WOW WOW WOW !!! IS IT A MOVIE MADE BY PAKISTANI ? EVERY MUZLIM IN HINDUSTAN SHOULD WATCH THIS MOVIE ..AND DECIDE OF THEIR STATE IN HINDUSTAN AS COMPARED TO THEIR COUNTERPARTS IN PAKI ! JAI HIND !!!
Looking at the state of Pakistan now and especially after watching this movie, I feel our elders have failed us. When these extremists were spreading hate in the name of religion and Zia's armies were taking many of the youngsters away, why on earth weren't they trying to protect their generations from such deliberate hatred and misrepresentation of their religion. Why did they stay silent so now their next generations are suffering. Hopefully we wont fail our next generations and do something!
I am a Pakistani - My forefathers were Sikh. And I am proud of my Heritage just like my Family. No one can pull an inch off my Heritage. Sikh were,are and will remain Our Brothers. Insh'Allah
religious fundamentalism is a threat to human emotions, this threat is more severe when religion becomes official, pakistan need to rethink its position in this 21 century
what a wonderful movie....and Molvis they always have been try to make us fool in the name of islam...this is bad luck of Pakistan.....Pakistan has not been in good hands...ever!....I salute Kiron Kher for her performance and we would like to thank her for choosing this film and she worked for Pakistan...and I would like also to thank the director Miss Sabiha Sumar for making such a significant movie...and for delivering great message for our nation through this film.
what a wonderful movie....and Molvis they always have been try to make us fool in the name of islam...this is bad luck of Pakistan.....Pakistan has not been in good hands...ever!....I salute Kiron Kher for her performance and we would like to thank her for choosing this film and she worked for Pakistan...and I would like also to thank the director Miss Sabiha Sumar for making such a significant movie...and for delivering great message for our nation through this film.
what a wonderful movie....and Molvis they always have been try to make us fool in the name of islam...this is bad luck of Pakistan.....Pakistan has not been in good hands...ever!....I salute Kiron Kher for her performance and we would like to thank her for choosing this film and she worked for Pakistan...and I would like also to thank the director Miss Sabiha Sumar for making such a significant movie...and for delivering great message for our nation through this film.
jo apni maa da na ho sakya oho kise mazhab da kive ho sakda hai.pakistani loka ch kai change lok vi hunn par jo islam dharam hai ohdi galat varto kaaran ajj pakistan di eh halat hai.islam nu tyag ke vekho rabb milega.change karma naal te maa payo di seva naal
wow wowowwowoowow what a movie what a movie really waht a movie i dont know what to say just a wounderful movie you know no matter what religion you keep but humanity is biggest religion which i feel told us this great movie nice
@ghayasbilbees Although I feel what happened in 47 is not discussed in our society, it is considered a tabboo and people are to afraid to talk about what happened. The Germans acknowledge what happened in WW2 and moved on, we havent really acknowledged what and who was responcible for what in 47
Really nice film...i hated the selfish son..Islam and Quran says to respect your parents no matter what....and what he did to the girl was really bad cause you can show interest in any one as long as you are a man but for a woman to say i love him is like HELL break lose....She is bad and called names......K. Kher was wonderful...
I had been waiting for this film for a long time.Thanks to u tube i saw it.This is Kiron Kher's master piece.The film shows the dangers of Zia(Mulla) version of Islam and today pakistan is paying the price of these obscurantist ideas.Perhaps the day they restore Jinnah"s version of the National anthem written by Jagan Nath Azad...things will begin to change for the better...or the slide towards talabization will continue which means only more misery for the women.
Before Britishers, muslims were the rulers of India. Why would they need to get protected after independence? It was all about politics and power which resulted in Pakistan. If you know a bit of history, the Pakistan was demanded first time in 1942. Even at the time of partition, there we more muslims in India than in Pakistan.
pakistan was not made for islam. it was made to protect the constitutional, cultural and social rights of a minority group in indai, namely muslims. so to say that pakistan was made for islam is fundamentally incorrect.
agar aisee hi baat hai to aj bhi muslims ki zyada tadad India mein rehti hai.
If I take it for granted what you are saying, than would you explain why the Slogan of the Pakistan Movement was 'Pakistan ka matlab kia - La ilaha ila Allah'
This movie has touched my heart so deeply and I am still unable to stop thinking about it. Thank you so much for uploading this movie on Youtube. I think there is not much difference in our cultures in India and Pakistan and I pray to the almighty for the peace, development and harmony in both the countries.
