Wow, thank you so much for sharing. It is such a shame throughout the 25 years of this show that NO OTHER African American man has ever played this part.
god, I cant stand dale kristen! she is not a good actress!! if you want to see a christine acually do something during music of the night, find a video of gina beck in phantom..... wow... :D
@TheTitanic4 you are totally right.. Gina is amazing! Dale Kristen GRRRR! what is she? Made out of stone? Why doesn't she move she just stands there like a statue.
@4everPhantomslover I saw them both perform this and there was a lot more movement on the actual stage. I saw Dale perform as Christine 4 times and she did a great job. That little clip does not do her justice at all. She was wonderful to see perform with Michael Crawford as well.
I love seeing differen't ethnicities and voice types play the phantom but I prefer the higher tenor. Like michael crawford and tim martin gealson. The deeper vocie just doesn't do it for me. Robert Guillaum is extremely talented however.
I've been looking for this for a very long time, too. Just a nitpick note, this wasn't from Motown 25, that was in 1983, four years before Phantom came to Broadway, but you're right, this was a Motown special, I want to say from 1993 instead.
Aside from that, I've loved this performance for a long time, and I appreciate you finding it.
@Bomberzone1745 Thats PHANTASTIC!!! I feel like the role of the Phantom, Vocally anyway, is PERFECT for an African American !!! ..... Especially Norm Lewis !! lol
Roberts great!! Awsome seeing an African American as The Phantom! it should happen more often! ... speaking of which ... NORM LEWIS! Wouldnt he be a PHAN TASTIC PHANTOM!!!!? Dale is very ... robotic here! she has no expression!
Oh, thank you for posting this! I've been wanting to see more of Robert's Phantom after hearing him sing the title song. I really like his voice! The only thing that bugs me about this particular performance is that Dale is just standing there, I wish they could've had her move just a little bit. Anyway, this video is a great find, thanks again for uploading!
It's odd that at the end, he turns to Christine and shouts, "Krause!"
PlanitReality 3 days ago
I've been dying to see that for YEARS! Thank you so much!!
PlanitReality 3 days ago
wow
redberry0 6 days ago
I wonder what his deformity looked like...
spiderpigc 2 months ago
Robert has a very nice opera singing voice.
bobbo06 3 months ago
Beautiful. Really beautiful. I love his performance. But it's out of sync.
inlovewithKStewart22 3 months ago
i didn't know Robert Guillaume has played the Phantom! this is the same guy who was the voice of Rafiki for 'The Lion King'.
ttqsg 4 months ago
Intonation Robert??? What happened LOL
3rdknukl 5 months ago
Wow, thank you so much for sharing. It is such a shame throughout the 25 years of this show that NO OTHER African American man has ever played this part.
lakeshoretony 6 months ago 2
god, I cant stand dale kristen! she is not a good actress!! if you want to see a christine acually do something during music of the night, find a video of gina beck in phantom..... wow... :D
TheTitanic4 8 months ago
@TheTitanic4 you are totally right.. Gina is amazing! Dale Kristen GRRRR! what is she? Made out of stone? Why doesn't she move she just stands there like a statue.
4everPhantomslover 7 months ago
@4everPhantomslover I saw them both perform this and there was a lot more movement on the actual stage. I saw Dale perform as Christine 4 times and she did a great job. That little clip does not do her justice at all. She was wonderful to see perform with Michael Crawford as well.
lisaannejane2 2 months ago
I love seeing differen't ethnicities and voice types play the phantom but I prefer the higher tenor. Like michael crawford and tim martin gealson. The deeper vocie just doesn't do it for me. Robert Guillaum is extremely talented however.
randomania31 9 months ago
the words are off cause it's not matching to his lips.
Concertchoir76 10 months ago
I've been looking for this for a very long time, too. Just a nitpick note, this wasn't from Motown 25, that was in 1983, four years before Phantom came to Broadway, but you're right, this was a Motown special, I want to say from 1993 instead.
Aside from that, I've loved this performance for a long time, and I appreciate you finding it.
Russebby 10 months ago
@Bomberzone1745 Thats PHANTASTIC!!! I feel like the role of the Phantom, Vocally anyway, is PERFECT for an African American !!! ..... Especially Norm Lewis !! lol
SamSkii14 11 months ago
@SamSkii14 I think if any guy had the right voice - the role is perfect if your Caucasian, Indian, African, Asian, etc. :)
EmilyGreene1984 10 months ago
Roberts great!! Awsome seeing an African American as The Phantom! it should happen more often! ... speaking of which ... NORM LEWIS! Wouldnt he be a PHAN TASTIC PHANTOM!!!!? Dale is very ... robotic here! she has no expression!
SamSkii14 11 months ago
@SamSkii14 so just what do you think the role requires? Look deeper. Roberts, not great.
3rdknukl 5 months ago
@SamSkii14 I totally agree... I would LOVE to see either him or Brian Stokes Mitchell play the Phantom...
tjonesmusicman 5 months ago
He's got a good voice, but his acting really bugs me.
EmilyGreene1984 1 year ago
Oh, thank you for posting this! I've been wanting to see more of Robert's Phantom after hearing him sing the title song. I really like his voice! The only thing that bugs me about this particular performance is that Dale is just standing there, I wish they could've had her move just a little bit. Anyway, this video is a great find, thanks again for uploading!
EponineGraydeChagny 1 year ago
I really like Robert's voice but Dale Kristen is really annoying me. Who put the LND robot here?
TGITPC 1 year ago 13
very nice!! thanks so much for uploading!!!
DarthxErik 1 year ago 7
Loved it.
Concertchoir75 1 year ago 2