Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (341)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • Asalam alikum,First , thank you for making that great video ,what pissed me off was the comments on the video ,people here in our dear Egypt have been brainwashed to take certain ideas for granted without questioning them ,like the believe that is very common around ,I.E "Islam is a religion and a state" . which I believe is not part of Islam ,but part of the history of muslims which might've been necessary at a time ,but not at all obligatory ,specially if it'd turn us in2 a sectarian society.

  • Very nice video

    But not the 1st five khalfa’s but only the 1st four “radya Allahu 3anhom” were fair (Abu Bakr, Omar, Othman & Ali)

    The fifth was Mo3awya, the reason of Shia/Sunni Division (Al Fetna Al Kobra)

    The Fetna was a reason of mixing religion with politics

  • @85mamom The second Fetna Kobra .. plus 3 of the 4 were killed , and Uthman was frowned upon by his people even Aicha God bless them all .. Uthman's fitna was al fetna al kobra .. Ali & Mo'awya 's was al fetna al kobra al thanya ... ...... ..... secular and proud

  • @SuperScarfacejr

    that's right .. God bless them all

  • I'm Secular and Muslim...and I'm a proud secular and a proud Muslim!

  • May Allah/God free Egypt from Mubarak and religious fanatics/extremists.

  • Pakistan is a Muslim country and we make from screw drivers to space launch vehicles to Ballistic missiles , which means such a system wont stop you from progressing.

    Secularism is the way to go ? No ! its not neither is the current system in Islamic countries.

    We need to come up with a new democratic system which can accommodate everything that we desire.

    If the Islamic law has to be implemented then it is difficult but that doesn't mean that we should stop drawing it .

  • Brother when u explain ur interpretation of secularism that u believe that secularism is good n a man can be Muslim n secular at same time then I feel that u have same thinking as I do... I also have the same problem here but mullahs dont allow us to speak out... I m a Muslim from PAKISTAN and I AM A SECULAR PERSON... I believe in Islam N I believe in ALLAH ALMIGHTY.

  • when i download the videos of u to show to my frnds.... i dont get the words u write in the video. plz can u write the words in description so that we can see those saparatly.....

  • Secularism = KUFFUR!!!

  • @Parvez86 you piece of shit low life fanatic, stick your gay pakistani name up your ass and go blow up some more people...no wonder you country is nothing but a heap of shit blowing eachother up!

  • @ModernPharaoh77 You are the perfect example of what Secularism and Nationalism has done to Jahil Muslims. Just look at the filth that came out of your mouth! I ask you are these the words of a believer?

    Because you are so Nationalistic you look down on other Races and think they are inferior. You assumed by my name that I was Pakistani (as a lot of people do), I am Bangladeshi - not that it matters, as I am Muslim before anything Alhamdulillah!

    May Allah (swt) guide us all.

  • i'm happy that i found an egyptian like u .. !! god bless you and i'm muslim btw 3shan m7adsh y2oly enta yahoody w hagas m3a eny ba7trm el yahoodeya w el masi7ya ,, laken lel asaf el nas btfham el kalam ghalat :) !

  • You may like this one:

    laelhad.com

  • I guess that I know you Modern Pharaoh. I know that you are a muslim.

    There is something that is not understandable in your post: What do you mean by separating state from Religion exactly?

    Because as you know there are some rules in islam which we muslims respect , what if these rules collide with a political issue?

    please accept my best regards and Ramadan Kareem

    please join eltwhed.com to know more about why we cannot separate between the two.

  • I guess that I know you Modern Pharaoh. I know that you are a muslim.

    There is something that is not understandable in your post: What do you mean by separating state from Religion exactly?

    Because as you know there are some rules in islam which we muslims respect , what if these rules collide with a political issue?

    please accept my best regards and Ramadan Kareem

    please join eltwhed.com to know more about why we cannot separate between the two.

  • يعنى ملعش يا تتكلم عربى يا تتكلم انجليزى ... لا دى تبع العلمانية برضة ؟؟

    انا مختلف جدا مع وجهة نظرك وشايف ان العلمانية دى كانت لازم تظهر فى اوروبا علشان الكنيسة كانت بتعارض العلم , لكن الاسلام عمره ما عارض العلم والدليل ان العلم تطور كثييير جدا على يد المسلمين , فمش معنى ان المسلمين دلوقت متخلفين يبقى نتجه للعلمانية ... العيب فى المسلمين مش فى الاسلام , يبقى كان من الافضل اننا نحسن من المسلمين ونفهمهم صحصح الاسلام مش نبقى علمانين

  • اللهم ارفع راية الإسلام في تركيا واجعل زمام أمورها بأيدي المسلمين وادحر العلمانيين واجعل كيدهم في نحورهم واجعل تدبيرهم تدميرهم يا ذا القوة والجبروت ....

