suicide is painless marilyn manson

[hellowhatudoin1]

i love this video its exectly how i feel

[JoolsyB]

Suicide may well be painless, suicide attempts very rarely are though. If you're gonna do it, get it right or suffer the consequences.

[Robots4Sale]

@JoolsyB suicide is committing murder and goes against the 10 commandments

[MEGAINDIEROCK]

The Manics version is way superior to this crap.

[TheAnthony6771]

i think if he sang with the melody it would sound very weird like something from the 80's and people if you dont like manson then dont listen to this and talk crap about him

[EnosShuffle]

and you can do the same thing if you please.

[Brelb123]

i think that its amazing and i listened to the old version and i'm glad manson did this cover

[JobberBud]

Dear Mr. Manson: I know times have been hard for you since 1998 when the shock value wore off and folks stopped paying attention, but please stop ruining other people's songs. Thanks. -your friend, Bud.

[ctommy205]

He kinda fucked up this cover. I see where he's going with it, but he didn't quite cut it.

[apollo1064]

for a start its a copy. 2nd he's mobid as hell. what a load of cr"p

[FolkBoyify]

harry morgan who the fuck..?

[zar214587]

OK youtube which put advertising in my vid' without my approval...

[Scarypair92]

@zar214587 because you have copyrighted material in "your" video! so they have to finance that somehow......

[zar214587]

@Scarypair92 that's right but without me this vid can't exist (they didn't post it themself), so, even if I didn't create the music (of course...) they get money through a vid they didn't post themself. I understand why I don't tuch money : I didn't create anything, just put existant things together. But they could at least ask me before contaminate things I post ! Because believe me, they are happy to find this kind of vids.

[blahdob]

@zar214587 sux man, i know your pain even when i kinda created my song... :'(

[Scarypair92]

@zar214587 Still, they have all the right in the world to put in a commercial into the video, they own the site you host your video at for free, without the copyright holders permission, they need to somehow finance the copyright infringements you and others are responsible of through their site.

[koreanstyler]

@zar214587 Just use something like AdBlock+ (Firefox PlugIn) and you will not even know there are ads in here.

[beggo321]

@zar214587 You want money for this video? Youtube is a business and didn't become successful by writing a lot of cheques.

[hellowhatudoin1]

@zar214587 wow

[eternalrecreation]

i will never buy Golburn valley quencher! It's the most annoying drink on youtube!



[KLOLWTF]

Pretty shitty cover.

[beastie666]

RIP Harry Morgan... Manic Street Preachers FTW!

[procrastinator99]

R.I.P. Harry Morgan.

[THIRDSHOCKARMY]

@procrastinator99 it feels bad man

[procrastinator99]

@THIRDSHOCKARMY I know that feel.....

[XxMariaMansonMariaxX]

I'm sorry? I know that it was "Suicide is Painless", but I wrote it wrong. Sorry? u_u

[TheDarkDawn3312]

@supernowhereman1965  Your grammar "suck".

[moad1000]

you ruined it

[ApalacheeTube]

I am a 50 year old fan of MASH. I can tell that he understands the song. To be honest, I don't like M.M. and most covers...but this is a phenomenal version. Give M.M. props for a brilliant take on a classic song!

[buzzboy199]

@ApalacheeTube your one awesome 50 year old imo :D

[jmoore9able]

@ApalacheeTube I never listened to Manson, until recently. I'm 38. I listened to a lot of his interviews. Not only is he quite intellectual, he is witty, and very spiritual and thought provoking. I give the man credit. I used to think he just wanted to shock people for attention, but he is so much deeper than that. I really can't get enough of listening to him talk lately. He is so well-spoken and knowledgeable on a vast number of topics.

[chopperboi89]

I have a bunch of Manson, and it's pretty good. But I have to say this is crap! For anyone that doesn't have a clue, go watch M*A*S*H*, not the show, the movie...

[Squidpus]

lolol, so much shitstorming over a song

[fredickErased]

does my health insurance cover this?

[UntitledKirk]

The original sounds so lame... I like the freaky sound of this one. Depressing music is something I've always liked. I'm not sure why :\

[bokuzenkosugi]

@UntitledKirk The original is better.  This faggot shouldn't have soiled such a good song.

[UntitledKirk]

@bokuzenkosugi Oh boohoo did I offend you? FUCK OFF.

[bokuzenkosugi]

@UntitledKirk Don't worry faggot, you didn't offend me. The only thing that offends me is this horrible cover of such a good song.

But the, Marilyn Manson sucks, so I guess I shouldn't have expected anything else when I clicked on this video.

