judge the quality by its price.. if you want something very great, just spend 2.3 million USD and feel please to own a veyron. this economically cheap car is just to transport people from one place to another. if you want nothing worst than benz's quality but low price just proton, for god sake, you'll never get it. the thing that differentiate between men and animals is the ability of thinking but not saying.
hey top gear... try making a test on satria neo lotus r3 version and try to see can a honda or mini copper beat it. .. i bet yu will not take this callange .. cause yu know that satria neo lotus version can do the job.. come to malaysia to pick it up ..
I'm a Malaysian I won't felt disgrace that our Malaysian cars were criticized by foreigners. Simplest example, even the cars are produced by our own country, yet it's selling higher price than the cars exported to foreign countries. What is government thinking ? The foreign cars' tariff is much higher, 200% tax imposed to Mercedes-Benz, BMW ? It sucks, government sucks.
i think Proton Satria Neo, Perodua Myvi, Chevrolet Aveo car maker should stop send car to they country.
They should pull the plug for Land rover sale in malaysia because the price it so high many people in malaysia can't afford it.The malaysian people could american car that the euro car.i would american cars like gmc, Chevrolet,Cadillac and Buick.They have nice interior,exterior and fully of technology like onstar intergrated on the car and other feature and safety are more completed.
hahhaha...to tell ya the truth..i agree with what those top gear trios says....you buy that not because its cheap and affordable...its just u havent try any other than these...hahahah protong oh protong....wat a disgrace...LOL :-)
For someone's information, Perodua Myvi is the best selling car in M'sia because there is no other car left for Malaysian to choose from. If you are sound enough to do a research, you will find out that Malaysian imported cars are the most expensive amongst ASEAN countries. In a nut shell, Malaysian bought Myvi not because the like it, because they are forced to buy it (since there are only two cheap car brands in Malaysia, when I say cheap, I mean both inexpensive and low class.)
@nadalstephen And You calling me a dickhead coz I am blaming Malaysia cars and not engineers? For your information, a product reflects its manufacturer. So the main problem is not those engineers coz THEY ARE HIRED!!! If Proton and Perodua are not exploiting you and me, THEY WOULD HAVE HIRED PROFESSIONALS!! So think before you write.
even imma malaysian i have to agree with those comments.. the "rubbish" parts as well as the "its a sunny day, put the visor down" part.. HAHAHA.. a big LOL for PROTON!
Jeez guys, ease up a little. It's just a program for laughs. They are known to be morons at time just for the fun of it. I guess you guys never watch Top Gear much huh, well except for this episode cuz they have MALAYSIAN cars in it. I reckon all these energy will be more useful if channeled towards the reformation of our country which will then, stop producing shitty cars. On the side note, I have 2 myvis and a proton at home. They serve me well. Cheers.
Although I own an Proton MPV called Exora, but I had fed up with the stupid features, like the plastic dashboard, cheap leather seat, powerless engine and I also face a problem of the broken air-cond that cannot control the temperature in car. So as a result, Proton is a rubbish manufacture that was copying the Japanese car.
All you Malaysians in the comment are just making Malaysia look bad. The reason people buy local cars is because of the government charging high taxes for foreign cars. They said its to help the local car industry. Well, they are if they can make the cars any better. Protons and Peroduas are just a tool, not something to actually enjoy having. Nothing special about them. They are designed to satisfy one purpose: transport people from one place to the other.
I'm a bruneian and I own a satria neo and bmw f10..to be honest my satria neo still in great condition since i bought it last year and i never replace anything from it..while the f10 always have problem even i've just bought it last february..now the f10 still in workshop..now,im using my satria anywhere i go..so,basically for me..the proton and japanese car is much better than those european car..haha..no offense,its just my opinion..sorry for the grammatical error..
klau nk dibanding kn dgn kereta2 mlysia ngan luar negare mmg x setanding.. coz mlysia mmg menghad kan enjin berkuasa kuda yg tinggi bagi perkadaran jalan di mlysia.. dengan itu sepatut nye mlysia harus lah menaik kn cukai pada negara2 luar.. bagi besaing dari segi ekonomi.. oleh itu sekira nya kereta2 mlysia mengeluar enjin yg berkuasa tinggi jgn lah kerajaan mengambil tindakan bagi kepentingan negara sahaja..seperti menghad kn enjin yg di cipta oleh kilang PROTON, oleh itu demi maruah negara...
man2012ism do you have problem with me ~! ooo well i am a noob... ur a big fucking moron who just happen to know everything .you claim to be" Malaysian" ... oo big woop. I hope u are a Malaysian ,it's guys like you i would not mind ramming my car into ...just for the fun of it.....hehehehe
kumarg83 do you have problem with me ?? grammatical correctness? this is just a comment box bro ... are you expecting me to fuckin essay or something ??
so what ? Perodua Myvi is the best selling car for 2006, 2007, 2008 and 2009 in Malaysia.. why? Malaysian LIKE it :) we bought the car tat we affordable..
I don't mind. But I am happy that Malaysia actually have our own brand. So its okay. I don't really care what those Brits want to say. Cause in the end if you like it you will buy it. Hehehe.
no wonder brits are such ass.... considering the Malaysian market and the brits market there a big different ..... u want a to compare Ferrari and neo ....aiyoo big difference la u can't be askin scissors door to be put on a neo crazy ar... anyway i am malaysia a proud melayu ... all of you rich freaks can just SUCK IT~!!!
no wonder brits are such ass.... considering the Malaysian market and the brits market there a big different ..... u want a to compare Ferrari and neo ....aiyoo big difference la u can't be askin scissors door to be put on a neo crazy ar... anyway i am malaysia a proud melayu ... all of you rich freaks can just SUCK IT~!!!
