The Smiths & Joy Division Live Versus Cancer Love Will Tear

[azarze01]

It's NOT Joy Division without Ian Curtis -- just a cover including some guys that played with him...

[LeLimeLine]

The Smiths suck, but they play this well.

[piguitit0]

part of the two best bands ever created

[Blueloire]

please re-title this properly andy rourke wasn't a smith. ever

[narcher91]

@Blueloire Andy Rourke most certainly was a smith. Crucial to the sound and some of the greatest smiths songs. Who are you to judge, he's an exquisite bassist.

[Blueloire]

@narcher91 he wasn't a Smith, Marr wrote all the music and their deal stated that the Smiths were Morrissey and Marr the other two were hired hands.

[narcher91]

@Blueloire I think you may be slightly ignorant on the matter. However, Andy Rourke DID write the majority of the bass lines. Mr Moz very sneakily only put his and Marr's name on the document for his own very lude, selfish financial gains alas the court processes soon followed. Since when did his financial standing matter in something as beautiful as the smiths anyway? I'm sorry sir but Rourke was definitely a Smith.

[narcher91]

@Blueloire Like saying hooky wasnt in new order, just because he didn't sing or play guitar like ian or barney. None of them were even contracted to factory, as tony wilson said 'they had the right to fuck off at any time'

[vinniesmithefc]

It can't be joydivison its on a camara phone and joy division split up over 20 years ago, its new order and the smiths

[vindictivevillain]

JD and the Smiths heaven

[moz1snorac]

what the hell!

could be anyone

[jeffydiablo]

If I go to heaven (actually i'm athiest, but I fantisize about the impossible) there will be Joy Division, and Smiths concerts every night.

[cancerbero8]

@jeffydiablo

why bother insulting other people's beliefs in a MUSIC video? Imbecile...

[sallyheartjack]

is this seriously them? that's awesome.

[karziflora]

Yes it is. Peter Hook & Andy Rourke.

[karziflora]

2 bass legends on the same stage, Rourke n Hook. Amazing.....

[uigweyi8eguigf]

yes ^_^

[thekillervinny]

Is peter hook wearing a Unknown Pleasures tshirt!?

[ciarankeavney]

i live next store to badly dawn boy and he was shiting his pants when he was there he was apsoloutly pissed he lives in chorlton

[nihilnoise]

3 bassist in one band, great idea! (not being sarcastic)

[HerrHorst303]

bloody hell!

you had an ace view!

was a top gig that! good video!

x

[bluebird264]

Bit difficult to live up to the heights of last year's line up.... disappointed this year didn't have as many one-off memorable moments.... disappointed is the word.... the atmosphere just wasn't there like the other years....

[ourhands]

badly drawn boy is incredible!

[matthewburton7]

I agree apart from supporting the charity I thought this was about celebrating manchester bands ! Where were they !!

[RichSelly]

gtta say no aywher as good as last yr bt stil a decent ending.... wot a top nite it wa tho!!

[jpwilkin]

and... this prick didn't know Instant Karma.

[jpwilkin]

after the Happy Mondays it was an anticlimax, what a fuckin let down. BOS

[ShaunC]

they tried to make it into a singalong at the end .. and embarressingly failed

you watch videos from last year of 15,000 people singing 'I am the Resserection'.. and this isnt a patch on it

'Step On' Was a highlight like!

[TehCooljon]

Yeah. I saw the video last year. That was probably music history made... not this year as Andy Rourke said. I don't think you would beat that, not unless you had all the massive Manchester bands all on the stage at once doing something. But I still think people singing Love Will Tear Us Apart was immense :)

[TehCooljon]

THIS WAS AMAZING. The whole crowd shouting Love Will Tear Us Apart. Last night was quality. Definitely going next year, shame about the Verve and Liam Gallagher.

[alexkw2112]

Was it ek as shit u dont know what ur on about

MONDAYS WERE BRILLIANT AND SO WAS FARM.

[whitelabeldemo]

last night was shit.

[ShaunC]

Shits not the word to use, dispointing would be better.

Was hyped as the best yet etc.. and just failed to beat the amazing lineup from last year

[whitelabeldemo]

after going to the previous two years, last night was shit in comparison.

[tolley87]

has anybody got the instant karma video from last nite?

[ciarankeavney]

AMAZING THAT WAS