the original version didn't have music until vadar started throwing shit at luke... and then it cut off until he lost his hand... the music in this vid obscures vadar's lines
The original trilogy lightsaber battle shit all over the new ones. These are so epic whereas the new ones are pure garbage, choreographed ballet bullshit. The atmopshere and emotion in the originals destroy everything in the new ones. Even Vader vs Obi-Wan in a New Hope is better by a million miles. The orginal battles are character driven. The new ones fail cause there have absolutely no character.
i know fuck... the new ones could have been so much more well made had somebody just slapped george lucas a couple of times and asked him what the fuck he thought he was doing... anakin was SUPPOSED to be a bad ass jedi and a decent person UNTIL he turned to the dark side... but they made him into a total bitch and whiny asshole from the very start... how can this darth vader in the clip above even have the same name as the whiny ass in the prequels...
@Hallucination wow! another Star Wars fan who noticed the exact same thing I did! Qui-gon vs Maul had no magic, regardless of the speed of the combat, there was no dialogue whatsoever. Than qui gon died and Obi faced off against Maul just as though Obi-Wan was the hero of the story and he and Maul had been nemisises. For the birds!
This duel has the best atmosphere out of all the duels in the series. The moment at .30 where the two of them are these shadow figures armed with swords of light is one of the most iconic in the series.
There is a REASON why music was not originally in his duel. Besides the fact this track wasn't written in 1980. That's the problem with the new duels, is the dialog and the music. Music is good and all but no music in a fight scene draws the viewer in making it ore real. I.E. Bourne Ultimatum. Dialog is what made this scene truely shine, which in this version is over shadowed by your musical choice. Which is selected from a far inferior Star Wars Film.
There was music written for this duel. It was never added in the movie.... but it was added in the CD sound track. However..... I do agree with you about this duel. It works because the music was added.
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
dude wtf?????? -.- T_____T
shouldnt lukes hand be spouting blood wen anican cuts it off wit da light saber??????? daz da ting wit star wars wen people cut off oda peoples hands wit light sabers, they DONT SPOUT BLOOD!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! freaky .....
Its not freaky at all. The reason they don't spout blood is because a light saber can cut through anything, thus making it hotter then lava. If one of your limbs is cut off and you burn the limb it seals up. So in this sense when Luke gets his hand sliced off it instantly seals up.
That's a good point. If I had to guess, I'd say because both cuts (to the leg and arm respectively) were only superficial and very light, which would probably cause an incomplete cauterization. In every other lightsaber wound (barring the OT due to insufficient SFX technology), you can clearly see that the wound is cauterized and not bleeding.
Wellllllll he didnt technically destroy the sith, only temporarily. in the extended universe there quite a few more sith masters. so yeah only temporarily.
he uses anakins original wepon from 2-3 and vader destroys it , and in episode 6 obi wan guides him to produce his own lightsaber , in similar construction to obi wans
@RegenerationStorm Actually your wrong there. Anakins lightsaber in episode 2 got crushed by a machine while his arm was in it. Thus after the battle with count Dooku he was to construct his own model with a few changes in the hilt. 2nd of all Luke found a book on how to construct a lighttsaber at Obi-Wans hut back on Tatooine that Obi-Wan was writing for those 19 years "Dark Times". And its a Jedi tradition to have your Lightsaber hilt modeled similar to your masters. So yeah that explains it.
@JoeyAdamsTAW ok , but youre also wrong there too - anakins lightsaber looked nothing like obi wan's in attack of the clones? and also , what i meant by 2-3 is that in the ending scenes , anakin would have been given another lightsaber in the same style to the destoryed one from attack of the clones (eg the wedding scene , anakin would have a fixed version) but yh , as i explained , this lightsaber is given to luke , but he finally looses it in his duel with vader at Cloud city
This is as unoriginal as can be. Really. You might as well have added Duel of the Fates. In fact, lets just play that on a continuous loop through the whole film.
and seriously the battles from the origional movies are a lot better when you add music to them, only the return of the jedi duel had music, because john williams tought it would be a good idea, thats why all the prequels have music. the music makes the duels a lot better... as u can tel with this old skool clip and music added
For a first video, this was really well done! The Episode III music really added some drama to an already emotionally-intense fight scene. Good stuff.
