Though I am a Hindu, but I have lot of respect for Sikhism and Sikhs. There are some people who want to create devide between two for thier personal interests. Those who are inteligent does not get influenced by such selfish people. I love my nation first, then my religion!!
What a load of Bull. Prof. Darshan singh is RSS . He is now a Hindu . All he is trying to do now is find faults in Sikhism so he can divide the SIKHS. He is a puppet of the Fascist Hindu govt. Why did he not speak out when he was Jathedar . ? He thinks
he has greater insight then Baba Deep Singh or Baba Nand Singh ji. He is A TRAITOR . KHALISTAN ZINDABAD.
@CalSingh Because those compositions have been agreed to be included into Nitnem by the Panth, not by the Granth (not DG, I'm talking SGGS) - obviously because they are not in the Guru Granth Sahib, and Guru Gobind Singh had every opportunity to include them into the Guru Granth Sahib.
As well, Guru Gobind Singh ji left me with the Guru Granth Sahib, I have no right to circumvent his decision, even if some "Jathedar" tells me to, because Guru made the decisions clear already.
@gaganjisinghji In DG Ragi = Rogi maybe this is why this Rogi is so upset.
But question for you is that when & Where Guru Gobind Singh Ji said "Guru Manyo Granth and where is the Bier (SGGS) which was given gurship ask this Rogi and let me know another follower of Rogi told me Bhai Mani Singh lost it and I could only laugh at the stupdity of the follower of Rogi Panthi's.
Following of Guru Granth Sahib comes ltr show me the proof that Guru Granth was given Guruship and where is this Bier?
@WarriorOfSSF Gur Fateh ji, you need to research: Narbud Singh
When there's enough evidence and the timelines make sense from all angles (i.e., when the observance was done, who else documented it, the age of the document). This was decided by vidhvan and the Guru 100 of years ago.
As well, if Guru Granth Sahib ji is not your only Guru then the panthic parvaan Sikh Rahet Maryada means nothing.
@WarriorOfSSF Stop patronizing me sir. It's easier to discuss when the other person is at least speaking politely. The answer to your quesion is Narbud SIngh, I have no need to baby anyone through it. Please do your own research. Especially if I have to deal with so much attitude... Take care ji...
@W That's where I'm happy we have the Guru Granth Sahib to compare all other 'dharmic/historical' texts with. Any other 'bani's' which were instated by Panthic Vidhvan 65 years ago are respected by Sikh's and I'm happy they made the decision what to and what not to include into the Sikh lifestyle. Thankfully the analogies the Guru Granth uses are not stories but exist in real life and can relate to me. That's where the Guru has given us gian to differentiate between its bani and "kachi" bani.
How many days you need to read it and become a vetenary doctor? If you can't do it than it's not sampooran. And now this type of attacks will come from RSS and it's also a FACT Darshan Rogi is working for RSS
You are questioning the Guru Granth Sahib now... Please re-read the shabad by Guru Amar Das ji...
> Khalsa was made Guru 1st than comes SGGS so which is the actual Gur?
SGGS ji and all previous Guru's are refered to the same Jyot/Sooch. The Bani is the Guru, and Guru Arjun Dev ji was only working on one scripture; Guru Gobind Singh ji was only to give "Guruship" to one Scripture, as it contained the Bani based on the same Jyot/Sooch.
Thankfully there is the Guru in every household, a Sikh does not worship the Guru Granth cause of its historical significance, he/she worship's it because it's a means to an end (i.e., how else would you pass on a message).
In this case, the divine word of the Guru (i.e., that jyot - that higher perspective of thinking).
In addition, Sikh's are not fond of "yatra"; let the Guru's bani be your "yatra"... as the Guru says.
That's definately not an answer to my question, this is purely running from the question. I know how much juice you guys have plus my comments on the approval. LOL
Sorry, I don't really understand. You are trying to prove a point, but I don't know what it is. Could you please be clear of your intension?
This video discusses agencies like RSS and their followers who believe Sikh's are but Hindu's and should follow what the Hindu's say... But we are talking about something else.
Please reiterate what this has to do with what your intensions are... Thanks.
Respect for elder? A person who's actually working and present memer of RSS and infact barks at my Guru deserve no respect, double face serpents should be shot in the head.
