Brits in a stereotypical kind of way have a very established opinion of the Irish and everyone seems to have an Irish relative so theres jokes in there we get that Americans might not, it wasn't due to offense caused (mainly because there was no offense caused), when it was adapted they saw potential for different jokes and they worked for us. Also a lot of the stereotypically Irish things in the eyes of Americans are more stereotypically Welsh or Scottish to Brits.
They changed the lyrics the same reason why the first Harry Potter book is called "...and the sorcerer's stone" in the US. Cultures are different. I can't understand why this is such a big deal
Thank you for posting this; it helped so much!!! My school is doing this musical, and I auditioned with this song and just found out I got the part of Paulette!!! So I really appreciate this video; the lyrics here are the ones in our script! :)
they were 'offensive', they just wouldn't work with a UK audience, we don't visualise Ireland the same way US audiences might (mostly because of the Troubles) so Paulette's dreams wouldn't've made much sense to us. I really like both sets of lyrics.
Brits in a stereotypical kind of way have a very established opinion of the Irish and everyone seems to have an Irish relative so theres jokes in there we get that Americans might not, it wasn't due to offense caused (mainly because there was no offense caused), when it was adapted they saw potential for different jokes and they worked for us. Also a lot of the stereotypically Irish things in the eyes of Americans are more stereotypically Welsh or Scottish to Brits.
TheSocksAreFun 6 days ago
They changed the lyrics the same reason why the first Harry Potter book is called "...and the sorcerer's stone" in the US. Cultures are different. I can't understand why this is such a big deal
warumonokao 1 month ago
Thank you for posting this; it helped so much!!! My school is doing this musical, and I auditioned with this song and just found out I got the part of Paulette!!! So I really appreciate this video; the lyrics here are the ones in our script! :)
ProdigiousHdawg 3 months ago
....................i really dont understand why this had to change. like, really dont. at all.
JerryO89 3 months ago
*no-one thought they were 'offensive'....
GaryTheGerbil3 4 months ago
they were 'offensive', they just wouldn't work with a UK audience, we don't visualise Ireland the same way US audiences might (mostly because of the Troubles) so Paulette's dreams wouldn't've made much sense to us. I really like both sets of lyrics.
GaryTheGerbil3 4 months ago
i love that musical
speke23 1 year ago 2
uhm........ why are the lyrics different? hahaha
jewey896 1 year ago
@jewey896 I heard it was because the thought the old ones might be "offensive"
SoCloseTogetherX 1 year ago
@jewey896 because the UK audiences wouldn't find it funny other wise....but im from the UK and loved the original, but i find this funnier!
MrKandyLife 1 year ago 3