Phil Labonte receives a lot of garbage for his vocal ability, but as a diehard ATR fan, an acoustic version as such that really exploits anyones' vocals is quite impressive in my opinion.
I love all that remains, this is the first time hearing the acustic version, its pretty good, except, him trying to scream it, u know, just "sing" it Phil :)
Ghost would do the best job. Matt Tuck would do a good job too. But M. Shadows voice is too whiney and if he covered it I wouldn't listen. I find it hard enough to even get through Avenged Sevenfold songs. The only redeeming qualities are Sinister Gates and The Rev RIP
ive been wanting to see these guys live, hows their live performance? compared to how like metallica sounds even better live than on cd, anything like that?
@JPAnthonyy Having seen both Metallica and All That Remains live, I have to say, ATR puts up one hell of a show. Visually Metallica is better, with the lasers and pyrotechnics, but soundwise ATR has them beat due to James's deterorating vocals. If you get a chance to see ATR live, do it. Phil Labonte is both badass and hilarious onstage at the same time.
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
this is by far the most queer bullshit i have ever listened to. i love how stupid you all look for liking these morons. i hope you all get your shit together someday.
@macdrian Whats more retarded? Us enjoying a song that in our opinion is great OR you insulting us on our choice of musical preference?
Our opinions are exactly that... OUR opinions. As im sure most people who are on this video will agree, there are two types of music genre: Good and Bad.
lol i love how litterally every badass band has to do an acoustic version of a song or just an acoustic song i like how its a change a pace and love the lyrics behind them its just so beautiful
5FDP did do an acoustic version of "The Bleeding". Might want to make sure you know all the songs before posting something like that up. Just saying. It was released on the re-release of The Way of the Fist.
@anthonytheshit123 hahaha if you think As I Lay Dying is increment, then you don't know what the fuck increment metal is haha want a link a link to my band?
If your a Real band like Metallica, Protest the Hero, Slipknot, Five Finger Death Punch, Pantera, or Disturbed, you dont need to do acoustics because they are pointless and dont sound right
@316elite321 That is one of the most stupidest statements I've ever heard. What does being a "Real" band have to do with doing something you love? You have no clue what music is kid.
@316elite321 Ever heard of Darkness by Disturbed or FFDP making an acoustic version of the Bleeding? Hell even Slipknot did Snuff which was awesome and acoustic in most parts. Yeah its acoustic and its fucking epic, so don't go around posting shit that you don't fully understand. Oh and Metallica did a shit ton of their music with an orchestra.
wow, my first time hearing this version it's amazing, i can't wait till the 24 atr aild carnifex and unearth hell yeah, check my band on my page have a few rough recordings of iron core, give local music a chance, one of the last times i saw atr phil told me it took him 10 years, i've been at it for 8, keepin my head up thanks phil
@Red8Jack all that remaims is always talking about how they want to go softer, so maybe you'll be in luck with that ballad. but ... i dont really care cuz there music is emotioal already. but that would be interesting, i'd perfer them to just do acoustic versions of hard songs tho.. (:
so, soooo, amazing:) i get chills everytime i hear it. This version has to be my faviort and this is one of the reasons i love this band cause they can play their things unpluged. Im a Grunge fan but i like this.
so, soooo, amazing:) i get chills everytime i hear it. This version has to be my faviort and this is one of the reasons i love this band cause they can play their things unpluged. Im a Grunge fan but i like this.
so, soooo, amazing:) i get chills everytime i hear it. This version has to be my faviort and this is one of the reasons i love this band cause they can play their things unpluged. Im a Grunge fan but i like this.
To ATR: Please do an all acoustic album, it would be insane.....\m/
ryanko6 2 weeks ago
@ryanko6 I love how that comment was posted "2 weeks" ago. Plus that would be sick!
avalanchefan42 11 hours ago
honestly his voice sounds better in non acoustic versions
fluffleB 1 month ago
Phil Labonte receives a lot of garbage for his vocal ability, but as a diehard ATR fan, an acoustic version as such that really exploits anyones' vocals is quite impressive in my opinion.
jaredmbrill 1 month ago
@jaredmbrill
Much better than Matt Tuck, M. Shadows, or Ivan Moody.Lol. Agreed man.
Ragnarok0Aeirk 1 month ago
his voice is straining more than half this song. he did alright but this is not in his range.
