Added: 3 years ago
From: marcel78FR
Views: 708,751
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (505)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • It would be cool if you could get this device to run automatically at the frequency to make the dog whine.

  • FEDD THE DAM DOG!

  • If only if only the hungry dog cries...you'd feed me instead of playing with a motor that doesn't work. That is how that goes right? XD If anything, it's a nice conversation piece.

  • missing a few gates? need to re do you math and invert the input to a push with caps and resistors. and transistors. a few feed coils and flyback windings you might have a real toy. let me know if you need more info, if you finish remember this post.

  • Take a physics class

  • the question is; will this work in the aftermath of the solar storm?

  • Comment removed

  • FAIL!

  • well... spinning the machine actually makes the dog howling. What they don't show you in the video is that the dog is eventually connected to a rod, wich spins a wheel, wich pulls a lever, wich releases a magnet, wich turns a gyroscope, wich...

  • @ShahinGenerator Scammer!

  • wrap the stators in wire, run some power into that bitch an you got yourself a homebrew brushless motor :) 50 inch prop anyone? lol

  • May I suggest magnets that change in polarity strength layered together at each gate? - So what will happen is that the polarity is a bit weaker at the start of the gate and much stronger by the end (creating a slingshot effect) so that there is a force of 'propulsion' in effect. It would require either a larger system, or fine magnets. Perhaps the reverse may be better? Stronger magnets at the start of the gate and weaker at the end (of EVERY gate)... a thought anyways. Just toying w/ an idea.

  • WOW! It´s working! 

  • Ims seen other magnetically powered generators, and they powered themselves with electricity, then the surplus electricity you could use to power lights or whatever. Sorry Im not much help.

  • I built one and I got so angry that I SHIT MY PANTS. :-D

  • at first i was like WTF! but then is aw the slits in the wood XD

  • Damn it! I had a patent for a a magnetic generator 7 years ago! WHY DIDN"T I BUILD A PROTOTYPE INSTEAD OF SITTING ON MY ASS!

  • Excellent setup...

    If you want to get the Plans for the Free Energy Generator

    Go to Google and Search for "Best Magnetic Generator Review"

    Click the First Results (just Skip the Advertisements)

  • @OliverDepp Scammers!

  • Nice setup.Look at all the textbook fanatics go 'told you so!' , not for one second considering that a person that study magnetics for all his life, with military resources, maybe can discover something they've never been told...(Howard Johnson _ Spintronics) don't let them, or a non working setup kill your spirit, read up on pole shifting and manipulation, shielding with new mu-metals and the unknown(for old textbook readers)exchange forces. Bushmans magnetic beam is also future txtbk material

  • Hey, at least it looks cool.

  • the bendini brake seems to live upto its name. Perpetual motion may be impossible with the laws of physics we are given but its what we dont know that interests me.

  • Yup. Just keep spinning the fucker till you die of old age.

  • So, you've accomplished nothing. Give up and go do something useful like feeding that dog.

  • @TheMrBlinx

    Yea maybe but its still better than sitting on couch and watchig tv every day.

  • @plebecjusz Yeah, I know how it is. I'm a bit of an inventor myself and have several rooms full of junk, prototypes and failed/abandoned projects.

  • I'm going to LIKE this video just because I'm grateful to finally come across one of these stupid magnetic motor videos in which the inventor seemed to learn that perpetual motion doesn't work.

  • Surely there's a possibility here for learned people to scam the un/misinformed? I've got this rock that keeps tigers away... No wait; that's been done...

  • Make the spacing of the gates slightly unequal or off timed a bit. It will work. Mine does! Looks very similar to yours.

  • @UNKLDAVE where is your video of it working??

  • dude now use positively charge the metal thing and the gate things and this thing would keep spinning for ever because the repulsion created by same charge

    .... and we van use this technology to power our houses :o

  • @juanduism

    4 years ago too...

  • shot the dog or the man...

