20080112 超級偶像@黃文星和曹格合唱-世界唯一的你

[like830825]

百分之百的模仿 斜音滑音ˇ都學

可是老蕭已經改了

你呢..... 你應該也要改的

[like830825]

沒特色 百分之百不紅

[Bruce868686]

請曹格來沒有叫他獨唱....這節目在想什麼

[TheJoofy]

覺得他在模仿蕭敬騰

[DarkViper30000]

曹格，楊宗緯，萧敬腾 都係唱歌大师哋。

[kyo1223]

黄文星的唱法好老腔哦~还是曹格好听~！！！

[vincentkllam]

曹格唱的一句：就算上天下地（３：２１～３：２４），　一句就顯出他天王級的功架了。。。　黃文星唱得不錯，　但像曹格說，　太多影子了。我理解曹格的像誰像誰的那一段話，其實就是暗示黃文­星沒有自己獨特的口音了吧。。。　還有唱錯歌詞，　巳經很大的錯誤了。。。　還說超偶之光呢。。。　有一點點保留，　不過也不能不說，　算唱得不錯了

[kittyleung1026]

我覺得阿京的比較感人

[w22130155]

黃文星感覺像在學蕭敬騰

[julia28p]

@w22130155

看你這樣一講還真的有點像欸

[crymeariver1]

黄文星的声音太低了，唱得没有那么好。那时芸京唱得比较好听。

[good373844]

曹格最後是想說他比楊宗緯帥吧......

還好沒講出來.

[shen2feng1]

haha..弱。。

[tea550]

曹格怎麼一臉不太甘願的樣子

可能覺得身為歌手跟節目參賽者合唱 很無趣吧

[Ginneyet]

Gary just try to follow Wong....

don't you down graded Gary...

[93421623]

那頭髮有點台喔

[xiaoliu321]

I still find Jam's version better..More powerful. But this version is also good too.

[procrastinatingpig]

love ZhangYunJing ang Jam's version..haha. incomparable :)

[yaahoo12345]

不過我想聽原版~

[chankato1231]

平心而論...蕭敬騰係星光唱個首~世界唯一的你~ 好聽唔知幾多倍... 震撼程度直頭無得比呀...

[long10717]

黃文星最高音沒到位

導致後面也都沒到 曹格合音功力再高都救不了XD

話說曹格竟然說的出這種話= =a

[buaysong]

cao ge is being too nice

[cc1164]

He totally lost the feeling of wholesome because he tried to combine Jam and Gary and Aska together. The result is bad,

[wongnyappong]

wen xing sing like uncle..

[jinglebelle2009]

rofl~ I read ya comment n watched the vid. I agree with u XD

[sumfinunique]

wen xing in drama love or bread looks so much like gary... haha

[ascncblue]

評審.....

主持人.....

連曹格的評語.....

真瞎

應該是照製作單位是先發好的稿子唸的吧

[iamdemvp]

not enough feel... but defintely got range

[kingyup]

曹格在最後一段不敢飊高音...

飊了,一定會蓋過黃文興.

不飊,又怕黃文興會破音.....

[procrastinatingpig]

Gary曹格 is my love ^^. hahaha!!

[kingyup]

很明顯在3:12,Gary的表情是在問:你到底行不行啊?

[richardkwok0128]

真的呀*口*||

不過黃文星唱得算是不錯的啦

[vicfreak99]

文星lost weight man.

go see the 超级偶像新年特别节目he look really really handsome compare to last time.

he improved alot.

go 文星!!! :)

[hkkwai21]

黃文星...唱這個很老蕭的感覺...

還有...他唱"你是我的眼"..也很像yoga跟銘偉的混合.­..

[z0972317765]

這樣就節目高潮了??

[Freeze123789]

這個什麼黃文興喔 ..

唱得還好阿=　=

[wuhahahahah]

说文星模仿萧的人都是没有认真听过看过文星唱其它歌的人.他一直­如此投入

[wwekanegreat]

模仿蕭敬騰?  蕭敬騰有這麼難聽嗎?

[SantaComingToTown]

no. listen to his other performances, his vocal different from this. 1.46-1.48 listne to that and xiao's one and you will see.

[p753159]

why do some of you insist he's copying jam's voice, instead of accepting the fact that some people have similar vocal

[hoyun]

wow, no harmony at all.

either of them know how to 唱和音

[calsberg]

其實像蕭的聲音也是有西方的陰影.. 唱歌本來就或多或少會有模仿的時候.只是看你能不能模仿而加入自­己的風格讓人聽出有不一樣的歌聲.而黃文星,我覺得他未能成功找­出自己的曲風,所以讓人覺得模仿.而且最主要的是技巧方面的運用­有,可以很聽得出就是蕭所創出的. 這方面黃應該加以改變,

[bb623824]

這明明再摸仿 痾...當我們都沒聽過簫唱的嗎 不要騙別人更不要騙自己 這樣超偶就很強嗎 不過是走人家走過的路 懂唄～

[a577427]

文星不管唱台語歌或國語歌

都有自己的特色~

絕不會去刻意模仿誰

他是憑自己的實力獲得第二名的

超偶1每個都很可愛 我們永遠支持~ 加油!

