Added: 4 years ago
From: u2discotheque
Views: 181,863
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (169)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • Great !!!

  • Pop is called underrated only because it was poorly promoted, otherwise it would be up there, a masterpiece aswell. As for this version of Please...just amazing

  • somebody tab this version!!

  • The electric version shits all over this

  • Post 9/11 shows. Very emotional time.

  • I've been addicted to this song for the past few days, and now Osama bin Laden is dead! Hooray! Bono must be pleased too!

  • its the heaven you keep you stow not stole

  • WAR and the Unforgetable fire the best albums for me!

  • The clicking noise is what either Bono or The Edge are hearing in their in ear monitors, it gives them a tempo to play to, it is used by all live bands these days,when people make recordings like this from live concerts they tap into the in ear monitor channels and record them instead. Thats why the sound quality is so good. I hope that answers the qustions about the clicking sounds!!!!

  • Comment removed

  • no one can say bono's not a christian after this :)

  • AMEN!:)

  • che bella cristo santoooooooo

  • What is that godawful clicking in the background?

  • @Caladolen I guess some guy added this sound to the audio recording, then put the audio on top of the video.. Its awful indeed

  • @Caladolen That's the Metro Gnome.

  • great song, much deeper than sunday b sunday. classic tune.

  • It's good but Popmart version is better

  • This acoustic live song is  Absolutely Fabulous!!!! but the live performence in the kuip in rotterdam 1997 is better!!

    greetings from a u2 fan;-)

  • Why are they using a click track on this purely acoustic version? I think a few tempo changes here and there could add more authenticity to the unplugged nature of this version.

  • i love U2, ive been obsessed with them for like most my life... but sometimes the god talk makes me feel uncomfortable.

  • @ThisIsDJJD I totally agree

  • @ThisIsDJJD amen brother, im exactly the same, got hooked on them when i heard when love comes to town, 23 years later, not much has changed, they are still heads and shoulders above the rest....

    that said, excessive bono talk distracts focus from the greatest gift,,,,,their music...

  • IF WE TALK ABOUT THE INSTRUMENTAL TECHNIQUE IS SURE THAT THERE ARE A LOT OF ROCK BAND THAT GIVE MUCH MORE THAN U2.

    BUT BONO IS A POET,HIS WORDS AND LYRICS ARE REALLY IMPRESSIVE , AND TOUCH ME INSIDE THE HEART AND SOUL MAKING ME TO MOVE.

    HE MAKES ME TO INTEREST TO MANY THEMES SUCH AS GOD,SUFFERING OF PEOPLE, WARS,POLITICS, LOVE AND FRIENDSHIP.

    ALL ARGUMENTS THAT IT DISPLEASES TO ME TO SAY THAT WE UNDERRATE AT TODAY

  • There's a "click" in the edge's hears....

  • this is the best live version of please that they ever are going to play

  • this is the best version of please ever played :D

  • What amazing acoustic version of please i've never heard it that way thanks for the video!!!

  • Please is an amazing song, really deep., Much better song about N Ireland's troubles than Sunday Bloody Sunday

  • theres no religion - theres only people who wanna believe there is

  • I'm absolutely fed up about Bono's religion. How I wish he would leave our minds in peace!

    They are the very best pop/rock group worlwide, but god fanatics, and laicism is the only way to find peace on earth any day, somebody should tell him about it.

  • why does he have to ruin this song with religious drivel and propaganda. the catholic mindset is what's evil. I still love U2 as musicians and I'll let this song mean what it means to me. This is their best album...for sure.

  • @cheworks The Catholic mindset isn't what's "evil" if anything is evil it's the religous mindset! Without religion we wouldn't have all these wars!

  • Catholicism is a religion, right? So I guess you agree with me. I loved Sinead tearing up the pope's pic. And Bono's respect is waning as U2 turns into religious rock. let him keep his evil-loving views to himself.