[UntitledKirk]

@bokuzenkosugi Everybody has their own opinion. Stop acting cool over the fucking internet little troll.

[Lastman0nEarth]

@bokuzenkosugi Trollsauce

[UntitledKirk]

Lol how old are all of you people that "hate" this? M*A*S*H is like 60 fucking years old. This version is good and all of you are just whiny little pussies because Marilyn Manson "ruined" the song. If it was a bad cover, there would be a shit ton more dislikes. You don't have to listen to it if you don't like it. Jesus... so pathetic..

[DecloberatorJack]

gross.... i feel violated now. i just got my ear molested and whispered off creepily

[MeCommentNoHere]

ew >.<

Manson, what the hell? 

[ral1334]

I guess he's too cool to actually sing the melody.

[MrAlbo420]

@ral1334 It's Marilyn Manson!! WTF do you expect, the New Kids On The Block, Version!! YES, he IS TOO COOL to sing something, EXACTLY AS IT WAS!! It's HIS interpretation, C'MON!!!

[ral1334]

@MrAlbo420 I honestly have nothing against MM; I was just disappointed by this cover. I love the original for its combination of really happy music and devastating lyrics. It seems like MM just took the super-obvious dark route though, which just doesn't do the song credit in my opinion.

[NathanGrimace]

@ral1334 Well it's a cover...

[someguy131415]

he's ruined a classic...

i hate this fag.

[501joshb]

WOW, this cover sucks. Nothing can beat the original

[cocky04]

Manics > MM

[mechaghostman2]

@cocky04

They are both good. {:-p

[ILoveCurves88]

@ ikristyful THANK YOU!!! I think this is an AMAZING cover...

[122amsterdam]

HE DID NOT WRIGHT THIS !

[weedmasterfreak]

@122amsterdam Write* you idiot. Johnny Mandel and Mike Altman did, everyone knows that. This is what we mildly intelligent people call a fucking COVER!

[BryanJ136]

This is really bad. Lady and Bird's cover had passion and meant something. This just sounds like a man whispering and trying really hard.

[EmilySuydam]

@BryanJ136 To me the whispering shows a lot of emotion....the way he decided to sing this has tons of emotion, is it different from other covers? Yes, but I still find it wonderful. And for me this cover is much more depressing than any other cover which is how I think the song should be.

[ikristyful]

it is MM and it sounds amazing. i can feel the raw emotion in every word... so fuck off haters. this is so deep and amazing

[jindigger]

I thought this wasen't marilyn manson, it just sounds like him sorta, I dont think it's really him

[skyspellsdeath]

manson always does it best i dont think that will ever change

[southamericanrocker]

The original is way better! (MASH Theme).

This cover is shit!

[TheStudioSEB]

I like metal in general, but I've never like Marilyn Manson... the original is better.

[TheRealPitchWhite]

At what minute mark does this get good?

[cllubberlaing]

@TheRealPitchWhite

3.48 when it finishes, Listen to the Manic Street Preachers version of this.

[scineram]

Yes, this is shit.

[Orz1205]

I like this cover!!

[ToshihaGeiko]

I love the original, and I like this remake too. The emotion in his voice is great. And I like the piano.

[FuckinJunkie1991]

Manson may be my hero (old Manson, that is), but you CAN'T beat the original version!!!

DISLIKE

[ThatHanniganfellow]

@FuckinJunkie1991 yes you can.

[neopagn2004]

the original is good but this version sounds like horse shit

[sahlabouhla]

Εδώ στην Ελλάδα κάθε μέρα πεθαίνει κι ένας διαφορετικός άνθρωπος...Τα μέσα μαζικής ενημέρωσης δεν αναφέρονται σε αυτά τα εγκλήματα,τα κρύβουν όμως η πραγματικότητα ξεπερνάει κάθε προηγούμενο....Άνθρωποι κάθε ηλικίας κάθε μέρα αυτοκτονούν γιατί δεν έχουν άλλη διέξοδο και ποιός ξέρει,τελικά η αυτοκτονία μπορεί να είναι ανώδυνη....η ζωή πάντως καθόλου!!Αφιερωμένο στην μνήμη αυτών των ανθρώπων που φεύγουν άδικα!!Πρόσφατα έχασα κι έναν δικό μου άνθρωπο

If you wanna know what I say translate to Greek.

[ImZeify]

WAT DA FOK!?

[Avatar230594]

This isn't the best modern cover of a song I've heard.

[hassandandsumaya]

Marilyn Manson is a genius...........

[ddswooten]

sucks!

[mreducogo]

this is a good version, the original is too

[robotfunk]

way NOT better than the original. wow.

