Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (27)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • cool idea raimit, to combine the two film versions. in certain ways I found the old film even better than the new one. a bit more suspense-oriented and mysterious.

    Thanks for your work!

  • you know what would be really cool?

    Bashki footage and Jackson sound.

  • This was actually ridiculously interesting! I'm definitely intrigued to check out the whole movie!! Good job! Must have taken eons.

  • Still Sir Ian Mackellen is the best Gandalf Evaaaaa- xD

  • This is so awesome. Needs more hits.

  • "Gandalf i dont wanna stay here" xD

  • Not all young ins disregard the glory of the old cartoons or books :) i have them all on dvd :) this brought back scenes from my childhood of wathcing the lord of the rigns cartoon over and over again ! loved it just interesting especially since at certain parts the words matched up exactly in both versions.

    I do agree though so many people watch tons of the movies but never read the books very frustrating

  • I really don't see the point in ruining the scene...

  • Okay...? Well, don't run it.

  • @raimat66 BRavo!! very well done I started wondering if Jackson synched his direction like this on purpose somehow as a hidden easter egg tribute to Bakshi, but then I noticed you edited it in a loop.

  • @lotrfan771 You admit your failure. admirable.

  • Trust me, I didn't know what I was about to see(I don't even know why I wanted to find out), but I did and now I know. I'm just saying that no one should even touch that genious directed by Peter Jackson.

    P.S. Can't wait for the Hobbit to come out.

  • @lotrfan771 im sorry. but you're dickriding. If it wasn't for Bakshi taking the first shot, you probably wouldn't have the same Peter Jackson films you've come to know and love. Give credit where it's due.

  • @boondocks43 I doubt a lot of that and I thought I was allowed to make my own opinions, but if you want to comment on half-year old comments then go right ahead.....

  • @lotrfan771 It's not the same audio. That's the point.

  • gOOD job! amix of booth thats what jacksons version should have been in my humble opinion

  • well done

  • is this dubbed from the cartoon?

  • is the audio from the cartoon, its a shame they never managed to finish due to funding :(

  • i appreciate the time u spent doin this but cudnt u have jus uploaded the fuckin movie!!!!

  • Do you mean the f-in movie that Bakshi made or the f-in movie that Jackson made?

    Anyhow, my work (witsh was very funny to do) was to mush up the to films. That was my joy. Then people said to me that I should upload my finnished work. Okay, so then I just uploaded the f-in movie that I hade made.

  • Well : ) : ) My work was to mashup the two films. Not to mush up the to.

  • which!!!!! Sorry

  • Good Job!

  • Lousy fucking dubbing!

  • It's not meant to be a dubbing. It's meant to be a mix of sound and pictures from two similar movies. If I find a lip synch, it's just a lucky bonus. But if it was meant to be a dubbing, I agree. It would be a lousy fucking dubbing. :)

  • I stand corrected.

  • Hey I love the clever way you did this I understand how difficult this was for you, but the new generations nowadays who dont know the books and dont want to bother reading them or watching Bakshi just dont get it, so if you get criticized by them, I wouldnt listen, take it from an old timer Tolkien fan, you did good!!

  • the voices are just off enough to bother me. lol

  • I am loving this

Loading...
0 / 00Unsaved Playlist Return to active list
    1. Your queue is empty. Add videos to your queue using this button:
      or sign in to load a different list.
    Loading...Loading...Saving...
    • Clear all videos from this list
    • Learn more