@mubrew123 I dont think there is, Pakistanis are shown in Indian media as v dif to what they are, we have a shared history, culture, and religion isnt as big a dividng factor as we think or like to think. Certainly the time of Zia ul haq was a very changing time in Pakistani society, but i think the effects were some what grossly exaggerated in the film
Guys Guys Guys!!! Stop pulling each other's legs, beliefs. Comment on the movie and concept behind it. It's a story of a woman which suffered and many like her suffered due the conflicts which we muslims have with Muslims or with Sikhs. The other message which this movie gives is to follow Quran and not some rebel or guy from a street who is willing to teach you Islam. We shall not have our own beliefs but have one belief based n QURAN. That's why QURAN was sent though 3 other books were there 2
I felt extremely ,,,;( sad after watching this Movie very very sad but very very true things things happened now matter what we say do or act these things and these types of people do exits in our society I should say double minded people
I am glad that my ancestors are persian muslim from Prphet family(syeds) and i love/respect all religions what ever thy ar wherevr thy r from, at the end of the day we all r human first and then religion comes...
You are proud (or glad) on something you never had anything to do with! How can you be "proud" of your race and still can respect others? Thats called hypocrisy! look it up. By the way - all Pakistanis think they were descended from Persians and Arabs. You might not know that Persians and Arabs don't like Pakistanis a lot. They're actually more racist than you are. Do some research n you'll find out.
my comments are misunderstood i didn't mean that, ERIKCARTMAN or Arepha(u shoud b prud on wat u r but respect others wats wrong wid dat)unless u might hav som thin to be ashamed on (e.g.YAZID family)but i am glad that my family/ancestors are meeting with Prophet(S.A.W)by Imam Moosa KAZIM(shajra-e-syed). .research is required by ppl having no backround,not to thos u read DAROOD in every pray.(AL-E-MUhammad (s.A.W)
these things are meaningless. no one will be rewarded or punished by God based on their blood lineage. No matter how much you like to think how lucky you are, you'll be surprised to find yourself among everyone else when we all shall be judged. Put down your blood-line info manuals and your Sect-text and read Quran.
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
u silly bugger, u need some research(read the family of IMAM after Karbala where did they go and how many son's they had (just for your knowledge) and dont copy it(lol) Imam Moosa Kazim (sevethn son) and in Kazman Iran(all Kazmi's) are from, i shuldn't tell u but just thought,u did a good effort to put this drama and btw wats ur research about urself(Sardar, Cheema,Rajput or....)
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
sabee66 I know the history and i CONFIRM it for you. YOU DO HAVE A RESEARCH. YOU GUYS SHOULDN"T ARGUE ON THESE THINGS. I KNOW WAT U R SAYING BUT STILL
Our original family name is 'Janjua' and I just found out that Janjua Rajputs are actually Kshatriyas in the Hindu caste system. Most Punjabi names show our Hindu origin. I was really surprised bc I always thought I was descended from Persians.I used to look down on Hindus before, like when I heard about them venerating even cow urine. But now I can't-how can a Pakistani hate a Hindu so much when they have the blood of thousands of Hindu ancestors in their veins?
dont worry mate, half of pakistan is in your position...I am glad that i am iranian decend with syed family but i love/respect all other religion or sect and dont beleive on cast system
Don't worry Sabee, more than half of the Pakistanis try to prove that they are hashmi, farooqi, usmani, syed etc, migrated from Iran, Arab, Afghanistan. You are just another in the lot. But I don't see any reason to be "glad" on that. May God have mercy on you.
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
if ESA(aw) was glad to be UMATI from MUHAMMAD(S.A.W), i think there is a big reason to be happy to be from his family, dont worry u wont understand these things...u might know ppl who r proving/claiming, but ALhamdulillah, come to my Great Great Grand father shrine and you will find out, like i said dont worry u wont understand this, i just said that , forget it
@arepha I could ideally start naming out ayaat of quran and ahadees which speak on this subject, sufficient to say is these examples: no matter how good your lineage it will not save you from the fire, whether its being the son of a nabi (e.g Lot (AS)), the wife of one (Lot and Nuh (A.S)) or the Prophet (SAW)'s mother. And people from the worst of households, the wife of pharoah (the person promised the worst punishment in the hellfire) being of the 4 women who perfected thier faith
Well, in most cases, ALL the blood they have are from the Hindu ancestors - for Hinduism was around when Islam wasnt around here but your Hinfu ancestors where still somewhere in the Rajasthan-Punjab area.
wow! this movie worth to see, i am proud of this movie, Islam is not a religion of Hate, but some people are using it for there own ideas and cause. May Allah give a right path to muslims and every body.
much better than the over-hyped 'Khuda ke liye'.Shows the self-hate that Islam induces among the converts.Not only that,the mulsim are always suspicious of the new converts.Read the book 'The other side of Silence' by Urvashi Butalia to know more about the hate faced by the Hindus/Sikhs who were converted muslims by force.
