Added: 4 years ago
From: SnapeSoul
Views: 117,235
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (226)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • 1,771,561 tribbles would make a nice bed.

  • people of youtube pls see in the relationship what you will. i personally like K/S cause i just do but its fine to see them as friends too. plus may i remind people of the term T'hy'la which means friend brother and lover. they can be all or just one but the creator of the show coined that term so it is completely legit to see them as lovers or brothers.

  • @datawolf39 From the novelization of Star Trek, editor's comment on t'hy'la and the lovers rumor: "I was never aware of this 'lovers' rumor, although I have been told that Spock encountered it several times. Apparently, he had always dismissed it with his characteristic lifting of his right eyebrow, which usually connoted some combination of surprise, disbelief, and/or annoyance. -->

  • @datawolf39 Novelization, Admiral Kirk comment continues: "As for myself... I have always found my best gratification in that creature called woman. Also, I would not like to be thought of as being so foolish that I would select a love partner who came into sexual heat only once every seven years." So if you want to try and use the book to support your gay fetish fantasy, then accept what the book actually says.

  • @Mikanojo actually i was using the information from a interview that i saw if you really must know and i dont think that you are being very mature by saying mean things just because i like this slash pairing. on yeah and by the way what you said to disneyholic08 is not that accurate. sure the hand things were kisses but just because vulcans go through pon'farr does not mean that they can only have sex every seven yrs. im sure serek and amanda were intimae more than that.

  • Comment removed

  • There is room in the universe for both points of view. This was the first K/S video I watched, had never considered the possibility before that point. It was a stepping stone to answering my own questions about sexual orientation. If one person reaches a greater sense of self acceptance as a result isn't that more important than fighting over eros, philios and agape.

  • Gosh people.. calm down. I think this slash thing is funny and everything and the video is great, so stop arguing whether they were supposed to be gay or not. We can't know it. No reason to get mad at each other. I love this video and can somebody tell what the song is? I love it! :P

  • @RalfSchmitzfan13 Stephen Lynch - If I were Gay

  • What's the song ?

    Great video ! It's not the fist time I watch it, and the more I watch it, the more I love it.

    ;-)

  • Why do so many openly or still in denial gay men and a few perverted women keep insinuating and fantasizing about Kirk and Spock being gay lovers? Is it that you really are so ignorant of the many kinds of love that you cannot tell the difference between brotherhood and sex or is it just longing about the heroes you wish you could have had sex with? i have seen TOS, every episode now and if i had been alive and at least a teen in the 60s i would have wanted to have either of them as lovers.

  • @Mikanojo Well...when interviewd with the creator of the show and asked about it, he simply said 'if it was accepted at that time' and thats all. of course, the vulcan word, th'y'la means, friend, LOVER, BROTHER, as in, more than a friend, closer than a brother, more than just a lover. Theyre love was based on the Greek take on male/male love. and whats this about 'perverted' women? are you implying that there is something wring with loving a member of the same sex?

  • @Chloeissocoollad i am a lesbian. What is perverted about this whole star trek phony gay idiocy is that there is nothing in the series about it - rather a few perverts are trying to force it on the characters in lemon fanfics and these silly insinuative videos. I have no idea why you would claim the brotherly love between Kirk and Spock has ANYTHING to do with eros.. male/female love. And Spock NEVER used the word th'yla to describe his relationship with Kirk.

  • @Mikanojo Sorry that you were flamed. As a Slash writer I do see a different view of the K/S dynamic but I accept that is only my perspective. The way I see it is that we should respect each others different interpretations there is sufficent room for alternative views. I am grateful for the concept of slash, the internet doesnt have much to say abpout late blooming, but the K/S concept helped me to understand and accept my own sexuality (bi).

  • @JENATIM11 Oh please no worries? i was not offended by the comments. i wrote strongly as well. i have no issue with sexuality at all. i agree that too many people do confuse filios (brotherly love) with eros (sexual love) And confuse lust: the selfish desire to take, control and use -- with love: the desire to give, to honor and to yield. But when speaking of Trek, mai personal view is that i love it for what it WAS, not for what others wish it had been.

  • @JENATIM11 Why can people not simply accept the characters as they were actually portrayed, not dream up ridiculous theories about homosexual acceptance on television in the 1960s, not mix sound bites and video clips to try and make Spock and Kirk appear to be gay just to fulfill your own sexual fantasies about them? If you honestly like them for who they WERE, then let them BE who they were. If you honestly liked the show, then HONOR the show as it actually was.

