World: Class Dismissed in Swat Valley - nytimes.com/video

[shafi11pk]

War propaganda

[ASIFKARACHI1988]

Biggest fraud of the history of the mankind…...is the Bukhari and his fabricated book so called hadith. Both are bullshit drama. Like a ashorkan or kamasutra of Hindu’s.

All the taliban and al-quida are the followers of bukhari his hadith.

They are the followers of bukhari haram zada and his shit book hadith.They don’t follow Rasool-e-pak and Quran. And Fuckin Abu Huraira is the main contributor in this fraud and fabrication.

[ad8369]

it is sad all this destruction and loss of freedom. I hope it get better.

[ukkayani]

Thanks to Allah and pak army with their G8 sacrifices that these thugs and murderers and drug traffickers have been kicked out of the Swat :)

[rknayani]

This is pathetic some one controlling some once education. No one has right

Education is birth right. I am strong believer of prayers Let us pray for the girls, and Malala’s dream of becoming Doctor.

[platypusmaximus]

Has anyone bothered to ask the Taliban in Swat what their reasoning is for disallowing the girls schools? I would find that answer very interesting.

[Nusrat5791]

how can you not fall in love with sweet, charming malala and her father. they are true patriots, not the cancerous islamist brigade and mullahs.

children like malala, who have more courage in their fingernail than almost all of pakistan's respected [male] members of national assembly and tv anchors, are your country's hope.

follow malala - she will lead you to the promised land. follow the likes of jamaat e islami's paracha and zaid hamid - they will introduce you to dante's 7th circle.

[mehboob355]

Malala  sweet

i'm sure you will come a good doctor ,a plastic surgeon or politicin to educate ,threat and help millions of people.

[azamjaved]

Western regimes and Local sellout traitors leaving no stone unturned to cover their crimes and anti social ways and show the chaos which is created by themself and propgating against those who want to educate their childern free of western or satanic type of education where students and teachers having sex and drugs and alcohol.

[kalim196]

good documentry .there are always brave people in the world. this documentry was made in the hot days of taliban regime in swat but know the situation s totally change in the area.we should require to make a new documentry to show the world that swat vally regain their beauty as it used to 10 years prior.most of the time people does not belive that but once you will visit swat you will also astonished as i saw in julay 2010. and this cerdit goes to brave soldiers of pakistan army .

[mafiabros66]

indeed..yes this girl cares about her education..and thy her father did come her to america only bcz of these two vids..and he did come to my dads house..they are friends and i have went through the same situation

[khurramwaqas]

@ ahmeddeedat786 you choose such a respectable name for such a vile purpose...u are an uneducated bafoon and have no idea what you talk about,, i pray that it is you who recieves hidayah

[extravaganza82]

We need men like you.You really impress me.

[Barnadshah]

SO NICE OF YOU ZIA UDDIN , WE PROUD OF YOU,

[AhmadDeedat786]

Mujjahideen Are Beautiful and Totally Korrekt But I Must Konfess I Love The Father And Daughter, How Much They Kare For each Other And Aww May Allah Bless his Daughter She Kries Like An Angel. But She Needs To Realise That She Is hasinng Kafir Dreams Foolishly. May Allah Guide Her To the Right Path Insha-Allah.

Doktors R Nothing But Money hungry greedy Skum Bag Agents Of the Zionist jewish Pharmaceutikle (Medicine Making) Kompanies. Yes They Do Some good But over 99% Of their Work Is Vile.

[AhmadDeedat786]

Point Number One, The Mujjahiddeen Are Only Against Waste Ejukation Of western Style Which Even The USA Scientists Are Konfirming Is Rendering People Dumber Than Donkey's Rears. The Mujjahiddeen Are Saying That Islamic Ejukation Must Kome First Then after Anything Else. The Teachers In Most Skools Were Westernised Short Haired Women Especially Paid By The Western Agents To Korrupt Conservative Values.

Point Two The Start Is Soooooo Decieving Of This Vid, The Gun Sound Was The Police Shooting!

