Love Crimes of Kabul filmmaker Tanaz Eshaghian

[kakazadani1]

fuck iraniajn look at them self they are the beggst bitches in the world

[snifrol]

Mind your own bizznizz bitch

[khatera333]

I live in west but I am horrified by your western laws open prostitution brakes millions of families a part teen pregnancy and their boyfriends are not willing to pay child support and alimony etc. so don't even tire to show our culture weird cause it is not it is a beautiful culture the problem or unfortunate is poverty and luck of education. if our people would not have been corrupted by westerns they didn't had to worry about their economical situation and how to raise their kids.

[feroz12554]

well i live in canada ,i visited afghanistan last summer , life for women are way better in afghanistan than canada, for ex, in canada women think they are freedam ,but this is not true ,women has no value in canada cazz i fucked more than 80 women but in afghanistan u cant, hahahaha fuck fox new and american system

[tanha416]

it is interesting that iranian filmmaker go to afghanistan why she dosen´t go to her own country ´,they just makee business on afghan kultur. ,

[farid5979]

who A R U ?

[maiwandwal]

I am sorry but I dont have a lot of time and certainly this is a complex issue which we cannot resolve here on utube with word limit lol GOOD LUCK my friend - I can see you want good things for our nation but choose your battles well :) May the force be with you lol

[Homaira143]

@maiwandwal as i explained everything in the message.. but please don't tell me that afghans don't rape and they don't beat their women. ONLY MEDCs have record and us, afghans we have no record because beating women is legal in Afghanistan. and is that humanity? ME? i'm a woman! a female! who can no longer see my own relatives and sisters and myself in such situation. We have great social scientists who can gather infos of what women desire. its not beating and cruelty,i hope its not urs anyway

[maiwandwal]

YES but when we do it in the natural order of things then the world is in harmony but when we go agaisnt it it causes suffering, destruction and chaos - as can be seen by anyone when they look around ANY Western nation who have women in the work force and its impact on the family. We are in the throws of the destrcution of the family and you want that to become the social norm in our nation> you have got to be kidding!

[maiwandwal]

How do you think great civilisations and empires were built? It was because women took a supportive role and man an active role in politics and organisation etc. That doesnt mean they were more clever or more capable than women - JUST we are biologically wired for different things. God made us into nurturers and men as our protetcors and providers - can we do these things ourselves -

[Homaira143]

@maiwandwal WHO says "God made us into nurture?" we made this lifestyle ourselves. we made many mistakes in our lifestyle. but men as OUR PROTECTOR? from what exactly? wolves? lions? this was when we lived as cave mens. not anymore, time has moved on. we need to move on too. It's not mens job to protect women but its both of genders responsibility to protect their community. not just men. but discuss this in the PM :) but thanks :D

[maiwandwal]

ooops I meant there is nothing more sacred than family and rearing children

[Homaira143]

Iran is not Free-er for afghans. it is just to run away from horrible family. they go there to be away from people but unfortunately they'll experience life worse than they do in Afghanistan

[maiwandwal]

@Homaira143 Look at the west, there is domestic violence, drugs, peadophilia, rape and murder - no different to our problems just different labels. Afghanistan is a place of great culture and tradtion far from hell - lady - get ur facts right!!!! BTW the femonazi movemnt was what killed the family in the west. If I were you, get INFORMED before u start harping on abt womens rights. That is a VERY dangerous road to walk down. Womens rights = no responsibility to husband. to children, to the home

[Homaira143]

@maiwandwal No difference to our problem? OUR COUNTRY is s'posed to be ISLAMIC! this is the main difference. i live in a western country. i had to leave Afghanistan because i needed education. i needed my human right. afghanistan didn't give much my right to do what i needed to do. we shouldn't even compare western countries to Afghanistan. because we are Islamic republic and they are not. we should be a role model but look at Afghanistan.

[maiwandwal]

@Homaira143 "Needed" human rights? Honey you were born with those rights. Having rights doesnt mean at the expense of ur family. Get an education for what? Our purpose in life is for family and God - NOT work.. STOP reading sociology books which are destroying u as a woman. I have 2 degrees and I can tell u now my family comes FIRST.

[Homaira143]

@maiwandwal; so you are telling me that we've always been like we were under Taliban regime? this is where you are wrong. look at the history of Afghanistan. how we were and how we are now. Women didn't had to wear Burqa. With Education comes understanding. people who are not educated are like blinds. they won't be able to run the family properly (even if we had to stay at home) i can't believe you are a woman and you still say stuff like this?