  • @Mikanojo - It is sad that so many people distort the relationship between Spock and Kirk. They loved each other but in a NON SEXUAL way. Their bond made the show great.

  • @socalcraigster i agree completely.. people who have no respect for Trek, who have only immature ideas about love, who confuse it with sex - these people are dishonoring the memory of the show for the sake of their sexual daydream. Apparently young Mr. Shattner and Mr. Nimoy were such sex symbols that gay men and girls who get excited by gay men are having kink sex dreams about them and now trying to spread lies about the characters on YouTube. It is awful.

  • @Mikanojo

    See the problem is that you are implying that the superior relationship is brotherly platonic love and devotion. Why should a person consider a loving homosexual relationship based on love and devotion, inferior to a platonic one? If that is your belief than that is your belief that is another issue entirely.

    (Cont)

  • @Draqonelle1 It is NOT a matter of superior or inferior, it is a matter of fact as opposed to fiction. This can be applied to any characters in any book. Suppose that some one started a site or wrote a book dedicated to Harry Potter, but decided to make him muggle, claimed Ron was gay and Hermione was actually a death eater.. would you appreciate such a site or deny its claims as being a lying mockery of the original story? i love and respect the ACTUAL story, not the mockery.

  • @Draqonelle1 If Kirk and Spock had been gay it would have been fine. But they were not. Ever. And to push the lie until it becomes a small following of yaoi fandom just to give you and your little group one more reason to fantasize and touch your selves dishonors the characters, and the incredible work that Trek became. The fact remains, the characters were not gay, their form of love was brotherly, not sexual, and no amount of revisionist porn is ever going to change that.

  • @Mikanojo Calm down.

  • @davidls11 The slash game is not American but it seems it took Americans to turn it into desecration of loving memories and assassination of characters, How does dishonoring a show by twisting the main characters into homoerotic fantasy in any way honor them? It is only honoring the fetish of some people who apparently do not have enough actually gay people in their lives so they must invent them.

  • @Mikanojo decaf.

  • If Spock and Kirk are gay how does that change the beautiful bond of love we all can see between them? We don't just say that they are gay as an insult, we want to find these sort of characters in our lives. The question is are you okay with a loving gay couple who will live and die for each other... some people can't deal with that. Because we all know that this show depicted such a strong love between two men that it actually started ALL slash fandom. We should be celebrating love in its IDIC

  • @Mikanojo

    If Spock and Kirk are gay how does that change the beautiful bond of love we all can see between them? We don't say that they are gay as an insult, we want to find these sort of characters in our lives. The question, is are you okay with a loving gay couple who will live and die for each other? Can't we celebrate love and IDIC? The infinite combinations of lovers, brothers, friends, comrades? That make this relationship so compelling.

    And you can always mash on the dislike button

  • @Draqonelle1 I am lesbian, married to a wonderful woman, and have absolutely no issue with homosexuality at all. It is not really a question of accepting homosexuality, it is a question of letting some people who have no respect for Trek as it actually was, trying to reinvent the characters to suit their sexual kink. Saying that they were gay is a blatant lie, and the lie being spread dishonors the story and the author of the story.

  • @Chloeissocoollad i have seen every episode now. All of them. And all that i see is that some people WISH Kirk and Spock were gay, or they FEAR that Kirk and Spock were gay, because they really have very little understanding of brotherly love. The same idiots who thought Frodo and Sam must be gay because they hugged and Frodo kissed Sam on his forehead suffer from the same lack of wisdom.

  • LOL! Considering these two were the *original* slash pairing...This is a brilliantly funny vid. Thank you so much for making it.

  • I only clicked on this video because I knew that the word 'IF?' would be the top comment and I wanted to help it along.

  • a true piece of art

  • Stephen Lynch Rocks.

  • @hakuren10 Patterns of Force. 2x23.

  • what episode is 2:00?

  • i'd like to order one cheese sandwich, please.

  • this is my absolute favorite spirk vid. hilarious

  • Congratulations! You've been nominated at wicked_awards on livejournal for best music video. To accept or decline please pm me here on youtube or go to the lj community wicked_awards

    angelus2hot

    I didn't have any other way of contacting you

  • IF???!!! WHAT??! OH GOD OOPS!

  • Whiskey oddly looks like gasoline

  • 1:27 Denny Krane!

  • XD LOL

    

  • I think Spock is gayer...meh

  • thats so funny. KirkXSpock rulz.

  • Okay, you are directly responsible for waking my roommate. I laughed so hard, he woke up. Then I showed him this, and he spit water out his nose.