  • علمانيه ايه وجهل ايه ربنا يحفظ مصر من الفكر المتخلف

    مصر اسلاميه وانا بقول اسلاميه مش معناها النصارى مش مصريين لكن لان الاغلبيه مسلمه والرئيس مسلم عشان محدش يحرف معنى كلامى

    ربنا يحفظ مصر من المتطرفين فكريا وعقيديا

  • @egyptswain meen aal en el 3ilmaniya kofr ya gahil...el 3ilmaniya siyasa malhash da3wa bil deen...3ayiz shari3a 3la 7asab fahmak lil deen mashiha 3la nafsak

  • @ModernPharaoh77 مين اللى جاهل يا حمار انت ؟؟؟ العلمانيه اول طريق الكفر والعلمانيه سياسه و بيحولو يعملوها دين

    ثانيا يا جاهل لو انت كنت مسلم فلازم تكون عارف ان الاسلام شرع الله فى الارض وانا اشك انك مسلم اصلا لانى دايما بشوفك بتسب الدين للمسلمين بعكس اللى انت كاتبه فى قناتك يا منافق

  • @ModernPharaoh77 ثم يا جاهل يا متخلف لو انت بتقول ان العلمانيه سياسه فعلا ليه كاتب عنوان الفيديو الاسلام والعلمانيه ؟؟؟ ليه بتقارن الاسلام بالسياسه ؟؟ وليه مش بتقول المسيحيه والعلمانيه ؟؟؟ ياعم ده حقدك على الاسلام واضح جدا من اسلوبك الحقد طافح على وشك العكر عيل منافق

    متنساش بقى تتلزق فى الاسلام وتقولى انك مسلم هاهاهاهاها

  • @egyptswain ah muslim ghasbin 3an eli khalifo omak ya motakhalif..ba3deen enta mal deek omak ana muslim wala misi7y wala yahoody aslan? fakir nafsak rabina ya gahil? yalla roo7 raby da2n we asar bantaloonak kida tikhosh el ganah....nas motakhalifa daya3to ma3na el islam, omal a7na leeh ba2ina dowal kolaha motakhalifa..min el tatarof wel habal

  • @ModernPharaoh77 انت يا حلوف يا خنزير حمار بديل مره اشوف بتسب الدين للمسلمين ودلوقتى بتقولى ديك امك يعنى قصدك الدين ومره اشوفك بتقول على الشيوخ متطرفين ودلوقتى بتتريق على المسلمين السنيين الملتزمين وفى الاخر بتقول انك مسلم تحب اشخرلك ؟؟؟

    على العموم يا معرص بيناتك عندى اسمك وعنوانك وكل حاجه عنك يا خول تحب اكتبهالك عشان تصدق؟

    اظبط نفسك بدل ما اظبطك يا روح اهلك

  • Comment removed

  • you are against people wearing bikini???? first think, do you really believe in the equality of men and women.... should you be the judge of what women wear???? you are not a woman and you are not those people, why is the religions always based on sexist approaches..... and also secularism means the seperation of state and religion, it is not an adjective for people... secularism protects the rights of believer and non-believer people...

  • بسم الله الرحمن الرحيم

    {وَكَذَلِك جَعلناكم أمَّةً وَسَطا} (البقرة: 143)

    الله سبحانه وتعالى قال (امةً وسطا) يعني لا منحرفه لاخر حدود الانحراف الاخلاقي ولا متشدده لأخر حدود التشدد. الاتزان امر صعب بس مش مستحيل.

  • @sabi79797 kalam gameel

  • PLEASEEE WEAK UP ISLAM WORLD !!..... weak up and fight with CAPITALISM !!.... fight with fcuking fascist america..... CAPITALIST FASCIST AMERICA has one DREAM"""make slave all arabian islamic world for IMPERIALIST AMERICA"""".... are you ready next 9/11???..... i think so all CAPITALIST FASCIST reactionary morons need hard cocky or next 9/11

  • Bro, I think it is fair to listen to the best argument the other side has to offer. So I would say listen to some of the Salafis or Ikhwani Sheikhs just to understand them, not to youtube users who can be overzealous idiots.

    Because in all fairness, I think you are misrepresenting them. They are not one monolithic block, they have many differing views among them. From what I know about them, the Ikhwan are far more sophisticated than you make them out to be.

    peace

  • El nasara andaf minak we min eli khalifook 3la fikra, EL YAHOODY EL SAHYOONY ar7am minak we min eli zayak ya salafi ya ars!

  • slaafiprincecb

    انتا ليه بتبعتلى ع الخاص

    مهو انا شايفة الرسالة هنا

    مش عايزة رسايلك فى الانبوكس بتاعى

  • عايزه و لا مش عايزه.. الرجال قوامون على النساء ... و هى كده.. واضح أنك لم تقرأي قوله تعالى: "لتجدن اشد الناس عداوة للذين ءامنوا اليهودوالذين اشركوا".. و لم تقرأي قوله تعالى: "كفر الذين قالوا الله ثالث ثلاثة" .. و تقولي اخواتنا قال .. بتقري قرآن و لا ميكي للجيب؟؟؟

  • ربنا قال:"ولتجدن أقربهم مودة للذين آمنوا الذين قالوا إنا نصارى"

    و الرسول (ص) قال(من آذى ذميا فأنا خصمه، ومن كنت خصمه خصمته يوم القيامة) واضح انك لا تعرف أى حاجة عن أصول التعامل مع اخواننا المسيحيين و لا حتى المسلمين و بتكره ميكى ليه؟عشان فى شيخ زى ما بيسمى نفسه كفره

