In my opinion generic music includes Nirvana, Slipknot, AC/DC and Beatles. And this type of music doesn´t fulfil me. I need to hear something more artistic like Orphaned Land.
@MrStotts This makes me think of a few years ago, at a porcupine tree concert, when some people in the crowd started a little moshpit during Blackest Eyes and Steven said at the end something like : "come on guys we're not at a Slipknot concert!" It was really funny ^^ But I don't know if he likes them..
You obviously didn't listen to anything else besides what you heard in this video, then. Oh well, you're entitled to your opinion. I listened to almost everything by them and can tell you they ARE unique in a beautiful way and they ARE heavy.
He's not sayin AC/DC is shite he's just saying there's many bands that sound similar to them. AC/DC were pretty unique when they emerged and they are good but too many bands these days just rip them off instead of creating an own style.
Listen you morons, he's not saying that Nirvana and AC/DC were shitty bands. He's saying that too many bands sound are trying to sound like those bands and other bands. And for you people who think Porcupine Tree sound like Pink Floyd you must know nothing about either band. Sure Dark Side of the Moon was a seminal record in helping Wilson establish his style, but his style is completely his own.
@Jalanko13 I have to disagree somewhat, they definitely have Pink Floyd influences, but they also have the metal element in some of their songs, which Pink Floyd doesn't have. Their earlier stuff sounded more like Pink Floyd, but I still think Porcupine Tree have devloped their own style over the years. Just my opinion......
@pwoods100 I agree. Porcupine Tree used to sound like Pink Floyd on their early albums, but they have definately developed their own sound/style over the years. That doesn't mean that they have ceased to use elements of PF in their music. A song like "Time Flies" from their latest CD is surely inspired by Pink Floyd's "Dogs" from 1977.
@MrVoiceofreason123 I agree in what you say my dear fellow :) But if you listen to Porcupines more early records, like the sky moves sideways you will hear that it's sounds very much like Pink floyd. But porcupine tree HAVE changed their style. ( I love both old and new porcupine tree) :)
everybody can be hypocritical sometimes. And I used to love Nirvana and I don't think there are many bands that sound like them and do a good job at it
In my opinion generic music includes Nirvana, Slipknot, AC/DC and Beatles. And this type of music doesn´t fulfil me. I need to hear something more artistic like Orphaned Land.
dardamil 1 month ago
Hell yeah, i'm totally agree with this guy arguments. Orphaned Land is a band with new music.
Benkrock 8 months ago
What is the song playing in this video?
bRain524 1 year ago
@bRain524
sapari
morwsl 1 year ago
this guy knows
Hugoj33 1 year ago
I wonder if he actually likes Slipknot. That would surprise me. PT, and the Knot are my Two favorite bands.
MrStotts 1 year ago
@MrStotts This makes me think of a few years ago, at a porcupine tree concert, when some people in the crowd started a little moshpit during Blackest Eyes and Steven said at the end something like : "come on guys we're not at a Slipknot concert!" It was really funny ^^ But I don't know if he likes them..
Deadwing6 1 year ago
@Deadwing6 I wouldn't be that surprised, he has a very interesting range of music that he likes. That is kind of funny though.
MrStotts 1 year ago
@Leodude1
You obviously didn't listen to anything else besides what you heard in this video, then. Oh well, you're entitled to your opinion. I listened to almost everything by them and can tell you they ARE unique in a beautiful way and they ARE heavy.
jrockzmyv382 1 year ago
nobody sounds like porcupine tree most talented musicians in the industry and live they are incredible
PTHead1 1 year ago
@PTHead1 I believe you are forgetting Opeth
3dDuke 1 year ago
He's not sayin AC/DC is shite he's just saying there's many bands that sound similar to them. AC/DC were pretty unique when they emerged and they are good but too many bands these days just rip them off instead of creating an own style.
thrasher298 2 years ago 2
Listen you morons, he's not saying that Nirvana and AC/DC were shitty bands. He's saying that too many bands sound are trying to sound like those bands and other bands. And for you people who think Porcupine Tree sound like Pink Floyd you must know nothing about either band. Sure Dark Side of the Moon was a seminal record in helping Wilson establish his style, but his style is completely his own.
MrVoiceofreason123 2 years ago 25
@MrVoiceofreason123 Damn straight!
But Porcupine Tree Sound A LOT like Pink Floyd.
Jalanko13 10 months ago
@Jalanko13 I have to disagree somewhat, they definitely have Pink Floyd influences, but they also have the metal element in some of their songs, which Pink Floyd doesn't have. Their earlier stuff sounded more like Pink Floyd, but I still think Porcupine Tree have devloped their own style over the years. Just my opinion......
pwoods100 10 months ago
@pwoods100 I agree. Porcupine Tree used to sound like Pink Floyd on their early albums, but they have definately developed their own sound/style over the years. That doesn't mean that they have ceased to use elements of PF in their music. A song like "Time Flies" from their latest CD is surely inspired by Pink Floyd's "Dogs" from 1977.
wellendorph 9 months ago
@MrVoiceofreason123 I agree in what you say my dear fellow :) But if you listen to Porcupines more early records, like the sky moves sideways you will hear that it's sounds very much like Pink floyd. But porcupine tree HAVE changed their style. ( I love both old and new porcupine tree) :)
ingvaldandre 8 months ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
What is he saying? Nirvana & AC/DC are unique!
Yev300 2 years ago
bands that sound like them
chantofeskhaton 2 years ago 9
This comment has received too many negative votes show
they suucckkkkkk
xxchannelelliott 2 years ago
Great music!!
nocturnalconcerto89 2 years ago 5
So how come porcupine tree's voyage 34, sky moves sideways and loads of their stuff are Pink Floyd rip offs.
theporca 2 years ago
everybody can be hypocritical sometimes. And I used to love Nirvana and I don't think there are many bands that sound like them and do a good job at it
scrubbycritter 2 years ago
Why is he subtitled in English when he's speaking english?
abermouse 2 years ago
For people who don't speak fully english but can read them better than understand maybe.
AstralJokers 2 years ago 5
lol, i love how he just throws in ac/dc like the last minute...
octavarium008 2 years ago 3
0:21
Yeah...cus we're not used to hearing SHIT!!!
HA!!!! lol jk they're not that bad lol ;-)
labarrera13 2 years ago
Interesting. Hail Orphaned Land
Chuloloc 2 years ago
im actually kind of excited to see how this cd will sound.
grindcoremaniac 2 years ago
Steven Wilson is awesome :D
The new Orphaned Land album is beast, too. Can't wait till my copy comes.
MelodeathAddict 2 years ago 3
Do you know where I can preview it??
senzafine578 2 years ago
@senzafine578 Torrent.
MelodeathAddict 2 years ago