  • The video is soo great :D

    And Leonard Nimoy is amazing!! :D

    Please make more!! ; )

  • funny song! lol

  • Thanks for using this song, usually ppl use the Avenue Q one, but this one is better I think

  • I read If kirk were gay and the song that came to mind was " If you were gay that'd be okay. I mean cuz Hey I like you anyway~~~~~"

  • I always just assumed they were gay.

  • what's the title & artist of the song?

  • @skewlboypin Stephen Lynch is the artist and I don't know the name of the album or dvd it came from

  • what's the scene at 0:15? also I don't remember the episode at 0:30.

  • OMG, I knew it! lol

  • Kirk loves Spock in that special way, the way that made the relationship between ship captains and cabin boys so legendary. In fact, when asked what he thought of Spock once, Kirk said.. "well, on the (w)hole...

  • this is one fandom where i can scream "ITSNOT IN MY HEAD". but still the trekkie men refuse to believe me.

  • They are gay, its just subtle because back than gay wasnt politically correct. The writer even said there gay several times in interviews before he died

  • 9:48 IS SPOCK NAKED!?!

  • that's great!

  • LOL There is no if! XD

    If you have seen the show and the first three movies you know they are gay for each other :D

  • LMAO!!!! This video is awesome!! XD

  • Who are the 32 downers who thumbs downed this video!?! Downers!

  • grat song choice!!! lol leonard nimoy is very hot in an exotic sort of way. william shatner knows he wants a piece of that!!!

  • @AustinaCronk Yeah and Spock knows he wants Kirk too...in fact, it's driving him out of his Vulcan mind...

  • Oh? I thought that Kirk *IS* gay. My bad...*SNORTS* XD

  • jIH rop pa' wIj qogh Daq lIj yotlh

  • They can also be in love without sex being involved. <3

  • I LOVE SPOCK

  • ...I've heard this song too many times. Still makes me laugh.

    Awesome vid!

  • HA awesome combo with the song and clips.

  • Comment removed

  • @disneyholic08 Wau.. so you never understood the touches between Sarek and Amanda either? It was not sex.. the Vulcan sex is an emotional breakdown they involuntarily suffer through approximately every seven years, where they are overcome with instinct to procreate. The touches between Sarek and Amanda were the only public displays of affection that Sarek would allow.

  • what episode is 0:50 to 0:52 from?

  • @MiraChan: It is not an episode, it is from Star Trek IV "The Voyage Home"

  • Actually, isn't that from "Star Trek II: The Wrath of Khan"?

  • that's one of the movies

  • LOl i love this song :P ive heard it before but this is just hilarious XD Kirk. Is. BAMF.!

  • I don't know why but 0:08 into the thing just cracked me up.

    Good job on the video!

  • IF? What do you mean if?

  • 1:40 is from Amok Time.

  • Can someone tell me what episode 1:40 is from?

  • the one when spock is supposed to perform the vulcan wedding ceremony and believes he killed kirk, but mccoy had only sedated him.

  • this is beautiful xD i love it.. Spirk=OTP

  • OMG!!!! Just when I thought I had the last laugh with this song and the Kirk/Spock 'romance'!! Fantastic!

  • lol WIN!

  • wat episode is it where spock and kirk both have there shirts off and they have cuts??

    0:56

  • Patterns of Force.

  • the nazi one - patterns of force

  • @luv2angel The BEST episode *passes out* I think sadly it's the only one where Spock gets topless...

  • I love how the Amok Time fight scene looks so homoerotic now LOL!

  • This is awesome! Nice Lens Flare you GQMF!

  • 0:28 LOL! drunk again! xDDDD

  • Oh platos stepwhatever was terrible for me to. I don't think I can bear it once again. I just can't!!

  • Stephen Lynch...what a legend!

  • Comment removed

  • *IF*???

  • This is great. X3 Even if I did almost start crying when you flashed the scene of Spock's death. =3=v I liked it, though. X3

  • This is pretty cute!

  • If spock were gay, none of us could date him, tho.

  • LOL, I SOOO agree! :D

  • I agree with HArriet123p, plus it was a very funny, awesome vid. Love it!

  • Very funny ... works with the song really well. I like it as loving send-up of slash!

  • AHHH!!! This is fabulous. KOCK, it's why we have slash.

  • Does anyone know where this track comes from? SNL sketch or what?

  • it's steven lynch. he's a singing comedian.

  • Stephen Lynch, Comedy Central singing comedian. <3

  • Envy......it must be.