[novayne]

way better than the original. I used to watch the MASH show too.

[MrSatan666ism]

Beautifull, I like this better than the original. It provokes my inner Ruinenlust perfectly.

[easternelf71]

I like that his version puts a darker twist on the lyrics. The original is awesome, of course, and I love M*A*S*H, but I don't think he ruined the song. He just interpreted it a bit differently.

[Parkinstark]

It's okay. I prefer the original, though.

[TheDarkenedWorld]

Ok to all the people who believe that he ruined the song, are you sure he did?

I just listened to the original and I am freaking in pain. My ears hurt.

I mean, yes I like Manson but i am not a crazy fan. But still...How can you think that the original is better? It is like a song for kids. MM's versions contains all the pain and the sadness. And the song is about suicide. So yes. Shut up and enjoy, you know you like it.

[mirzahujdurovic]

thi dumb fucker ruined the amazing song of suicide is painless

[moxiox93]

This cover is bad, and Marilyn Manson should feel bad for essentially whispering the soul away from this song.

[trench1253]

O.o i am twelve years old.... this is MASH 40 years later when hawkeye starts suffering from PTSD

[Schutte2717]

Thanks to this freak, my image of mash is ****** up

[1996emmo]

@Schutte2717 fuck off

[Schutte2717]

@1996emmo What a cleverly conceptualized insult...now allow me to proceed and tell you to fuck off and die.

P.S. Marilyn Manson's a freak of nature... but I like him anyway

[evilvampireEater]

@Schutte2717 aww ur so sweet callin the god of rock n roll a freak see what i figured is the only reason ur calling him a freak is because ur jealous of him

[Schutte2717]

@evilvampireEater Oh no you didn't! God of rock?! Please. And seriously?! You think I'd be jealous of this mother fucker?! About 95% of the people who have heard his music and seen his creepy face dislike him. The rest think he's a "God," like you. It's pretty sad actually. If you want real rock, why don't you listen to David Bowie, Rolling Stones, or The Who or something, I don't know...

[evilvampireEater]

@Schutte2717 u r jealous and he is not creepy he is just ok with being himself unlike u fake ppl who wouldn't know a a dick from poptart

[Schutte2717]

@evilvampireEater Sorry to disappoint you, but in the documentary bowling for columbine, he states that he is just being a character in his music and his music videos.............awkward....

And if this is him being himself, then I won the argument of him being a freak...

[evilvampireEater]

@Schutte2717 so the hell what if he is freak at least he shows kids its alright to be urself instead of the lil fag bieber who shows kids how to be fake

[Schutte2717]

@evilvampireEater Just stop messaging me. It's clear you're too dumb to understand anything I am telling you, because all you do is send me the same message that he's being himself (and very poorly thought out analogies.) Do you think that if you don't dress up like a tree (one of his music videos I randomly stumbled upon) and be a transvestite (album covers) and fuck up perfectly good songs (The one I commented on originally) means that you're fake?! Good luck in life you moron.

[anime3806]

@evilvampireEater a dick from a poptart huh well first off i dont put dicks in toasters to warm them up lmao hahahahahahahahahahah

[MrJburkeIV]

MASH will never be the same.

[MrJburkeIV]

Easily the most effed up cover ever made!

[mermaidwoman1000]

is creepy watching this guy.. lol

[atrill84]

mash



[bigbigman3]

Whatever you want to do with yourself is still in the minds of others... Be careful of letting some one else hold your tears.

[mofforya000]

I agree man Manson is a creepy lookin dude. But people like him and i respect that.

[killertaco97]

this reminds me of mash, that show was awsome, i watched it as a kid

[SuperCrapper12]

this version would be way better if the original was meant to be creepy, but since it isnt, this blows. manson has some good ones though...

[Spunjo1221]

Original version of this song = 1,000,000X better. This version blows.

[cloud6060]

@Spunjo1221 Sooooo true. M*A*S*H FTW!

[cryz8210]

@Spunjo1221 They are both different, but with the same lyrics, go fuck yourself.

[Spunjo1221]

@cryz8210 Nope. This version sucks you fucking asshole.

[cryz8210]

@Spunjo1221 Just cause you don't like it, doesn't mean it's bad at all, have a more open mind or stop wasting your time fighting over something you don't like anyways.

[Spunjo1221]

@cryz8210 I wasn't fighting, you were the one who replied to my opinon. So for that I'm sorry, I didn't realize I wasn't entitled to an opinion. Even though it is a FACT that Manson's version is fucking terrible.

[cryz8210]

@Spunjo1221 Indeed, you are not entitled to an opinion, when your opinion isn't correct and that you actually say it's fact that it's bad.