@prosdi36 With that attitude there's no wonder our cars are that bad. It's a surprise Proton gets away with charging such prices for such substandard quality. Face the facts, those cars were awful, even by Malaysia's poor car manufacturing standards. No-one can argue with that. Can I also ask you to please post with some measure of grammatical correctness? Your poor standard of English (and your out-of-context exclamation "i am malaysia...") is just embarassing to yourself and the country.
@prosdi36 well, first of all your english sucks. What a noob . Im a malaysian, and i do admit that car manufactures in Malaysia are sucks. They only making cars to make money. The standard here are still very inferior. Sigh. Btw, please open up your mind prosdi. That kind of mindset will lead you nowhere.
I'm Malaysian and i gotta say, i was offended during the first few mins but after that I realized we should embrace this criticism. Whatever they said are true. We need to improve way more than this, why protect an inferior good?
proud to be malaysian... all malaysian is for drag used fools.not on the road...coz we modified more then u know... so , important things your car is not suitable in our country.. AND OUR IS NOT SUITABLE TO YOUR COUNTRY. thats all...
Maybe Malaysia should consider buying another British Motor company...oh...is there any left ? or are the Germans and Japanese and Chinese queueing up up to buy more junks from the UK ? Wheres their Rovers...heard its bought by the Chinese and recycled to another car. Maybe Clarkson should review their es Rovers-turned-tractors...hahahahah
cheap!!! satria neo is a rubbish cause compare to ford fiesta, how much it cost ya?? plastic car....hahahaha...that's what happen to malaysian when they want to buy a new car....sooo sadddd
"I'm not sure it's going to do the acceleration that the M3 does" - WTF is that?! sheessshhh ladies.... -.- it's so obvious that there is a large gap in power, lol. These brits are pure idiots. How can you ever compare cheap cars with super cars? It's like comparing an ant to an elephant..... The maths is simple, more cash = more speed = more quality = more comfort. Do the maths people, who the hell would sell a car with high quality, lots of speed and good comfort for a cheap price?
u also must understand, we malaysians are hyper sensitive to criticism, which is why our cars, or anything else thats malaysian made, will NEVER improve. thats a fact.
actually u people don,t know about this so just don,t make all the MALAYSIANS angry please if u are making a episode of PROTON please do nice episodes not about the disadvantages of this cars
fuck.. they are comparing with BMW M3 n BMW X5.. satria neo and myvi is compact car n cheap car.. not like BMW.. their car is expensive car..stupid top gear!!!
JEZZA YOU'RE THE BEST,really im 110% agree with this review because it should be look at these cars they all rubbish unlike usual city car for example Ford Fiesta,Opel Astra,VW Golf,Peugeot 206.All of these cars still have "the joy of driving" but these two malaysians crap car is more like "the misery of driving" they just hideously rubbish.PROTON AND PERODUA YOU ARE HOPELESS
i prefer Morris Marina or soviet cars than these two shameful cars
sebenarnya kereta Malaysia tidak perlu mainkan sentimen kenegaraan sebabnya jika mereka(PROTON N PERODUA) 'BENAR2 JUJUR' dalam membuat kereta dan bidang2 yang lain pasti rakyat akan berbangga jika barangan Malaysia lebih canggih dari luar negara. Memang susah untuk keluar produk tambahan pulak semua itu dikawal oleh golongan 'bukan orang Malaysia',nak paten enjin perlukan kelulusan puak2 ini,tambah nak buat sebijik kereta..
cipta kete baru yg terbaek..gegar kerajaan suruh mintak org2 yg bodoh menganggur tu bekerja buat keta..apelah bengap sgt kerajaan nie..dlu malaysia takdela haprak cmni..la ni sume msalah timbul....bikin keta tahap international punya..ni keta haprak kau jual luar negara ape la bodoh kepala hotak.kau..pastu kena maki 1 malaysia malu tau tak..jgn bagi setan2 mat salleh ni m'perlekehkn kita..kalau akn dtg still mcm nie ..ade lagi baik cipta satu keta mainan buatan m'sia..pastu import
@radhio8tive tak mudah , susah bukan sume orang bley buat keta, kitorang suma tahu , bukan kau sorang je tahu...habis drpd remaja melayu kte tak keje , pastu merempit elok dye bekeja buat kete ke motor ...sape kte aku nak keta kt malaysia ni mahal , aku pun nak keta kt malaysia ni murah ..aku pun bknya berduit pun..pkirla skit nak jual biarlah barang baik..biar keta kte bagus tak kne hina..ini buat sambilewa body tin sardin..pkir biar jauh jangan buat bodoh je..
Corruption, Malaysia's Government is protecting the companies with tax. Import car in Msia is 60-120% taxes, we have no idea but to afford the local car manufacturer of Proton and Perodua.
Malaysian failed to make a real car..body is an exact copy of Mitsubishi or some other Japanese cars but with zero performance and also the engines are made in Japan and imported to Malaysia..for Malaysian people if u don't know that proton car is quite cheaper outside ur country ,,i hope u will stop making cars and start to get Toyota or Nissan and with 5% gov tax only..it will sound nice..
today i watched this episode of top gear on one of malaysia tv channel, and guest what, they cut this part of the section....lol, they trying to hide the truth...hahahah
I would agree on the Satria Neo. The first time I saw (and sat in) it, I was suprised on how cheap the interior is. For a 1.6L car, it sounds and act slow. Cheap plastic, a heavy door with a malfunction window and of course, the aftermarket tank cover is all but a classic Malaysian car. We have such a big tax on car but somehow try as we want, we cannot deny the fact some of us, the 1st car will be a PROTON
i think there no problem with the CEO or engineer of proton or perodua, i think its a problem of the malaysian government. If they wanna make a good car, it will need lots of supply's. can malaysian government give this supply? and the government dose something really stupid. by selling the car to the local with a higher price to cover the cost, that they sell outside the country.
hm.. I'm Malaysian too. Yes I admit that Malaysia car is cheap and easily spoiled. But please all of western/asian or Malaysian(self country people) don't always scold about Malaysia's products. Please respect Malaysia products and I also respect all of the things which made by other countries.
