Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (295)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • this was so amazing i was crying at the concert

  • i was there

  • aww he sounds so cute ... him singing this song make me wanna cry. :p

  • Asdfghjk

    There's like, no words to describe the amazingness of this preformance.

    Well all right, here's one. AMAZING. Just truly, wonderfully amazing.

    Then I love how they go from a amazing, emotional song like that to BOOM. I'm Not Okay..

  • Asdfghjkl one of the most magical nights of my entire life. I cried so much during this song and just, I didn't know what to do with myself. xD

  • to the three idiots that disliked this: IM GONNA RIP OUT UR HEART OF STONE AND CHUCK IT AT UR FACE!!!!!!!!

  • crying..

  • Man!!! Im kicking myself for not going when they where by me!!! i wish they would redo this song in like this one (slower and all) The song is amazing ether way, i just would like it even more if it was kind of like sing i guess hahah

  • This was one of the best nights of my life.

  • This song is so emotional.... It made me cry :'(

  • i was here for this :D i was at this concert and pretty much cried wen i heard this <3 its so beautiful i love them so much, they just always know how to touch our hearts and no matter how much they change this is still what their message is, to inspire and give us hope and thats why i will always love them

  • God, I wish I could have been there for this. It is so beautiful.

    This broken city sky, like butane on my skin. Stolen from my eyes. Hello angel tell me where are you. Tell me where we go from here.

  • We walk in single file We light our rails And punch our time, ride escalators colder than a cell. These broken city skies, like butane on my skin. Stolen from my eyes. Hello angel, tell me where are you? Simply beautiful

  • Oh Gerard♥ Your so amazing

    Where would I be now without this band and To my Killjoy family we have never met but I love you guys Let's all keep on running and never let them take you alive ♥

  • Beautiful <3

  • I was at the show the day before and on world contamination and they never played this.. i wish i could have seen this live live.

  • im going to fuckin kill u if u disliked this song

  • Such a full circle moment. See guys, it totally worked out, and now here you are singing infront of thousands the first song you ever performed. <3

    Also , I would like to personally disembowel the 3 who disliked this amazing moment.

  • I dont see how someone could dislike this video, its beautiful, amazing, and probably one of the most memorable and historic event of MCR's history.

  • Oh my. This is so emotional. This means so much to me and my dad. Gerard Way, You are the man.

  • i can just say one thing... Amazing

  • My cousin was there. :( Lucky bitch.

  • I cry

    I cry because I know that the black years are done for them

    I cry because I know that they're all happy now

    I cry because this song means much more than just 9/11

    I cry because this was the beginning

    I cry because this could mean the end, but it's the beginning of the end

    I cry because of you people who watch this and know the meaning

    I cry because this song is beautiful

    I cry because even though it has been seven years since they played it...

    ... they still know every chord to it.

  • @BeatrizMartinezE These aren't the same chords from the original song so..

  • i just only cry

  • I feel special because i was there

  • wow..... they came to my town on 9/10..... they didnt play play this :(

  • It was awesome there..

  • I would have liked to be there... *o* Just perfect. *crying*

  • My god. The emotion in his voice just... reverberates. :') I envy anyone who was here... that was just beautiful. <3

  • Oh my , even his words in the beginning are emotional :'(

  • I am honored. I was there and this was the first time I saw them live. Made my life for real. <3

  • this is so beautiful!!!! it gets stuck in my head all the time. Gee you're so Geemazing (see what i did there? lol) <3 i envy whoever was there.... where was this? so i'm writing this personal narrative and its about how MCR saved my life :) MCRmy for eternity <3

  • @MCRandBVBfanfreak796 This was at DTE Energy Theatre in Michigan. (:

  • i saw all the comments about crying before he started singing and i was like. heh. could be emotional...didnt. know..i would cry too. holy fuck... brings me back to 2002 when i was 9 first hearing mcr. Headfirst For Halos. my life has changed and has been inspired by them completely. i have a vid on my channel for the first experience mcr contest. im cant stop crying

  • This is the most beautiful thing.

  • I'm crying.