OhMrWilson21 2 months ago in playlist Liked videos
@OhMrWilson21 I don't think thats it at all.....thats not straining....thats him putting his strength and metal touch to an acoustic song
ShadowSC2 2 months ago
@Lovemetal629 how about none? How about keep it Phil, because he did just fine?
darkslayer666999 2 months ago
I love all that remains, this is the first time hearing the acustic version, its pretty good, except, him trying to scream it, u know, just "sing" it Phil :)
mgs19901 3 months ago
Ghost would do the best job. Matt Tuck would do a good job too. But M. Shadows voice is too whiney and if he covered it I wouldn't listen. I find it hard enough to even get through Avenged Sevenfold songs. The only redeeming qualities are Sinister Gates and The Rev RIP
AdvancingDarkness 3 months ago
his singing in the verses shouldve been less forced..and the chorus shouldve followed the original.
xxxWolFangxxx 4 months ago
@xxxWolFangxxx thats just his singing style. without it being "forced" it wouldnt sound like ATR
Acrell96 4 months ago
@xxxWolFangxxx your fuckig retarded
scarboundloner 3 months ago
is OP
turbointro 4 months ago
ive been wanting to see these guys live, hows their live performance? compared to how like metallica sounds even better live than on cd, anything like that?
JPAnthonyy 4 months ago
@JPAnthonyy Having seen both Metallica and All That Remains live, I have to say, ATR puts up one hell of a show. Visually Metallica is better, with the lasers and pyrotechnics, but soundwise ATR has them beat due to James's deterorating vocals. If you get a chance to see ATR live, do it. Phil Labonte is both badass and hilarious onstage at the same time.
UltimateSephiroth060 4 months ago
One word:
E-X-E-L-L-E-N-T
AlexeyXTI 5 months ago
@AlexeyXTI ...Sick song and great describing word but........you spelled it wrong...\m/
ryanko6 4 months ago in playlist ryanko6's favorites
awesome version of this song.
EpicRyKnOW 5 months ago
this song makes me feel all warm in my human parts. :D
EvalPanda 5 months ago
Going To be able to see them in December when they come to Louisville!
luke00224488 5 months ago
Going to see them in November cant wait!!!!
BvbArmyGirlA6 5 months ago
@BvbArmyGirlA6 me to :)))
xxtallmanbabby 5 months ago
@xxtallmanbabby nice! wait im going for the planets birthday bash....is that what your going to? hahaha
thezi1 5 months ago
@xxtallmanbabby lol sorry...I forgot I was on my brothers account....(thezi) lmao
BvbArmyGirlA6 5 months ago
sooo good :D
D000m3 5 months ago
I love it when Rock and Metalbands do acoustic covers of their songs. It ALWAYS sounds amazing! :)
RavonLF2 6 months ago 48
@RavonLF2 hell yea, it shows how even more awesome they sound, ATR for life!
mgs19901 3 months ago
@4cellar2door0 ...and do what?
darkslayer666999 6 months ago
@darkslayer666999 back when this had 1 dislike, he wrote that comment saying he wants to kill them
6smosh 6 months ago in playlist More videos from Edgecrusher66
in the top 5 bands in the world ..
GrahamL619 6 months ago 3
Who thinks Matt Tuck, M. Shadows, or Ivan Moody should sing this as a cover? In the acoustic version.
Lovemetal629 6 months ago 44
@Lovemetal629 Ivan Moody, hands down
FusionGuitarist1 3 months ago
@Lovemetal629 why would ivan waste his time with m. shadows? ivan is a way better metal singer then m. shadows
dylanxfriends 3 months ago in playlist Liked videos
@Lovemetal629 NO FREAKING WAY! Tuck and Shadows blow so much dick compared to Phil. Phil is one of the best singers in the genre.
YouRGHostiSAGiFT13 2 months ago
@Lovemetal629 Ivan Moody would KILL this. I agree with you.
OhMrWilson21 2 months ago
@Lovemetal629 would love to hear them sing this
986trx200sx86 1 month ago
the arpeggiated riff sounds like a final fantasy theme song
slimjim561 6 months ago
I like this but lets face it, Phil isnt the best at acoustic
FreakyKing2 6 months ago 2
bing bing bing
naruto99124 6 months ago
How is musically possible that the rough sound coming from Phil, because of all his screaming, sounds that amazing when they're playing acousticly?
It doesn't make sense, but when you listen to it, you can't even remotely imagine it being sung any other way.
Am I right?
kerrigor666 7 months ago
philip is fucking awesome :D
dimadima91 7 months ago
yay thumbs up for me! im like # 220! xD
Un4gvn5810 7 months ago
3 people will be caged in our hands.
hackzor09 7 months ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
this is by far the most queer bullshit i have ever listened to. i love how stupid you all look for liking these morons. i hope you all get your shit together someday.
who am i kidding, you can't heal the retarded.
macdrian 7 months ago
@macdrian Whats more retarded? Us enjoying a song that in our opinion is great OR you insulting us on our choice of musical preference?
Our opinions are exactly that... OUR opinions. As im sure most people who are on this video will agree, there are two types of music genre: Good and Bad.
