All of these players and the conductor rock absolutely! For me as a percussionist, it would almost heretic not to mention Stefan Rapp, the timpanist. He is probably one of the best interprets of Beethovens quite challenging timpani parts.
just wondering what that is at like 8:13.....ive never seen it before...is it a really old version of the trumpet you know where you gotta lip slur and stuff or somethin else...
the introduction is way too fast, it doesn't feel anything like adagio molto anymore (and beethoven's adagio is slow!), and the allegro con brio sounds almost like a caricature, it's so fast that there's no time to create and shape sounds and phrases, it all sounds like a mannheim steamroller, and it's not. it's beethoven, young, but individual, personal beethoven.
but again, for me harnoncourt/COE is the best beethoven ever. nothing comes close.
I wouldn't say this performance is too fast at all. There is much evidence from research that tempos in the 18th and early 19th Centurys were a lot faster than is considered "normal" today, and then that Beethoven pushed orchestras further to play even faster than they were comfortable with. There are contemporary reviews which indicate this movement lasting around 8 minutes with repeats, which is roughly what Järvi achieves here.
the performances by jarvi of this and the others are really fantastic. the energy and sensitivity! those players really give their all for him. thank you for posting these.
The players gave their best for Beethoven. Jarvi is full of himself and does not shape the structure. He just has generic "excitement" because he obviously does not take this great music seriously and certainly has little depth.
Listen to Klemperer, Kleiber and other serious conductors. But the orchestra is great.
This Beethoven 1 is even more amazing than the one performed by Haitink + LSO, live in New York Avery Fisher Hall this year. Thank you for sharing this performance!
Just incredible. They've got it.
ceebass 1 month ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Wonderful performance. Great spirit, articulation and tempo
soloists1 8 months ago
Wonderful performance. Great spirit, articulation and tempo
soloists1 8 months ago
All of these players and the conductor rock absolutely! For me as a percussionist, it would almost heretic not to mention Stefan Rapp, the timpanist. He is probably one of the best interprets of Beethovens quite challenging timpani parts.
Bravo!
DavidTimmePerc 1 year ago
The most amazing music and the greatest SYMPHONY ever composed.
LordMSh 1 year ago
They're herald trumpets.
mahlermahlermahler1 2 years ago
I have never heard beethoven 1st symphony. this is beautiful
luckyday465768 2 years ago
amazing
is beauty
blsfaqmer 2 years ago
SEHR TOLL!!!
Johnoooh 2 years ago
wunderbar...
legrenouille 3 years ago
just wondering what that is at like 8:13.....ive never seen it before...is it a really old version of the trumpet you know where you gotta lip slur and stuff or somethin else...
brycet93 3 years ago
The instrument @ 8:13 is the Frecnh Horn...
SmythC17 3 years ago
ohh sorry i looked at the time late its before the french horns like 8:05
brycet93 3 years ago
pretty...pretty...pretty gooood,
just sick,thanks to person who posted
guillaumepirard 3 years ago
I love it
I love this masterpiece
Insanelycoolprincess 3 years ago 2
Amazing
cutencrazy07 3 years ago 4
the introduction is way too fast, it doesn't feel anything like adagio molto anymore (and beethoven's adagio is slow!), and the allegro con brio sounds almost like a caricature, it's so fast that there's no time to create and shape sounds and phrases, it all sounds like a mannheim steamroller, and it's not. it's beethoven, young, but individual, personal beethoven.
but again, for me harnoncourt/COE is the best beethoven ever. nothing comes close.
10clowns 3 years ago
I wouldn't say this performance is too fast at all. There is much evidence from research that tempos in the 18th and early 19th Centurys were a lot faster than is considered "normal" today, and then that Beethoven pushed orchestras further to play even faster than they were comfortable with. There are contemporary reviews which indicate this movement lasting around 8 minutes with repeats, which is roughly what Järvi achieves here.
TheCrazyCello 3 years ago 8
wow. this is even more intense than karajan's. Bravo!
kwangzero 4 years ago
the performances by jarvi of this and the others are really fantastic. the energy and sensitivity! those players really give their all for him. thank you for posting these.
vincesjm 4 years ago
The players gave their best for Beethoven. Jarvi is full of himself and does not shape the structure. He just has generic "excitement" because he obviously does not take this great music seriously and certainly has little depth.
Listen to Klemperer, Kleiber and other serious conductors. But the orchestra is great.
zenoky2000 3 years ago
This Beethoven 1 is even more amazing than the one performed by Haitink + LSO, live in New York Avery Fisher Hall this year. Thank you for sharing this performance!
cy0708 4 years ago
They are wonderful!! I went to see their concert at Rose Theater (NYC) last week and it was just unbelievable.
lawmanhung 4 years ago