  • so fuckin amazing...can't stop crying <3 mcr is so much more than just a band,they're inspiration,love,fun,and just FUCKIN AMAZING!!! <33<33 :33

  • if all they wanted to do is inspire people they've been doing it right for the past ten years i'm a guy and i just FUCKING LOVE MY CHEMICAL ROMANCE! They really are an inspiration in my life :')

  • tears :'3

  • Comment removed

  • Rare shit right here man.

  • OMG crying so hard.... thank you so much for filming this!!!! Ihope they play this at they're show in vegas!!

  • I WAS HERE, HOLY SHIT I WAS HERE. it was awesome.

  • Who the fuck would dislike this beautiful performance?

  • I was @ This Concert....and as this song ended i was balling my eyes out!! the made it a awesome concert!!! both bands together made it a aweosme day!!

  • This was so amazing live :'D~<3. I'm so lucky I was there, and I love MCR c:.

  • this is too beautiful.. i love my chemical romance forever. no any other single bands outside can sing like this!!

  • oh god, this made me cry so hard:') r.i.p. all those people who died on 9/11, finally a band with amazing & beautiful music that gives a damn about something other than making money. <3

  • I was crying so hard. I was way out on the grass and I thought that since I was so far I wouldn't have fun, but like.. This was amazing.

  • crying.

  • i cried for the first time in years i miss you vinny

  • i cried for the first time in years

  • I'm thankful you got this, @CQuard . I was there and it makes me tear up every time I listen to it.

  • I am so fucking glad this is such a good recording. The song moves me normally. .. but that. .. that's such a ... an impossible thing to discribe. And for them to play this.. . Oh It pulls my heartstrings. I remember sitting and watching the towers fall at home after school, and though I'm brittish, I still think about all them people who were affected. In or outside, directly and indirectly. This was such a move. And this is why I love them so much.

  • Thank you so much ! 

  • Shivers down my spine...

  • @jamieleexo You're right. I mean, I wasn't at the show, but even when I just listen to the vid, I can see that everyone is/was calm.

    I won't imagine how hard it must have been for Gerard to sing this song again...

    And yeah, I'm sorry for my creepy english ^-^

  • that.

    was.

    beautiful.

    thanks so much for recording this.

    Im finding it hard to hold back the tears.

    Anyone else?.

  • All I can say through the tears is:

    BEAUTIFUL.

    and Heartbreaking...<3

  • thanks for the upload of this amazing vid

    ♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥­♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥ to MCR and to all the Killjoys all over the world ♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥­♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥

  • I can't seem to explain completely my reaction when I heard this.

    My breathing got heavier, I got goose bumps, my eyes went all watery... THIS IS BEAUTIFUL! Gerard got so into it... and when he said "This broken city sky.." a tear almost rolls down my cheek. Thank you so very much for recording this.<3

  • gerard's voice is so beautifully haunting singing this.

  • ba sério que isso mcr , mcr de antés era beeeeeeeeeeeeeeeem melhor!

  • why are people talking!!!!! PEOPLE NEED TO SHUT IT, for 2 reasons 1. respect for what gerard is trying to portray in this song 2. because they never fucking play bullets songs

  • This broken city sky says it all

  • Gerard's Jersey accent has gotten way stronger xD

  • I totally did not expect this to be as beautiful as it turned out, I first heard the couple seconds and was like "This is okay I guess..." but as soon as Gerard got into it, it turned into the most beautiful thing I ever heard and brought tears to my eyes. <3

    I love you MCR

    Thank you for 10 amazing years and many more to come

    You have touched many lives including mine <3

  • that was just beautiful!

  • You Killjoys Rock!! I love you all We are one giant family all around the world.

  • This is truly amazing, thanks so much for uploading it for all of us who couldn't be there. I have so much love for this band and all you Killjoys out there!

  • I Cried So Hard When I Watched This

  • I Cried So Hard When I Watched This

  • Sitting with tears in my eyes.. and I'm not usually the crying kind of type.. This song just touch something inside me (I can't explain what)

    Love My Chem and I love all you Killjoys out there!