Skcull210 6 months ago
I like it when a band like this does acoustic versions of their songs. Shows real talent. KC 2011 they kicked ass
TheGuitar1337 7 months ago
Wicked!
fezzverbal 8 months ago
two people should each play Russian roulette with 6 bullets (:
failurecubed 8 months ago 3
I need two bullets...
phonessakuraba 8 months ago 2
lol i love how litterally every badass band has to do an acoustic version of a song or just an acoustic song i like how its a change a pace and love the lyrics behind them its just so beautiful
youmadbroskii 8 months ago
fantastic acoustic
scripter101 8 months ago
Fantastic! \m/
I'd love to hear an entire acoustic album by them.
ryanko6 8 months ago 8
Hi Jakeypoo! :3
raptor01105 9 months ago
@raptor01105 It's funny 'cause I'm called Jake and this randomly scared the shit out of me. ^_^
jbelgian13 8 months ago
@jbelgian13 XD SAME HERE YO
SynVenganceShadows 8 months ago
@SynVenganceShadows you're missing Johnny and The Rev in your name! lol
IfAsEnFaN 8 months ago
@IfAsEnFaN youtube believe or not has a limit to the amount of epicness in your name so i had to leave them out
SynVenganceShadows 8 months ago
@SynVenganceShadows aw that sucks! Poor guys being left out! I'll have to make a name with just the 2 of them to make them feel more included!
IfAsEnFaN 8 months ago
@IfAsEnFaN The Rev alone is too much epicness for one name they dont let it happen they say " Using God as a username could be offensive"
SynVenganceShadows 8 months ago
@316elite321
5FDP did do an acoustic version of "The Bleeding". Might want to make sure you know all the songs before posting something like that up. Just saying. It was released on the re-release of The Way of the Fist.
wolf2000sc 10 months ago
what album is this on?? Is it on an album??
Ajbadboy252 10 months ago
@Ajbadboy252 It's like a seperate disc sorta thing. Like bonus features? It has the original and the acoustic. That's it.
ItsPistashioMan 10 months ago
@Ajbadboy252 dammit cuz i have their discography but i don't have bonus content
Ajbadboy252 10 months ago
@Planbsk8erdude7 i bet your band sucks cocks ;)
dalar48 10 months ago
haha only two dislikes,,, IDIOTS LOL
sdsmith2012 10 months ago
This is incredible ;D
MrMeowchy 10 months ago
@anthonytheshit123 hahaha if you think As I Lay Dying is increment, then you don't know what the fuck increment metal is haha want a link a link to my band?
Planbsk8erdude7 10 months ago
@NakedBellyProduction haha kid this music blows dick, MY band makes better metal than this... literally
Planbsk8erdude7 11 months ago
@Planbsk8erdude7 lmfao OKAY KID i dare u to be better than all that remains haha
Kovy1008 11 months ago
@Planbsk8erdude7 your band blows dick. dude stfu, ATR is lyricly and incrementally better than any bitch band like your will ever be :D
anthonytheshit123 10 months ago 3
Love the solo...All That Remains last two albums have been increadible.
ChadAustinWilliams 11 months ago
I like his voice in this. It's aggressive & moderately melodic at the same time. Just like my pubic hair.
WhatisaTaint 1 year ago 8
Phil sounds a lil weirder acousticly but it's still great
BIgGary1000 1 year ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
This band sucks haha
Planbsk8erdude7 1 year ago
@Planbsk8erdude7 Yeah sk8er dude, YOU OBVIOUSLY KNOW WHAT YOU'RE TALKING ABOUT! Go back to listening to your blink-182 and sucking dick ;)
JayFFAFAlesanaES 1 year ago
@Planbsk8erdude7 You're a douche :)
KoRnescence93 1 year ago
@Planbsk8erdude7 Hahaha, No one likes you cuz you're a fag. :3
NakedBellyProduction 11 months ago
It's February now :D
hackzor09 1 year ago
3 people listened to justin bieber, died of their shock and pushed the dislike button with the head :D
Mariyouable 1 year ago 4
@Mariyouable Actually, they probobly just hit the dislike button cuz they're most likely mentally retarded.