[VeryLike5566]

黃文星模仿蕭敬騰

這太明顯了吧.....這裡不是模仿大賽...ok？

沒創意還可以得第二名

操嘔實力可見一般......

[candy4127]

文星唱的不錯啊!很難得有人可以台語國語都唱得有水準的!

[SantaComingToTown]

i think gary speak too kindly. 黄文星 can never sing like Yang Zongwei and Xiaojing Teng and Gary. 黄文星 can never sing the way like Zongwei. Zongwei's singing has lots of emotion and touched many people but 黄文星 did not. 黄文星 also does not have a thick and strong vocal like Xiaojing Teng. He will never reach the level of these 2 singers.

[tmnews2008]

又沒人在跟蕭敬騰比，要比要跟曹格比吧= ="

愛支持誰就支持誰，何必特別來說別人模仿?有聽過他唱其他歌的歌­聲嗎???

那我還想說星光整個節目看起來氣氛不舒服，主持人感覺很討厭(要­說誰都可以說)，請問感覺如何?

[rockhwd]

他很明显是在模仿萧敬腾吧?其他歌我不懂,但至少这首肯定是..­.

[tidus1804]

其實還不錯聽

每個喜歡唱歌而去唱歌的人都有自己的夢想阿

何必在那邊比來比去呢

曹格幫文星注入一顆震撼彈了

接下來就看文星如何使用

[gigihowhow]

文星天生聲音就不錯聽~

渾厚充滿男人豪邁~

[jibikao]

Mmmmm, I don't like 黄文星's style. It's too "straight". There is no emotion at all. Better than Yang and 蕭? Oh please... he is good but not THAT good. Gary is much better. His voice is so smooth.

[aNXie1y]

damn sick, another imatate dude sounds like 蕭敬騰. To be frank his voice doesn't sounds comfortable, it just sounds so annoying.

[yomisun]

不喜欢黄唱的，有点做作哦。曹格唱的好听。

[ttoomm00002]

模仿蕭敬騰嗎??

其實捧的太高耶!言過其實

少了星光的那種真實氣氛

應付的比較多!!

[iamboy100]

曹格說的話真的太客氣了一點了吧......

不過他畢竟都是原唱者...

如果說黃文星的歌比他好的話就真的有點誇張啦

只是個人感覺

[seanliucool]

那些拿來比較的人 都是王八蛋  我也比較喜歡蕭敬騰

但是 每個唱歌的人 都有自己的夢 他沒說比蕭敬騰強

他來參加比賽 他至少實力都比你們這些批評的人好= =

[94501023]

唱的真的很棒

[greenmango77]

learned of to admire to enjoy to appreciate.

[hippokathy88]

the thing i like about wen xing is hes rarely offtuned in his performances

[luohanju]

黄文星唱歌那么直，歌的线条都没有了。。。

[p740427]

傻眼...想說來看看超偶的參賽者唱的怎樣..

結果 有失望到 星光2有好幾個已經跟1班差很多了

沒想到超偶更虛 曹格太謙虛了

他是我覺得目前線上的歌手實力超強的一個

當然 蕭的未來我也很看好 這個人想學....差的遠勒

[diy650530]

這首歌被蕭敬騰詮釋過後已成經典

回去看蕭版的之後.覺得他們.....

沒辦法就是沒辦法.但是還是加油

[assassins8740]

黃文星的台語歌比國語歌唱的好

他用台灣國語唱起"背叛"

聽的不是很蘇糊~功力也平平

個人認為星光的"終極背叛三人合唱版"(曹.蕭.楊)

那才是經典中的經典

無人能出其右

[xcxcz123]

如果蕭是100分他只有5分

[iceland1119]

totally....真的是摹仿蕭敬騰的太~~過了!! =_=

曹格跟那個人(can't remember the name)真的是雲泥之差

[airhealth]

感覺前面都很好，只是副歌飆高音的時候跟曹格完全沒有融合在一起­，會覺得有點小吵，3:09 - 3:20 特別明顯。不過還是唱得很好啦。

[celina214]

Copycat....Copy Jam's singing style of this song.This Mr.Huang's vocal and power are not strong enough to do Jam's technique of portamento/slide.When he forced himself to do the slide,his ending of that sentence is very unstable.Too far away from Jam's level.