    Peace n' Love <3

  • this is beautiful. just beautiful. :')

  • i'm crying...

  • Crying.

  • I was listening to this with my head on my desk, in what you might think of as an emotional silence. This version is so beautiful.

  • This is the definition of "Beautiful".

  • thank you so much. Part of the reason i got into MCR is because of this song. It means a lot to me and many others that everyone in the MCRmy and all the Killjoys can stand together and remember. I am glad to consider myself a part of this group.

  • oh my god. this is the most beautiful thing i have ever heard. this is so emotional and raw, i'm so glad they played it differently. <3 :')

  • 2:15 always gets me

  • @iceygreens Same here.

  • Oh my god, i almost cride looking around at this :(

    I was there. I took a video, yours is so much beter thoug

  • i was here, i was soo amazed at the sights of the phones it was crazy

    

  • I was here!!! it was an awesome concert and I remember this and it was beautiful

  • spinetingling... absolutly amazing!!!

  • "that's all we ever wanted do. To inspire somebody to be who they want to be" ...and people dare to ask why I love this band. Thanks Gerard for being our angel for all of these years. <3

  • I cry every time I watch this. Thank you to the person who recorded this wonderful experience.

  • @MCRmyRiverside It was really emotional, in all honestly, I was struck silent by it. Could hardly believe it was happening! And you're very welcome, I'm glad to have brought my Canon to capture the moment for all you Killjoys. (:

  • @GQuard From one killjoy to another: Thank you for that, you're great.

  • @MCRmyRiverside Aww (((HUGS))) I cry at this song too :'')

  • I was front row, center for this show. Hearing "Skylines" was amazing!!! LOVE MCR!!

  • This is beautiful :')

  • i don't even listen to this band but that was a great move. 

  • People wonder why I am in love with this band, and the people in it.. I show them this. I love you, Gerard, Mikey, Frankie, Ray (and Bob).

  • Beautiful <3

  • I love that man so fucking much.

  • goosebumps

    

  • Loved it

  • this is completely beautiful, there are tears

  • <3

  • crying.

  • You're not in this alone let me break this awkward silence Let me go, go on record Be the first to say I'm sorry, hear me out And if you take me down or would you lay me out And if the world needs something better let's give them one more reason We walk in single file We light our rails And punch our time Ride escalators colder than a cell This broken city sky like butane on my skin Stolen from my eyes hello Angel Tell me where are you tell me where we go from here
  • absolutely beautiful. i almost cried :')))

  • there are tears.

  • that was one of the most beautiful performances i've ever seen in my entire life. they are amazing.

  • I'm so glad that they played that song.

  • I was there and even though I was way in the back I was able to see it all pretty well. This almost brought me to tears when I heard it and i'm so glad I got to hear it live :') So beautiful

  • So raw. Absolutely gorgeous.

  • The tears. The fucking tears. This is so beautiful.

  • I listened to this song all day yesterday

    its amazing

    I'll love MCR forever.

  • I was Third row at this concert, I LOVED how this song was played. Was an awesome show, and This arrangement and dedication of this song was awesome.

    and great quality!

  • I was Third row at this concert, I LOVED how this song was played. Was an awesome show, and This arrangement and dedication of this song was awesome.

  • This band is legendary.

  • Wish I could have been there but living in the UK, I don't get many chances to see MCR and I love every thing they have done. Saw them in Feb this year and thought they were fantastic.

  • The first time in seven years?!?!?!?!?!/1/1 woah o.o

  • I cried :')

  • I think I was right behind whoever filmed this... Love this!! So glad I was able to see it!!!

  • I WAS THERE I SAW THIS LIVE :D its so beautiful MCR is just amazing and they are so inspiring i dont know what the world would do without them <3

  • thanks so much for recording this, means a lot

  • Every bad thing that happens has a good consequence. That's the balance of our lives. It's the only thing that keeps us going.

    9/11 created MCR, and they've kept me going.

  • OH COME ON I WAS AT THE INDIANA SHOW AND I LIVE IN DETROIT! I should have argued with my parents more about this...

