You need to get backup singers that can find their voices. The blond is no where in key. I thought I would never say an unkind word about the BG'S music. It is a great song; however.
I adore Robins voice, but this song is just not suitable for him, thats what made the Bee Gees so unique, different vocals for different songs, I happen to think they got it just right too. I would not choose either voice as my favourite, I like them both.
Of course, but Robin must sing some of Barry's song because his career doesn't have many hit dance numbers.;)
If you listen closely Robin's vocal on this is alright, there's no other way he could sing that, remember the original had a lot of echo; go to his website and he's got great new live versions of Holiday and New York Mining Disaster from after this concert that you'll like.
robin's fan you all love his choking voice just cause he is a bee gee how pathetic are you.. bee gee with out barry is no bee gee you barry haters.. lol robin should stick to back up and let barry show how these songs should be perform with the real lead singer.... eat your heart out fans of robin lol
@hunters11111 Has it occured to you that this is Robin's way of dealing with the loss of his twin. Barry responded by retreating from Bee Gee's and took years to deal with it all. He has been more reclusive, Robin has had to keep going, keep working. I'll bet Robin would rather have done this with Barry than alone.
Sounded very good to me, I want to punch the backing singers in the face and some of the band, but Robin sounds perfect.
If you look at his performances around December-now, he sounds brilliant, even Night Fever sounds good, check his website for 2 January 08 performance, and they are great.
Thanks for uploading and record this video for us to share....Robin sing this song is better than sing Night Fever and Stayin Alive....In my opinion, Robin shouldn't sing Night Fever & Stayin Alive...It's the worse song if him! You guys should watch him singing that on Miss World 2006! Like a Bee Gees faker!
This is SO recent!! How can I get a schudle of his tour dates? His website isn't up & running yet..If anyone knows; please respond to my Playlist........
This has been flagged as spam show
Great song and video and thanks for posting this and love the song.
PamelaRP 9 months ago
Great song and video and thanks for posting this and love the song.
PamelaRP 9 months ago
Great song and video and thanks for posting this and love the song.
PamelaRP 9 months ago
Dearest Robin
You need to get backup singers that can find their voices. The blond is no where in key. I thought I would never say an unkind word about the BG'S music. It is a great song; however.
Luv you no matter!!!!
bushmuffin 9 months ago
I adore Robins voice, but this song is just not suitable for him, thats what made the Bee Gees so unique, different vocals for different songs, I happen to think they got it just right too. I would not choose either voice as my favourite, I like them both.
slugman2000 1 year ago
I agree Robin sound fine - it the backup singers who is messing the song up plus Robin can sing any song he want to cause he a part of The Bee Gees
rob4everbg 2 years ago
Greetings from LT! This 2009 year, is the Lithuanian name millennium.Copy & Paste this because this event is very important to Lithuania. ;)
Whitebear989 2 years ago
get the backround singers out lets hear more robin
Iloverobingibb4eva 3 years ago
I generally really like Robin Gibb, but somehow I think this song was perfect for Barry's voice, and not for Robin's.
Emmalala123 3 years ago 4
oh my god this is terrible. sorry Robin some songs like juliet are yours and some are Barry's and this is definitely a Barry song.
pipes1919 3 years ago 3
Of course, but Robin must sing some of Barry's song because his career doesn't have many hit dance numbers.;)
If you listen closely Robin's vocal on this is alright, there's no other way he could sing that, remember the original had a lot of echo; go to his website and he's got great new live versions of Holiday and New York Mining Disaster from after this concert that you'll like.
I do.:D
LukeShoveller 3 years ago
robin's fan you all love his choking voice just cause he is a bee gee how pathetic are you.. bee gee with out barry is no bee gee you barry haters.. lol robin should stick to back up and let barry show how these songs should be perform with the real lead singer.... eat your heart out fans of robin lol
hunters11111 3 years ago 2
@hunters11111 Has it occured to you that this is Robin's way of dealing with the loss of his twin. Barry responded by retreating from Bee Gee's and took years to deal with it all. He has been more reclusive, Robin has had to keep going, keep working. I'll bet Robin would rather have done this with Barry than alone.
emmyjo720 1 year ago 2
Robin Gibb Sounds fantastic. the back singers destroyed the song
dehtour 3 years ago
Sounded very good to me, I want to punch the backing singers in the face and some of the band, but Robin sounds perfect.
If you look at his performances around December-now, he sounds brilliant, even Night Fever sounds good, check his website for 2 January 08 performance, and they are great.
LukeShoveller 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
it just sounds like he couldn't wait to get out of there terrible
davewoodywood 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Terrible! He needs to team up with Barry again.
minoozola 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
That's a bloody AWFUL version.........embarrassing to watch, and he himself seems to realise it's falling flat.
foneill9 3 years ago
good!!!
Dalman4 4 years ago 2
Great job mr Gibb. I really like this song and you are still good!
ballongen100 4 years ago 8
I agree KensY it's like if Barry started singing "I started a joke" or "for whom the bell tolls" it wouldn't sound right.
gameshowfreak2007 4 years ago
good job robin
kuuipo03 4 years ago
Thanks for uploading and record this video for us to share....Robin sing this song is better than sing Night Fever and Stayin Alive....In my opinion, Robin shouldn't sing Night Fever & Stayin Alive...It's the worse song if him! You guys should watch him singing that on Miss World 2006! Like a Bee Gees faker!
Thanks anyway, shebalin! We love it very much!
KensY 4 years ago
This is SO recent!! How can I get a schudle of his tour dates? His website isn't up & running yet..If anyone knows; please respond to my Playlist........
DUPONT24JJ48 4 years ago 2
WOW WOW WOW WOW...thanks SO much for sharing these great videos of Rob's show in Russia!!!!!!!
Gibb embraces
Claudia
beegeeschile 4 years ago 2