  • Free Energy Step By Step Instuctions part 1

    search this for an easy open source energy build

  • Bedini is a scam artist. Or maybe just a moron.

  • JUNK !! Who is pulling ticks off of the dog in the back ground noise ???

  • et alors ? il est ou ton principe mouvement perpetuel, that is your bullshit

  • does it tell the time?

  • Propaganda!!

  • run all 10 gates wound with copper to a box below that orients a switching mechanism that times the motion of the arm passing through it. when the arm moves through one gate a switch signals the gate in front to create an attractive magnetic charge and the gate it passes through a repulsive charge. This will like a swingset propel the arms through each gate by a timing mechanism.and would not take much of a current to run, you could start the timing mechanism using solar power

  • Established rules would have saved you time ;-)

  • wow failed megnet motor

  • WoW great job

  • If the Bedini motor worked he would have sold the idea years ago instead of making money off suckers who buy his "Experimental Kits"

  • you have to be really thick minded to think that energy doesn't just appear..

  • kick that dog, slap that bitch

  • The reason it doesn't work is..... hang on 606230 hits on youtube you bet it works.

    I'm going to build one tomorrow. Where do I buy the Bedinis from?

  • The reason it doesn't work is because your not using the right angles for the magnets. Look at some of the other videos the ones that work have a spiral spaced magnet design or some sort of V shaped magnet are being used to make these motors work.

  • @EntropyOfTime Clue from a physicist:

    NONE of them work, they violate the second

    law of thermodynamics. if somebody makes

    them look like they work, they are cheating

    and scamming people.

  • @EntropyOfTime If this was to work, you'd have to have PERFECT right angles, PERFECTLY uniform magnetic field, and NO FRICTION...in other words its impossible by todays standards

  • Yep none of these motors ever work. I built a different one many years ago because I was curious, or stupid. I knew that over unity couldn't work because there could/can be no net gain of energy. True over unity machines might just just be possible but they require FTL interaction - - literally Star Trek technology.

    The only way to have anything like perpetual motion is to have a system with zero energy out, like planets orbiting a star. Even th slightest leak will eventually bring to a stop.

  • @Lucien86 "The only way to have anything like perpetual motion is to have a system with zero energy out, like planets orbiting a star. Even th slightest leak will eventually bring to a stop"

    slight leak, in the form of friction being the first one to tackle :)

  • @TheSuperFungus Even planets will eventually stop. They aren't frictionless.

  • no sirve

    

  • But look at how beautiful it is...and how much you learned!!

  • crap,who goin to do that all day

  • It certainly does work... can't you hear the dog in the background hollowing in pain... Great Dog Control device... ;-)

  • off the top of my head, in this case ... a static magnet will push away equally on the approach as it does on the exit. You wont gain or loose anything. You do loose through friction, Therefore the system cannot be stable, let alone 'generating'. The end.

    PS thinking about it could prove that, so building it was pointless. Sorry. :) No hate, just fact.

    x

  • make the loops coils of wire, 4 driving coils, 6 pick off coils WALLA ! Free energy?

  • @MattBlytheTheOne voila <- proper spelling sir. Have a super day!! :o)

  • @scootkh sorry it was the Australian spelling :P

  • @MattBlytheTheOne No, it's just an incorrect spelling (that may have been passed on to you by others). No matter where you are it's Voila because it's from the french word. And while I'm here I hope you don't also use any of the following: "Pronounciation" "Excetera" "Exspecially" "Prostrate" "For all intensive purposes" "Libary" or, "Old-timers Disease" <-- My favourite They're all "common" mistakes that people believe right. (If karma holds, I'll have made a mistake in this message...)
  • @plukerpluck hahaha :P nah mate, itz definitely the Ozzy spelling, have a gooday! WALLA lol

  • ..... wait what is that thing?