All of you must know this moral: Please respect the things or people which are come from foreign countries. People who don't know how to respect then that means they don't have family education.Cheers :D
@tingxyu If you want people to respect you then build something that worth other's respect, you gain respect from others, not by begging it. Cheers.:D
@tingxyu ts not about morals n respect.this is a car review show and they say what they think...whether its a crappy or nice car they will say it as it is.and thats what u watch the show for ryt?
this is just fuck-up..I'm Malaysian..i think i can design cars better then those who design "The" Malaysian cars..damn..and guess what..these cars are going to rust in few years...
What's with the comment saying "Najib is stupid" . If he is, I wanna see you run the goddamned country Whatever it is, if you dont like the cars, you have a choice not buying it.
you Malaysians must realize that these guys are not wrong to criticize your cars. I studied in Malaysia and got my first hand experience with these peroduas, protons and nazas. Some of the worst cars I've driven and when I found out that they're actually selling these cars at a cheaper price OUTSIDE the country, I thought these companies are downright mad! Please, for the sake of basic human safety, improve your cars!
@almaraiman never mind them close minded lot. I'm a malaysian and I will never go near a proton/perodua. All they care about is ripping of the rakyat(citizens)
don't fight each other by this kind of video... they were telling us the truth that there are a lot more better car in the world.. but we need to realize that not all nations worldwide really need a car as super duper as they prefer.. and each nation in the world has their own need.. if malaysian car is bad, improve it.!
and i think british are one of the most fussy nation in terms of choosing their need.. haha.. by the way, this is what makes the world to be awesome.. hahaha (^^,)
diorg(malaysia) yg buat kete ni nk duit jer...tambahan plak kepentingan politik pun ada...mmang hampeh la jadinyer... membuat kereta tiada keiklasan langsung utk rakyat nye..aku sndri pkai BMW E46 318i..bru btul2 iklas...open ur mind rkyat mlysia..
i don't need to buy a proton car to know tat it is fucking cheap and lousy! Proton cars are never in my sight. My first car is a Mercedes Benz C-200 and it's fucking reliable and awesome!
I could not understand what are your objective to make this video , if your are saying Proton is bad , then .. give them some time , they maybe could make this car better in future , if you're professionals , but for you information , professionals do not insult about low quality car , or maybe not even low , professionals comment and tell that what to do .. so , you're not ! and ! If you saying Protons car are not safe enough , ask Princess Diana do Merc are safe enough ?
No point in swearing, you do get what you pay for, I bought a Proton Savvy just about the worst car I have bought in 50 years of motoring, we kept it for twelve months, how I just do not know, you would be desperate to thinking Proton could make a decent motor, they can't.
@salmanfarruz at least we still have our own carmaker company. we just need more time to develop our products. blame on CEO or engineer of proton. they need a radical changes in their company structure. its has nothing to do with najib. dont be so stupid.. you mixed up politic and other things. huh
Do the people of Malaysia to buy their own national car, national car is no quality of the high price? while the national car in Malaysia to sell overseas at a low price? at least if the quality of the national car is not improved, why not lowered prices of their own country? till garbage collector at overseas can buy proton impian, i mean in malaysia proton waja......
hmmm..ever seen this 3 dudes in any F1 match ....naaaaaaaaaa
applecinnamonflower 2 months ago
Proton has like 7+ crony vendors just for one car part for one model. The vendors themselves drive BMWs :D
Aggrofool 2 months ago
Racing stripes on a stupid proton Satria Neo? I'd better buy an old AC Cobra 427.
scuderiaferrari2008 2 months ago
you know what?we need to spent rm400k for damn audi TT in malaysia!we can get even r8 in in US fuck govermrnt!!
amars93 2 months ago
You want cheap and cheerful, try the 2012 Hyundais.
betatalk357 3 months ago
judge the quality by its price.. if you want something very great, just spend 2.3 million USD and feel please to own a veyron. this economically cheap car is just to transport people from one place to another. if you want nothing worst than benz's quality but low price just proton, for god sake, you'll never get it. the thing that differentiate between men and animals is the ability of thinking but not saying.
TheThex115 3 months ago
Love the long face!!
V3gard 3 months ago
fuck malaysian cars, they r not safe at all, o%.
MrThebek 3 months ago
Clarkson like Bugati Veyron.. So buy that ass..
shahril24rz 3 months ago
we are paying overprice cars due to the taxing of cars. Ask any malaysian MYVI, proton are their last choice because we do not have a choice.
thenokiagallery 3 months ago
40 people forgot to deploy their cheap and cheerful parachute.
