Added: 4 months ago
From: ToneNoir
Views: 60,232
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (62)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • i don't know who really don't know how but i always mix this song i mean the original, with songs of garbage.

    in some place of my heart i was feel this song was for them.

  • It's even more haunting and beautiful to me than the U2 original--like Billie Holliday and Edith Piaf combined.

  • Love this song but Bono pises me off, so now I can finally listen to it without being ashamed of myself:)

  • saw her at new year's eve in nyc. she blew me away with this song. brought me and her to tears. patti shows the incredible beauty of U2's lyrics (which normally i don't notice due to slick production).

  • It feels like everyone who did this had no interest in doing so. I'm glad she at least tried to be inventive about it

  • This is the best cover in this compilation. Well done Patti!

  • Better than the Real Thing...you can hear the great lyrics. Bono's drunken mumble through the original made right here.

  • No no no no Patti just KILLS it genius that she is. U know Bono would bow to her and cite her as a key original influence. Bet he was beside himself hearing her do one of his... Patti is the poetess with the mostest... Wake up people glad to know some people get it... Wow

  • exquisite rendition bravo! wwwgreatbuyoutletscom wwwtopfuelsavercom

  • Outstanding cover! Patti is a genius.

    There are only two artists who are able to record covers that are better than originals: Patti Smith and Tori Amos.

  • @muminek79

    In other words you have only come accross two artist you believe can do better covers than the originals, a very shallow and close minded comment.

  • Well this is just terrible. I understand making the song your own, but this one doesn't sound good to me at all/

  • You know, the way she covered Gimme Shelter and Smells Like Teen Spirit, I'm not surprised she did a great job here as well. She is a legend.

  • Will they make a movie about U2 listening this remake album? Me wonna watch!

  • Oh Patti , why do i love you so much?

  • this entire album is as good as the original

  • wow. absolutely amazing. my favorite cover..hands down.

  • This is absolutely incredible.

  • Haunting rendition. Kudos to both Patti & U2 for this.

  • makes me think of Leonard cohen for some reason

  • It's Patti's band , right? Lenny and the guys?

  • great cover. It's almost as if it was written for Patti.

  • This is amazing, I think the job of a cover version is to make you NOT think of the original, apart from a vague feeling of recognition of the words. And this so does that.

    Incredible cover.

  • I'm gonna cry... =D

  • Nice cover! BUT I think the soul of the original song is the electric sound and the power of the distortion.

    I would like to hear a cover of this one from The Verve.

  • I hated it :(

  • SUCH A DIFFERENT !  GOOD COVER BUT I LOVE THE ORIGINAL!!!!!!!

  • She sounds sooo good : - ).

    Rock on Patti

  • Very good cover!!!

  • Love it Patti!!!

  • It's Patti for cryin' out loud! What's with all the miserable critiquing? It's not supposed to sound like, and it shouldn't be compared to, the original. It is simply magnificent...

  • I´m sorry but this cover is awful, lost the essence of the original, sorry sister

  • I love Patti Smith and U2, but I can't connect with this cover at all. Its stripped of emotion, at least moreso than Bono's, her high notes are weak. She did a great cover of Teen Spirit using a similar formula of stripped down accoustics and unusual singing quirks but it doesn't work here. Its depressing from the first minute and lacks the ambivalence of U2's version which was bitter sweat, this is just bitter.

  • wonderful voice, great song

  • I like it but I would rather prefer the original.

  • I´ve said it before and I´ll say it again, a cover can be better, worse or just as good as the original. This one is worse period! .-)

  • Comment removed

  • I liked it....it's different like very sad very stripped down....very acoustic

  • Oh, Patty, this is simply wonderful! Thank you!

  • It is always a matter of opinion, i think it´s a great version, patti is always interesting and making interesting stuff

  • Comment removed

  • THIS VERSION GETS CLOSER TO STAY (FARAWAY, SO CLOSE)

  • Interesting... but doesn't touch the original.

  • I think its great that a beloved U2 song still sounds so amazing when completely reinterpreted. I think this is lost on a lot of listeners....

  • @mcveenman Agreed

  • this album should not have been tampered with

  • it bacame a "I'm drunk and alone in the woods missing my lost love"

    grrrrrr

    it's impossible to be as good as U2, even playing one of their songs.

  • Magnificent !

  • YUCK!!

  • Stripped down U2.. This is the way i imagine all the greatest U2 songs.. They should do an album of all Acoustics.. Loved it!!!!

  • mammamiaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa­ <3

  • I like what she's done with it

  • @Rabidlamb I am in agreement with you there; one of the best tracks off the album.

  • @Rabidlamb , yes great interpretation. I was very impressed. Probably the best song on the album.

  • bellissima reinterpretazione ! genio allo stato puro!

  • Magnificient. Love Patti!

  • What a pollution. Please, STOP! This is really bad, ugly and anyother negative adjective you might think...

  • @Noua78 I agree. Thought she would make a great cover but this is terrible

  • great version !!! Thanks !

Loading...
Alert icon
0 / 00Unsaved Playlist Return to active list
    1. Your queue is empty. Add videos to your queue using this button:
      or sign in to load a different list.
    Loading...Loading...Saving...
    • Clear all videos from this list
    • Learn more