  • Enta MOTAKHALIF!!! we batal til3ab bikalam el Quran ya WATY, mahiya deeh el MOSIBA en himir zayak biyfasaro ayat 3la mazag omohom ya ghaby! Yil3an bo el salafiyeen dool 7aywadoo el Islam fi dahya...SAMIMTO EL DEEN ALLAH YIL3ANKO

  • ايه علاقة الرجال قوامون على النساء دلوقتى

    هوا لازم العقد بتاعت قهر المرأة تتحشر فى أى موضوع

    و بعدين قوامون معناها ان الراجل يطلع عين أهل الستات اللى ف عيلتو ف رأيك؟

  • khalas ya coolgirl ana 3amalt A7la BLOCK lil motakhalif dah ba3d mashoft el message eli howa ba3athaly on my comment page...ba3it biyishtim shatayim kabi7a 3an Ahl el Kitab, wadi7 eno motakhalif we la nikash ma3ah, HE HATES EVERYONE, typical SALAFI IDIOT

  • even hates himself loooool

    أحسن حاجة عملتها!!البتاع ده حاجة ملهاش مثيل فى التخلف و الغباء و التعصب

    أغرب حاجة انو الناس دول عاملين مؤمنين و هما بيقولو شتايم قبيحة و لسانهم عايز قصو

    هوا احنا رجعنا ورا من شوية

  • @

    ModernPharaoh77

    واحد كفر المسلمين مستنى منه يقول ايه عن المسيحيين

  • العلمانية كفر

  • YAbny enta wa7id GAHIL wala ta3raf ya3ny eeh 3ilmaniya Aslan, 7atkafar kol el 3ilmaniyeen kaman..lol, ya wahabi ya ibn el bor2os roo7 eshrab bool gamal aw erda3 min kibeer ya gahil

  • العبادة مختلفة عن السياسة يعني السياسة مثل الفقه بالإسلام يبقى فيها أكثر من قول إثنين أو ثلاثة أو أكثر لكن السياسي المسلم لا يكذب على شعبه أشكرك لتوضيح هذه النقطة للناس العبادة يجب اتباعها كما أمرنا النبي ص

  • يعني انت اللي شكلك مووووس مقطع الكتب .. عامل نفسك برم و لابس نظارة شمس في الظلمة.. أكن البنات حيبصبصوا عليك !! العلمانية كفر و كل من يحاول أن يفصل الاسلام عن الحكم كافر: و من لم يحكم بما أنزل الله فأولئك هم الكافرون، و هم الظالمون، و هم الفاسقون. افتح مصحف يا أعمى القلب و البصيرة

  • ok ya takfiri ya ahbal! mahiya el 3ilmaniya mawgooda 3shan takfiriyeen wahabiyeen zayak 3omrohom mayi2zo 7ad ya salafi ya motakhalif! Roo7 fagar nafsak we kafar nas ya hayif ya Maltasha

  • قلت لك افتح مصحف و اقرأ كلام الله .... و بلاش تخلف عقلي و كلام قهاوي يا تافه

  • lollllllllllllllllllllllllllll­llllllllllllllllllllllllllllll­llllllllllllll

    hhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhh­hhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhh­hhhhhhhhhhhhhhh

  • very funnnyyyyy

  • I mean الاهبل اللى بيقول العلمانية كفر

    انتا كوميدى أوى

  • @coolgirlegy

    و من لم يحكم بما أنزل الله فأولئك هم الكافرون

  • @EgyptianPrinceCB ya sheikh ETNAYIL enta 7ato3od tifty we ta3milina fiha 3alim ya motahalif ya WAHABI-SALAFI ya bita3 el gahiliya!! etnayil 3amal TIKAFAR meet 7aga we tideena ayat aw a7adith malhash da3wa bil mawdou3

  • شوف ا لتعريص بتاعك؟؟؟!!!! بتقول أن العلمانية ميت فل و عشرة، و أنا بقللك العلمانية كفر استنادا لقوله تعالى و قال الله و قال الرسول، و انت مش عاجبك.. "إنما كان قول المؤمنين إذا دعوا إلى الله و رسوله ليحكم بينهم أن يقولوا سمعنا و أطعنا" .. يعني اسمع و تتكتم خالص

  • @EgyptianPrinceCB enta wel khara el wahabiyeen bitou3ak tifasaro el deen 3la mazag omoko, malkoosh da3wa biya, ana Muslim, mish motakhalif zayoko..yalla ba2a..kas BOOL GAMAL we rawa2

  • EgyptianPrinceCB

    و مين اللى هيحكم بما أنزل الله الايام دى انتا و امثالك السلفيين؟؟؟؟

    يبقى نص البلد هيهدر دمها و تتقتل

    و توئدو البنات

  • شكلك مغسول مخك بأفلام عادل امام و هوليود و كلام اليهود ...