Your channel "GuruManyoGranth" or you operating it and from gaganjisinghji you are commenting, that's also label as being double face serpent.
Ekis Ke Barik is the organization your elder barking dog is member of and his co member Chela Ram insulting SGGS Ji everyday, why he don't stop chela ram?
In a weeks time I've resolved my issue how about this NUT CASE self proclaimed professor resolving his issues on mental imbalance ?
He calls himself DOG of the GURU but when a DOG goes MAD he/she starts to bark at his owner is such cased DOG is shot in the head BUT Idiots like you make him Guru and start to follow a MAD DOG. You need to resolve ur own issues, come back when u two are down with them.
hindu only ever meant from india..it is a name given to bhartatiyas from persians!
if by hindu you men an ARYA no Sikh is not hindu! however brothers remember that nanak was born an arya!
this is simple why all the arguments..argue with govt of india ..not aryas! and the arya samaj is wrong in its version of Sikhs! enough i love you sikhs very much and it pains me these silly arguments! we are all bharatiyas ..thats all hinu ever meant..from BHARAT nothing more!
you are a very brave man,one against many, others have bowed to the rss and badals, you are now the only thorn in ther arse, first they bought the dasam granth to the for ground and callender , wish you was 50 years younger as we need leaders like you. in 20 years punjab will be ruled by hindus and peyers from behar, badal has destroyed punjab more then any one in 300 years as his distroyed the youth (seed) of punjab with his bjp daddys
The false book was given different names at different times in the following order:
a) Bachittar Natak
B) Daswen Patshah ka Granth
c) Dasam Granth
d) Sri Dasam Granth
e) Sri Dasam Granth Sahib
f) Sri Dasam Guru Granth Sahib
These names are very misleading, and the pity is that these have been given by individuals, small organizations or publishers who wish to confuse sikhs.
prof..darshan singh is true khalsa of sri guru gobind singh ji.......prof saab carry on with ur good work.....waheguru hor kirpa kare tuhaade te....bole so nihaal...sat sri akal...
The talk of changes in Nanak Shahi Calender IMHO is a grave mistake as it compromises the independent identity of Sikhs it will dilute Sikhism as a unique &distinct religion free from the ill effects of Benaras Ke thugs Brahmins of Varanasi . The Sikhs can now celebrate all their events independently without any directions from BRAHMIN DEVTAS of Benaras . If any changes are made Sikhs will again have to look towards wily Brahmins who set Bikrami calender & follow their directions all over again
bhut hee jaroori point chukey gaye ney,,,,,, ghatu ghat hun ta oh lauk samaj jaan ke ke prof. darshan singh ji ik chanke sikh ne te jo kuchh kardey b ne uh b sikhi layee hai,,, ki eh sare point kise jathedaar ne ya kisi akhunti sant ne chukey??? nahi uh ta app hee RSS de cholichuk ney,,,,,, jago khalsa ji, jo sikhi layee datt ke parchaar kardey uhna da sath deo,,,,,,
Prof Darshan jee well said!
vikchillz 4 months ago
Though I am a Hindu, but I have lot of respect for Sikhism and Sikhs. There are some people who want to create devide between two for thier personal interests. Those who are inteligent does not get influenced by such selfish people. I love my nation first, then my religion!!
narendersharma72 7 months ago
@narendersharma72 yes..you are right brother.. i am sikh...i am totally agreed with you... they speak because they need money and publicity...
randassy 4 months ago
Prof. Darshan Singh Khalsa ji is a living legend of sikh kom
Bachitersingh100 8 months ago
Anyone who dislikes this = supports the actions of the RSS in India against the Sikh's...
gaganjisinghji 9 months ago
CalSingh challenge to Darshan Lal
CalSingh 9 months ago
Prof sahib ur true warrior of Sikh religion , hes very knowledgeable preacher. It's sad that we as sikhs have not recognized that
njzen1 11 months ago
What a load of Bull. Prof. Darshan singh is RSS . He is now a Hindu . All he is trying to do now is find faults in Sikhism so he can divide the SIKHS. He is a puppet of the Fascist Hindu govt. Why did he not speak out when he was Jathedar . ? He thinks
he has greater insight then Baba Deep Singh or Baba Nand Singh ji. He is A TRAITOR . KHALISTAN ZINDABAD.