  • That's Bedini's gate hypothesis :/

  • I see that one magnet is 0.00000001 mm out of alignment....that's why it doesn't work..♪♫♪

  • u know how to make it spin for longer? take those stupid gates off....

  • There are no free rides, ever.

  • think we experimented wih ideas like this when we were 6yr old. then we grew up.

  • anyone doubting this is a hating ass robot who believe what they are told, magnet engines probably behave differently in space, free of earths magnetism, heck spend a billion or two engineering and building one, and it will probably work, government sectors know it works but the business sector don't want to hear it..

  • Surely the concept relies on the motor having zero drag. You've had to put kinetic energy in to get the thing started and even if it did run forever; what on earth would it do other than spin endlessly (in a vacuum, with zero friction, at absolute temperature)? Any load on the device, such as a generator, would create too much resistance of for it to work surely.

    I'm confused???

  • @MajorComedown

    No because once it starts going, the magnets propel it further, and the resistance of such things is not enough to halt it against neodymium magnets. So you attach a generator, or if u put copper coil in those gates and it would still spin endlessly and create energy, however would use no energy to run, just magnets.

  • @mvenom101 I can see where you're going. Allow the object to gain enough momentum to allow a 'paddle' to be placed in it's path with sufficient drag to power a generator but not enough to reduce the objects momentum. The reason I feel that this hasn't been put into place is that kinetic energy is essentially 'balls' and conversion to electrical energy relies on the generation of a magnetic field (wire, coils, pieces of iron, yawn, etc). So for a magnetic field to power a traditional generator...

  • @MajorComedown Simply but the principle of perpetual motion doesn't work in any system where there is a force that works in opposition to momentum e.g. friction. No system is 100% efficient, so will always gradually lose energy. Hence perpetual motion is not possible.

  • did i hear fa fa fa fa fa.....FAILURE!!!

  • what ya expect? Perpetual motion? infinite energy? because f*ck you laws of thermodynamics? But gotta say: Good building skills.

  • The dog was saying, wrong, you're an idiot ... and then broke out laughing ....

  • @spasticos I think the dog has more brains/IQ than the guy who made the device.

  • wow... thats all the physicist has to say... wow...

  • @rocksparadox: actually, I have a B.S. from ASU, but thanks for the offer.

  • @Mrtomczarnota: who do you work for? Exxon mobile?

  • @xquisitaz Who do you work for, ''r-tards r us'' ??

    Get a high school diploma and understand that infinite energy from a finite machine is REALLY stupid.

  • If you positioned the magnets at a 45 degree angle (like a cone shape) then it would work.. at least a bit better.

    At the moment, the energy required to get into the magnetic 'zone' is being matched and therefore canceled out.

  • Check out the Laws of Thermo-Dynamics then you'll see why it doesn't work, and why it will never work...come on this is far too simple to extract free energy from Zero point Vacuum or where ever else you think it might come from, of course the things going to stop! Nice try though I like it, well made and an interesting Device none the less so well done :)

  • i think you did it wrong!

  • There's no such thing as free energy. Get this throuqh your heads.

  • Yea baby fed that dogs asshole with sperm until she drips! OH FUCKING BABY YES!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • @KyleTheLamma what the fuck are you on dude??

  • @Punkdude561 Im on my bitch fucking her right now nigga!!!!

  • I suggest you take the dog out for a walk before he does an accident :)

  • What is this, a Bedini brake?

  • @MucusFelidae tss tss...yeah...dat's a good one...tss...tsss...

  • french cant make anything useful except for white flags

  • @KentuckyFriedWalrus ahahaha..

  • Magnetic brake!

  • That poor cat is hungry.

  • wtf are they doing to dat dog ?

  • sadly you could use it as a generator but how much power could you really produce is beyond me without know the specs of the coils etc. doubt it would produce more power then a conventional rotatory generator. but still good to try as a science project.

  • It will run a lot longer if you remove the magnets.

    You've actually built a very poor magnetic brake.