  • @EgyptianPrinceCB wenta shaklak maghsool 3a2lak bi ayman el zawahri wel khawal Wagdy ghonaim we bool el gamal

  • بتقول يا حقير يا عديم التربية و الاخلاق "خ..." على الشيخ وجدي غنيم؟؟؟ أنت لم تذكر بوش أو شارون أن أولمرت أو الصهاينة بهذا اللفظ الحقير يا حقير. يا رب ينتقم منك و يجعلك عبرة لكل متكبر عنيد

  • @EgyptianPrinceCB mada takhalofak fazi3, kol shwaya ti2ool BAS ENTA MA2OLTISH mish 3arif eeh..eeh el habal dah, yil3an abook 3la abo Wagdy ghonaim 3la abo BUSH , 3la sharom 3la kol el sahayna 3la el Wahabiyeen!! ay 7aga tanya ya prince? ti7ib ashtim hitler, we kaman a3raf esm el kofar bitou3 ayam el Rasool wa ashtimhom wa7id wa7id la7san ti2oly eni niseet ashtimhom?? lol..bas wagdy ghonaim 7akeeeeeeeer

  • Comment removed

  • جزمة وجدي غنيم أشرف منك و من أمثالك

  • حلو السجع ده هوليود و كلام اليهود

    مهو الشتيمة ان مكنتش بالشعر و السجع و الفصحى تبقى حرااااام

    و انتا مخك مغسول بأفكار الوهابيين و شبه الجزيرة العربية

    عادل امام أحسن طبعا على الأقل مبيكفرش الناس

    بس أحب أقوللك إنى مثقفة جدا و عمرى ما كفرت حد اتناقشت معاه الحمد لله

  • ما شاء الله على السقافة ... مسقفة! الحمد لله ما اعرف سوى الحلال و الحرام، و ما أمر رسول الله و ما نهى عنه. و عادل امام في حكم الله أسوأ مليون مرة من راسم الرسومات الدانماركية للانه تهكم على القرآن و الصحابة و المسلمين و قدس عباد الصليب و حقر المسلمين ارضاء لشنودة

  • hahhhahha, Adel Emam ba2a aswa2 min dah?? lol, danta darib! Ba3deen 3shan howa ya7tarim el MISI7IYEEN zay mal Quran aal, yib2a kadashom..danta homar gidan!

  • يحترم النصارى بسب ا لاسلام و التهكم على الصحابة و أصحاب الذقون و اهانة الاسلام و المنقبات و التعريص العلني و المزاح الفاجر المشين المعيب للمسلمين.. عادل امام أسوأ مليون مرة من سلمان رشدي... و تنظيم القاعدة عنده حق يهدر دمه

  • الحمد لله و دى بقى وظيفتك فى الحياة اذا كان الرسول (ص)ما أمرش بالعبادة بس يللى بتفهم فى الحلال و الحرام لو مسلم كفر التانى و مكنش كافر يبقى اللى ابتدا هوا الكافر و لا دى ما عرفتهاش لسه؟كل اللى تعرفه ان العلمانية كفر زى ما بتقول؟و الأغانى حرام و الوش حرام كمان؟

  • و مين عباد الصليب دول قصدك اخواننا المسيحيين

    دول المفروض تعاملهم كويس و ما تكرهش كل من قال فيهم كلمة حلوة و حاسب لتكفر انتا من كتر منتا عمال تكفر الناس

    من الآخر التكفير سبة ع لسانكو لكل من خالفكم فى أفكاركم

    ..يلعن أبو كده

  • "اخواننا المسيحين" .. هيه.. في أى آية قرآنية أو حديث صحيح أو حتى في أي ضلالة عباد الصليب هم اخواننا؟؟؟ قال الله تعالى "انما المؤمنون أخوة" .. مش المسيحين النجس.. الكافر الملحد أرحم مليون مرة من النجس المسيحي الذي يؤمن بالتثليث و الوثنيات.. أرحم لك أن تأخي ملحد و لا تمشي مع مثلث ذ

  • Ah ikhwana ghasbin 3an omak ya sayi3! ya 3onsory ya motatarif ya kalb...tfoo 3la shaklak

  • عرفت بقى انك ماشى ع شرعك مش ع شرع ربنا

    المسيحيين ربنا قال عنهم انهم أقرب ناس للمسلمين يعنى اقرب كمان من اليهود

    شرعك و شرع شيوخك السلفيين قال عادوهم و كفرو المسلمين

    اه اخواننا و كل واحد حر فى عقيدتو مسلم ملحد هوا حر و مش هنعاملهم وحش و موت بغيظك

  • يا ريت ترجمة .... مش فاهم حاجة الله يرضى عليك

  • أحسن برضه .. هو ده كلام يدخل عقل واحد

  • viva secularism,I like this video...let ppl know who we r

  • viva death to you

  • 3la fekra elly beyd3y 3la 7ad betetradeloh wala mate3rafsh de ya sedna el sheekh ya ahbal

  • False: many nations around the world were ruled by fascist reiligious fundamentalists ( Central Asia, Latin America, Europe, East Asia) of different skin (islamic, christian, bhuddist,etc) but after religious nighmare was over, life goes on and culture prevails.

    Culture without religion brings more integration , unity for each nation.