Too bad that you're just a close minded, shit-pushing faggot to realise that you are actually just upset that you just don't like this one, so you try to make everyone think it's bad.

Now go fuck yourself, you sad piece of queer pussy.

[WolfTearsOfBlood]

the dislike bar is like lady gaga's penis it really shouldn't be there

[cryz8210]

@WolfTearsOfBlood She.. Doesn't have a penis, you know this, right?

[MrNICOLETTE82]

oi all of you... it's a guy..and he's more talented than any of us

[nynth]

Jesue fucking christ...why would he want to ruin such an awesome song...such epic fail. Seriously fucking hell.

[girgurmesh]

how does he and or she have a career?

he or she is just whispering

and its creepy as shit

the origonal song is waaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa­aaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaay better

[theMightyandAce]

@girgurmesh Well he has alooooooot more money than probably anyo of us watching so, he knows something that we all dont about whispering and being creepy as shit..

Learn from it.

[shaggybowie]

This sucks balls.

[christchen96]

SUICIDE IS PAINLESS IT BRINGS ON MANY CHANGES AND I CAN TAKE OR LEAVE IT IF I PLEASE...that is all

[btan1185]

this one just doesnt seem to have the impact of the original. maybe its the difference in context or maybe just the cheap creepy voice. i dunno.

[Spunjo1221]

@btan1185 definitely the cheap creepy voice

[jacobofunlivion]

I forgot all about this song so emotional....

[lliwsnave]

@musicxcrazy666 im not disagreeing with you. but here is nothing wrong with being 'emo" it means emotional, if you didnt know, i cant find anything wrong about that, and people like there own music, i personally love MM, but others might hate him, which is impossible, js

[henryvamp]

@lliwsnave well said. ALL music is emotional, well maybe very few recent music but finally someone who writes a true coment abot what "emo" even means. even though i dont like the style of music of emo today and dont even like that much of Manson i apreciate this song.

[demonlordkristina]

Oooh, that was a pleasant chill down my spine <3

[EmOGuXx]

I love this song it calms me down

[Beatnikzombie]

There are a lot of stupid comments on this video.

[Scott1759]

a bunch of emo fucks!!!!!!go outside get a tan and stop feeling like the whole world owes you....get over it everyone has a bad childhood.....

[WaterDemon55155]

@Scott1759 I actually had a wonderful childhood, and I still like Marilyn Manson.

Besides, you're the one coming to the "emo music" anyway.

[voodoochildjeff]

@Scott1759 you my dear friend, are an asshole. i think you should go jump off a cliff. that is all.

[UntitledKirk]

@Scott1759 Wow calm the fuck down it's just a song.

[BeastlyLamb]

this does have a Silent hill feel to it... ups the creep factor

[BrianWarner1996]

My cousin and I were best friends until he hung himself to death. I played this song in the car for 2 hours while I drove to his funeral. I decided to leave suicide that day and live in tribute to him with his tattoos on me.

[MySavior39]

Does this remind anyone else of Silent Hill?

[wfkTVpl]

ŻAL !!!!!!!

[loser1802]

I like Manics' version better. But Manson do it in their own way, so it's good anyway. I have always loved the song.

[DoNMoSs2]

The original was simply better 

[ABleedingRose]

@emobanana22 im a straight guy, but if Marilyn wanted me, hell ill say yes

[danschaoticmind]

@emobanana22 I see the logic in disliking him. If all he does is cover music, then he doesn't have much originality. Thus is a facet of logic that goes into it. I rather like the guy but do admit I would like to see more originality out of him. That's just me though.

[cloud6060]

@emobanana22 First of all all he is doing is whispering like the little faggot he is. And he wears a shit load of makeup which just proves more that he sucks cock and his music sucks and I would slit his throat in a heartbeat. He is too old to be acting like a 15 year old emo faggot. Get a life you fucking punk!

[TheVampiressLisa]

@cloud6060 Big words coming from a guy who seems to enjoy belittling others. I'm assuming your an "adult" (and I'm using that word VERY loosely). If my assumption is correct, why not just admit you don't like it, accept the fact that others do, and move on? Yes, I admit, there are some MM songs I'm not into.But I don't go bashing those songs. Hell, I don't care mush for this song, to be honest. I'm just gonna move on to the next vid.It's called respecting the opinions of others.

[cloud6060]

@TheVampiressLisa I just hate when people don't have the brain cells to listen to something good. I do like one or two of his songs. And I'm not gonna lie, I'm not an adult. I'm 15.