  • @theworldinblack ...What Indiana show? *is from southern IN*

  • I was there. best moment in my life.

    great things come from tragedy like mcr.<3

  • I saw them the day before this in Indy... They were absolutely amazing but I wish they would have preformed this then too... Beautiful <3 <3 <3

  • I saw the rude comment made by @Mr666buckethead and it's been promptly deleted, I want no fights or negativity on this video, seeing how much it means to me and other fans.

    Just thought I'd let you all know. Thanks to the fans who handled that comment maturely, I'll be keeping an eye out.

  • its sorta sad that not many of the people in the audience are singing along

    :(

    but still the newly joining fans probably dont know the lyrics

    well i cant say much i have every CD except for Bullets, So i wouldnt know the lyrics either

  • @SuperSidewalkChalk I was there. I think most the reason people werent singing it was just...because everyone was like in shock. It was beautiful. Like, i started to sing, and i felt wrong in doing so. It was a song that only made sense if he was the only one singing it.

  • There's no reason to be afraid anymore. We live in a derailed world, but for better or worse, that makes this a world without rules. So there's no excuses anymore to not be yourself and do whatever you want. That's what I get from this video.

  • ouch my heart. thank you for everything, i mean this more than words could ever say, thank you.

  • @Mr666buckethead

    Even if you don't like the band you shouldn't write it on THIS video. This is a sensitive topic and time for the band and for most people its just insulting.

  • wtf is katy perry doing on the recommendations!?

  • i wish i could have gone!!

  • I'm pretty sure that just made my life.

  • @Mr666buckethead Oh dear. My friend, I think you'd better stick to your MLP episodes.

  • Beautiful.

  • cryingggg

  • THIS. IS. AMAZING. <3

  • @Mr666buckethead lol Fail Troll.

  • @Mr666buckethead Congratulations! Would you like a medal? Douche

  • This is so beautiful, this is so perfect., oh my god, this is just wonderful.

  • you were the person standing directly infront of me..... AWESOME! :)

  • Why was I not there.?

    Curse me being across the country.

    I really hope they play this in October.

  • how special that must be for him to be singing that, on the day it all began....

  • I am in tears

  • It's so amazing they could come so far. They wrote that song ten years ago, with no idea how successful they'd be. Just imagine how they're feeling while playing that song now.

  • HOLY SHIT!

  • OMG! im crying this is just fucking beautiful! <3 <3

  • I don't have words to describe how beautiful this is.

  • omg!! this is just so freaking beautiful version! I'm dying! My god!!!

  • Oh my Gee....I wish I was there, if I lived there. :P This is such a great performance! #ThankYouMCR

  • He has just a beautiful voice I'm crying

  • This is beautiful in so many ways. I love this band so much, and everyday i realize how much they mean to me and how big of an influence they are on my life. I seriously don't know what and where i would be without them. They didn't safe my life, but they changed it in so many positive ways. This amazing performance makes me cry <3

  • I knew he would sing this song.

  • THIS IS SO BEAUTIFUL!!!!!!!!!!!! sakjdsjkahd I can't even...

  • This is so beautiul, who else cried? oh im so emotional. <3

  • Oh my god oh my god oh my god take me there.

  • This is beautiful. I loved Gerard's voice in it. Thank you so much.

  • I NEED THE DOWNLOAD LINK. NOW. PLEASE. OMG I DIED.

  • Beautiful.

  • I was at this concert. It was so beautiful. <3

  • Wow, this was amazing. I love how Gerard's voice sounded so raw while he sang. Thanks for posting it!

  • Its hard to believe that something as terrible as 9/11 could end up creating one of the most brilliant bands today.

  • Just started crying.

  • I literally just got teary.

    This is why i love them.

  • Where was this concert?

  • @SmileyPeaceGURL Detroit, MI

  • @GQuard Actually, it's in Clarkston. People just assume that Pine Knob (now known as the DTE Energy Music Theatre) is in Detroit.

  • @GQuard Actually, it's in Clarkston. People just assume that Pine Knob (now known as the DTE Energy Music Theatre) is in Detroit.