Abus709 4 months ago
hey top gear... try making a test on satria neo lotus r3 version and try to see can a honda or mini copper beat it. .. i bet yu will not take this callange .. cause yu know that satria neo lotus version can do the job.. come to malaysia to pick it up ..
bintikwala 4 months ago 2
@bintikwala you sound so pissed lol
nadalstephen 2 months ago
@nadalstephen yes i am..
bintikwala 2 months ago
monkeys from canary wharf drive M3s..something's terribly wrong :)
kubek555 4 months ago
Comment removed
kubek555 4 months ago
I'm a Malaysian I won't felt disgrace that our Malaysian cars were criticized by foreigners. Simplest example, even the cars are produced by our own country, yet it's selling higher price than the cars exported to foreign countries. What is government thinking ? The foreign cars' tariff is much higher, 200% tax imposed to Mercedes-Benz, BMW ? It sucks, government sucks.
reidyee 4 months ago
what we want? ASTON MARTIN!!!!
rafalexpx 4 months ago
Land rover sale in malaysia are rm 200k to 500k.
in here you can get beautiful and luxury house...people would thing a few time to buy it.
soebardini94 4 months ago
i think Proton Satria Neo, Perodua Myvi, Chevrolet Aveo car maker should stop send car to they country.
They should pull the plug for Land rover sale in malaysia because the price it so high many people in malaysia can't afford it.The malaysian people could american car that the euro car.i would american cars like gmc, Chevrolet,Cadillac and Buick.They have nice interior,exterior and fully of technology like onstar intergrated on the car and other feature and safety are more completed.
soebardini94 4 months ago
@soebardini94 dude englishhhh!
leonardlim10 4 months ago
for malaysian car i prefer protons coz they have more quality..
BMS5621 4 months ago
hahhaha...to tell ya the truth..i agree with what those top gear trios says....you buy that not because its cheap and affordable...its just u havent try any other than these...hahahah protong oh protong....wat a disgrace...LOL :-)
dengdeng80 4 months ago in playlist @PROTON
For someone's information, Perodua Myvi is the best selling car in M'sia because there is no other car left for Malaysian to choose from. If you are sound enough to do a research, you will find out that Malaysian imported cars are the most expensive amongst ASEAN countries. In a nut shell, Malaysian bought Myvi not because the like it, because they are forced to buy it (since there are only two cheap car brands in Malaysia, when I say cheap, I mean both inexpensive and low class.)
TheKeithoh 5 months ago
@TheKeithoh dickhead we're not asking your choice, but blaming the fake Malaysian engineering. how can these people do that ??
nadalstephen 2 months ago
@nadalstephen And You calling me a dickhead coz I am blaming Malaysia cars and not engineers? For your information, a product reflects its manufacturer. So the main problem is not those engineers coz THEY ARE HIRED!!! If Proton and Perodua are not exploiting you and me, THEY WOULD HAVE HIRED PROFESSIONALS!! So think before you write.
TheKeithoh 2 months ago
The door rubber of the Chevy Aveo came off just like that ??!!! Worst than our Proton cars LOL... And he called it the Perodua 'Mivi' :].
ale03000 5 months ago 3
Comment removed
ale03000 5 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Which season and episode is it?
karolzet 5 months ago
Comment removed
karolzet 5 months ago
up to you all what you like ha ha ha....
Samatalun 5 months ago
all comments is so funny ha ha ..........
Samatalun 5 months ago
even imma malaysian i have to agree with those comments.. the "rubbish" parts as well as the "its a sunny day, put the visor down" part.. HAHAHA.. a big LOL for PROTON!
wafadzel 5 months ago
Lol Malaysians please look at your English. Please brush up your English before arguing with British.
lanjiaojibai123 5 months ago 5
well the Satria Neo got help from Lotus i think. it should be a rally car because the car is plasticky but pretty light
sarconista 5 months ago
shit cars made by shit people
the9darkknights 6 months ago
this episode taught us to change for better if you think positively. it funny & i learn somethin about car!!
mssite 6 months ago
Jeez guys, ease up a little. It's just a program for laughs. They are known to be morons at time just for the fun of it. I guess you guys never watch Top Gear much huh, well except for this episode cuz they have MALAYSIAN cars in it. I reckon all these energy will be more useful if channeled towards the reformation of our country which will then, stop producing shitty cars. On the side note, I have 2 myvis and a proton at home. They serve me well. Cheers.
hamchel 6 months ago 2
@hamchel i guess ur life kinda sux
xXDiUNiXx 6 months ago
geez.. now i'm officially turned to korean cars
gameznunux 6 months ago
Although I own an Proton MPV called Exora, but I had fed up with the stupid features, like the plastic dashboard, cheap leather seat, powerless engine and I also face a problem of the broken air-cond that cannot control the temperature in car. So as a result, Proton is a rubbish manufacture that was copying the Japanese car.
lovemobilenavi 6 months ago
All you Malaysians in the comment are just making Malaysia look bad. The reason people buy local cars is because of the government charging high taxes for foreign cars. They said its to help the local car industry. Well, they are if they can make the cars any better. Protons and Peroduas are just a tool, not something to actually enjoy having. Nothing special about them. They are designed to satisfy one purpose: transport people from one place to the other.
symustafa1996 6 months ago 28
@symustafa1996
u are absolutely right!!
nobody want proton or perodua if they can afford another brand..
phklucas7 3 months ago
malaysia cars is really expensive and useless
DBC5499 6 months ago 11
@DBC5499 Jangan malukan negara sendiri mat..Kalau mampu guna kereta luar, jangan dok bantai kereta negara sendiri.
zophindudeke 2 months ago
Please respect stupid
zerozuas 7 months ago
Owh my goodness..i think this show just plain stupid!!