Think about this, that lightsaber Luke was using is the same Lightsaber Anakin was using when he lost to Obi-Wan on Mustafar. That damn lightsaber is bad luck.....lol.
Excellent point. Probably the same lightsaber Anakin used when he lost his arm at Geonosis...definitely just as well Luke lost that thing at Bespin...
Why was there no blood when luke got his hand choped off
peytomack14 1 month ago
@peytomack14 a lightsaber is extremely hot, and probably cauderized the wound very effectively.
BlueRoyalProductions 1 week ago
different music. i want old music
PLeasureJet 1 month ago
man Empire Strikes Back is easily the best Star Wars movie of them all. The music alone makes this scene just all that much better
Alive4Metal 2 months ago
@Alive4Metal also the most memorable line: "no luke i am your father" NNNNOOOOOO!!!!
i bet people who saw this movie in movie theaters shat their pants
talking of which when the original episodes 4-6 comes to movie theaters on 3D i will definitely go watch them
( i dont know when but i saw a trailer on movie theaters )
apinafilms 1 month ago
the best star wars movie every
nick790100 6 months ago
how the fuck has 8 people not liked this its from the best star wars movie ever
THE4thTARDIS 1 year ago
this is great and all, but guns were advented in the 1500's.
victimofrothschild 1 year ago
@victimofrothschild ...advented...fucking idiot
teffabob02 4 months ago
I like to think of this film as a stand alone product.
NejiKusa 1 year ago
Very well edited with the music. Pretty cool to see the EP III music to this battle.
fsouth627 1 year ago
@Kaous10 I never thought of it like that. but your right.
Nightwalker191 1 year ago
Good video, well edited.
zieba 1 year ago
I still never understood what happened when vader falls at 2:20 Does he just get up and quickly run down the tube thing? /shrug
toadyalfred 1 year ago
the original version didn't have music until vadar started throwing shit at luke... and then it cut off until he lost his hand... the music in this vid obscures vadar's lines
ApocalypticDAN 1 year ago
@jake23atx I know not Maul the Mute nor Dooku the Dunce nor Grevious the Agrevating or even Palpatine can match his charisma!
KingofBionicle 1 year ago
This duel proves that you don't need an overdone battle over lava done at superspeed to be epic!
KingofBionicle 1 year ago
i forgot how epic and unique their first show down was. Lots of creepy crevices.
sdn14 1 year ago
At 5:01 when vader makes that noise that part freaks me out every time it just such a creepy noise
westeastxybzd 1 year ago
The original trilogy lightsaber battle shit all over the new ones. These are so epic whereas the new ones are pure garbage, choreographed ballet bullshit. The atmopshere and emotion in the originals destroy everything in the new ones. Even Vader vs Obi-Wan in a New Hope is better by a million miles. The orginal battles are character driven. The new ones fail cause there have absolutely no character.
Hallucination 2 years ago
i know fuck... the new ones could have been so much more well made had somebody just slapped george lucas a couple of times and asked him what the fuck he thought he was doing... anakin was SUPPOSED to be a bad ass jedi and a decent person UNTIL he turned to the dark side... but they made him into a total bitch and whiny asshole from the very start... how can this darth vader in the clip above even have the same name as the whiny ass in the prequels...
fulloftruth 2 years ago
Indeed! Those original battles are more like struggle between 2 characters, 2 warriors. New battles are struggle between... lightsabers...
zieba 1 year ago 2
@Hallucination wow! another Star Wars fan who noticed the exact same thing I did! Qui-gon vs Maul had no magic, regardless of the speed of the combat, there was no dialogue whatsoever. Than qui gon died and Obi faced off against Maul just as though Obi-Wan was the hero of the story and he and Maul had been nemisises. For the birds!
KingofBionicle 1 year ago
Obi-Wan was the best Jedi of all time
mattsson20 2 years ago
Great lords of Film-making, please grant us the blessing of new masterpieces at a level like this.
