those who state that this man is wrong for sharing his wisom of the harp may need to stop playing their own harp not everyone can afford private lesson and most people who are called to play the harp is connected to elements in some way dont hate give thanks i like what he said each to the own haters
@3M00RI No, it isn't :). Yeah, the basic idea when people think of it is Greek or Northern women playing the harp for entertainment of lords or at festivals, but...for example, look at Apollo, and maybe Pan! You can find guys playing the harp in even ancient stuff.
i dunno, from what i hear in comments of this channel's videos, these expert village 'experts' don't really teach things that are considered to be standard in their respective fields. same for the concert/irish flute video
@chansherly212 You're right, I've seen some about crafting, cross-stitch and Wicca, and while they're not necessarily wrong all the time, they're just really mediocre.
@sirchristian12 Once you know where the strings are, I'm sure it would be relatively straight forward. There would be a few techniques to learn, as with any instrument but I wouldn't expect it to be difficult.
Hi welcome to expert village. Today I'm gunna teach you the harp. Ok the first step is eating eggs lots of eggs imported from my farm. Next watch me waste your time telling you more uninteresting, uninformative, and inaccurate things so you will give up. Also the current president in bill clinton. I like men. (Lesson ends...)
Yep! It'd be really nice to see what you're talking about rather than just a transcription of what you're saying ( Hmmm! I can already hear what you're saying!!! )
I MAY AS WELL BE LISTENING TO THIS ON THE RADIO!!! ... It really is that useful!!!
Con te uno dovrebbe essere chiaro? Dopo che insozzi i video di un amico che per vivere non fa musica ma fa l'infermiere? Visto che ti piace la buona musica tra i miei potevi ascoltare Django Reinherdt, uno zingaro che diventò il chitarrista più grande dopo aver perso l'uso di due dita della mano sinistra. Ma tu devi essere uno di quelli che suonano con un neurone che si accende a intermittenza
I tell my students that it's the mass of the vibrating object, along with the amount of tension, that determines pitch. Mass and frequency being somewhat inversely proportional, all other factors being equal. Only when you have a string of the same width, material and tension, will the "half-the-length-twice-the-frequency" rule work. Thus harmonics. Any questions?
a string of the same pitch one octave above is not strictly half of the length of the string an octave below. I did not mention string diameter in my account, and my understanding of how string diameter compensates for what i guess is utilised for instrument design convenience and playability is rudimentary at best. Anyone have the answers on this?
Having taken lessons for three years, about seven years ago, I had hoped to find something to help me get back into it. Unfortunately, the top response for "harp" seems to be misinformed at best, and utterly wrong at worst. I suggest you research some, and try again.
I'm sure your intentions are sincere but you really shouldn't be teaching things which are plainly wrong. An octave string on a harp is NOT exactly, or anywhere near, half the length. Relative pitch is dependent on length AND tension and gauge of the string. Your other videos are also dubious as to the techniques you are putting across. Unsound tuition can promote bad habits. I think you need to review all of your videos and examine whether your lessons are valid.
Well, actually, all other things being equal, (string diameter, string material, etc. ) the octave string would be exactly half the length. Actually, this whole discussion of length vs. pitch is more suited to the pipe organ than it is to the harp.
It is not so bad as you think. I am a harpist for 11 years. And in Moscow all harpists play C-C with curled 2-d and 3-d fingers. it does not metter. I am sorry for my English.
It is seriously bad for the tension in the hand, and usually makes a bad sound.. I am spaking of curling the fingers high when playing 1-4.. nor keeping the finger round into the hand
it is unintelligent to make assumptions about pitch... i happen to know that pitch is measurred by vibrations per second, maybe if you knew that it would all make sense
Pitch IS measured in vibrations per second (Hertz). But length, tension & diameter cause the amplitude & frequency of vibration, resulting in pitch.