Thats the whole reason why the cars are cheap..it were made purposely cheap, and its called affordable cars!!! just plain stupid
milomice 7 months ago
Don't forget these people drive Lambo's and the like, and they still find their flaws. So yeah... I think you catch my drift.
precisionkid 7 months ago
I'm a bruneian and I own a satria neo and bmw f10..to be honest my satria neo still in great condition since i bought it last year and i never replace anything from it..while the f10 always have problem even i've just bought it last february..now the f10 still in workshop..now,im using my satria anywhere i go..so,basically for me..the proton and japanese car is much better than those european car..haha..no offense,its just my opinion..sorry for the grammatical error..
kuchiki511 7 months ago 5
@kuchiki511 your gay bmw r better and u prefer ur shit box man u need an doctor
bmw4lfe 6 months ago
@bmw4lfe well yeah..my bmw are gay..thats why i prefer using my worthy "shitbox"..than worthless and wasting money bmw..
kuchiki511 4 months ago
klau nk dibanding kn dgn kereta2 mlysia ngan luar negare mmg x setanding.. coz mlysia mmg menghad kan enjin berkuasa kuda yg tinggi bagi perkadaran jalan di mlysia.. dengan itu sepatut nye mlysia harus lah menaik kn cukai pada negara2 luar.. bagi besaing dari segi ekonomi.. oleh itu sekira nya kereta2 mlysia mengeluar enjin yg berkuasa tinggi jgn lah kerajaan mengambil tindakan bagi kepentingan negara sahaja..seperti menghad kn enjin yg di cipta oleh kilang PROTON, oleh itu demi maruah negara...
koze1991 7 months ago
what a fool trio
madinime 7 months ago
hahaha...banyak pakai meterial plastik pun jual mahal kat negara sendri..
azamL200 7 months ago 2
man2012ism do you have problem with me ~! ooo well i am a noob... ur a big fucking moron who just happen to know everything .you claim to be" Malaysian" ... oo big woop. I hope u are a Malaysian ,it's guys like you i would not mind ramming my car into ...just for the fun of it.....hehehehe
prosdi36 7 months ago
kumarg83 do you have problem with me ?? grammatical correctness? this is just a comment box bro ... are you expecting me to fuckin essay or something ??
prosdi36 7 months ago
Comment removed
prosdi36 7 months ago
so what ? Perodua Myvi is the best selling car for 2006, 2007, 2008 and 2009 in Malaysia.. why? Malaysian LIKE it :) we bought the car tat we affordable..
from : Malaysian
alson04 7 months ago
@alson04 Yea, because it's Japanese in the first place.
ClubbySuperCharged 7 months ago
I don't mind. But I am happy that Malaysia actually have our own brand. So its okay. I don't really care what those Brits want to say. Cause in the end if you like it you will buy it. Hehehe.
khairaoul 7 months ago 3
V8, not G8! Hit the banks, not our tanks! Wow, didn't know Jeremy had such good protesting lines.
primeholyassasin20 7 months ago
how the fuck did I get here from a black ops video O.O
TheCrazy135 8 months ago
Holden FTW
TheCrazy135 8 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
no wonder brits are such ass.... considering the Malaysian market and the brits market there a big different ..... u want a to compare Ferrari and neo ....aiyoo big difference la u can't be askin scissors door to be put on a neo crazy ar... anyway i am malaysia a proud melayu ... all of you rich freaks can just SUCK IT~!!!
prosdi36 8 months ago
no wonder brits are such ass.... considering the Malaysian market and the brits market there a big different ..... u want a to compare Ferrari and neo ....aiyoo big difference la u can't be askin scissors door to be put on a neo crazy ar... anyway i am malaysia a proud melayu ... all of you rich freaks can just SUCK IT~!!!
prosdi36 8 months ago
@prosdi36 With that attitude there's no wonder our cars are that bad. It's a surprise Proton gets away with charging such prices for such substandard quality. Face the facts, those cars were awful, even by Malaysia's poor car manufacturing standards. No-one can argue with that. Can I also ask you to please post with some measure of grammatical correctness? Your poor standard of English (and your out-of-context exclamation "i am malaysia...") is just embarassing to yourself and the country.
kumarg83 8 months ago
@prosdi36 well, first of all your english sucks. What a noob . Im a malaysian, and i do admit that car manufactures in Malaysia are sucks. They only making cars to make money. The standard here are still very inferior. Sigh. Btw, please open up your mind prosdi. That kind of mindset will lead you nowhere.
man2012ism 7 months ago
stupid comparison... proton / produa is low cost car manufacture... how you can compare to Lamborghini, ferrari or mercedes..?
encore86 8 months ago
look at what they're driving over there at britain and what we have here in malaysia
turbovolution 8 months ago
I'm Malaysian and i gotta say, i was offended during the first few mins but after that I realized we should embrace this criticism. Whatever they said are true. We need to improve way more than this, why protect an inferior good?
thelcfkilla 8 months ago 3
you know what, asian is smaller than you......thats why its created like that....
mrheadshooter 8 months ago
BUY BRITISH LAST......
csi2malaysia 8 months ago
i want malaysian cars to be in videogame such as gt5 or need for speed
SuperGangsta96 8 months ago
haha "lavishly equipped with doors" James is so funny
macbookusrkid 8 months ago
Ask them to do review on Satri Neo R3 and Myvi SE.....
XxBbOyZ92xX 8 months ago
@XxBbOyZ92xX
sure, pay 80k for a r3 when you can get a civic si for 70k once you factor out the unfair taxes levied against foreign mfg's...
DeepFriedPotato 8 months ago
@XxBbOyZ92xX
they'll still rate them as crap simply because a civic si at 70k, once u factor out the retarded unfair tax advantage proton has, > a r3 at 80k
DeepFriedPotato 8 months ago
That Satria Neo has a lot of potential.. Just look at the Rally version!!!
Karl2294 8 months ago
proud to be malaysian... all malaysian is for drag used fools.not on the road...coz we modified more then u know... so , important things your car is not suitable in our country.. AND OUR IS NOT SUITABLE TO YOUR COUNTRY. thats all...
