It is also a very good and cheap alternative to akadama and like i said it will never deteriorate like akadama will from weather and watering and such. As good and as cheap as it is it may be worth your while to pick up a bag and just try it out. If you like it great, if not use what you have and dont buy it again. Its also very good for adding drainage to potting mixes and peat mixes. I would never mention a product to someone that i didnt use and aprove of myself.
Oh yes bud, that just as i assumed. Dont feel bad. Alot of people compare pumice to perlite and they are two very different things. They arent even made from the same materials. Perlite is a man made product and is very light and brittle. Pumice is a natural occuring mineral just as lava rock. They are both forms of volcanic rock and pumice will not float. Its too heavey. It is also very hard and will never break down. Its washable, reusuable indefintly and is even sterilizable.
Thats fine, i dont look for arguements on here like some but pumice doesnt float. The italians use only pumice with no additives and with great results. It just depends on the climate where you live. Pumice is just an easier to find cheaper replacement for lava wich works. Its not exactly the same but if it came down to me having to search the world over or smash grill lava rocks with a hammer, id be using drystall.
@jake4bonsai Well, if the pumice is not as light as perlite, then it might just be a good alterntive. I don't know, I never worked with it before. It might indeed be better.
Oh, and they're not grill lava rocks. They're sold as outdoor decorative rocks in home improvement stores... but... yeah, the intended use doesn't really matter does it? Theres a lot of interesting soil ingredients and mixes out there.
You can get small pre-crushed red lava rock online, I just choose not to.
@wolfmeditation Yes you can get crushed lava rock online but the shipping costs 4 times more than the bag of lava itself. I think its rediculous! You can usually get your local feed or farm supply to get Drystall for you at no additional costs if they dont already carry it. Anywhere that sells products for the care of horses will have or be able to get it. Good stuff bud!
I meant to replace the lava. Sorry about that. its basicly the same as lava and comes in a 50lb bag and is very inexspensive. And if you sift it you can get 3 different sizes out of it although it doesnt have to be sifted except maybe to get the heavy dust off.
@jake4bonsai It's very different from red lava rock. There is no replacement for it. We can argue forever, but I won't change my mind. I found a soil component that works for me and I don't plan on changing it. Lava rock is more durable, heavier (wont float during watering), and has sharper edges than pumice
So why dont you just use Drystall? Its sold at almost any feed or farm supply across the U.S. Its sold as a product for putting in horse stalls to keep the moisture down. It never breaks down is washable and reusable and is acually good for plant cell structure over time in releasing sillica. Its 100% pure natural pumice and is an excelant bonsai soil ingrediant!
@jake4bonsai Red Lava rock is better. It is heavier so it won't flow all to the top like pumice. (Yes, red lava rock and pumice are very different). I imagine that Perlite is similar to Drystall (judging by appearance). I use perlite, but very sparingly, since as mentioned mostly flows to the top.
If you use a good quality it can stay for 2 to 3 years in a pot and besides that you have to regularly repot the tree and potting soil is very dusty and quickly choke your roots
@TheSiMoN797 Lava rock can be washed during a repotting and used for years and years.
Don't be so paranoid about potting soil. It's not a "bonsai killer" like most people think it is. After all, in nature trees grow in far more compact clay-like soils. It can become a problem if it interfears with drainage and airflow, but with more than half of my mix being lava rock there is enough air pockets formed, and during watering the lava rock tumbles around in the soil breaking it up each time.
@TheSiMoN797 Akadama dissolves back into soft clay over time, and will have to be replaced. Lava rock will not turn into mush. Then by combining lava rock with some potting soil, perlite, and pine bark you get a bonsai soil mix rich in nutrients that also is very light and will not compact down to choke the roots.
Good stuff!! You got it right, find a mix that works for your area with out relying on potting soil. Keep up the good work and vids. I'll mention you in one of my vids soon.
@wolfmeditation haha, good work. I laughed. Strange's is a big nursery. perhaps more local a chain than i imagined. has amazon failed you for lava rock? how bout pet stores?
@arachtation3 I can't until I find a place that sells finely crushed lava rock. The one I used for the current trees I had to make myself. Crushing each rock multiple times with a hammer. It took weeks. Never doing that again. I will make the soil video as soon as I can get the lava rock.
Thanks man, pretty informative for beginners like me.