  • Enta bayin 3leek mish bitifham English ya ahbal ya hamagy, ana Muslim ghasbin 3an Omak.3ilmaniya mish il7ad, fee 3ilmany Muslim we 3ilmany mol7id...we 3la fikra el yahood eli bitishtimhom dool Ahl el Kitab, lakin enta waty, we hamagy, we motakhalif...yalla yabny roo7 eshrab wa7id BOOL GAMAL we rawa2 nafsak..we bayin ahlak ma3irfoosh yirabook..7ata3mily fiha MUSLIM wenta bitishtim el shatayim deeh? lol, tab dah el mol7id eli biyitkalim kwayis ANDAF MINAK we min eli khalifook ;) ya ibn el bawab

  • مفيش حد في مصر كلها علمـآٍني يـعٍـني كل الي في مصر مسلمين ومسيحيين الخول الي حاطط الفيديو بدين امك علمانية اية يا كسمك هوا انتة اصلا عارف تكتب اسمك ؟ يلا يا ابن المتناكة يا خول يا جلنف روح اشتغل احسن من المتناكة امك

  • lol, wenta wadi7 min kalamak el wisikh dah enak muslim awy ya habiby! lol, ya munafik ya fasik!

  • Atheism are not welcome in Islamic world. Islamic sharia is the best for muslims and the non muslims who are living in the Islamic lands. This is the logic.

  • Well I think we should work rather than speakin ....Actions speak louder than words !!!Alright?

  • i agree with u, secularism is good,

    my first point is if it wasnt for secularism the muslims would have been annihilahted in india where they are minority.

    secondly secularism is good thing, its doesnt oppress ppl

    thrid thing, fuck all the arab goverment fuck egyot saudi morocco, fuck them all bunch of dictators what leader stayes in power for fucking 20 years?

  • Secularism was never the best thing... Look at Former Nazi Germany and Soviet Union's secular goverment and communist China... Hundreds of millions dead from secular government. Not only do you need Secularism but you need DEMOCRACY.

  • fuck secularism and fuck islamism,

    pan arabism is the best

  • Secularism isn't even a form of government, it's a part of many forms of governments like socialism and capitalism AND also pan-Arabist Baathism you idiot.

  • lol, Pan-Arabism (although retarded) is a secular movement, dipshit.

    Abd El-Nasser is a secularist.

    Hafez El-Assad is a secularist.

    Saddam Husien is a secularist.

    80% of Arab leaders in the 50's were secularists!!

  • haha is that ur voice?hahaha u sound like a total sissy, i never knew u speak in american accent hahaha i thought u speak broken english hahahaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa­a

  • i sound like a total sissy because i speak in an american accent & not broken english? loooool!! i think you need to go get your head checked!

  • yeah i been checked today, they gave me a clean cut.

  • almutairi I bet you're 8 years old, you must be for making fun of someone's voice you little shit (especially when there's nothing wrong with his voice) now SHUT THE FUCK UP.

  • Amazing video dude.

  • :) good one

  • Nasab be AsL weshak.TeLa'eek 7aree' ortak betomah,zay ba'eet eL nasbeen eLLy maLoo eL bald ~~~~~stop acting you're a good musLim~~~~~

  • Comment removed

  • Comment removed

  • o da men 2agmal sowar el takaroob been el nas el islam by5lilna entma2een

    entma2 el islam

    o 2entma2 lel watan be kol 3anasro 3shan lma ykon 7ad ded watano yob2a taba3an ded deno 3shan el deen byad3o el moslmeen lel defa3 3an 2adohom wa3ni watanhom ... yob2a leeh manesta5demsh el islam fel kol 7ayatna ???

    o sorry law tawelt 3aleek bs yareet te2ra kalami o trod 3aleeh

  • o msr lel masrieen bekol 2adianhom o da mesh klami wla kalamak da klam el islam bardo enena mane3tadeesh 3la 7d salemo maby3tadeesh 3alina fe 2ardena o masr de zay ma hya 2ardena hia 2ardohom..

    bs da klam islami mesh 3almani

    o ana ba7eb el turkish people 3shan homa moslmeen bel ra3'm men enohom mesh masrieen

  • o mesh mana kalami enena mansha3'alsh 3a2lena f el mawakef elly bt2abelna bs sada2ni law sha3'alt 3a2lak fe kol moshkela t2ablak hatla2y en 2este5dam el deen feha howa 2aksan krar ta5do 3shan t7el el moshkela de

  • ana mesh fahem enta leeh mesh 3aiez neda5al el islam fe kol 7aga f7ayatna ??

    2aslan el islan deen shamel le kol gawaneb el 7yah leeh b2a manesta5dmoosh fe kol 7aga ??

    ana mesh shayef 2ay mobarer lel kalam da ... el islam law 7ad fahmo 3'alat teb2a de mesh 3'altet elly bysta5demo el 2eslam fe kol gawaneb 7ayathom .. bel 3aks.. de 3'altet elly zayak elli by3amemo el namozag el motataref 3la kol el nas elly byesta5demo el deen f 7ayathom ..

  • Let me get to the point: At the personal level, do you believe that Islam is only practiced in the mosque, and probably home, away from every day life, or is a system that governs your whole life? We can then take it from there.

  • انت متاكد انك مسلم

    غريبة

  • You also say "I am politically secular, but my religion is 7amdullilah Islam".

    Being secular automatically means that religion is a private matter. If you really wish to practice what you preach you should not involve your personal religion/beliefs in any way shape or form in your arguments.

    I am against mixing religion with politics because it destroys both. I don't have to brandish my credentials as a muslim before I make such a solid and sound argument. This hurts (not helps) your argument.

  • BTW:

    Secularism (in the american model which you advocate) means that Bikinis and Niqab co-exist together in society provided that neither encroaches on the liberty of the other.