Nevecus 2 years ago 3
4:18 hahaha. Pretty cheap of you, Vader. haha
monkeywrestler08 2 years ago
Comment removed
monkeywrestler08 2 years ago
Comment removed
monkeywrestler08 2 years ago
This duel has the best atmosphere out of all the duels in the series. The moment at .30 where the two of them are these shadow figures armed with swords of light is one of the most iconic in the series.
Defenstrator 2 years ago
one of the most iconic in the history of cinema!
Hallucination 2 years ago
There is a REASON why music was not originally in his duel. Besides the fact this track wasn't written in 1980. That's the problem with the new duels, is the dialog and the music. Music is good and all but no music in a fight scene draws the viewer in making it ore real. I.E. Bourne Ultimatum. Dialog is what made this scene truely shine, which in this version is over shadowed by your musical choice. Which is selected from a far inferior Star Wars Film.
SilentEvil2 2 years ago 2
There was music written for this duel. It was never added in the movie.... but it was added in the CD sound track. However..... I do agree with you about this duel. It works because the music was added.
helper35 2 years ago
absolutely!
Hallucination 2 years ago
tanks 4 da explanation :D still weird doh
OOOOOOOOOO YA
check out midnights ghost its really good ma nd ma coz med it. . . .
CHECK IT OUT PLWZ!!!!!
AND COMMENT!!!!!!!!!! :D :O :U
wulfie100 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
dude wtf?????? -.- T_____T
shouldnt lukes hand be spouting blood wen anican cuts it off wit da light saber??????? daz da ting wit star wars wen people cut off oda peoples hands wit light sabers, they DONT SPOUT BLOOD!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! freaky .....
wulfie100 2 years ago
the heat of the blade seals off the blood vessles.
86cookiemonster 2 years ago 3
Its not freaky at all. The reason they don't spout blood is because a light saber can cut through anything, thus making it hotter then lava. If one of your limbs is cut off and you burn the limb it seals up. So in this sense when Luke gets his hand sliced off it instantly seals up.
JoeyAdamsTAW 2 years ago 3
The blade cauterizes the wound instantly, hence, no blood.
DarinSaine 2 years ago 2
@DarinSaine
so how com obi wan was bleeding when dooku cut him up in episode II???
darthneno15 1 year ago
@darthneno15
That's a good point. If I had to guess, I'd say because both cuts (to the leg and arm respectively) were only superficial and very light, which would probably cause an incomplete cauterization. In every other lightsaber wound (barring the OT due to insufficient SFX technology), you can clearly see that the wound is cauterized and not bleeding.
DarinSaine 1 year ago
@DarinSaine
haha ok fasho...i learned something new...thnks bro...:7)
darthneno15 1 year ago
@DarinSaine
I would say it's because originally, Lucas didn't plan to have lightsabers cauterize wounds. That's something he decided later.
StarCreme 1 year ago
The music is dominating the scene. It's too loud. You want to be able to hear Vader. His voice is dark and intimidating. Sweet.
WesMantooth73 2 years ago 2
they dont fight as well in the original trilogy
DarthTettrax 2 years ago
it isn't the original music from star wars
5 the empire strikes back
bad:-(
SiiNeKBoK 2 years ago
unfotunately the lightsaber battles arent as good as the battles from 1 - 3
Gerding88 2 years ago
easily the best lightsaber battle in the entire series.
srhiser13 2 years ago 5
i think one of the best dialogues.....
the lightsaber battle between darth vader and obi wan in ep. 3 is the best in my opinion
myJimcore 2 years ago
luke wouldn't stand a chance if vader didn't have that suit on
StratProductions 2 years ago
nice one.cut off at crucial moment
itaintedonei 2 years ago
I like it: It's like the movements they make go with the music
buscasololoesencial 2 years ago
Anakin was always called the "chosen one" because he would have a son named Luke.
vfgjhj 2 years ago
no anakin was supposed to be the chosen one,he was supposed to destroy the sith
he turned to the dark side to save padmé and in the last movie he kills the emperor
that means qui gonn was right he destroyed the sith ,he is the chosen one
xXR0883Xx 2 years ago 2
Without Luke that shit would've never happened.