Take a string & keep the tension steady. By means of shortening it you cause different pitches. Put a bridge under the string at half its length, the remaining part produces the octave to the original string-length.
This is how guitars, violins &c. work. This fact has been known to Pythagoras and is still valid in the modern science of accoustics.
@fingerhorn4 Yes i play a lot of instruments, and i understand what your saying here, but this is mostly for people who dont really understand anything about music.. they might learn the wrong way at first but they will catch on.. no need to be hating XD
@fingerhorn4 You think because you used a lot of fancy words there, that you are right? Idiot. This man is teaching one of the many types of ways to play the harp, there are also many different types of harps, each with a different playing style. Do not critisize on something you don't know, therefore, shutup.
@GloryRave1 no I didn't use fancy words and there is no difference in basic technique between different harps. I do know what I'm talking about so I'm afraid I won't shut up. Harps have the same principle of relative tuning no matter what type. I know the poster is trying to be helpful but he is not giving information that is reliable.
@xXblackXbutterflyXxx Happy to leave the man in peace. I'm sure he is sincere. For example of how to play the harp properly, see videos of Xavier de Maistre and a host of really good, professional players who know how to do it!
@fingerhorn4 better idea...anyone who thinks that they can learn harp by watching a youtube video needs to review their life and examine whether or not they might want to pay for an actual lesson!
@fingerhorn4 lol not trying to hate or anything but why are u here???xDDD i find it funny that in a tutorial video people that come to see them end up saying the tutes are wrong ahaha
Now teach me how to dougie!
usmcpaintballer 1 month ago
Valid, schmalid....whatever! Thanks for posting! This helped me "get it" and feel less intimidated to begin learning this gorgeous instrument!
bmcgill555 3 months ago
fingerhorn4 reveiw all 138000 of them
Moreintoit 4 months ago
Once again, another Expert Village video with bad information.
activesack 4 months ago
when im dead i want to play rock, cant do that with a harp
rosewell1983 4 months ago
You're cute. . . I like your hair.
volk410 4 months ago
Арфы Сamac в России
+79057035621, icq 618261305, skype aprel_m Maxim
aprelikov1979 5 months ago
why is it that all expert village videos are crappy, uneducated videos?
CameronSquirrel 6 months ago
i learnt so much from this, thanks.
st3reo23 7 months ago
i believe Flute and Harp is the first instrument on the worldddddd !
thekingvietnam 7 months ago
OMFG!! to tune must be a bitch xD
Koolikoo 8 months ago
@Koolikoo Lawl... i was about to comment the same exact thing xD
Hawkspire0 8 months ago
those who state that this man is wrong for sharing his wisom of the harp may need to stop playing their own harp not everyone can afford private lesson and most people who are called to play the harp is connected to elements in some way dont hate give thanks i like what he said each to the own haters
andrea11603 8 months ago
Thanks alot... it really is useful :)
Angelkid190 8 months ago
Carol Mukhalian changed the way I play guitar.
Cupidville 10 months ago
And I may not know much aboot harps, but he's got some rocking facial hair. Just saying.
TacosAndThongs 10 months ago
That must be such a bitch to string....
TacosAndThongs 10 months ago
this harp sounds flat...is it just the recording?
Beanmusic1 10 months ago
This will take like 2 years to tune..
fraekkerten 10 months ago
mediocrevillage
TravisTriplet003 11 months ago 2
step 1:
buy a $ 1,000 instrument.
lamunecadog 11 months ago 4
BBBBBBBBBOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOORRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIINNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGG
isaiahbeasley123 11 months ago
are you john lennon?
evannaratama30 11 months ago 5
um i think i'll be off by saying that but.. a guy playing the harp .. isn't a little gay!