[afghanempires85]

Fuck non of them speaking are Pashtun. These are Indics or Hindko specially this guy are 5:00 Zafudin what-ever his name is.

[aimalkhan123]

@afghanempires85 you my friend are mistaken. they are from minghora swat and the guy is speaking pushto at 5:00.

[afghanempires85]

@aimalkhan123 No Pashtun would support Pakistan, this guy maybe a Pashtun by simply calling himself "yusufzai," but I think his other side ie Mother maybe a Punjabi or Indic, because no pure Pashtun would support Pakistan.

[extravaganza82]

@afghanempires85 who said no Pukhtoon support Pakistan.Sorry mate 100 % Pukhtoons support and love Pakistan.You fucking Indian agent cant divide us any more.

[extravaganza82]

@afghanempires85 hahahahaha you fucking Indian agent get out from here

[qazibasit]

ha ha ha ha this girl is reading a written speech by some NGO, funded by the west i think.

[navgenuine]

now every thing is over,nd the Pakistani Army have done it,now Girls are going to school,nd the tourism industry has also resumed and Inshallah it will be more better in upcoming........

[pisho108]

NGO dramas

[aweiss]

5:35

that is a man!

[qazibasit]

@aweiss dude sometimes what we see is a mere deception. So one should see it by yourself. These are the agencies doing this stuff and again other agencies trying to stop them. It the civilian who suffers.

[aweiss]

@qazibasit ???

[aweiss]

America has to get some guns and some planes and kill some more fucking Islamofascists

[munazza1998]

when i see this vedio and the other in which showing the Pak Army beating a so called taliban..than..i m bit confused who is rite n who is wrong and why we support these so called taliban they r not from us..

[aweiss]

who supports pakistan? Why are you not sure?

[star67641]

Somebody powerful person like Saudi King should come forward with an amendment of Islam and Kuran and make both suitable to modern world, modern economy and to present situation... keeping the thousands of years old religion is good but the same rules is not better...somebody boldly should come forward and pin point the mistakes of prophet muhamad and make things good for the real world... A world Muslim army should be created to get rid of the ones who take Islam and Kuran for bad things!

[aweiss]

then it becomes irrelevant and powerless, which it should be

[aweiss]

@star67641 what part is worth keeping?

[sugaluv26]

@star67641 mistakes of our prophet? how can u say that.. thats like saying allah made mistakes.. cuz the prophet did wat allah asked him to do.. wat the taliban r doing isnt acceptable.. but dont say our prophet made mistakes..

[aimalkhan123]

@star67641 perhaps you need to reaserch alitte more my friend. there is nothing in the religion of islam or the quran which justifies what the taliban are doing.

[kazuya26xxx]

NO CIGARETTES, NO SLEEP, NO LIGHT , NO SOUND , NOTHING TO EAT NO BOOKS TO READ when no education means no money flow= Allah saves you people..

really Sad

[dirtymartiniify]

Are we ever going to get an update on whether this little girl and her family are ok????

[whosnext886]

yup Swat valley was saved by Pak Army.... now Girls are free to goto school and yes i think i saw him on a national TV ....

[zabybaby]

The situation is getting better Alhamdulillah, but the Taliban have not been completely expelled from Northern Pakistan.

[xcv1001]

this is true passion for education. I love my country and love my motivated people..screw the illiterate cunts with guns!!!

[larsanien]

well she wants to become smart.. all taliban want is to remain stupid!!!

[ulfenstyle]

poor girl... who can do this to people don't they have a mind?

[addyau]

@SETSETCIRLCE

Exactly! they are fighting for their freedom. Killing yourself with a bomb is one thing but killing others with it is an other.

[Iamgandhiful]

if anyone starts judging 4chan for immorality, they need to first look at this video. with no warning they show these gruesome images. I thought the guy was holding a machete but I relaxed when I saw it was a whip. and it didnt take long to show decapitated body.

how nice from new york times.

[metallicmalfoy]

Can you imagine living like this? I live in a country where my education is gauranteed. In a country where it is the norm to complain that we have to go to school everyday. I cannot even imagine being as brave as that little girl and fighting for my education when people are being decapitated down the street because they have fought for my right to shop or even go outside. When I walk down the street I do not fear for my life and I thank God for that, and I hope that one day these girls can too.