  • @cheworks Yes, Catholicisism is religion, but you sounded like catholisicm, was the evil thing, not religion! And catholicism is not more evil than any other religion...

  • @TokRa1224 agreed. so bono is spewing evil.

  • @TokRa1224

    It is right that many wars are released by religion, but it is the warfare of men who only call upon the name of God. God is love and not Hate!

  • @TokRa1224

    John 3,16: For God so loved the world that he gave his one and only Son, that whoever believes in him shall not perish but have eternal life.

    Matthew 28,19: Therefore go and make disciples of all nations,...!

    Jesus did not say: Go and kill all nations who do not believe what you believe in!

    The grace of god is for every tribe and nation!

  • @

    wrightherewrightnow9

    I agree with you! Pop is my favourite U2 album, and I think the songs are truly terrific! It's an underrated masterpiece.

  • Love this song but never heard it acoustic before...brilliant!! Cheers for postin it :)

    Bono ad-libs alot live but think I heard "Show me a sign" too.

  • I love these guys ... the band U2 and Dog Savanna are the bands that I like to hear! Viva Rock!

  • guys, your help again to figure out what does he say at 5:37, goes like "please, please... ????" ... appreciate any help, thank you

  • What I hear is show me a sign

  • you nailed it! thanks... I was hearing "sad" there.. no sense at all, thank you

  • i think he says "Show me the sound"

  • this song is just as powerful as sunday bloody sunday!!!

  • Impresionante. Siempre me ha gustado este tema. Thank you very much indeed.

  • Pop was underrated. The lyrics of "Please" are truly extraordinary.

    "You never knew, that the Heaven you'd keep, you stole...your holy war, your Northern Star, your Sermon on the Mount from the boot of your car".

    It just goes to show the standards they set themselves that songs like this weren't considered good enough!

  • @wrightherewrightnow9 thats so true. i think of please as the extension to Sunday Bloody Sunday

  • @wrightherewrightnow9 , well i think PoP was not underrated it is not a great album just like zooropa i think those albums of you to are personally form me the 2 worsed albums of u2 but they are so good they always manage to produce great songs also on these albums like Please and Staring at the sun great songs

    and on Zooropa Stay they just the best!!!

  • @wrightherewrightnow9 I agree. Pop was the last album that i truly like, from U2. Since then, i dislike. :)

  • @ornatosvioleta ditto. i love Pop only like the ones after that.

  • @wrightherewrightnow9 : I agree !

  • Que alguien lo traduzca!!

  • God is not Hate sooo true....

  • could somebody please help try to figure out what does he say at 1:44?

  • I think: "Do you know, I'm kind of one of those kind of people too. Honestly, shrinking God all the time."

  • U2 GRANDES!!!

  • Bono is just great with his vois here .... and not only here. Edge is great too. His guitar here is magnificent.... Love this version !! Love U2 !!

  • Awsome version .

  • Love this song. This version, not so much. The best part of this song is Adam's bass line, and it's really missing there.

  • totally agree. The bass drives this track, and its kinda naked without it

  • great version :-) wish to be there

    Thanks for sharing

  • we say we want change but seldom look with-in to find our unlimited potential to create or re-create love, to see that 'we are the one's the world is waiting for', we are the ones' we are looking for, we are the ones the world needs.

  • this song make me crazy, it's so nice, mysterious, wonderful best song from the album.

  • Lovely!!!

  • Comment removed

  • Seems like there will not be any POP TRACKS on the 360 Tour.. Shame... I love POP one of my favorite albums.

  • They are not even halfway on this leg,

    And they are going to do one after this,

    have patience , they throw in more songs after they feel good with the one's they play already

  • I have patience :) ... I just wish that POP would get more respect. I know they throw in more songs halfway into the tour or change them up but it seems like its always the 80s songs that make it into the setlists later. Example. New Years Day for Wild Horses

  • Yes thats true, I would love Pop getting more attention, its one of my favorite albums, Mofo, Thrill me, Please ,Discotheque, thogether with zooropa= awesomeness. I pray with you, that they throw in some pop. It would be cool if they did it from the start, I'm sorry if I came over negative :)

  • @ColorsBright Yes, my second fav after Josuha tree!