  • absolutely right, but we are not looking for perpetual motion, only an alternative to the burning of fossil fuels. I suspect that there is not only one answer, but rather a combination of several different technologies.

  • I could have saved you from loosing the time. There is no such thing as a perpetual motion machine.

  • @alphakid42 And the world is flat,,,,,,,how often are certainties disproved

  • @dudleypaints The world being flat was not a certainty, that was pure guesswork, and based on no rational reasoning, perpetual motion machines are only possible in quantum thermodynamics, where time can get kinda screwy. The best you ever get is a machine with 100% efficiency, However that will need to operate in a frictionless vacuum. You will never get something that will put out more energy than it takes in, unless you are going backwards in time.

  • @alphakid42

    the electrons in an atom, are in perpetual motion ...

    500,849

    93/172

  • @ttmot Not really, they aren't really moving, they exist as a probability cloud, and jump all over that, not really moving in perpetual motion, just existing in a state with energy and mass. Electrons in a superconductor (assuming it is actually a superconductor, i.e. r=0) are in perpetual motion.

  • Comment removed

  • It does work it just needs a ... motor :P

  • It does work. You just made the fan wrong. Your magnet bars needed to be smaller.

  • 1.21 Gigawatts! 1.21 Gigawatts! Great Scott!

  • @JeffroTV No, its not Gigawatts, its jigawatts. Very different, one is real, the other isn't.

  • hum, perpetual motion isn't possible even by non scientists? Who knew.

  • @kd0afk The really sad thing is that this guy has obvious mechanical skills. If he hadn't wasted them on an idea that was a complete non-starter, he may have come up with something useful. As it is, the time and money is all gone with nothing to show for it. I find this very sad.

  • I think I could make one of those!

  • кто-то собаке яйтса отрывает на фоне видео за кадром .... сцуки, так кумарят эти аматорчкие видео

  • Cool video. My favorite part was when it didn't work.

  • idiot

  • FAIL !

  • No they have the right idea, but they forgot a set of electromagnets one around each of the intervals in side each of their coils, these (magnetos) will turn on when the magnet passes thrue, and power the (magnet) behind it to (reppel) the central rottor ina cyclical forward rotation.

  • This does work, but they just haven't realised that a flaw in their design means that the delayed current flows through the dog instead. Listen closely after each spin.

  • @TableWolfMusic I was thinking the same thing!

  • @TableWolfMusic i cryed cuz i laughed so hard at this

  • Dang Germans

  • @cdoftx It's french.

  • Comment removed

  • did i miss it?

  • So Close! Keep Trying!

  • Keep Trying! So close!

  • Grats, you made a thing that spins on a shaft, and stops after a rotation or two.

    And... What is accomplished? I can spin the wheel of my bike, and that will keep going for a few minutes, far better than this crap...

  • c'est bien ton truc la

  • I don't know why the negative feedback. At least this video may save many from spending weeks or even months building useless contraptions.

  • use a homopolar motor at the top? then it will rotate and most likely never stop homopolar motor has fast rotation so it might be what you need i dont know though try it out and see. Id hate to see you lose faith in yourself and your effort. Thats the worst feeling in the world.

  • use a homopolar motor at the top?

  • Change the magnits, make them so they work with they motion of resist vs push on the going in and out. thats where the math problem is.

  • your medling with forces you dont understand!

  • As far as I can tell the all motion is simply imbalances in any given system trying to find a state of rest. Since motion is by comparison between objects being at rest with themselves, it is the desire to become one that releases the energy. Much like fucking my girlfriend

  • well that was a whole lot of work for nothin

    seemed like elementary school kids curious to try somethin scientific, but obviously they're grown up and can make them look "better" only

  • it doesnt work because perpetual motion is impossible

  • @karston6 Only in a vacuum or space if you want to.

  • add another five gates...

  • add another two gates...

  • fail

  • It would spin longer if you took those dang magnets slowing it down away...