[TheVampiressLisa]

@cloud6060 Ah. Well, while I do admit that it baffles me to know that some performers actually have fans in the first place (Justin Beiber comes to mind...) I try to respect the people that DO like them. Everyone likes different things for different reasons. My bf listens to stuff I hate, I listen to stuff that he hates. We just agree to disagree.

[1996emmo]

@emobanana22 kool <3



[Acrimonious10001]

The music almost has a Silent Hill feeling added to it with the piano and well just the whisper vocals and the slowness adds to it too.A decent cover.Also to all the people saying theirs no screams, listen to the original it's not suppose to, it's quite drastically changed as it stands from what he did to it.If he added more it would had been horrible.

[beat4me2in64]

I listen to every genre in music some artist I like some artist I know suck

[RinRanThatWay]

would it be better if justin beiber covered this?-sarcasm- of course because it's not marilyn Manson covering it.People should just stfu

[6BreakingBenjamin9]

Why is everyone being so mean? Like, every comment I see is dissing on Marilyn Manson. This is actually pretty good. He's one of my favorite artists. I don't "fail at life" for liking this song and Marilyn Manson is not "a hack." MM can cover songs if he wants. It's not always going to be better or as good. But I do think it's pretty good. So go hate on other people, like Justin Bieber. OH WAIT! You people probably enjoy his music! Shut up and go away.

[dewfall56]

Wow, didn't even scream once.

[chism26]

wow this guy sucks

[chism26]

no one reconises it as one of the most depresing songs

[chism26]

Marilyn Manson is a hack

[megageek2031]

not as good as the original but it's still okay



[theatomicskull999999]

the star ruined it for me

manson's kinda creepy

[pinatamarket]

if you like this and what it means, YOU FAIL AT LIFE. I wonder how many poor dorks killed themselves to this black song (1,008)

[Chalikun]

@pinatamarket You do realize it's not music that makes people kill themselves, right?

[pinatamarket]

@Chalikun "Through early morning fog I seeThe game of life is hard to play". Oh of course music doesn't inspire or motivate or compel people at all. Life doesn't imitate Art, right? Don't be a Fool. Sad music makes people sad and happy songs make people feel happy and evil depressing music makes people feel depressed. why do angry teen love Marlyn Manson because it feeds their Emotions. think critical man

[Mailyn666]

@pinatamarket Wrong.

Music expresses eventually suppressed emotions. And it's very healthy to let your feelings out or they'll strangle your soul.

[Chalikun]

@pinatamarket Songs cause feelings, yes, but it takes a certain type of person to ACT on those feelings. Normal people won't go shoot people because they're depressed. Not all fans are angry teens. Some people are casual 'some songs are ok' types. Most of the "angry teens" are the ones who go to his videos on Youtube just to talk about how much they hate him.

It's called self-control, it's something people seem to lack today.

Also, you realize this is a cover of the M*A*S*H theme, right?

[ShoutingParalized]

@pinatamarket nobody likes happy songs when they are truly sad, so they listen to depressing songs to feel better. just like when people get sad, they cry to get their feelings sorted out.

[mhatkins]

SACRILEGE!!!! To USE and DESTROY a song that was written for the movie and revamped for the tv show, and make it into this CRAP?????? I love Manson, but, he has gone too far! I'm a M.A.S.H fan for ever! Know every episode, word for word. Watch it EVERY day! Manson....you insult the genre and series.

[XxMariaMansonMariaxX]

I love Marilyn Manson!

This is so much better than the original!

My heart was bleeding, first time I heard this song.

And after that, I listen to this over and over again<3<3<3<3<3!

Suicide is painled...oh, god! I love this text c:

[mhatkins]

@XxMariaMansonMariaxX Okay, first. Put the crack and meth pipe down. better than the original????? Bwahahahahahaha!!!! Your heart bled?????? Suicide is "painled"????? It's PAINLESS! You kids are so confused and so lost. You REALLY do NOT know what the song REALLY is about! You hear "suicide" and all of a sudden, it speaks volumes to you. It MEANS shit to you. You have to cut yourselves. You are dumb ass brats! Stupid fucking kids! Grow the fuck up!

[quartarola]

why does he whisper most of his songs -.-

[dogieyoman3]

True shame marilyn didnt realize the songs suppose to be funny...

[TheGFBTV]

@dogieyoman3 the original is reconsigned to be one of the most depressing songs ever written...

[mhatkins]

@dogieyoman3 Meant to be funny? Are you a retard??? It was never meant to be funny, you mislead idiot!OBVIOUSLY, you are a KID without a clue..... So sad. I guess I should feel sorry for you, but I don't. Get some education before you speak. It is better to think you might be an idiot, than to speak and remove all doubt.