  • fantastic

  • What is edge playing here???

  • Riff of personal jesus by depeche mode:)

  • the worlds greatest rock band

  • God bless the person who posted this. Thank you.

  • You know some people read dates in the correct order.

  • Amazing... Thanks for uploading this. Surprisingly good quality!

  • GOD is LOVE

  • oh shiii

  • really? Three thumbs down...unknowable, unifiable??? If you only knew....

  • The best live performance of Please..how can you disagree with him?

  • Beautiful song.. And I totally agree. Jesus is Love.

  • u2, the best

  • that's good but the electric version (popmart tour version) is better I think

  • ez nagyon nagy!!!!

  • which you my love i could never believe. really. please. my ultimate facination with U2 is their ability to perfectly simply what it is to exist and what is real. if i could find a way to say what they say the way they it...

    I hope we all agree?

  • One of my all time favorite U2 songs... I can never listen to it once, I have to listen to it over and over.

  • BEATFUL SONG

  • i remember them playing this at the last Concert on that tour in NYC after September 11th, it was absolutly freaking incredible. They had the whole crown in tears.

  • they should not play this version, but the version they played in rotterdam 1997! that's really a powerful song!

    (i love the song trio of that concert; Miami, Bullet and then Please)

  • Great song with many hidden messages

  • You might be one of those people...

  • god is love¡¡¡¡¡

  • Awesome song. U2 has always been awesome. Beautiful speech too...

  • u2 please 2009 HUNGARY

  • u2 please 2009 HUNGARY

  • And by the way in Poland too!

  • Magnifique chanson méconnue...

    Issue d'un album qui n'a pas eu le succès qu'il méritait.

  • This is so ridiculously fantastic. They are an amazing band that has influenced almost every modern rock band in one way or another.

  • This is a real find! Thanks for this!

  • The version is great.

    I've done a cover using this arrangement as a model! Please Check it out!

  • what-a-performance!!!! just incredible thanks!!!

  • Very very nice, but the original album version is by far one of the best U2 productions ever.

  • this song is cool, but Bono just talks too much sometimes..

  • Singing is really "sustained speech," so bono is talking anyways through his music. its A.D.D. retards like you guys who are too obtuse and cant get his message and he has to be more clear cut with what he has to say. its important to him.

    hes giving u great music, at least have the decency to listen to what he has to say, hes got some good words and deep thoughts-- it might enrich your vapid life.

  • haha sweet comeback tuuk.

    you must annoy the hell out of the people around you

  • good not agree more

  • j love u2( j saw 14 gigs the first one in 1985) and j love this song...but j'm atheist,yes j believe in love but j don't believe in any kind of religion!love is not a religion's privilege!

  • fantastique!

  • I'm sorry 'bout that..

  • what is the name of this song?

  • Maybe,and I say MAYBE,I supposed this song(but I'm not sure about it.....)is called "Please"....LOL.

    I'm simply joking,so don't get me wrong!!!

    PEACE 3ever and...

    U2 are amazing.....unbeliavable.....

  • This song would go great with Love And Peace. Please has the lyric "get up off your knees" and Love And Peace has the whole "I'm not easy on my knees" lyric.

  • I think this is the last performance of Please they did thus far.

  • undescribable beautiful and true...my heroes 4 ever and always...

  • WISŁOKA DĘBICA

     POLISH

  • This is nice! Havnt seen or heard it b4.

  • Really dig the video. I like the song acoustic, makes me wnt to playt it. On the album, it's all drums> liked what bono said about Jesus, and man making him in his image--small

  • Bible bashers, the tiny, pathetic hate mongers he's talking about are the likes of YOU. Take your sin and hate and go away.