jatsher2 11 months ago
Sikhs are not hindus how long it will take for everyone to understand this simple thing??????????
aman1967 1 year ago
Comment removed
thescorpionking2020 1 year ago
well said prof saab
bostonbiker 1 year ago
@Crusaderdeluxe what u want to say?
neekmischa 1 year ago
Prof.Darshan Singh ji Khalsa thankyou.
shah13punjabi 1 year ago
singh sahib prof.Darshan Singh ji,i respect you,thakyou for info.
shah13punjabi 1 year ago
Alas
gagan1730 1 year ago
RSS are terrorists
jagsinrags 1 year ago
If you guys disagree with Sri Dasam Granth why do you recite Jaap Sahib/Chopai Sahib...
CalSingh 1 year ago
@CalSingh Because those compositions have been agreed to be included into Nitnem by the Panth, not by the Granth (not DG, I'm talking SGGS) - obviously because they are not in the Guru Granth Sahib, and Guru Gobind Singh had every opportunity to include them into the Guru Granth Sahib.
As well, Guru Gobind Singh ji left me with the Guru Granth Sahib, I have no right to circumvent his decision, even if some "Jathedar" tells me to, because Guru made the decisions clear already.
gaganjisinghji 1 year ago
@gaganjisinghji In DG Ragi = Rogi maybe this is why this Rogi is so upset.
But question for you is that when & Where Guru Gobind Singh Ji said "Guru Manyo Granth and where is the Bier (SGGS) which was given gurship ask this Rogi and let me know another follower of Rogi told me Bhai Mani Singh lost it and I could only laugh at the stupdity of the follower of Rogi Panthi's.
Following of Guru Granth Sahib comes ltr show me the proof that Guru Granth was given Guruship and where is this Bier?
WarriorOfSSF 1 year ago
@WarriorOfSSF Gur Fateh ji, you need to research: Narbud Singh
When there's enough evidence and the timelines make sense from all angles (i.e., when the observance was done, who else documented it, the age of the document). This was decided by vidhvan and the Guru 100 of years ago.
As well, if Guru Granth Sahib ji is not your only Guru then the panthic parvaan Sikh Rahet Maryada means nothing.
Guru bakhsish veerji...
gaganjisinghji 1 year ago
@gaganjisinghji It's strange that you guys know how to ask questions but don't know how to answer and I don't think you have answered me here.
You want to try one more time?
"Reha Piari mujh ko, Sikh piara nahi..." Keep dis obeying, you've earned it.
WarriorOfSSF 1 year ago
@WarriorOfSSF Stop patronizing me sir. It's easier to discuss when the other person is at least speaking politely. The answer to your quesion is Narbud SIngh, I have no need to baby anyone through it. Please do your own research. Especially if I have to deal with so much attitude... Take care ji...
gaganjisinghji 1 year ago
@gaganjisinghji Yea when we hear so called Older wise men saying "Kanjer Granth, Kanjer Kavita" etc ect that's quite polite, sin't it?
WarriorOfSSF 1 year ago
@W That's where I'm happy we have the Guru Granth Sahib to compare all other 'dharmic/historical' texts with. Any other 'bani's' which were instated by Panthic Vidhvan 65 years ago are respected by Sikh's and I'm happy they made the decision what to and what not to include into the Sikh lifestyle. Thankfully the analogies the Guru Granth uses are not stories but exist in real life and can relate to me. That's where the Guru has given us gian to differentiate between its bani and "kachi" bani.
gaganjisinghji 1 year ago
@gaganjisinghji In other word like the owner of this channel u'll say it's "Smapooran Guru"?
It's the questioning at the Guru by idiots that tomarrow world will point fingers and there is no kachi bani, there is no such thing.
WarriorOfSSF 1 year ago
@WarriorOfSSF
No, not like the owner. My Guru said it's sampooran. I don't need anything else.