3M00RI 1 year ago
@3M00RI No, it isn't :). Yeah, the basic idea when people think of it is Greek or Northern women playing the harp for entertainment of lords or at festivals, but...for example, look at Apollo, and maybe Pan! You can find guys playing the harp in even ancient stuff.
kalacs32 11 months ago
i dunno, from what i hear in comments of this channel's videos, these expert village 'experts' don't really teach things that are considered to be standard in their respective fields. same for the concert/irish flute video
chansherly212 1 year ago
@chansherly212 You're right, I've seen some about crafting, cross-stitch and Wicca, and while they're not necessarily wrong all the time, they're just really mediocre.
kalacs32 11 months ago
Through everyones comments or corrections I haven't read the single person mention the most important detail a harp is capable of...
Harps can summon Unicorns.
danvancool 1 year ago 72
@danvancool
Hehehe! That really made me smile
JoudanJanaiHa 1 year ago
i saw another guy from the same channel TRYING to teach cello, both are shitty
jessparkerrrr 1 year ago
I like the harp it is interesting but I also love piano
Celeistal 1 year ago
i could teach myself how to play this.i just need a harp
TrAcI419 1 year ago
I am a piano player, is the harp anything like it? could I pick it up easier?
sirchristian12 1 year ago
@sirchristian12 its like the piano if you know notes, so it should be easy for you
PhilliFlippy 1 year ago
@sirchristian12 Once you know where the strings are, I'm sure it would be relatively straight forward. There would be a few techniques to learn, as with any instrument but I wouldn't expect it to be difficult.
MorkaGraven 1 year ago
this is retarded son of a bitch
Proelloy 1 year ago
Hi welcome to expert village. Today I'm gunna teach you the harp. Ok the first step is eating eggs lots of eggs imported from my farm. Next watch me waste your time telling you more uninteresting, uninformative, and inaccurate things so you will give up. Also the current president in bill clinton. I like men. (Lesson ends...)
TheYeasteatingwalrus 1 year ago 2
Im happy my Coach didnt teach me this way or I would of never learned...
loveofmusic12 1 year ago
You look like John Lennon's son. I hate that copy cat fucker.
scartissue94 1 year ago
lol people don't know how to turn off the cc.
ThatOneAsianChick 1 year ago
how am i supposed to learn if i cant even see you play?
rocketgirl196 1 year ago
OH Forget it!!
I'll go elsewhere to find this stuff out!
There are plenty of other vids out there that'll explain this stuff without obscuring it with cruddy narration of what is being said!!!
I see you've posted other vids! ... I wont even bother with trying them out!!!
iceguyred123 1 year ago
Yep! It'd be really nice to see what you're talking about rather than just a transcription of what you're saying ( Hmmm! I can already hear what you're saying!!! )
I MAY AS WELL BE LISTENING TO THIS ON THE RADIO!!! ... It really is that useful!!!
iceguyred123 1 year ago
this is a video for all the people that just randomly go out and buy a harp and wanna learn how to play it lol
FireLover27 1 year ago
Is he retarded?
Mkalola 1 year ago
gay
duskedennis 1 year ago
Expertvillage sucks bawlz.... bawwhhhhhllllzzz.....
Sure, whatever, they can play instruments.
They can't teach though, and that's what their youtube channel is supposed to be for.
apes2gogo123 1 year ago
he kinda looks like john lennon (:
MrRedneck12345 1 year ago 17
@MrRedneck12345 He does o.o
drew2012 1 month ago
expert village has NEVER put out a decent video, what were you dumbasses expecting when you came here. i knew it was gonna be shit.
ibanezxiphos700 1 year ago 2
@ibanezxiphos700 I honestly don't understand why they even try. Why teach if you're teaching the wrong things??
Rainhylda 1 year ago
He took 3 minutes to say that this red string... is half the length of this red string... *face palm*
sisenikelet 1 year ago
If there was a social services equivalent for harps, I would report this man to them.
RagdollAlice 1 year ago
fail... fuck expert village!