vfgjhj 2 years ago
true
xXR0883Xx 2 years ago
no, Anakin is the chosen one because he deafeats the dark side, he kills the emperor, and by himself dying, all ties to the dark side are destroyed.
filthyassmonkey 2 years ago
I love how the chosen one is the one who kills all those poor young jedi in episode III and all those innocent people. Fuck Anakin
vfgjhj 2 years ago
wrong, only temporarily. in the extended universe (the books/comics) there are many more sith.
zkinsey24 2 years ago
We only care about the movies. If the extended universe mattered Darth Vader wouldn't have killed the jedi, Darth Sion would have.
shishiokirakun 2 years ago
Dude the extended universe is so much better than the movies, the movies stories suck in comparison.
zkinsey24 2 years ago
That's not the point. The movies are all that really matter. The thing is the rule of two is all that matters here.
shishiokirakun 2 years ago
yeah and the rule of two was created in 2 of the best books ever the darth bane series
zkinsey24 2 years ago
@filthyassmonkey
not to mention by killing all the jedi as well, you balance the force by eliminating both sides
ApocalypticDAN 1 year ago
@vfgjhj no it's because he killed Palpatine, thus bringing balance to the Force.
KingofBionicle 1 year ago
Excellent video it's great can't wait for your next 1.
TheLink232 2 years ago
great video everybody suscribe for me pleaseeeeeeeeeeee
darthvader312 2 years ago
it's really dumb how luke falls out the window in this movie
r2d2qa 2 years ago
omg. something tells me u have not seen all star wars. in 4 5 he has blue. in 6 he makes a new one thats green.
HI1111HI 2 years ago 4
No that was Qui-Gonns green saber given to him by Ben Kenobi in episode IV.
vfgjhj 2 years ago
no it was Anikan's when he was defeated on the fire planet, Ben kept it.
filthyassmonkey 2 years ago
He is the chosen one, he destroyed the sith. But no one knew how this was gonna happen.
CAPCBMERRITT 2 years ago
Wellllllll he didnt technically destroy the sith, only temporarily. in the extended universe there quite a few more sith masters. so yeah only temporarily.
zkinsey24 2 years ago
doesnt luke have a green lightsaber?
simoncase 2 years ago
he uses anakins original wepon from 2-3 and vader destroys it , and in episode 6 obi wan guides him to produce his own lightsaber , in similar construction to obi wans
RegenerationStorm 2 years ago 8
Oh i see, thanks! That all makes sense now!
simoncase 2 years ago
@RegenerationStorm Actually your wrong there. Anakins lightsaber in episode 2 got crushed by a machine while his arm was in it. Thus after the battle with count Dooku he was to construct his own model with a few changes in the hilt. 2nd of all Luke found a book on how to construct a lighttsaber at Obi-Wans hut back on Tatooine that Obi-Wan was writing for those 19 years "Dark Times". And its a Jedi tradition to have your Lightsaber hilt modeled similar to your masters. So yeah that explains it.
JoeyAdamsTAW 1 year ago
@JoeyAdamsTAW ok , but youre also wrong there too - anakins lightsaber looked nothing like obi wan's in attack of the clones? and also , what i meant by 2-3 is that in the ending scenes , anakin would have been given another lightsaber in the same style to the destoryed one from attack of the clones (eg the wedding scene , anakin would have a fixed version) but yh , as i explained , this lightsaber is given to luke , but he finally looses it in his duel with vader at Cloud city
RegenerationStorm 1 year ago
@RegenerationStorm
actually anakins lightsaber in episode 2 is alot like vaders lightsaber except the blade guard isnt black......remember it got ruined on geonosis....
darthneno15 1 year ago
remember he need to use his father lightsaber. then he losi and he gets the new one
The15chess06master40 2 years ago
in episode 6 he does
darthvader312 2 years ago 3
This is as unoriginal as can be. Really. You might as well have added Duel of the Fates. In fact, lets just play that on a continuous loop through the whole film.