TheAsrizal 8 months ago
Proton since 1985..now 26 years old..Honda,proton more than 100years..so i,m proud with proton just 26 years,proton can built they own design...
mushaddah7987 8 months ago
british babi
Paiseh9521 8 months ago
Maybe Malaysia should consider buying another British Motor company...oh...is there any left ? or are the Germans and Japanese and Chinese queueing up up to buy more junks from the UK ? Wheres their Rovers...heard its bought by the Chinese and recycled to another car. Maybe Clarkson should review their es Rovers-turned-tractors...hahahahah
poppytiger 8 months ago
cheap!!! satria neo is a rubbish cause compare to ford fiesta, how much it cost ya?? plastic car....hahahaha...that's what happen to malaysian when they want to buy a new car....sooo sadddd
samarendang 8 months ago
" I would rather be inside Paul Scholes"
hahahahaha
heyblackmoore 8 months ago
"I'm not sure it's going to do the acceleration that the M3 does" - WTF is that?! sheessshhh ladies.... -.- it's so obvious that there is a large gap in power, lol. These brits are pure idiots. How can you ever compare cheap cars with super cars? It's like comparing an ant to an elephant..... The maths is simple, more cash = more speed = more quality = more comfort. Do the maths people, who the hell would sell a car with high quality, lots of speed and good comfort for a cheap price?
bmfairuz 8 months ago
Keep in mind people, Aston Martin is owned by a Malaysian company...
codemonkey711 8 months ago
even i dont like the malaysian car..1 accident sure 40% u will get survive...but wat to do...the TAX is so HIGH for import car!
mcenro3 8 months ago
even i dont like the malaysian car..1 accident sure 40% u will get survive...but wat to do...the TAX is so HIGH for import car!
mcenro3 8 months ago
u also must understand, we malaysians are hyper sensitive to criticism, which is why our cars, or anything else thats malaysian made, will NEVER improve. thats a fact.
wallyboy79 9 months ago 2
actually u people don,t know about this so just don,t make all the MALAYSIANS angry please if u are making a episode of PROTON please do nice episodes not about the disadvantages of this cars
247faizal 9 months ago
malaysian
dy4062 9 months ago
fuck.. they are comparing with BMW M3 n BMW X5.. satria neo and myvi is compact car n cheap car.. not like BMW.. their car is expensive car..stupid top gear!!!
emy8876 9 months ago
@emy8876 yea..they are bad people...
faridaizatzuraimi1 8 months ago
ima use this car for throttle it over the limit aka. modification madness
MrLenzs 9 months ago
@MrLenzs hhahahahahhahaa
sreembit 7 months ago
lavishly equipped with DOORS... I love this :D
herrcoolass 9 months ago 2
JEZZA YOU'RE THE BEST,really im 110% agree with this review because it should be look at these cars they all rubbish unlike usual city car for example Ford Fiesta,Opel Astra,VW Golf,Peugeot 206.All of these cars still have "the joy of driving" but these two malaysians crap car is more like "the misery of driving" they just hideously rubbish.PROTON AND PERODUA YOU ARE HOPELESS
i prefer Morris Marina or soviet cars than these two shameful cars
alief54 9 months ago 3
weak malaysian people
autumnfadeashes 9 months ago
if proton and perodua join venture under one branding their name will be
..............POTONG DUA .............. hahahahaa
brown130388 9 months ago 33
@brown130388 lol, and the cars would be twice as horrible..
shobin05 9 months ago
sebenarnya kereta Malaysia tidak perlu mainkan sentimen kenegaraan sebabnya jika mereka(PROTON N PERODUA) 'BENAR2 JUJUR' dalam membuat kereta dan bidang2 yang lain pasti rakyat akan berbangga jika barangan Malaysia lebih canggih dari luar negara. Memang susah untuk keluar produk tambahan pulak semua itu dikawal oleh golongan 'bukan orang Malaysia',nak paten enjin perlukan kelulusan puak2 ini,tambah nak buat sebijik kereta..
TheKualipanas 9 months ago
Bunch of ugly ass cars there hahahahahahaha :D :D
AtL33T 9 months ago
proton perodua perlu bekerjasama kalau nk maju.jgn bodoh sombong membabi buta.
izzviper 9 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
24 dislikes are from Proton and Perodua fanboys + BN's ass-kissers who just can't accept the truth. lol
murssheed 9 months ago 2
Comment removed
murssheed 9 months ago
zaxvolten:kita sendiri yg patot same2 menaikkan name MALAYSIA.ingat skit ko tu rakyat malaysia.ko ibarat memperlekehkan dri ko sendiri.
arepTF 9 months ago
apsal x psng bnde ni kt tv yer??
guvernor90 9 months ago
that why la kemalangan maut kat malaysia tinggi!!!!
TheAraa3009 9 months ago 2
cipta kete baru yg terbaek..gegar kerajaan suruh mintak org2 yg bodoh menganggur tu bekerja buat keta..apelah bengap sgt kerajaan nie..dlu malaysia takdela haprak cmni..la ni sume msalah timbul....bikin keta tahap international punya..ni keta haprak kau jual luar negara ape la bodoh kepala hotak.kau..pastu kena maki 1 malaysia malu tau tak..jgn bagi setan2 mat salleh ni m'perlekehkn kita..kalau akn dtg still mcm nie ..ade lagi baik cipta satu keta mainan buatan m'sia..pastu import
zaxvolten 9 months ago
@zaxvolten
igt senang nk wt keta? igt sumer org nk keje wt keta?? haram..
jgn salahkan kerajaan sahaja! salahkan diri sendiri gak! dan bukan sumer rakyat malaysia mampu beli kereta bertaraf INTERNATIONAL!