[maiwandwal]

@Homaira143 No at all. I never siad that we were this or that. I know there was a time when wahabi style regime wasnt present in our nation, Even under Islam, we had freedoms we enjoyed than other muslim nations. I have heard abt the golden age of our nation when in the 60/70's women wore western clothes and went to university and travelled to/fro without being judged or harrassed. I know there was no burqa for many city ladies. things were chaning and life was very good

[Homaira143]

@maiwandwal Afghan women face discrimination every day. where as in England 4 example they don't. when i walk on the street i don't have any fear but when i was in Afghanistan i was waiting for my death every second. Feminazi? they may be a bunch of idiots but what does it make us? so, are you really telling me that afghanistan is a good place for women? they get killed if they ask for education. they get killed if they want to chose their own husband. ARGH!! i'm not even sure if they are human

[maiwandwal]

@Homaira143 I dont care abt my job. At my death bed , it will be MY FAMILY not what status I held or how much i was paid. Ultimately ppl want these things to make themselves feel superior - 'look at what I have achieved and look at what I do and how much I earn blah blah blah. I have all of that and beleive u me, its FAMILY that matters.

There are things I agree with u, we are not perfect. There's room for things to improve.

[Homaira143]

@maiwandwal I care about my family too. Thats why i can't stay at home and because of this tradition make the life of my sisters and my daughters living hell. you have 2 degrees and ur mind if still not open enough to see why women and men needs to be equal. do you really think Afghanistan is following Islamic laws? do you see how much women suffer in Afghanistan? do you not see their lifestyle? do you not see why Afghanistan never develops?

[maiwandwal]

@Homaira143 you are very wrong - my mind is very open BUT I have witnessed the tragedy of women in the work place and it's impact on society. I have researched the agenda behind things that are unfolding in the world right now. I think some of the things u have now stated is very different to what was veing said. Wearing the burqa or not is very different to women working and forgeting abt their families whilst they build up a never ending career. U ask abt development - what is ur definition of

[Homaira143]

@maiwandwal yeah this conversation face2face is better. but what i want for women in Afghanistan is to be equal. to experience a better life. i don't want them to end up killing themselves because of such situation. i want women to get educated. personally i want to work and i want my husband to bond and to nurture my kids as much as i do. i want to put food on the table with my husband. i want to share same responsibility. thats when equality kicks in. that's what i want.

[maiwandwal]

@Homaira143 yep, YOU want equal rights for women? Who are u or anyone else to dictate what is right for women. The women who desire something, they will always endeavour to reach their goal. IF YOU want freedom then choose that for urself. Instead, our ppl need food, shelter and clothes etc They are fighting for their survival and you want to talk abt womens rights (A Western concept) ANd which has FAILED 100% and you want to adopt this. U say its not western life, ......cont....

[maiwandwal]

contin...of course that is where you got ur ideals from. That is the modality that has been sold to you. Packaged to you just like a product. As previosuly stated, Women like you want us to forget abt thousands of yrs of knowledge and wisdom so that you can be free do work and make a 'career" - Go ahead but dont go harping on abt it for other ppl. They know what they want based on THEIR values and beliefs - not yours and not mine.

[Homaira143]

@maiwandwal oh so you work? that's interesting. imagine your life how most afghan women live. WOULD YOU REALLY WANT TO EXPERIENCE IT? would you happily give up your right to the cruel men? do you need PERMISSION to go shopping? would you willingly give control to men over your live? << THATS THE HUMAN RIGHT IN AFGHANISTAN. We don't need western life. we need a BETTER LIFE. do you think Afghan life is an ideal lifestyle? God. you gotta be kiddin' me.

[maiwandwal]

@Homaira143 I dont need to imagine anything. You are making Afghan men into animals... YOU are making OUR men into rapists and wife beaters. There is no more and no less domestic violence etc in our nation than in the West - where women apparently have many "rights" It doesnt stop rape or murder or violence.

[maiwandwal]

@Homaira143 The main reason why we as a people have survived so many invasions etc is BECAUSE of our strict lifestyle. Nothing is more powerful than family ties and tradition/culture. Women have freedom in the West - tell me how has it served them? I can see awful consequences for our western nations. Not long ago (maybe 60 yrs ago) they had their women at home as homemakers and there was less, crimes, drugs, paedophilia etc etc

[Homaira143]

@maiwandwal YOUR purpose is Family and GOD. my purpose is to serve my nation and women of Afghanistan thats comes my family and my humanity first. haha! am i not Muslim? funny! Does it look like i want women to be under the control of Men? In qur'an it clearly stated that men and women are equal. who are we to change that? actually PM me and i think we have a lot to talk. Theres nothing mentally that's bonds us.

[maiwandwal]

@Homaira143 development. What is it that u want? Many ppl want the same as what the west have and clearly that model has failed miserably!

I DO beleive womens place is in the home, taking care of the her family and dedicating her life to nurturing. What couold be more fulfilling than nurturing ur family and making stable little hyumans to continue the human race. SInce the 60's women in west have gone to work and look at the results!! ANyways this is a conversation to have face2face good luck

[maiwandwal]

@Homaira143 I want u to go and read some material by Dr Henry Makow. You will see WHO was behind the feminist movement and to what end it was created for. Their was an agenda behind the whole movement. Being informed is vital. Tell me what ur thoughts are after u visit Makows site. Take Care. We may not agree but we are both afghan women and that alon bonds us as far as I am concerned . BTW R U not muslim? PM me if u like :)

[Homaira143]

she says it cracks her when afghans think that Iran is morally loos. are you kidding me? Iran is worse than Afghanistan, the way they treat people in prison is just terrible. at least people have peace in prison in Afghanistan. Islamic Revolution (immam Khumeini) made the life of iranian 100% worse. They way Iranian treat afghans in Iran is disgusting. it shouldn't crack her up when afghans think Iranians are morally loos because they are.