    That is one form of secularism of course. The other more prevalent form is the French model, which is kind of the secularist democratic extension of the the athiestic communist/socialist ideology.

  • The founder of humanist secularism in Islam is non other than Imam Ali himself. That is why the khawarij (who are similar to most political islam movements today) fought imam Ali all throughout his reign. Ever sense we had cycles in our history: Periods of enlightenment (e.g. Andalucian Ummayads) followed by periods of darkness (Moravids, Order of Assasins in Alamut etc).

    Imam Ali's ideas were ahead of their time. Everybody who fought him fought him in the name of religion including Mu3awiyah.

  • Hello Pharoah:

    I have a friendly suggestion: I suggest that you either speak in Arabic (egyptian arabic), or English but not mix two languages together. We don't need Arabenglish to take over our lives.

  • Thanks but this is the way man y of us speak in Egypt..we mix a little!

  • The only people who mix are those who recieve "English Education".

    This education is devastating our societies and creating mentally-handicapped generations (I am not referring to you so please don't take it the wrong way. It is just a general statement).

    We should think in arabic not english. Germans think in german but speak great english and they never mix and so on.

    I am not trying to lecture you. I just care for arabic culture including egypt's sweet and beautiful dialects.

  • There are some worlds in both languages that just don't translate you have to use the other language...out of curiosity how in the world do you know how German's think? And even if the few you know do it doesn't mean they all do. My cousin's wife is puerto rican for years she thought in spanish and translated it to english before speaking PERFECT english but now they she's been around alot of english speakers for so long she doesn't have to thinking about the meaning anymore.

  • ATATÜRK says:

    Islam, this absurd theology of an immoral Bedouin, is a rotting corpse which poisons our lives

  • ممكن اخنق عليكو الاغانى والموسيقى حررررررررررررررررااااااااااااا­اااااااااااااااااااااااااااااا­ااام ..كل يوم من دا

  • What a silly video. Its not up to you when to decide to implement sharia, its the will of Allah (swt) that man live by the laws he prescribed. If you accept your lords guidance, peace to you. If your too "smart" to follow the guidance, then your only following the path of misguidance and a terrible end.

  • STOP calling god.. ITS ALLAH... second go commit sucide the world doesnt need people like you...

  • ima rape you bitch.. i have been in egypt..

    and they all likeD me.. and they also said they liked Turkey.. (and that was the real majority)... no fakes like you...

    mohamed your a STUPID mothafuckker who makes modernpharoah look bad u say hes a ZIONIST.. haHhH your the fuckking zionist here..

    TRIEN to set up everyone against eachother...

  • Egyptians were probably nice to you, b/c they are nice people. They will do 100 hard tasks before asking you to do 1 simple one. Its the way they are, so don't ever mistake someone being nice to you, for liking you. Besides, if they liked you its b/c they don't know your heart. And neither do I, but your word here make your heart look very black, and for that, I will say a prayer for you.

  • Perhaps ur just bored&typing meaningless words into a computer screen but what u say effects others&u may not care but believe it comes home.Not from Tarek or Mohamed but sum1 dear2ur heart that u never believed would hurt u.When it happens think of this&never do it again.U may never admit it happned2us but when ur alone@nite u cant escape ur self torture&shame n the dark where ur empty mind will terrorize ur heart.b careful what u say, u can never unsay it even if u are sorry even if u r 4given

  • You MUST keep in mind, these aren't empty screen names, these are real human beings behind them. Not just you, everyone commenting one forums and threads everywhere, no one sees what you write no one sees the pain you cause others, no one sees what your doing to your fellow man... no one... except God

  • moha who the fuck are you bitch... i live in the netherlands ZAANDAM perim 3...

    if you dont like me visit me .. ill show you what i do to people who dont like me..

  • lol, easy Kardash! in Egypt we have a saying when someone is very asaby (gets nervous) we say "i'm sure you have turkish veins) lol 3ir2 torkey!

  • KHALASSS MAFISH SHATAYIM WALA MIN FARO WALA MOHAMEDELFAR!!! stop it guys!!!

  • secularism+watered down islam = hosni mubarak

  • I know we don't enjoy living together, but dying together isn't going to solve anything....

  • no one said anything about death... there are rules and people live with it... for example there are loads of laws I HATE in Egypt yet I still live in it and abide by its laws... I HATE many UK laws and policies yet I still live in it and abide by its laws

  • Those are lyrics to a song... and it just means just because we don't enjoy living together we can still live in peace far away from each other... we don't have to even be near each other... not we as in you and i, we as in anyone who doesn't get along..i've never had a problem with laws in the US until i moved to cali...this state has the weirdest laws i've ever seen!

  • i think your ideas are flawed mr secularist go back and think it over after aquiring some more knowledge of islam has to say good try though LOL

  • Before you judge Mr "ISLAMIC SCHOLAR" watch the God damn Entire video & see if it makes sense!!! If you wanna be ruled by someone like the regime of IRAN-SAUDIA-Taliban AFghanistan- SUDAN then fine, but not me & not most people!!! Those countries above are the ones where people used RELIGION to rise to power & we saw the devastating results!