radhio8tive 9 months ago 2
@radhio8tive tak mudah , susah bukan sume orang bley buat keta, kitorang suma tahu , bukan kau sorang je tahu...habis drpd remaja melayu kte tak keje , pastu merempit elok dye bekeja buat kete ke motor ...sape kte aku nak keta kt malaysia ni mahal , aku pun nak keta kt malaysia ni murah ..aku pun bknya berduit pun..pkirla skit nak jual biarlah barang baik..biar keta kte bagus tak kne hina..ini buat sambilewa body tin sardin..pkir biar jauh jangan buat bodoh je..
zaxvolten 9 months ago
@zaxvolten kekeke..
mmg buleh bagi kerja kt depa.. tp nnt kao tgkla...
ap jadi.. keta cap tin sardin sekarang lagi elok dri ap yg akan
penganggur2 neyh wt.. hahaha.. mentality!
radhio8tive 9 months ago
@jonfer1 i would have bought an evo iinstead of these rubbish if the tax is just 5%
MegaPolart 10 months ago
Malaysia only have car rebadge industry.. sadly after all the these years..
But all is not loss.. don't worry
Now transforming into military trucks industry..
Maybe later weapons of mass destruction industry..
Can't have amerika, britain, france, russia, germany selling all the bombs/guns & monopolize the worrld market & selling the to friendly terorists..
glabagila 10 months ago
Corruption, Malaysia's Government is protecting the companies with tax. Import car in Msia is 60-120% taxes, we have no idea but to afford the local car manufacturer of Proton and Perodua.
FeonVid 10 months ago
this car mmg byk sohai. bikin malu negara. mahal je lebey.
telomasen89 10 months ago
i cant understand why people comparing proton with BMW M3? down right crazy! like comparing a baby with a full grown man. Give proton time dude!
nohal02 10 months ago
don't diss the perodua, I drive one and it takes me wherever i want.... I'm actually grateful with what i have, cos it could've been a lot worse :)
izzazalexander 10 months ago
holy crap
shamil9100 10 months ago
Malaysian failed to make a real car..body is an exact copy of Mitsubishi or some other Japanese cars but with zero performance and also the engines are made in Japan and imported to Malaysia..for Malaysian people if u don't know that proton car is quite cheaper outside ur country ,,i hope u will stop making cars and start to get Toyota or Nissan and with 5% gov tax only..it will sound nice..
jonfer1 10 months ago
today i watched this episode of top gear on one of malaysia tv channel, and guest what, they cut this part of the section....lol, they trying to hide the truth...hahahah
BudakApiti109 10 months ago 34
@BudakApiti109 lol on ntv7?
CraztSAMP 8 months ago
@BudakApiti109 which channel? i'm from Malaysia too
MissyNa91 7 months ago
@MissyNa91 its on ntv7 channel, 4.30 p.m every Sunday
unfantasize 7 months ago
the car price in malaysia is TOO HIGH with that rubbish quality!!!!TQVM 2 our PM 1MALAYSIA concept!!!
ikhwan2706 10 months ago
rubbish,rubbish,rubbish..so what?you have a lot of money dont you?go buy something else if u dislike it u moron!
luckyourfine 10 months ago
@luckyourfine
Bullshit, James owns a Panda which actually costs less than those cheap plastic shits. And when they tested the 500 they all loved it.
DubRighteous 10 months ago
@luckyourfine yeah. rubbish this rubbish that. buy something better with higher price la.
nurliyanayasmin 10 months ago
I would agree on the Satria Neo. The first time I saw (and sat in) it, I was suprised on how cheap the interior is. For a 1.6L car, it sounds and act slow. Cheap plastic, a heavy door with a malfunction window and of course, the aftermarket tank cover is all but a classic Malaysian car. We have such a big tax on car but somehow try as we want, we cannot deny the fact some of us, the 1st car will be a PROTON
dwdrule 10 months ago
i think there no problem with the CEO or engineer of proton or perodua, i think its a problem of the malaysian government. If they wanna make a good car, it will need lots of supply's. can malaysian government give this supply? and the government dose something really stupid. by selling the car to the local with a higher price to cover the cost, that they sell outside the country.
CryIngRaIn111 10 months ago
I drive an Aveo and I love it, It has never given me a problem and the ladies love it. So I don't give a shit what they say.
CrysisRequiem 11 months ago
Comment removed
CrysisRequiem 11 months ago
hm.. I'm Malaysian too. Yes I admit that Malaysia car is cheap and easily spoiled. But please all of western/asian or Malaysian(self country people) don't always scold about Malaysia's products. Please respect Malaysia products and I also respect all of the things which made by other countries.
All of you must know this moral: Please respect the things or people which are come from foreign countries. People who don't know how to respect then that means they don't have family education.Cheers :D
tingxyu 11 months ago 6
@tingxyu If you want people to respect you then build something that worth other's respect, you gain respect from others, not by begging it. Cheers.:D
zebra110 7 months ago
@tingxyu ts not about morals n respect.this is a car review show and they say what they think...whether its a crappy or nice car they will say it as it is.and thats what u watch the show for ryt?
leriq1 7 months ago
this is just fuck-up..I'm Malaysian..i think i can design cars better then those who design "The" Malaysian cars..damn..and guess what..these cars are going to rust in few years...
helltakker 11 months ago
I'm from Malaysia,and Perodua and Malaysia still to learn to make a good car..Please respect..
thedat86 11 months ago 2
I watched the program on Dave channel yesterday afternoon . Sad but true
sabung2008 11 months ago
im.. from.. malaysia....:(
blackside909 11 months ago
only GOD can safe Malaysia.