My Guru answers in this shabad:
it is a short link --> ow.ly/d/9Sg <-- it is a short link
gaganjisinghji 1 year ago
@gaganjisinghji
How many days you need to read it and become a vetenary doctor? If you can't do it than it's not sampooran. And now this type of attacks will come from RSS and it's also a FACT Darshan Rogi is working for RSS
WarriorOfSSF 1 year ago
@WarriorOfSSF You know what veerji. You win. I've realized this is a waste of my precious time, I'd rather be listening to Gurbani... Gur Fateh ji!
gaganjisinghji 1 year ago
@WarriorOfSSF The Guru Says: ਇਕਾ ਬਾਣੀ ਇਕ ਗੁਰ ਇਕੋ ਸ਼ਬਦ ਵੀਚਾਰ
Let the Guru answer your questions...
GuruManyoGranth 1 year ago
@GuruManyoGranth
Didn't Guru Ji made Khalsa his Guru and became Chela of his Khalsa. So how it's ਇਕ ਗੁਰ ?
Khalsa was made Guru 1st than comes SGGS so which is the actual Gur?
WarriorOfSSF 1 year ago
@WarriorOfSSF
> ਇਕ ਗੁਰ?
You are questioning the Guru Granth Sahib now... Please re-read the shabad by Guru Amar Das ji...
> Khalsa was made Guru 1st than comes SGGS so which is the actual Gur?
SGGS ji and all previous Guru's are refered to the same Jyot/Sooch. The Bani is the Guru, and Guru Arjun Dev ji was only working on one scripture; Guru Gobind Singh ji was only to give "Guruship" to one Scripture, as it contained the Bani based on the same Jyot/Sooch.
gaganjisinghji 1 year ago
@gaganjisinghji Where is this orginal Swaroop? Please direct me to it so we can do darshan of this orginal Bir.
WarriorOfSSF 1 year ago
@WarriorOfSSF
Thankfully there is the Guru in every household, a Sikh does not worship the Guru Granth cause of its historical significance, he/she worship's it because it's a means to an end (i.e., how else would you pass on a message).
In this case, the divine word of the Guru (i.e., that jyot - that higher perspective of thinking).
In addition, Sikh's are not fond of "yatra"; let the Guru's bani be your "yatra"... as the Guru says.
gaganjisinghji 1 year ago
@gaganjisinghji
That's definately not an answer to my question, this is purely running from the question. I know how much juice you guys have plus my comments on the approval. LOL
WarriorOfSSF 1 year ago
@WarriorOfSSF
Sorry, I don't really understand. You are trying to prove a point, but I don't know what it is. Could you please be clear of your intension?
This video discusses agencies like RSS and their followers who believe Sikh's are but Hindu's and should follow what the Hindu's say... But we are talking about something else.
Please reiterate what this has to do with what your intensions are... Thanks.
gaganjisinghji 1 year ago
@gaganjisinghji
Well if you are back to the point.
Well this Barking Dog (Darshan Rogi) himself has been given a dog bone by RSS and operator of this channel seems like is you (gaganjisinghji).
WarriorOfSSF 1 year ago
@WarriorOfSSF Thank you, that's what I was interested in knowing.
> Well this Barking Dog (Darshan Rogi)....
I believe you need to listen to the video again and try to contrast what you are saying and his point of view. It is not what you have said above.
In addition, it seems you have no respect for anyone elder than to you. I would work on that...
> and operator of this.....
Yes, I do support his efforts, more than anything I have done. Otherwise I wouldn't be here supporting his message.
gaganjisinghji 1 year ago
@gaganjisinghji
Respect for elder? A person who's actually working and present memer of RSS and infact barks at my Guru deserve no respect, double face serpents should be shot in the head.
Your channel "GuruManyoGranth" or you operating it and from gaganjisinghji you are commenting, that's also label as being double face serpent.
Ekis Ke Barik is the organization your elder barking dog is member of and his co member Chela Ram insulting SGGS Ji everyday, why he don't stop chela ram?
WarriorOfSSF 1 year ago
@WarriorOfSSF Wow buddy, I think you got some issues to resolve. Take care...
gaganjisinghji 1 year ago
@gaganjisinghji
In a weeks time I've resolved my issue how about this NUT CASE self proclaimed professor resolving his issues on mental imbalance ?
He calls himself DOG of the GURU but when a DOG goes MAD he/she starts to bark at his owner is such cased DOG is shot in the head BUT Idiots like you make him Guru and start to follow a MAD DOG. You need to resolve ur own issues, come back when u two are down with them.