  • IRAN-SAUDIA-Taliban AFghanistan- SUDAN if you think this countries are islamic your out of your mind you right we all would liked to be led by secularist lie MUBARAK SADDAM AND AL ASSAD ZARDARI NOT

  • mashallah bro i like this straight punch in the nose LOOOOL

  • Who doesn't enjoy a good punch in the nose... but seriously sometimes people do need a good slap in the face and told to wake up! There used to be a guy on the radio that will say some silly stuff about serious matters, like his response to animal rights activists saying who will save the vegetables slaughtered for decoration but he ended every segment..."WAKE UP AMERICA" b/c ppl don't see the big picture, Tarek's fighting4freedom not fighting against religion, ur attacking the wrong guy.

  • I slapped a guy the other day in Hyde Park for the same reason you said... to make him wake up... I dont mind doing it again... I am sure it helps... Tarek needs to clarify himself in a better way so he can avoid the confusion he is causing... he is using some expressions but giving them different meanings so he needs to stress the other meaning he intends...

  • was he literally sleeping or his brain was...lol...i wish i could just slap people sometimes...hahaha i feel like it a lot, but i could never actually do it...but that's just hilarious! I think he does, but I think before hearing him out people attack which cause him to defend something he isnt doing and trying to revert back to the subject but every new person who watches drags him back down there.They say never argue with an idiot they will drag you down to their level and beat with experience

  • What happened in Speakers Corner is that an Egyptian was cussing all arabs and all arab women (really bad names) so arabs came around him and started cussing egyptians... I came and strated challenging this guy trying to stop him but he ignored me... so i said out loud that his opinions do not represent that of egyptians.... they are strickly HIS opinions... so the arabs calmed down and applauded to me... his friend was angry that i failed their plan so he pushed me so my reflex was to slap him

  • Exactly Mojo, they come & ATtack, they see the word "secularism" & they think its against Islam or its Athiesm (istaghfar Allah) they dont even watch the video..they just attack & say they are better Muslims & blah blah blah without hearing my point, i clarify it a MILLION TIMES, look at all the ANNOTATIONS i even added to the video! But those people are very radical they just ATTACK!

  • Modern: you are using controversial terms and giving them NEW definitions so you can excuse them for the misunderstanding and you can never control how people think or react...

  • but secular isn't controversial, am i wrong? what has he given new definition to, but perhaps sometimes things need to be redefined in the mind of people who have been taught something is wrong. I grew up believing Islam is wrong, but when I met my husband he redefined the meaning of Islam in my mind. Giving old things a new definition is sometimes the way to go, especially when its the right definition and the wrong one has been heavily emphasized for far too long to unsuspecting recipients.

  • I am glad to hear about your positive experience :) Secularization as defined by its founders is defined as 1) the deinsitutionalization of the church n splitting it from the state 2) the liberation of people from the religious obligations and boundaries... i.e. extinction of personal piety... The first part is the only part famous about the definition the second part is less known... Tarek believes that Islamic law should be fully applied once sufficiency standards are assured within a society

  • I think only Tarek should make declarations of his beliefs but liberation of religious obligation...OR liberation of SOMEONE ELSE'S religious obligation. I don't want to be forced to say Jesus(pbuh) is God. He's the word of God made flesh but being in a secular country I am free from being forced to declare Jesus is God. Although it does free Christians from having to do that as well, but the intent is so I CAN do MY religious obligation NOT what the leader of my country thinks is the RIGHT way

  • I am asking him to explain his beliefs to better express himself... I didnt tell him what to believe in or how to express it... I am telling him that the message he is sending is not reaching the audience and my advice is that he should better express it in the way he finds right

  • You should be more patient with them sometimes, educate the uneducated.[i know ur trying!] People believe strongly b/c of what they were told. But when you start to open your mind and find the truth its alot easier to understand others point of view even if it is wrong. So go easy on the ignorant, but don't go easy on the stupid, b/c there is no cure for stupid =] We all start out ignorant but there is a point when we choose to search for truth or choose stupidity. And there is no excuse for it!

  • Ofcourse they are not ISLAMIC, but they claim to use SHARIA, why dont you get my point! They use SHARIA according to their own twisted thoughts, THATS WHY THEY ARE REDICULOUS & MORONS! They used religion to gain support, then they interpeted to their own way! I never said Mubarak or Assad were examples either! i said ERDOGAN, ERDOGAN! watch the DAMN VIDEO!!! Tell me, WHO now can lead the Islamic world CORRECT according to the Quran? Tell us a PLAN & FACTS not just your empty slogans!

  • you really want secularism but want to tell us its islamic secularism your argument is twisted forget my plan YOUR ideas are flawed and you wont get a majority of ppl who agree with you LOL

  • I agree that erdogan if given more space he will be able to apply islamic law inshallah... but regretfully he has to be VERY diplomatic and manouver a lot to reach his goals due to the secularism which is rooted in some elites in Turkey

  • I certainly don't! I want to vote, and know it counts. If someone is always gunning for your vote, they will always keep whats best for you in mind, even if they don't necessarily want that for themselves... like in Iran he promised woman things and didn't give it, but when they voted against him he was given the election anyway... real great implementation of the Islamic value-Honesty.... yeah right give me a break...