  • thats heavy.

  • Woah.never heard this version before.

  • fala mais do que o reginaldo rossi  ¬¬

  • Without the wrath of God We could not truly know how much God loves us.

    God hates sin. Humans are born with sin. We are his enemies. But He loves us and has died and Risen for our sins. So that some of us could be renewed and come to know him and live with him forever.

    Now loving your Friends is one thing. Everybody does it. But Loving your Enemies aswell thats true love. Jesus is Truly Divine Love.

  • "And let none of you imagine evil in your hearts against his neighbor; and love no false oath for all these are things I HATE, saith the Lord." Zechariah 8:17

    God does hate, he hates sin.

  • Hate the sin, love the sinner.

  • how have i never seen this before. That was just amazing. I have to learn tht one. you can kinda make out the power chords edge uses. Just an amazing version of the song.

  • Da pelle d'oca!

  • Very nice song.

    Also a very good quality

  • I too would like to know how you play this song. It is gorgeous.

  • does anyone have the tab for this...or any clues on how to play it

    my band wants to play it live on acoustic...

    cheers everyone

  • This is absolutley amazing. Never heard this before. By far the best version of this song I've ever heard. Unreal!

  • great speech, and also great song. i never realy liked this song, but when i saw this live performance i just had to change my mind, i just love it and always will! you're doing a great job! go on!

  • boje19,

    I never really liked this song before either, now I love it, and Bono's speech was so amazing it made me tear up, and I don't really cry that easy, except U2 can bring me to my knees where the tears are streaming down my face, and it's mostly only u2 that can do this. Except the Bob Seager song "The Famous Final Scene."

    God Bless,

    Robyn

  • U don't have 2 b on ur knees, U2 is rite!!!

  • SWEET ASS SONG!

  • Really beaultiful and strong movie. We can stop and think about ...

  • Wow I cried the first time I heard this version...absolutely to die for. From Edge's gutiar to Bono's wailing and his little speech...how can these guys be so amazing?

  • quanto è bella così please! Mai sentita! grandi u2

  • poesia

  • THANKS!!!

  • This version is soooo unique... Very similar to the acoustic version of Ground Beneath Her Feet - Exact Same Feel, PERFECTion. On Your knees people.

  • Guy check his watch at 3.15 :O

  • Very very good acoustic performance....although the electric version is really fucking amazing!

  • I guess you need to use profanity to get your point across. It's very inappropriate for this song.

    God Bless, Robyn

  • I missed the profanity, and generally would agree, but it is their song, and the appropriatness of their expression is up to them.

    God Bless you also.

    leslie

  • bonovox510,

    I'm not talking about U2's profanity. I was talking about the comment Vlaco84's comment, about it being f*****g amazing. U2 would never use profanity in this song, now would they?

  • *great version

  • freat version.i never thought that `please`can be played wit an acoustic guitar.sounds really good.

  • Pretty good, not their greatest acoustic moment but it's a good song. I kinda miss the high bit at the end!

  • very very good.

  • i love this song......

  • Me too!! And I think Bono has a lot of guts to talk that openly about Jesus, because there will only be PEACE ON EARTH after Jesus comes back to bring his believers home, and throws Satan into the pit of hell, then there will be PEACE ON EARTH for the rest of eternity. Like the Good Book says, a perfect Heaven, and a perfect Earth. I can't wait. Not only will I meet God, but the boys too(:. God Bless, Robyn

  • Freak :)

  • amen brother.......

  • ur Pathetic

  • pOpmart

    No, you are a very sad person, that have to knock other peoples beliefs. Ever hear of coexist.

  • Very nice!!!

Loading...
Alert icon
0 / 00Unsaved Playlist Return to active list
    1. Your queue is empty. Add videos to your queue using this button:
      or sign in to load a different list.
    Loading...Loading...Saving...