Absolutely stunning! What an amazing little girl --- I can't believe that so much talent can shine through such a young child. She has to almost stand up to reach the pedals! :)
One could practice everyday for years on end and never reach the level that this child has already attainted.
All the best in your future and for as long you love to play --- please keep sharing your incredible talent with the world! :)
Sounds like a talented adult playing instead of an eight year old girl. If someone were to listen to this without seeing the pianist, they'd probably think that, too.
Elle est merveilleuse. Je joue du piano depuis 9 ans et je suis incapable de jouer ainsi. Son interprétation est fantastique c'est vraiment beau. Seul Chopin lui même pourrait la jouer mieux. Bravo.
unlike a lot of children playing this piece and trying to act "cool" because they can play fast, this girl really has talent and plays this with heart and emotion. well done. not grouping her with adults or children, i'd say this is a very good interpretation.
Holy cow! She played that like a total veteran! If I wasn't watching the video and saw a little girl there, I'd swear it was someone with 20 years experience just by the sound... thoroughly impressed!
Very nice! But please: none of those mannerism like LH conducting starting in 2:03! It doesn't do anything to the music and won't impress any musician!
Many great pianist have played this piece, and their interpretation varies a lot, not only amongst each other but also from Chopin's notation. We've already heard elements such as exaggerated staccati in the A part, accelerando in the B part, the right thumb melody in the B part, and so on. Phoebe seems to have combined those elements into her own interpretation, and it works quite well!
The special use of this length rubato is her own interpretation. With it, is emphasized the dance aspect. What is important here, is the fact she is interpreting to the extent that she does. And, wonderfully.
I personnaly think that Phoebe's interpretation of Chopin's Valse is very original and I like it deeply! On the contrary, I think Phoebe takes all her time to make to music flourish. And to contradict you to the end, I consider Phoebe to be already a great pianist.
I would quite simply say for your technique that it is frankly very good , but, Chopin sees in this opus 34 n31 flown away in a hurry. But I understand that you are desired of your share, to interpret it this manner; you have me a good technique to study it still more deeply, and to still read again this partition.
Still much you work will become a very large pianist...
I LOVE your rendition of it. I like how you started slowly and the sped up. :)
EmilyBearfan 8 months ago
My life long dream has always been to play on a Bosendorfer... That aside it's technically sound :)
RoyalDecapitation 9 months ago
Absolutely stunning! What an amazing little girl --- I can't believe that so much talent can shine through such a young child. She has to almost stand up to reach the pedals! :)
One could practice everyday for years on end and never reach the level that this child has already attainted.
All the best in your future and for as long you love to play --- please keep sharing your incredible talent with the world! :)
NoelleandOwen 1 year ago
so nice....
bravo......i think u grow up is a amazing person...
ryeon9 1 year ago
I think I'm in love with you
Volendammtje 1 year ago
WoooW!!! Beautiful!! I loved it!!! =D!!
edtskyline 1 year ago 2
waouaaouuuhh VERRY VERRY GOOD <3
I LOVEEEE SONG :D
jadouxxi 1 year ago
Adorable ponytail.
steveaulie 1 year ago
she's good
Finalist7 1 year ago
hmmm loved the tempo and the way she uses the pedal .
timfey 1 year ago 11
perfect regato's when used.
and you have good accenting just would like to hear more dramatic piano's and forte. other than that, amazing!
devo2746 1 year ago
She's still so young and small, except she can play so well
cingle2004jp 1 year ago
not a stable tempo and sometimes too harsh tones :S
but otherwise good :)
butterbeatsmargarin 2 years ago
its beautiful. you are very talented. i hope you can keep this up and don't lose yourself
apfelchiang 2 years ago
Beautiful, Very nice!!, congratulations
gasato01 2 years ago
it is very nice beautiful!!!!!!!!!
mei58226 2 years ago
Tears to my eyes.
Wonderful!
Patsik 2 years ago
very well played ;)
but isn't it opus 64 2?
djsmuekoe 2 years ago 5
@djsmuekoe What??? it's opus 64 No. 2!!
edtskyline 1 year ago
oh my gosh!!!!! you are so soooo amazing i can not believe how good you play!!!!!!!!
swisters2922 2 years ago 10
This is one of my favorite piano songs. :D
GREAT JOB!!!! CONGRATULATIONS!!!!
Zsannush 2 years ago 2
I can't stop listening to this performance!! It is so beautiful!
stephmac5 2 years ago 3
You has got your hand in a positive and correct way on the piano. Particularly, I just love your left hand !!
More over, I like your clothes :D
Take care and keep your playing well :))
flytrance 2 years ago
You has got your hand in a positive and correct way on the piano. Particularly, I just love your left hand !!
More over, I like your clothes :D
Take care and keep your playing well :))
flytrance 2 years ago
man if you play this well now by the time ur an adult you'll be like the best pianist everr xDD
great job!!
babablacksheep232 2 years ago 2
!!! very good
NNCwatcher2 2 years ago
brava!
hellokitty336 2 years ago
She's amazing. Age has nothing with talent!! An 8 year old can be just as good as a 18 year old! All it is is practice and dedication!!!
animalfreakforever 2 years ago 3
Comment removed
AvidHobbyist 3 years ago
Sounds like a talented adult playing instead of an eight year old girl. If someone were to listen to this without seeing the pianist, they'd probably think that, too.