  • lets not buy the western propaganda... since when and they care about unfair elections... why didnt they make similar propagandas for the last egyptian elections where protestors were killed as well... its just because they are against Ahmedi and they want him down thats why they are spreading rumors and ehancing the opposition in Tehran

  • you're right, they only care b/c iran isn't an ally, but that wasn't my point, the comment was made that iran is a good example of implied islamic law, it wasn't about western interference with elections, obama said he wasn't going to interfere and we aren't going to just like we didn't in Egypt,athough i dont know what you are talking about b/c i only became interested in politics of any country in the last year but i know most countries other than america get elected once then never leave

  • in Egypt they were NEVER elected :D (if you are talking about real elections) and its the same in many other countries BUT NOT Iran... Iran is a respectable example of free elections and an Islamic Shi'i System.. This is their system and this is how it is... It is working perfectly fine... they are not banning peaceful protests and they will sit with the opposition to check their concerns

  • Like I said-ignorant is different that stupid.I'm ignorant in world politics, but it doesn't make me stupid. I can also see what's going on in Iran, but by the same token, the other choice they had, from what I understand was one of the ones who turned Iran the way it is today, but now people think he would change from what the current pres is doing...i have my doubts! Stephen Colbert says it right when he says the pres of Iran has declared jihad on neckties, y won't that man wear a tie?!=]

  • Look you have to know that the general policies of Iran and its foreign policy are not controlled by the president there is a religious head of the state who is in control of these issues. moreover, the fact that the west is commenting on the tie means that they are annoyed and bothered that he is not wearing one... which means that it is very important

  • well, actually i didn't know that until recently, but you're right i have no grounds for a political debate, i didn't say he wouldn't leave, i said it was handed back to him. And I'm not sure anyone noticed until Colbert brought it up, i think its cute that he doesn't wear one..kind of like the rebellious teenager of world leaders...id say they arent comfy at all, so why wear em?! i do think they look good tho, but the man obviously has style sense.. are you sure he isn't egyptian?they got style

  • Its importance is derived from the comments the westerns make against it... which means that they understand what it means and they wana impose it and refuse seeing him rebelling against it even if it was just a tie

  • Stephen Colbert is a comedian on a fake tv news show, he's just kidding, and so was... just to lighten the mood. infact, they used an image of Stephen Colbert in an add outside of a store in Iran and photoshopped his tie out... which is what started the talk about it in the first place, its funny the photoshopped the tie out and used his picture without permission. He thought it was funny too, which is why he talks about it so much

  • Its enough that it was raised and the question was asked, for me to ask what is very noticable about him not wearing a tie???

  • they took the picture of Colbert from another ad and in the other ad he was wearing a tie, and he was puzzled why they took out the tie, and then Colbert was looking at footage of the Iranian pres and he couldn't find him in a tie, he thought it was just one of those funny things that maybe iranians just dont like neckties, and just decided to bring it up. you have to admit, its much better than some things people say about him, right? just a little humor where most americans don't find it

  • SIMPLY FUCK ARABS.. exterminate them.. and you will do the BEST thing for islam.. they only fuck up islam...

    they make it look bad and they make it BAD... ARABS are untrusteble sand pigs..

    may their destiny be hell AMIN!..

  • Mhen and I assume that what you are saying now makes Islam look better?

  • @mhenlomatras: I'm sorry but i dont agree with you, because ofcourse not all Arabs are the same, you dont sound any better than the extremists my friend when you say EXTERMINATE arabs & they are pigs..lol!!! What we need is Education, & understanding & good people teaching us our religion!!! not extermination ;)

  • you are right.. but i am just angry.. about their stupidness.. and i am bored 2 death (broke my foot so i come on youtube pretty much (all the time... and then write pretty bullshit

    altought its not that i like arabs.. i quite hate them

  • and they hate you too... and Egyptians those like me (majority) also hate those like you... :)

  • ohhh Mo has arrived now! lol, Kardash, dont pay attention to him, he's with the wahabis! ;) lol

  • and you are among the pathetic apologetics Tarek as usual... you side with ANYONE against any point I make even if you admit that the other side is wrong... you are in an existentialist crisis... self hater

  • Saudi's its not only the teens.. their fathers raise them as shit criminals uneducated motherfuckers.. arabs are the cancer of humanity since EVER.. and they FUCK up islam... they betraye the caliphate..

  • Islam was given to an Arab! I would think long and hard before insulting the heritage of the Blessed Prophet Muhammad(pbuh) May Allah guide us all! If the Arabs have messed up somewhere at something its b/c of one simple fact--they are human. We all mess up! But by the Grace of Allah we are forgiven, we are given the chance to learn, prosper, love and enjoy happiness!

  • Which arabs are you suggesting that they might have messed up something? try please to be more specific so i can respond specifically as well... thanks

  • He put that Arabs mess up everything and they messed up the view of Islam, and I'm trying to say if they messed up anything ever, its not b/c they are stupid or unworthy, and when i say anything, i mean even forgetting to do something simple, i'm just trying to point out ALL people mess up, everyday, about everything, and they must have done A LOT right b/c the Qu'ran is still intact, its all its perfection, glory and honor, how can you ask more of a people than to keep God's Word perfect?!

  • mashallah your arguments are clear and strong and I totally agree with them... yet we might still disagree on the scope of application of Islam :)

  • I'm glad we agree, but like one sister put on another website, empires rise and fall but Islam stands true from beginning to end. You must apply Islam to your life, something that will face eternity with or without God depending on its application. D