NakedBellyProduction 11 months ago
the acoustic verisons are always as good as the norm
Pamahana97 1 year ago
fuck, this song is just awesome :D
Mariyouable 1 year ago
THEY NEED TO DO MORE ACOUSTIC COVERS!!!!!!! This is Awesome!!!!!!!!!!!!
theyoyoyoyorobert 1 year ago 2
@BelairedBiatchezz
If your a Real band like Metallica, Protest the Hero, Slipknot, Five Finger Death Punch, Pantera, or Disturbed, you dont need to do acoustics because they are pointless and dont sound right
316elite321 1 year ago
@316elite321 That is one of the most stupidest statements I've ever heard. What does being a "Real" band have to do with doing something you love? You have no clue what music is kid.
xLesPaulGibsonx 1 year ago
@316elite321 WHAT almost all of those bands have an acoustic version of one of their songs. STFU before you say something else that stupid
bladeviper66072 1 year ago 3
@316elite321 Ever heard of Darkness by Disturbed or FFDP making an acoustic version of the Bleeding? Hell even Slipknot did Snuff which was awesome and acoustic in most parts. Yeah its acoustic and its fucking epic, so don't go around posting shit that you don't fully understand. Oh and Metallica did a shit ton of their music with an orchestra.
malifor00 7 months ago
this is love. <3
chickaaYEAAH 1 year ago 2
When he says "I know we could've done this together" and goes down in pitch insteead of up, i nearly cream my pants.
RKDproductionss 1 year ago 4
We need to hunt one person down :D
4cellar2door0 1 year ago 31
@4cellar2door0 Make it two people.
masterchiefnarbiter 1 year ago
@4cellar2door0 3!!
6498liltoker 1 year ago
@4cellar2door0 make it 3 now >:O
ragnerock117 1 year ago
@4cellar2door0 oh, make that 1 more
jaybugo 10 months ago
@4cellar2door0 make that two
PivotCooler 10 months ago
@4cellar2door0 Three people's hearts will be forever in our hands, literally. >:D
kerrigor666 7 months ago 3
@kerrigor666 you used "literally" correctly! good job!
Miscorock 7 months ago
@Miscorock Why does that surprise you? And does it warrant patronising?
kerrigor666 6 months ago
@4cellar2door0 3 now let's destroy them
Ryannpwns 5 months ago
FUCKING EPIC!
Gir42069 1 year ago
man it seem like a totally different song
midgety1 1 year ago
this was so amazing it nearly brought a tear to my eye
theepicherbster 1 year ago 3
@theepicherbster :)
hackzor09 1 year ago
@theepicherbster nearly always does for me!
jacksonguitarsrule1 1 year ago
@theepicherbster nearly always does for me!
jacksonguitarsrule1 1 year ago
Comment removed
theepicherbster 1 year ago
Awesome! You're not a REAL band until you do an acoustic song or re-do one as acoustic xD
Belairedbiatchezz 1 year ago
"How I miss February still now that this becomes the moment of all our failures" Best part Imo ( ;
HumiIiation 1 year ago 37
they are awseome just like this video
tictacfanman 1 year ago
wow, my first time hearing this version it's amazing, i can't wait till the 24 atr aild carnifex and unearth hell yeah, check my band on my page have a few rough recordings of iron core, give local music a chance, one of the last times i saw atr phil told me it took him 10 years, i've been at it for 8, keepin my head up thanks phil
societylabeledme 1 year ago 3
in my KIDNEY!
xchehuevox 1 year ago
atr should put a ballad on their next album
Red8Jack 1 year ago 8
@Red8Jack all that remaims is always talking about how they want to go softer, so maybe you'll be in luck with that ballad. but ... i dont really care cuz there music is emotioal already. but that would be interesting, i'd perfer them to just do acoustic versions of hard songs tho.. (:
kiidso0freshh 1 year ago
@Red8Jack haha and they so did, For We Are Many- The Waiting One, its amazing
pabinator 1 year ago
@Red8Jack They did, and it's simply beautiful...
tetrico22 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
so, soooo, amazing:) i get chills everytime i hear it. This version has to be my faviort and this is one of the reasons i love this band cause they can play their things unpluged. Im a Grunge fan but i like this.
dylanshay2006 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
so, soooo, amazing:) i get chills everytime i hear it. This version has to be my faviort and this is one of the reasons i love this band cause they can play their things unpluged. Im a Grunge fan but i like this.
dylanshay2006 1 year ago
so, soooo, amazing:) i get chills everytime i hear it. This version has to be my faviort and this is one of the reasons i love this band cause they can play their things unpluged. Im a Grunge fan but i like this.
dylanshay2006 1 year ago
where can i get this song?
RandomFatKid1 2 years ago
is it bad i like this more than the original?
s0ccurpr0 2 years ago 4
no its not i like this verson i dedicated this to my gf for our 3 year anniversary.
1993MercuryCougarXR7 2 years ago
That's pretty bitchin', man. You picked a good song for it.
Daedalus1776 2 years ago
thanks man
1993MercuryCougarXR7 2 years ago
Aye, you're welcome. This is a great song. :D
Daedalus1776 2 years ago
im learning how to play it on the acoustic hopefully i get good at it
1993MercuryCougarXR7 2 years ago
Takes a lot of time and effort, mate. Best of luck t'ya.
Daedalus1776 2 years ago