PSR2100inUSE 1 year ago 2
good fr the beginners,thanks,useful
maellen1 1 year ago
dumbass village much
BrillianceIsForever 1 year ago
I dont mean to sound like a smartass, but I think everyone knows the strings get shorter towards the top.
drumaster24 1 year ago
100% percent WRONG!
tonyonly2 1 year ago
Con te uno dovrebbe essere chiaro? Dopo che insozzi i video di un amico che per vivere non fa musica ma fa l'infermiere? Visto che ti piace la buona musica tra i miei potevi ascoltare Django Reinherdt, uno zingaro che diventò il chitarrista più grande dopo aver perso l'uso di due dita della mano sinistra. Ma tu devi essere uno di quelli che suonano con un neurone che si accende a intermittenza
TheMILITANTPSONS 1 year ago
the harp makes me get a huge boner!
TheShoppingTrolly 1 year ago 7
Great... Had to know that... Really.
Apopholis 1 year ago
this is exactly what i was looking for, i totally wanted to know the lengths of strings THANKS.
heyitskarlalara 2 years ago 3
I tell my students that it's the mass of the vibrating object, along with the amount of tension, that determines pitch. Mass and frequency being somewhat inversely proportional, all other factors being equal. Only when you have a string of the same width, material and tension, will the "half-the-length-twice-the-frequency" rule work. Thus harmonics. Any questions?
grandmasoldguitar 2 years ago
My mistake!
a string of the same pitch one octave above is not strictly half of the length of the string an octave below. I did not mention string diameter in my account, and my understanding of how string diameter compensates for what i guess is utilised for instrument design convenience and playability is rudimentary at best. Anyone have the answers on this?
myspace,com/jessesparhawk
And I'm down for some raw vegan apple pie...
sparhawk5000 2 years ago
Very interesting thank you so much for the info make sure you post up more...i might end up buying a harp LOL
NON55378008 2 years ago 2
Having taken lessons for three years, about seven years ago, I had hoped to find something to help me get back into it. Unfortunately, the top response for "harp" seems to be misinformed at best, and utterly wrong at worst. I suggest you research some, and try again.
Best regards,
Elizabeth
LilyoftheShadow 2 years ago 2
This has been flagged as spam show
Hi I like pie.
redrubberyboots 2 years ago 176
I also like pie. Apple is the best :-P
blueeulbdude 2 years ago 7
Comment removed
Musio215 2 years ago
OMG yes, mmm Applepie...
xxSPFxx 2 years ago
@redrubberyboots Hi, who doesn't?
revolutionary210 1 year ago
thanks im56 male wantig to play saving few pennies now and agian towards harp like yourcamac how much would they run cashcool9
cashcool9 3 years ago
I'm sure your intentions are sincere but you really shouldn't be teaching things which are plainly wrong. An octave string on a harp is NOT exactly, or anywhere near, half the length. Relative pitch is dependent on length AND tension and gauge of the string. Your other videos are also dubious as to the techniques you are putting across. Unsound tuition can promote bad habits. I think you need to review all of your videos and examine whether your lessons are valid.
fingerhorn4 3 years ago 97
Well, actually, all other things being equal, (string diameter, string material, etc. ) the octave string would be exactly half the length. Actually, this whole discussion of length vs. pitch is more suited to the pipe organ than it is to the harp.
bartk1448 2 years ago
I'm more worried by his curled fingers... not good for the sound or the hand!
barokharp 2 years ago 6
It is not so bad as you think. I am a harpist for 11 years. And in Moscow all harpists play C-C with curled 2-d and 3-d fingers. it does not metter. I am sorry for my English.
LediTananda 2 years ago
It is seriously bad for the tension in the hand, and usually makes a bad sound.. I am spaking of curling the fingers high when playing 1-4.. nor keeping the finger round into the hand
barokharp 2 years ago
Yes, anyone with only an average ability to measure by sight can see that he is telling nonsense.
sonof444 2 years ago
No, that's physically how strings work. When you cut a string to half the length, you get an octave. He's telling the truth.
