It turns out (but it's not at all obvious) that the number of times a voter is critical in winning coalitions is equal to the number of times he/she is critical in blocking coalitions.
My book doesn't say anything about blocking coalitions. It says the way to find the Benzahf power index is to find every possible winning coalition. Count up the number of times a single player is critical in those winning coalitions (X), and and then count up how many times ANY player is critical in a winning coalition (Y). X/Y = the answer. Not a word about blocking coalitions.
Is that wrong, or will it lead to the same answer as what you're getting with your method?
It turns out (but it's not at all obvious) that the number of times a voter is critical in winning coalitions is equal to the number of times he/she is critical in blocking coalitions.
HamblinMath 5 months ago
My book doesn't say anything about blocking coalitions. It says the way to find the Benzahf power index is to find every possible winning coalition. Count up the number of times a single player is critical in those winning coalitions (X), and and then count up how many times ANY player is critical in a winning coalition (Y). X/Y = the answer. Not a word about blocking coalitions.
Is that wrong, or will it lead to the same answer as what you're getting with your method?
afterapplepicking 5 months ago
Thanks so much! Was really helpful info.
Ohemgee35 6 months ago