  • 0:12 spock is really hot

  • He's always really hot. Leonard Nimoy is such a beautiful man, he really is.

  • EEEEK.

    Kirk/Spock<3

  • Added to faves and given five stars!

  • wow that little audio at the end....lmao greatness

  • I nearly had a HEART ATTACK because i was laughing so hard. I am SO showing this to my sister.

    XDDDDDD

  • I am really not a Spock/Kirk fan but this is possibly the greatest thing I've ever seen in my life! Love Star Trek! :D

  • This is slahy, but looks awesome in a black shirt

  • At 2:07 what is the word that is being sung? I keep listening but I can't make it out.

  • I think he's saying "drawers".

  • You're right. I've read the song's lyrics some time ago because... I wanted to sing along correctly.^^

  • "drawers". It means pants.

  • i think its draws.

  • Yeah I later looked it up so I could do the same as Roxanaroxa.

  • LOLYAY. X'DD

  • Okay, okay I gotta know.

    Which episode is 0:27 ?

  • Pretty sure it's The Naked Time.

  • The Naked Time :-)

  • 0:27 is Plato's Stepchildren. One of those episodes from the third season when it really helped to be stoned when you watched the show. At one point, Kirk crawled around on all fours braying like a mule with a midget on his back. I kid you not.

  • It's physically painful for me to watch that episode. It's like a car crash, it's like a car crash, horrifying to see, yet you can't look away.

  • Yeah. I've been slowly watching all of TOS episodes on Hulu and I can't bring myself to click on Platos Stepchildren. I was probably 13 the one and only time I saw it and I have no desire to relive the experience.

  • Ugh..try watching it with your dad... Uncomfortable.

  • Yeah, but Barbara Babcock makes it for me.

    I had a thing for her ever since "Black Marble" (movie, not a Star Trek episode).

  • Comment removed

  • LOL O.o XD GAYLORDS!!

  • "So won't you stop cupping my.....hand!" lmao.

  • lmao especially hard because vulcans kiss with their hands XP

  • omglmao!!!!it's awesome!!

  • I love Stephen Lynch and Star Trek...this is amazing!

  • this is so gay

    lol haha

  • ...brillant. ROTFLMAO.

  • cute! XD

  • lol, the tribbles and 0:28 are the best. this is great! xD

  • 0:29 you mean! Agreed!

  • i think i am in love with you for making this. the editing, the song, dennis lerey (i can't spell) everything was perfection!

  • YOU MEAN IF SPOCK WERE gay

  • Hahaha... I just got up from rolling on the floor laughing. Brillant!

  • "J/7 would work if Janeway stopped trying to assert her authority.

    Picard/Q would work if Picard loosened up a bit.

    Kirk/Spock would work if....they were locked in a room together for twelve hours."

    LOL! So true! This was fucking hilarious!!!

  • that was...genius. thanks for the laugh. xD

  • You're ace! *worship: Funniest thing I've seen for a long time, can't stop grinning while watching! Thanks for many funny K/S-moments, you really rock!! <3

  • LOL!!!! Who Says they arent ^w^

  • Hilarious! I just looooove this one:o) Incredibly catchy song:o)))))

  • rofl this made my day. Just for this, may you live long and prosper.

  • how does this not have a 1m views or 5 stars??

  • TWELVE HOURS?

    I'd say five minutes, at the MOST.

  • AWESOME! x'D

  • you've made my day :) thanks, this is an awesome vid

  • Funniest thing I have seen on YouTube!

  • Pretty funny!

  • lol

  • Beautiful...

  • I keep getting Star Trek videos in my "Recommended For You" list and I don't know why. I mean I've never even seen the show before. This video is cool though. Slash is always fun.

  • Maybe you should just go with what's recommended - youtube obviously thinks you're a trekker at heart!

  • LOL. I guess so. I'll watch some Star Trek episodes. Thanks for the info. :)

  • Hope you enjoy! BTW is luvsirpaul ref to McCartney?

  • Yes. I love the Beatles.

  • Good taste :)

  • @luvsirpaul To be honest, I'd recommend Star Trek to anyone! It's hilarious!

  • dementia - just out of interest, why are you watching this if you're not fan?!

  • Maybe she's like me and YouTube recommended this to her for some unknown reason. But the video is still enjoyable even if you're not really familiar with the show.

  • If you like slash you should really watch the show - it's where it all started!

  • Slash started with Star Trek? I may have to check it out. Is the series available for download somewhere?

  • There are some episodes on the official website. Fans started writing slash in the early 70s - it was known as Kirk/Spock (where 'slash' c