AvidHobbyist 3 years ago 2
o.m.g. this piano plays beautifully!!!!!
and so does the player!!!
halloingerman 3 years ago
op 64-2 .. nice done :)
zielarzopl 3 years ago 5
wow - this is amazing!
instrumentenfreak 3 years ago
wow.
notacase 3 years ago
i love little asian girls who play the piano, they are amazing ! :)
nosoyunvirus 3 years ago 5
O_O
Skyindarkness 3 years ago 2
Shes cute when trying to play the piece.
But this piece is for 15-16 years old high schoolers. Even most of them cant play it well.
konzolmester 3 years ago
excellent!!
taiyo1964 3 years ago
Jesus, this is very beautiful. Even without counting that it is a little girl who's playing, it is played unbelievably awesome.
Please just change the title to opus 64 n°2 if possible...!
sylviajp 3 years ago 5
this is very nice phoebe!
davidhong97 3 years ago
nice job phoebe! I wish I can play like that!
davidhong97 3 years ago
wouaaa
It's amasing 0_0 !!
She plays very very well !! *-*
SiSsILoLa89 3 years ago
totally no emotion put into the piece. horrible!
ryanyee1234567890 3 years ago
yes, and this girl is like 8 years old. What's your problem?
I love it!
slobo1987 3 years ago 3
yeaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa
edgarkeyboards 3 years ago
tocas pero muy bonito apezar de que eres muy pequena
edgarkeyboards 3 years ago
bravo!!!!!!!! awesome awesome im amazed u truly have talent !
9Christina9 3 years ago
Elle est merveilleuse. Je joue du piano depuis 9 ans et je suis incapable de jouer ainsi. Son interprétation est fantastique c'est vraiment beau. Seul Chopin lui même pourrait la jouer mieux. Bravo.
MercedesManaSpectra 3 years ago
DEAR LORD. i wish i played HALF as good as her!
krystle823 3 years ago
i'm 90 percent sure this is op. 64, not 34.
unlike a lot of children playing this piece and trying to act "cool" because they can play fast, this girl really has talent and plays this with heart and emotion. well done. not grouping her with adults or children, i'd say this is a very good interpretation.
TrevorKingKwong 3 years ago 2
yes, it's certainly not opus 34 I'm sure too.
Junhyung3 3 years ago 3
I have been playing since age 5......and still can't play this piece.....guess I should have practiced more.....
Very good, and I love the piano too!
thelmaharper2005 3 years ago
great, but this is nr. 64, :)
michielxboxer 4 years ago
wow *_*
She plays very well!! I like this song very much!
Dara8 4 years ago
Holy cow! She played that like a total veteran! If I wasn't watching the video and saw a little girl there, I'd swear it was someone with 20 years experience just by the sound... thoroughly impressed!
johnpc831 4 years ago 3
That's a great rendition by a young pianist!
BTW, please fix the title of the video so people can find it when searching for op 64.
coffeetea 4 years ago
God! She's amazing! It blew me off my feet! I bow to you!
sofiankrt 4 years ago
what you have is a true love for the music. when some people play it sounds like work, but your playing is free.
CarlLefrancois 4 years ago
Very nice! But please: none of those mannerism like LH conducting starting in 2:03! It doesn't do anything to the music and won't impress any musician!
prongated 4 years ago 4
damn.....the young ones kick my ass...lol
Kotani301 4 years ago
Many great pianist have played this piece, and their interpretation varies a lot, not only amongst each other but also from Chopin's notation. We've already heard elements such as exaggerated staccati in the A part, accelerando in the B part, the right thumb melody in the B part, and so on. Phoebe seems to have combined those elements into her own interpretation, and it works quite well!
I myself cannot play this any better...
shyic 4 years ago
The special use of this length rubato is her own interpretation. With it, is emphasized the dance aspect. What is important here, is the fact she is interpreting to the extent that she does. And, wonderfully.
mason104 4 years ago 2
I've never heard so original dynamics or interpretation. I am astounded!!! It is the most BEAUTIFUL WALTZ! BRAVA!!! OMG!!! I don't know what to say!
mason104 4 years ago
this is op.64 no.2, not op.34 no.3
aStrimbu 4 years ago 3
Beautiful!
wifi888 4 years ago
It's just wonderful! Bravo!
pianogirl98 4 years ago
Dear Mr. lepaintre ( Jacques de Paris )
I personnaly think that Phoebe's interpretation of Chopin's Valse is very original and I like it deeply! On the contrary, I think Phoebe takes all her time to make to music flourish. And to contradict you to the end, I consider Phoebe to be already a great pianist.
Patrick
klingsor93 4 years ago 2
Nice!
Linhdanvo 4 years ago
Phoebe, You are excellent!!!!!!!!!
Pianoloverok 4 years ago
Just right!! ... beautiful
blueyoyi 4 years ago
I would quite simply say for your technique that it is frankly very good , but, Chopin sees in this opus 34 n31 flown away in a hurry. But I understand that you are desired of your share, to interpret it this manner; you have me a good technique to study it still more deeply, and to still read again this partition.
Still much you work will become a very large pianist...
Mercie
jacques de paris
lepaintre123 4 years ago