WarriorOfSSF 1 year ago
@WarriorOfSSF BAHOT THIK KEHA VEER JI , U R 100% RIGHT YEH SARNA TE DARSAN KUMAR KHUD HI RSS DE BANDE NE
66LOVEPREET 11 months ago
Anti Sikhs whether is parramjit sarna or darshan.
gurukakookar 1 year ago
NICE Prof Saab.... Keep it up
bostonbiker 1 year ago
hindu only ever meant from india..it is a name given to bhartatiyas from persians!
if by hindu you men an ARYA no Sikh is not hindu! however brothers remember that nanak was born an arya!
this is simple why all the arguments..argue with govt of india ..not aryas! and the arya samaj is wrong in its version of Sikhs! enough i love you sikhs very much and it pains me these silly arguments! we are all bharatiyas ..thats all hinu ever meant..from BHARAT nothing more!
so lets stop the SEMANTICS!!
WORLDARYANREVIVAL 1 year ago
Khalsa ji proud of you. Tell us what to do next. Raj karega Khalsa
fuckhindubitch 1 year ago
If the RSS leadership has said this, they need to change their leadership and change their philosophy.
tomtomttom 1 year ago
people in akahl takht have distroyed every thing and only take orders from badal,
balgill 2 years ago
you are a very brave man,one against many, others have bowed to the rss and badals, you are now the only thorn in ther arse, first they bought the dasam granth to the for ground and callender , wish you was 50 years younger as we need leaders like you. in 20 years punjab will be ruled by hindus and peyers from behar, badal has destroyed punjab more then any one in 300 years as his distroyed the youth (seed) of punjab with his bjp daddys
balgill 2 years ago
The false book was given different names at different times in the following order:
a) Bachittar Natak
B) Daswen Patshah ka Granth
c) Dasam Granth
d) Sri Dasam Granth
e) Sri Dasam Granth Sahib
f) Sri Dasam Guru Granth Sahib
These names are very misleading, and the pity is that these have been given by individuals, small organizations or publishers who wish to confuse sikhs.
Dolly0rkut 2 years ago
@Dolly0rkut
u talking about dasam granth
tu menu mill te me tenu hi mislead kara deha
karamjit7 1 year ago
Wah Khalsa Ji the way you have describe Sudharshan Kumar words, No one couldn't explain in that depth
We have to say you are (prof. Darshan Singh Ji) is only one person in this age taking the step in Sikhi step, jeon praani jal bin haai marta
bmandur 2 years ago
prof..darshan singh is true khalsa of sri guru gobind singh ji.......prof saab carry on with ur good work.....waheguru hor kirpa kare tuhaade te....bole so nihaal...sat sri akal...
300khalsa 2 years ago
RSS is one of the biggest enemies of India as they violate Indian Laws at same time RSS is giving Hindus a bad image ---- Peace
fukraadmi 2 years ago
bahut vadhia pro.sahib ji dattey raho pakhandi sahmney
TheMultisadh 2 years ago
Prof. Sahab, Sudarshan is not Sardar. watch your words at 1:42 of this vdo
Singh01699 2 years ago
The talk of changes in Nanak Shahi Calender IMHO is a grave mistake as it compromises the independent identity of Sikhs it will dilute Sikhism as a unique &distinct religion free from the ill effects of Benaras Ke thugs Brahmins of Varanasi . The Sikhs can now celebrate all their events independently without any directions from BRAHMIN DEVTAS of Benaras . If any changes are made Sikhs will again have to look towards wily Brahmins who set Bikrami calender & follow their directions all over again
dalbirk 2 years ago
Wah Prof darshan Singh ji tuhadi daleel ton ashke jaan nu jee karda hai, par inah baajian da ki kareiay jihrhe sade te kaabaj ho chuke ne.
harnekification 2 years ago
bhut hee jaroori point chukey gaye ney,,,,,, ghatu ghat hun ta oh lauk samaj jaan ke ke prof. darshan singh ji ik chanke sikh ne te jo kuchh kardey b ne uh b sikhi layee hai,,, ki eh sare point kise jathedaar ne ya kisi akhunti sant ne chukey??? nahi uh ta app hee RSS de cholichuk ney,,,,,, jago khalsa ji, jo sikhi layee datt ke parchaar kardey uhna da sath deo,,,,,,
yaarjabbowalia 2 years ago