[Iamgandhiful]

whats so brave about this girl? if she would stay at home, hidding in a basement, that wouldnt be brave anymore? bravery is a buIIshit word.

[addyau]

@SETSETCIRCLE

its not like that the Pakistani military force rammed into the Talibans and started killing them for no reason. I'm not sure if you know but the government for a long period of time was just trying to talk this situation out with them but when even the scholars of Pakistan itself wanted an operation it was then they decided to take it forward. (You can not just look at someone who has a bomb tied around them and not do anything when it is certain that you'd be killed).

[SETSETCIRCLE]

when you dont have any thing to live for the shortest way out of your mesery is to fight your way out or kill your self in a bomb, what did the pakistani goverment do to improve the life of these peaple

[SETSETCIRCLE]

what kind of islam taliban is traying to implement girls in Saudi aribia attend schools

[SETSETCIRCLE]

for evry action thers is a reaction equal in force, using force againest milltincy only worsen the situation, there should be peacful intervention between the goverment and the milletent, the civil war and milltency in Algiria stoped after such interventions that was supported by muslim scoulars from Saudi arabia and others, in Saudi arabia the goverment intiated a munasaha program, to treat the religous baises of the extremest idiology ,

[Iamgandhiful]

newton said that. action-reaction only works in physics, not in psychology. civil war in algeria was a different thing than the situtation in pakistan. hey, belize banned guns and violence rates decreased, but when britain did that, violence rates increased.

as long as there are narrow minded people on earth and this immoral religion created by a pedophilistic serial killer, there wont be any peace. islam is only a middle eastern mythology and all the science behind it, is pseudo-science.

[SETSETCIRCLE]

you are misinformed about the reality of the real true islam, what you are seeing is Tribal Mentality of uneducated militia group

[Iamgandhiful]

I wasnt misinformed, I read that right in the quran. its narrow minded people like you that cant see the immorality of the holy book. its the same with bible. people dont see anything bad cause its all in codes or written in english from 17th century that no one uses anymore.

"turned into a pillar of salt" - in other words "she got killed!". "slay the idolaters wherever ye find them" - in other words "kill wherever you find them!".

religion is only a mythology but people take it too far

[SETSETCIRCLE]

dear angry friend the verse you have quoted is taken out of context, in its context god forbade Muslims from any violent resistance for 13 years, then when the enemies attacked the new Muslim state, god gave them permission to fight back

[SETSETCIRCLE]

in the verse you have quoted, god is saying to them that they should fight and kill those were ever they find them in the battlefield, and by the way the Jews of medina were in this fight with the Muslims against the idolaters army

"God is Beautiful and Loves Beauty" Prophet Muhammad

[jbabarjan]

it was a very gud video ..,, i cudnt even trn away my face for a seond frm screen ,, nirmally we see vrey common videos of talibans and migrations etc but this video shows how actually people survived ir r surviving this war ,,,,

[doctorasstastic]

where's greg mortenson?

[byafu]

subs even when they speak english why

[papastiffy]

"Who will solve our problems?"

"Who will return our valley to peace?"

Two quotes from the little girls speech. But I would like to ask these people something, Who will bring back our economy? Who will bring back my fathers job?

You will laugh at these because they are silly, and rightfully they are. But we had figured out the "great" mysteries of how to not fight and stay civil.

Please, figure it out.

And to "macbrack" on Islam, your most likely right. Its all they have and it sucks

[shahzadkhan007]

Things are going better in Swat by the Grace of Allah.

[Skorz3ny]

Why this upload now ..... this documentary is about 8 months late

[hinara1]

y dont u just the fuck up its not our fault this is happening u idiot

its not about ur religion y dont u go to hell

[macbrack]

This is the face of Islam all over the world either extreme or moderate it still stifles peoples lives, murders and cripples their society.....All religion is wrong but islam the worst.....abandon this medieval barbarism and your lives will blossom!!!

[wasup46]

first