[tsaiwangsky]

Celina,

哇 你從星光轉戰到超偶來了

真的耶

我又回去聽Jam的版本

真的是無人能比

私訊給你

[celina214]

Jam's unique and uncomparable.Jam's great because he's got his own style and not copying anyone. That's why he always remains in everybody's heart.

Gary added a lot to this guy's performance.

[ifyouleavenow]

我覺得文星唱得很好喔,加油喔^^

[yyccc1618]

i agreed with chang520wow. don't you think 蕭 sings all kind of songs with same skill? people will get tired of listening to him if he keeps using the same skill. the way he sings, he might damage his good voice soon.

anyway, 蕭 is still young, he might improve his skill later.

[yyccc1618]

he sings much better than 蕭, 蕭 has good voice, but 黃 did better on skill.

[iamkys2003]

那個黃先生聽起來在唱蕭敬騰的版本

要當歌手還是要有些個人風格才好

[winsonpower]

如果蕭是98分他只有28分

[qszwax92]

他的聲音好像故意模仿蕭ㄟ 雖然我不是消迷聽起來感覺

[yanalo]

參賽者高音有點勉強....gary is good

[chang520wow]

蕭的Vocal POWER很夠,不過這整首歌有溫柔有堅定,感覺蕭在唱這首歌太­過賣弄歌唱技巧,聽起來很像把橡皮筋拉緊的感覺,雖有彈性,但是­感覺就是很緊,至於感情就不用說了,感覺不到.

[180cm20cc]

高音部分沒上去

曹格和稀泥有掩護的嫌疑

說比你曹格唱得好我沒意見

但把別人拖下水

聽眾不是沒有耳朵

[oris1665]

差差差....差敬騰太多ㄌˇˇ

[Hahayayayo]

he's pretty good, definitely better than average~

but gary's voice i dun't think anyone can compete! just like jj's and jay's unique styles in singing.!

[seahorse333]

I like Gary's voice

[shineluvslambiel]

比較想聽曹格獨唱

這位黃先生說實在唱的有點難聽耶

[david90531]

Gary's still the best. Love his voice

but this guy sings pretty good too! props

[ericchiou2004]

很讚!

[owenlee1241]

雷文20080126！他下一集将会唱霹雳迷城的-与我争锋-分­数很高！值得期待！林宗兴的师傅既然是杨培安！

[weien19812001]

很瞎~評審也很瞎~

[el850211]

but gary is still the most suitable singer for his own song...

no one is better than him....

the contestant sang too loud d, like wanted to fight with gary...hehe :P

[kay1812]

參賽者模仿蕭敬騰模仿得太凶了吧

[700Galant]

沒辨法，蕭敬騰的唱法已成經典。

[xevie37x]

did anyone leave in this episode?

[ksyting]

no...

[woo83]

pretty good!!!

[wenyen813]

gary有收

應該是想讓黃文星表現吧

黃文星好像還不錯

第一次看超偶就有注意到他

但我比較想聽曹格跟蕭敬騰版

[ndylau]

如果有蕭曹版那就真是太太太好了....

我好想聽

[smwsabrina]

Gary got really big heart, he supports others who might become his competitor. He should be respected for this.

[smwsabrina]

Gary is the best ! Although the other guy got potential but Gary sing with his heart. Gary has more feelings.

[steadyfastest]

JAM is the bast////

They are all good!^^

[zax52010]

gary...整個幽默到!!!

我...個人想法啦!!

gary整個太讓了...(蕭敬騰也會這樣!!)

有點搭不起來!!

gary很深情.黃文星太衝....

[sanngee]

gary is the best singer....

dun cry again.....

i will support u 4ever.....

[yauming2nd]

gary did great..tat guy wasnt

[912911]

Well done!

[owenlee1241]

兄弟说得没有错！但是在现场唱可是有很大的压力，敢和曹格合唱要­不少勇气啊！再说,他唱到中间（第三段）自己的味道出来啊（就算­上天下地-就算世界于我为敌）=自己的味道出来了！曹格也称赞阿­~~~~~~~

[HEIZIZI]

說得好聽是會用歌曲的優點唱

難聽就是在抄嘛..

有好的唱功就應該試試加入自己的特色在裡面

兩頭不到岸

真失敗

[dotkyo]

that guy is so lucky to have gary sing with him... and encouragement from gary.. awesome.. not bad.. cept he was kinda unstable

[pehsher]

amazing...gary...

[owenlee1241]

很好听！很会运用歌曲的优点唱！开此唱，是你~~（就是应该常出­来）很像萧敬藤的感觉。但是接下来听（中间部分）又有些扬中伟和­自己（黃文星）的感觉（耳目一新），最厉害的是唱到最后的用曹格­的音唱完（收尾音）！

一句话说完-棒！难怪曹格说它是3位一体=萧敬藤+杨中伟+曹格­！这句话说得一也不假！

继续支持你！！！我爱超级偶像~