shocktrooper327 2 years ago
and seriously the battles from the origional movies are a lot better when you add music to them, only the return of the jedi duel had music, because john williams tought it would be a good idea, thats why all the prequels have music. the music makes the duels a lot better... as u can tel with this old skool clip and music added
Alive4Metal 2 years ago 2
the song fits in very nicely.. father vs son is A LOT MORE emotional than friend vs friend
Alive4Metal 2 years ago 2
i think this song fits episode 5 luke and vader battle really good too. it fits alot like it fit the 3rd anakin and obiwan duel! i liked he video!
SaveTsccSeason3 2 years ago
"the force is with you young skywalker..... but you are not a jedi yet"
socarulz 2 years ago
Manage to ruin a classic scene. Forshame
hugeloads 2 years ago
Excellent job! The new music actually fits in with the duel between Vader and Luke!
jchiv17 2 years ago 2
james earl jones plays the voice of darth vader.
deadlyaim27 2 years ago
great editing
autobotman 2 years ago
yo this is a 5 star classic u da man the music makes it sound badass homie
makavelieazyetherock 2 years ago
For a first video, this was really well done! The Episode III music really added some drama to an already emotionally-intense fight scene. Good stuff.
BishopAP 2 years ago
@BishopAP yeah it kinda gives us a glimpse at the deeper struggle between them.
KingofBionicle 1 year ago
4:24 Vader is angry! omg :|
RoniRotta94 3 years ago
How does Darth vader talk while he's breathing?
iguana990088 3 years ago
mechanical.maybe something else breathes for him.
JSKinnovations 3 years ago 2
yeah the thing he breathes through isnt actually him its a thing in is mask which is hooked up to his lungs
daniboi12345 2 years ago
rofl @ 2:18 darth vade: OOOOOOF!
adamtoward1 3 years ago
he also went oof at 5:02 :p
StatueofLiberty3 3 years ago
haha i love it (:
adamtoward1 3 years ago
they atack really slow coz the lightsabers were 40kg lol
rsndsw 3 years ago
Think about this, that lightsaber Luke was using is the same Lightsaber Anakin was using when he lost to Obi-Wan on Mustafar. That damn lightsaber is bad luck.....lol.
Kaous10 3 years ago 22
Holy crap, you're right.
Luke is lucky he didn't lose more than an arm!
ElComico 3 years ago 2
Excellent point. Probably the same lightsaber Anakin used when he lost his arm at Geonosis...definitely just as well Luke lost that thing at Bespin...
Darkjedi030 3 years ago 2
@Kaous10 yeah and you'll notice as soon as he lost that thing he became badass!
KingofBionicle 1 year ago
@Kaous10 You are right.
captianjoel 1 year ago
suck your little light saber jawa boy
morfius93638 3 years ago
omg luke is still weak ... look at 0:38 he fall down
PanTegir 3 years ago
only because vader is really strong. he has cybernetic arms.
MCRtothemax 3 years ago
the music is fuked up
morfius93638 3 years ago
the music is battle of the heros you asshole
BeatLizad 3 years ago 2
SUCK A NICE VIDEO MEN !!!
tyme3drums 3 years ago
why did daver die
ICavalcadeI 3 years ago
At 5:02 it sounded like Vader said "Fuck"
Achrones 3 years ago
I heard fool not fuck.
ApostolosTheGreek 3 years ago
When he raises his saber to hit Luke it sounded like he said Fuck.
Achrones 3 years ago
Good work! You should make a video for the next duel of Vader and Luke on Death Star II.
athanasiadis24 3 years ago 2
nice plus 2
rysarhysa6789 3 years ago 3
nice
SirGerProductions 3 years ago 3
cool video...its been like 10 years since i last watched this movie
zacharykt338 3 years ago 3
Thanx and I will do Dual of fates on the next video for Obi-Wan vs Anakin
hhhvance 4 years ago
I love it! Hell, I loved both video's.
For your next video, try using the 'Duel of Fates', I would love to see that.
ThePissedOff 4 years ago 2