[weppi91]

Shes Iranian.

[martyaus2905]

Afghanistan is a total shit hole.

[azaadi8]

Idiots! Afghanistan is not in the Middle East. Also, adultery is illegal for men and women and they both get punished, so don't make this about injustice against women.

[nazeerrockbreaker1]

i think she her serlf[tanaz] the way she speaks it looks like she is addicted . may be she could be a junky .

and she says it cracks her when afghans think that Iran is morally loos as my self been in tehran for several years that is true and if the west attack Iran i am 100% sure iranian bra will be looted by brits and the under wear by Americans AH AH AH AH HA HA AH HA AH AHHA HA H AAH H

Iranian nation is the most loos and dishonor nation i have ever seen among the meddlestres

[nazeerrockbreaker1]

i think she her serlf[tanaz] the way she speaks it looks like she is addicted . may be she could be a junky .

and she says it cracks her when afghans think that Iran is morally loos as my self been in tehran for several years that is true and if the west attack Iran i am 100% sure iranian bra will be looted by brits and the under wear by Americans AH AH AH AH HA HA AH HA AH AHHA HA H AAH H

Iranian nation is the most loos and dis honor nation i have ever seen among the meddlestres

[maiwandwal]

Freedom of choice in the west? Really, u need a licence to fish, gun licence, drivers and marriage licence, dog licence, tv licence, licence to protest in 'zones' what fucking freedom do you have? Bush gets in without enough votes and u call this freedom and democracy hahahahaha

[maiwandwal]

This bitch is a traitor - making this to show in the human rights watch WTF its none of ur fucking business. What u prefer all women to be whores and go dancing on tables, dressing like whores, pole dancing at 12??? I prefer the customs in AFghanistan any day and I grew up in the west!! Fucking arrogant dumb bitch!

[maiwandwal]

@AbdurRahman1776 No I am Christian and what does that have to do with anything?

[Homaira143]

@maiwandwal it is everyone's business. as a woman this is something she thought she needs to do, the whole world needs to know what afghan women are going through.. look at afghanistan. are you kidding me? Afghanistan is a hell on earth for women. they have no right as a human. Islamic? DAMN IT!

[maiwandwal]

@Homaira143 NO it is NOT! She has no right to speak for the women of Afghanistan./ Tradition is tradition. A womens place is in the home NOT at work and not leaving her children in childcare. Sure we have problems in the country such as acid throwing but which country doesnt? She make us look like barbaric ppl and like a fool you defend her!

[Homaira143]

@maiwandwal OH MY GOD! are you for real? Stuff that tradition that makes women to stay at home. you have no idea how much you made me angry with this statement. traditions which is not good for our society we must not follow it.. ARGH! Women are driven to kill themselves because of such situation. women and men are equal. women needs to do what they want, same goes for men. and to be honest my aim in life is to make a change for women in Afghanistan. i'll work, who is there to stop me?

[maiwandwal]

@Homaira143 OMG are YOU for real? Seriously "stuff tradition which makes women stay at home" ? Honey you have been reading too many sociology books. So YOU want US to forget thousands of yrs of accumluated knowledge adnm wisdom which has brought incriedbile empires so that u can go to work. Tell me what is more important your "work" or ur family,ur husband and ur children? There is nothing more scared than our families. Work wass to enhance our familiy life not destroy it as we have seen in west

[kataSang]

Arabs brought this culture when they occupied Afghanistan which sucks and it bothers me all the time as an Afghan seeing no major changes in the lives of women and children especially. 85% of Afghans are uneducated i think. I will remain hopeful till the day we get ride of those hardcore uneducated Afghans both men and women. Once we get to that stage i think we will accomplish something & will see improvement otherwise there'll be some barriers.

[Albertanator]

@kataSang I agree....if Afghans can discard Islam, their nation will be going in the right direction.....right now their is too much radical islam there though....hopefully that changes!

[maiwandwal]

@Albertanator IF ONLY afghans turned to Christianity then we can have a sound religion and progress in a moral way - most of the problems stem from Islam

[baturaftam2334]

she is wrong about the part that Afghans go to Iran because its free-er, they go thier just to be away of their family, so that nobody could find them.

[bacheshiraze]

111

[weareallanimals]

It's always interesting to see another country's customs and rituals. I enjoyed it thoroughly. I think all US women should watch this documentary and thank the lucky stars they don't live there.

[sol88850]

your amazing

[Meher2008]

Thank you Steve for posting this!

[ulyssesgood1]

great Job!

[afghantemprament88]

i watched it today for the 3rd time....really interesting and a well done documentary...good job