found you and you it cause now we all get to bath in your talent*

  • The best 4 contestants are left now, and by next week there will be 3, Josh, Chris, and Melanie. I love them all. I love Josh's voice and style, Chris' originality and songwriting and Melanie has a beautiful voice as well. Any of them can win, but i think they will all have recording contracts in the future, as a matter of fact i think any or all in the top 7 could have recording contracts.

  • Love the Krajcikmagic.

  • i would pay to hear him sing! his voice is so powerful and moving. i love all the contestants but josh had me at "the first time ever i saw your face". Wow!

  • Love Josh. Will buy his music. Cant wait till this is over, Xfactor is cruel to the contestants.

  • People are honestly talking about not voting for him to avenge Rachel? Jesus christ, what fucking children. This is a life changing event, don't jip him because of something he had no control over. Also you shouldn't even be mad at Nicole because you didnt even fucking vote for Rachel in the first place.

  • He is in a league of his own. LOVED IT!!!

  • Josh has done a mighty fine job of this song! I honestly think that his version is slightly better that The Beatles although The Beatles are amazing and i love them but Josh Krajcik just sounds amazing and soulful. Josh has done The Beatles proud and he 100% deserves to win this competition. All that needs to be done now is him doing a full version so we have more to enjoy.Oh and to the Judges THE SHOW IS ABOUT THE CONTESTANTS NOT YOU SO STOP ACTING STUPID AND ACTUALLY LISTEN TO THE CONTESTANTS

  • @123aliciakeys The Beatles were famous for pioneering their genre, their arrangements, and lyrics. They had no vocal talent that stood out whatsoever. It was their musical concepts that displayed their genius. Josh can just plain sing the heck out of just about anything. Amazing natural talent. Young Joe Cocker without the drama-hopefully.

  • @hiccup32 beatles had no vocal talent???? what did you smoke?

  • @hiccup32 yes, the Beatles were famous for pioneering, their arrangements, and all their lyrics but they also had amazing vocal talent. I think you must have the wrong Beatles or something because the one you just described sounds nothing at all like The Beatles i know with John, Paul Ringo and George.

  • hes sexy

  • I changed my mind. MELANIE WILL WIN IT

  • Josh is amazing. His voice is so unique and instantly recognizable. the only problem I have with him is that I don't really like looking at him. I guess you have to be a total package to make it in this business and I just don't think he will go all the way. I think it will be between Melanie Amaro who is so one of the best singers on this show, Chris Rene, the most commercial, and Rachel Crow, the dark horse who can take it all.

  • @1mondavia2 And the shallowest comment of the day goes too..

  • @1mondavia2 Cocker was weird looking, it doesnt matter when your super good, just take a look Susan Boyle

  • @1mondavia2 How old are you? I have a deep appreciation of manly men, and he is one. Obviously a lot of people agree with me. I could look at him for hours, and do. Of course, I am also listening. Thank you, you tube.

  • Last night I almost got an orgasm from listening to him singing.

  • I think he is more Bob Seger than Joe Cocker

  • Sorry but I am not a fan of Josh haven't liked anything he has done> I am also a huge fan of the Beatles and that was a bad version of the song in my opinion. Melanie is going to win it all

  • @themuskokan Do you not like MUSIC?

  • @themuskokan lol go to church motherfucker to go hear melanie sing

  • @themuskokan You have taste for shit.

  • @themuskokan WOW..you really must be either crazy or death because Josh has an extremely unique voice and well Melanie just needs to go back to church with her voice..yes shes good but good is where it stops but Josh, Josh is far beyond good, he s amazing.

  • voten por un artista completo, sin artificios de maquillajes, vestimentas, escenografias y bailarines, una voz que trasmite emociones que estamos escasos de esos y en esta competencia solo existe uno: josh krajcik

  • Josh has some of the same vocal qualities that Bob Seger and Joe Cocker have with his own unique sound and style too

  • @themuskokan This song was written by George Harrison. I am sure he would have loved to hear Josh sing it, and most likely John would have loved it too.

  • john lennon is rolling over in his grave at this lousy performance

  • @themuskokan How was this lousy? It sounds exactly as it was intended.