  • interesant!!!!!

  • визг собаки на заднем плане - как иллюстрация облома.

  • Over unity NEVER WORKS.

    Get used to it.

  • @azn nice bro so u saying it can't be done just cuz it's theory ?

  • Fail

  • STOP BEATING THE SHIT OUT OF THAT POOR DOG!

  • je suis ptet débile mais pourquoi ne pas utiliser des bobines à chaque porte ?

    disons qu'une bobine sur 2 envoit des impulsions à un moteur "léger" pour soutenir le mouvement de l'hélice et une bobine sur 2 produirait un petit surplus d'électriité. Le but étant de pouvoir au moins auto alimenter la rotation ...

  • Comment removed

  • i know how to make this work marcel w a little phenomenon i found while experimenting w different kinds of magnets. on the outer magnetic corridor stagger the magnets so they are repulsing each other. the magnets on the spindle should be football shaped and hooked up to freely rotate. move the outer magnets out to where the magnets will move through the space where the magnet is broken. as the spheroidal magnet moves through the gate it will spin as it passes causing a push pull sequence.

  • Of course this doesn't work! This dabbles in the theory of zero point energy! Which there's no such thing! For every positive energy there's an equal negative energy. So you have magnets pushing it forwards but those same magnets are also pushing backwards on the other side!! Let me also point out that it is "Bedini's gate theory" notice the word THEORY in there....if it were real or worked, it wouldn't be a THEORY!

  • @AznGothic The word theory doesn't mean that it could not work. A scientific theory is a hypothesis that has been tested. A theory is such when it can easily be verified and *perhaps* falsified. In this case, the theory got falsified. That just doesn't mean that it could not have worked because it was a theory.

  • replace the rings with copper coils and put strong mags on the prop and you got a good generator(bullet magnet through copper coils?)

  • quê merda....

  • you're too lazy. you need twice more gates and it will work. Dont give up

  • a perpetual thing can never end, consiquently it can never begin

  • @DasBasdoInc dont act like such a genious. perpetual is in the same category as infinity. its nothing more then an idea.

    this is being fueled by a source of power. the magnets. theyre fueled from the earth and other external forces. all we're doing is harnessing that. that is not an attempt perpetual motion in this video.

  • @Exgaves many laim that this is proof of perpetual motion, and thankyou for not trolling

  • @Exgaves dont act like such an idiot. Magnets are *NOT* a source of energy.

  • @playaspec then please enlighten me on how you define the force that magnets apply to objects oh great one.

  • @Exgaves Well, to speak for playaspec, that force stores energy but doesn't create it. If a magnet pulls something towards itself it uses energy, but you will also need the same amount of energy to pull the object away from the magnet. If the force magnets apply to objects was created by the magnets themselfs the magnets would have lost energy somehow due to the second law of thermodynamics.

  • The dog agrees it's shit.

  • At least your honest. Hmmm...what if you tilted the gates at slight angles and also tilt the magnets at slight angles to the gates angle and that way they would face each other and repel each other directly giving maximum force rotation in one direction, no?

  • hey! feed the dog assholes!

  • @Edubbplate Nah, the dog knew where they did wrong, and he couldn't stand not being heard...

  • @Edubbplate they were planning on eating it anyway so.....

  • Eso gira por inercia.

  • Stop killing the dog! lol

  • I will help!!!!! The magnet in the ring needs to be bigger your gates further apart...I think ur gates are 2 close causing the fields to not function properly...try a bigger magnet traveling through the gates and stretch the gates further apart...Hope that helps???

  • it coule work, you jsut need to use a magnetic shield on one side to make it a "one pole" magnet, then the other magnets cant apply a force int he other direction and the only direction the magnets would apply forces to is the direction its spinning. i would say use a metal plate to atleast reduce the magnets strength on the directiont hats pointing opposite to the direction its spinning, its a good idea :)