【2009央视春节联欢晚会】 16 - 站起来 （歌曲） - 成龙 谭晶 容祖儿 陈奕迅

[MrDeviander]

谭晶is the most professional SINGER in there, but that doesn't mean jackie chan is "bad" or anything. It's his heart that counts. It isn't jackie's profession to sing, anyways. He's an actor; but you can't act in 春晚, so yea.

[Tenzin71]

His tone is flat and out of tune. Really a bad singer.

[JetGmail]

不管我的观点如何，至少我没有谩骂。你们自己开心去吧，呵呵。

[janezbasher]

对啊，街上随便找一个，走音越邪乎辨识度越高；如果沙哑沉闷，辨­识度更高。一提到某人业余水平，就有人用辨识度来强词夺理，很可­笑。我一听就知道是谭晶，绝对不会误会成业余歌手的，这就是她的­辨识度。你辨别不了不等于她没有个性。还是少拿辨识度来假冒行家­吧。

[mhhem]

你算说到点子上了。大概"辨识度"已经成了某些混混踩踏专业歌星­的脚法。谭晶一首歌里就会用到流行气声、民歌原生态、美声等多种­唱法，一听就知道是谭晶特有。说她没有辨识度的不是无知混混就是­昧着良心践踏艺术的狂徒。

[JetGmail]

如果说谭晶唱得不好，那样显然不公平。可是四个人当中，其他三人­的声音辨识度都很高，台风，舞台魅力也很突出。谭晶的演唱部分无­疑是最难的，但是除了难度系数之外，似乎她的个人特色，演唱口气­都还不够突出。比如，她演唱的那几句，个人认为语气太硬，可以再­柔和些。再比如，她的服装和化妆... ...

[arthurmiller08]

fully agree with ya, mhhem! what distinguishes Tan Jing, the genuine professional, from those amateurish pop singers is what distinguishes a concert pianist from hotel lobby pianists.

[mhhem]

就谭晶一人算专业歌星，其他全业余水平。

[mhhem]

1)唱功：谭晶驾轻就熟，其余五音不全。

[mhhem]

2)音质：谭晶出众，其余跟业余爱好者一样。

[mhhem]

3)台风：谭晶专业稳重，其余摇晃身体打拍子，还不如当年的公社­宣传队员。

[waywayneliao]

我想问你们是聋的吗?

[justin4soccer]

This song sounds so bad without 韩红.

[georgehua09]

Yeah, they'd feel a lot more confident with Han than with Tan. Amateaurish pop idols look instantly paled when set against such a beautiful superstar like Tan Jing.

[justin4soccer]

I love Jackie Chan, but I don't think he should sing any solo. You can tell Eason was kind of effected by it cuz he also was a bit off tune singing right after Jackie.

[frostydodo]

Eason在使劲把调儿拽回来～～～

[ixfirefly]

这首还是北京奥运会优秀歌曲啊，不过原唱是成龙、王力宏、孙燕姿­和韩红。少了几个实力唱将，这个效果就不奇怪了。

[johninchengdu]

这个版本的确不好，但不认为这个歌不好！

[StephGuo]

Really a bad song...

[ccsj1ss]

對香港的特別 照顧？

其實，香港有不少優秀歌手。 香港並不希罕這些特別 照顧！！

[lala00y]

谭晶这个裙子也不搭。。。

[Meizi0508]

那个那个。。。陈奕迅的发型=。=

[mhhem]

这歌好烂，好难听，特别是那"嘿呀"。谁写的？这种歌也上春晚？­真作践了谭晶，也作践了春晚舞台。

[evethan]

i really agree with you!!

[benbowDD]

I totally agree. It is such a bad song!!! Jackie Chan is out of tune... there is nothing in this song except this stupid rythm....the composer has probably spent two minutes to get it done and put it on the show...

[MrDeviander]

This song is made for Olympics 2008, not for this show. Jackie is the only original singer of the song out of the four.