KeeennethVo395 3 weeks ago
It is also a very good and cheap alternative to akadama and like i said it will never deteriorate like akadama will from weather and watering and such. As good and as cheap as it is it may be worth your while to pick up a bag and just try it out. If you like it great, if not use what you have and dont buy it again. Its also very good for adding drainage to potting mixes and peat mixes. I would never mention a product to someone that i didnt use and aprove of myself.
jake4bonsai 1 month ago
Oh yes bud, that just as i assumed. Dont feel bad. Alot of people compare pumice to perlite and they are two very different things. They arent even made from the same materials. Perlite is a man made product and is very light and brittle. Pumice is a natural occuring mineral just as lava rock. They are both forms of volcanic rock and pumice will not float. Its too heavey. It is also very hard and will never break down. Its washable, reusuable indefintly and is even sterilizable.
jake4bonsai 1 month ago
Thats fine, i dont look for arguements on here like some but pumice doesnt float. The italians use only pumice with no additives and with great results. It just depends on the climate where you live. Pumice is just an easier to find cheaper replacement for lava wich works. Its not exactly the same but if it came down to me having to search the world over or smash grill lava rocks with a hammer, id be using drystall.
jake4bonsai 1 month ago
@jake4bonsai Well, if the pumice is not as light as perlite, then it might just be a good alterntive. I don't know, I never worked with it before. It might indeed be better.
Oh, and they're not grill lava rocks. They're sold as outdoor decorative rocks in home improvement stores... but... yeah, the intended use doesn't really matter does it? Theres a lot of interesting soil ingredients and mixes out there.
You can get small pre-crushed red lava rock online, I just choose not to.
wolfmeditation 1 month ago
@wolfmeditation Yes you can get crushed lava rock online but the shipping costs 4 times more than the bag of lava itself. I think its rediculous! You can usually get your local feed or farm supply to get Drystall for you at no additional costs if they dont already carry it. Anywhere that sells products for the care of horses will have or be able to get it. Good stuff bud!
jake4bonsai 1 month ago
all these discussions are very good, thanks, I will try Lava rock, and Drystall too
TheBonsaiStudent 1 month ago
I meant to replace the lava. Sorry about that. its basicly the same as lava and comes in a 50lb bag and is very inexspensive. And if you sift it you can get 3 different sizes out of it although it doesnt have to be sifted except maybe to get the heavy dust off.
jake4bonsai 1 month ago
@jake4bonsai It's very different from red lava rock. There is no replacement for it. We can argue forever, but I won't change my mind. I found a soil component that works for me and I don't plan on changing it. Lava rock is more durable, heavier (wont float during watering), and has sharper edges than pumice
wolfmeditation 1 month ago
So why dont you just use Drystall? Its sold at almost any feed or farm supply across the U.S. Its sold as a product for putting in horse stalls to keep the moisture down. It never breaks down is washable and reusable and is acually good for plant cell structure over time in releasing sillica. Its 100% pure natural pumice and is an excelant bonsai soil ingrediant!
jake4bonsai 1 month ago
@jake4bonsai Red Lava rock is better. It is heavier so it won't flow all to the top like pumice. (Yes, red lava rock and pumice are very different). I imagine that Perlite is similar to Drystall (judging by appearance). I use perlite, but very sparingly, since as mentioned mostly flows to the top.
wolfmeditation 1 month ago
@ wolfmeditation
If you use a good quality it can stay for 2 to 3 years in a pot and besides that you have to regularly repot the tree and potting soil is very dusty and quickly choke your roots
TheSiMoN797 1 month ago
@TheSiMoN797 Lava rock can be washed during a repotting and used for years and years.
Don't be so paranoid about potting soil. It's not a "bonsai killer" like most people think it is. After all, in nature trees grow in far more compact clay-like soils. It can become a problem if it interfears with drainage and airflow, but with more than half of my mix being lava rock there is enough air pockets formed, and during watering the lava rock tumbles around in the soil breaking it up each time.
wolfmeditation 1 month ago
Why don't you use 100% akadama?
TheSiMoN797 1 month ago in playlist More videos from wolfmeditation
@TheSiMoN797 Akadama dissolves back into soft clay over time, and will have to be replaced. Lava rock will not turn into mush. Then by combining lava rock with some potting soil, perlite, and pine bark you get a bonsai soil mix rich in nutrients that also is very light and will not compact down to choke the roots.
wolfmeditation 1 month ago
Good stuff!! You got it right, find a mix that works for your area with out relying on potting soil. Keep up the good work and vids. I'll mention you in one of my vids soon.
OrlandoBonsaiTV 2 months ago
@OrlandoBonsaiTV Thanks, I actually started using the red lava rock after seeing one of your videos. It works great.
wolfmeditation 2 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@wolfmeditation haha, good work. I laughed. Strange's is a big nursery. perhaps more local a chain than i imagined. has amazon failed you for lava rock? how bout pet stores?
berobinson82 4 months ago
o_O he's talking from the future people!!!! Thanks for the tips as always.
berobinson82 4 months ago
Can you please show us a video on your bonsai soil :D
arachtation3 4 months ago
@arachtation3 I can't until I find a place that sells finely crushed lava rock. The one I used for the current trees I had to make myself. Crushing each rock multiple times with a hammer. It took weeks. Never doing that again. I will make the soil video as soon as I can get the lava rock.
wolfmeditation 4 months ago