Juzaname91 11 months ago
I really hope one day Proton will produce something like a ferarri @@
Jet2197 11 months ago
@Jet2197 That day will probably never come.
PianosWill 11 months ago
What's with the comment saying "Najib is stupid" . If he is, I wanna see you run the goddamned country Whatever it is, if you dont like the cars, you have a choice not buying it.
AHMADF93 11 months ago 3
u want beat me..hahaha...ferrari vs bmw e46... unbelievable..its ok..i try..hahahahaha...
azamL200 11 months ago
you Malaysians must realize that these guys are not wrong to criticize your cars. I studied in Malaysia and got my first hand experience with these peroduas, protons and nazas. Some of the worst cars I've driven and when I found out that they're actually selling these cars at a cheaper price OUTSIDE the country, I thought these companies are downright mad! Please, for the sake of basic human safety, improve your cars!
almaraiman 1 year ago 65
@almaraiman: nothing much we can do...... it's d government..... we Malaysians hate those cars as well.....
it071406 8 months ago
@almaraiman never mind them close minded lot. I'm a malaysian and I will never go near a proton/perodua. All they care about is ripping of the rakyat(citizens)
jmok92 8 months ago 2
@almaraiman i dont get it
bioniclemoc 7 months ago
@almaraiman i bet you'll hate it because you're a fucking indonesian!
huckim222 7 months ago
they are right..
look at viva
its made from biscuits tin!
MrPaanJr 1 year ago 2
This has been flagged as spam show
"honestly, I would rather be inside Paul Scholes" haha
jmnge1 1 year ago
Comment removed
jmnge1 1 year ago
Comment removed
jmnge1 1 year ago
im going to dislike this video as a malaysian
wilson5941 1 year ago
korang dh besar...dh blh pikir apa yg membebankan dn apa yg tk membeban kan...
enjoy ur car masing2..pda aku..the best car yg aku pkai bmw e46..conar baring pun tkder hal sbb ada automatic stability control (ASC)...cayokkk...
azamL200 1 year ago
@azamL200 i beat you...hahah i drive a ferrari...... :p
0176777054321 11 months ago
don't fight each other by this kind of video... they were telling us the truth that there are a lot more better car in the world.. but we need to realize that not all nations worldwide really need a car as super duper as they prefer.. and each nation in the world has their own need.. if malaysian car is bad, improve it.!
and i think british are one of the most fussy nation in terms of choosing their need.. haha.. by the way, this is what makes the world to be awesome.. hahaha (^^,)
iluvmeonly88 1 year ago
The Chevrolet Aveo is by far the worse, th ebadge is in the wrong place for gods sake!
MegaMrDamo 1 year ago
diorg(malaysia) yg buat kete ni nk duit jer...tambahan plak kepentingan politik pun ada...mmang hampeh la jadinyer... membuat kereta tiada keiklasan langsung utk rakyat nye..aku sndri pkai BMW E46 318i..bru btul2 iklas...open ur mind rkyat mlysia..
azamL200 1 year ago 3
i don't need to buy a proton car to know tat it is fucking cheap and lousy! Proton cars are never in my sight. My first car is a Mercedes Benz C-200 and it's fucking reliable and awesome!
chesterwlz 1 year ago
@chesterwlz
Great choice on car my first car is a merc C-180 and i love it.
smugtugboat 1 year ago
@smugtugboat
yeah..nice choice! mercedes benz ---the best or nothing. =)
chesterwlz 1 year ago
Damm FUCK, make me no face after i watch it
lsa81 1 year ago
I could not understand what are your objective to make this video , if your are saying Proton is bad , then .. give them some time , they maybe could make this car better in future , if you're professionals , but for you information , professionals do not insult about low quality car , or maybe not even low , professionals comment and tell that what to do .. so , you're not ! and ! If you saying Protons car are not safe enough , ask Princess Diana do Merc are safe enough ?
stuntman623 1 year ago
No point in swearing, you do get what you pay for, I bought a Proton Savvy just about the worst car I have bought in 50 years of motoring, we kept it for twelve months, how I just do not know, you would be desperate to thinking Proton could make a decent motor, they can't.
PEYIAKID 1 year ago
produce and export to other nations cheaper
produce and induce to our nation expensive
even a 5 year old knows it does not make sense
Bindimbu 1 year ago 3
@Bindimbu true true, so true. lets pissed on M'sia Government. 'Eat my shorts!!' boooooooooooo!!!!
azactobacter 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
najib is stupid!!
salmanfarruz 1 year ago 45
@salmanfarruz that's not right, you should point at their car brand manager.
evo5pro 11 months ago
@salmanfarruz at least we still have our own carmaker company. we just need more time to develop our products. blame on CEO or engineer of proton. they need a radical changes in their company structure. its has nothing to do with najib. dont be so stupid.. you mixed up politic and other things. huh
proofreader81 11 months ago
@proofreader81
so agree with u
eimin24 11 months ago
@proofreader81 dude have u forgotten the tax imposed on imported cars?
Soonn917 10 months ago
@salmanfarruz
xder kene mengene la sial ngan org tua tuh!
radhio8tive 9 months ago
HAHAHA...it say Rubbish= =
EdwardLaiPY 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Do the people of Malaysia to buy their own national car, national car is no quality of the high price? while the national car in Malaysia to sell overseas at a low price? at least if the quality of the national car is not improved, why not lowered prices of their own country? till garbage collector at overseas can buy proton impian, i mean in malaysia proton waja......
RazendO2 1 year ago
Comment removed
RazendO2 1 year ago
Comment removed
RazendO2 1 year ago
Comment removed