Muenchies 2 years ago
No, because he is talking about a harp. The strings of a harp do not have the same diameter. The lowest string is thicker than the top most treble.
Take a monochord and you get an octave by 1:2, a fifth by 2:3 &c.
sonof444 2 years ago
My mistake. I wasn't aware that their diameters varied.
Muenchies 2 years ago
The diameter is not so easy to see in the video, but you can also tell from the actual lengths of strings an octave apart.
sonof444 2 years ago
do you even know how to measure pitch... didn't think so by you're unintelligent comment... sonof444
JoeEllis1026 2 years ago
[to: JoeEllis1026] Did you read the tread?
And can you explain what you think to be unintelligent?
sonof444 2 years ago
it is unintelligent to make assumptions about pitch... i happen to know that pitch is measurred by vibrations per second, maybe if you knew that it would all make sense
JoeEllis1026 2 years ago
Pitch IS measured in vibrations per second (Hertz). But length, tension & diameter cause the amplitude & frequency of vibration, resulting in pitch.
Take a string & keep the tension steady. By means of shortening it you cause different pitches. Put a bridge under the string at half its length, the remaining part produces the octave to the original string-length.
This is how guitars, violins &c. work. This fact has been known to Pythagoras and is still valid in the modern science of accoustics.
sonof444 2 years ago
@fingerhorn4 I've noticed that nearly ALL the expertvillage videos I have seen- the people have NO clue what they are doing XD
pruedence110588 1 year ago 2
@fingerhorn4 woooowww u are SMART lol + good in describing the correct posture and way of the harp. DOUBLE THUMBS UP !!! [ if i coud ] haha(=
pikachu72147 1 year ago
@fingerhorn4 It's EV, they never get it right.
Rainhylda 1 year ago 2
@fingerhorn4 Yes i play a lot of instruments, and i understand what your saying here, but this is mostly for people who dont really understand anything about music.. they might learn the wrong way at first but they will catch on.. no need to be hating XD
Punk8Musical8Gamer 1 year ago
@fingerhorn4 You think because you used a lot of fancy words there, that you are right? Idiot. This man is teaching one of the many types of ways to play the harp, there are also many different types of harps, each with a different playing style. Do not critisize on something you don't know, therefore, shutup.
GloryRave1 1 year ago
@GloryRave1 no I didn't use fancy words and there is no difference in basic technique between different harps. I do know what I'm talking about so I'm afraid I won't shut up. Harps have the same principle of relative tuning no matter what type. I know the poster is trying to be helpful but he is not giving information that is reliable.
fingerhorn4 1 year ago
@fingerhorn4 Just leave the man in peace. Whoever choses to take his lessons can. If you don't want to then that's fine. Do you play the harp? [:
xXblackXbutterflyXxx 1 year ago
@xXblackXbutterflyXxx Happy to leave the man in peace. I'm sure he is sincere. For example of how to play the harp properly, see videos of Xavier de Maistre and a host of really good, professional players who know how to do it!
fingerhorn4 1 year ago
@fingerhorn4 OKAY mister scientist!!!
Zelcibot 1 year ago
@fingerhorn4 better idea...anyone who thinks that they can learn harp by watching a youtube video needs to review their life and examine whether or not they might want to pay for an actual lesson!
zachmasterzach 10 months ago
@fingerhorn4 lol not trying to hate or anything but why are u here???xDDD i find it funny that in a tutorial video people that come to see them end up saying the tutes are wrong ahaha
realderekbrothers 10 months ago
shame he's wrong about the length of the strings
wbrigg 3 years ago 8
What kind of Harp is that?? I want that exact harp. Please tell me. Thanks!
Chocolatelover123 3 years ago 4
This harp is a Camac Korrigan.
gh0stbitch 3 years ago
dubble amaaaazing!
GhostGirlsays 3 years ago