Islam doesn't induce any self-hatred amongst the converts. As a matter of fact no religion does that. Its the minority of people who strive on the fear induced in public and this clergy system exists in all communities. Also, this is the story of both sides.
Yes it does.Just observe the number of neo converts to Islam being involved in terrorism related activities like Dhiren Bharot..The hatred of the son of the main protagonist once he finds out that his mother was a non-muslim is so telling.I have read a few such personal accounts in Butalia's book.The complete denial of the present day malaysians/pakistanis of their Hindu past is an example of the self hate.Same is true for the Bangladeshis which were Buddhist.
HOw can a Muslim remember his Hindu past? A hindu has a set place in society, he has a caste: for a muslim to hold on to his Hindu past (which in all likelihood got mixed up wiht several other caste groups within Hinduism and other races from outside hindu fold over the centuries) would be to hold on to Hindu casteism. Islam's effect in India has been the breakdown of castes with each generation. hinduism's effect has been to further subdivide people into castes over the centuries.
A Hindu who converts to Muslim remembers his or her Hindu past just like a son or daughter remembers their parents life. Trying to erase the life and thinking that the belief of your own forefathers and your own blood was something inferior than what you believe in, is really hating one's own blood.This is what is called self-hate. If a modern Hindu denies his/her non-Vedic past, it is similar self-hate.
saw this film today with an english and a brazilian friend and they were totally shocked by this amazing film. Humanity has no language, country, colour or religion
saw this amazing film one night on channel 4. Myself and an english friend. We were rivetted by teh end and were almost in shock at the final scene. My friend was old enough to know of the partition and he had tears in his eyes. what a film.
over all a very good story and true, Islam is not to hate or kill others its meaning are to love humanity in any way. These extremist terroist are killing not only Pakistan but Islam, and the main persons responsable are General Zia and the Saudi's who know nothing about Islam. All you have to look in to the love given by our Prophet Mohammed who shold nothing but peace and love never started any fight first
i totally agress with you. prophet muhammad (pbuh) never waged war against anyone, all the wars in his time were in defense. it was after when he passed away that some of his companions took it the wrong way, his message was love and peace and you can prove your point with force!Awesome effort with t his film
great work!... its true one follows certain relegion to be a good person and have a personality that attracts other people towards you instead of being someone who scares others away
see theyy made fun of sikhs in the movies 4-5 times,which i personally did not like, but on the other hand i know that the movie is not abt making fun of sikhs,but it is about sending some great message,and i got that, its humanity, but i would have liked it more if there wouldnt be any thing in the movie making fun of sikhs
I see where you're coming from...but this movie is based on the true story of many people of that time. The movie wasn't made to make fun of Sikhs, but rather to show that there are people of that sort. I know you would like this movie more if they didn't, but wouldn't we all? Life would be so much better. Sadly, you'll find people like that today too...Muslims were also discriminated against as well. Basically this movie depicts the reality of those years.
Every religion came as revolution to free people but sadly, with passage of time religion becomes property of a few clercs who rule people on the name of religion. It happened to every religion from hinduism to Islam. I am muslim but I think Sikhism is latest, so it's less authoritative yet.
G8 movie arepha thks for uploading it .Iwas born in 1949 so i dont have any personal memories of the 1947 riots but what i have heard of them they were gory and we can not but hang our head in shame whatever we are Hindu Muslim or Sikh . Pinjar and Train to Pakistan are equally good movies on similar subjects
Very good villian they have made. Portray practicing Muslims in whatever role and made them extremist.
Me myself is a practising Muslim but alhamdulillah I respect every religion and so is my Islam.
In Islam U cannot kill women, children,old persons and those who r working in their fields even during war.
It is portrayed that a practising boy lost his mother bcs of fundamentalist and than he is not guilty and even sad???
tazeenhasan 1 day ago
maa marwa di,mashooq gawa dee,kia mila itna sekht ho ker,islam zeberdesti nahi phelaya ja sekta or orat ko azaadi hasil he islam mei
perfectlife4u 1 month ago
very gooooood film
MsZano69 2 months ago
Excellent movie depicting reality of gruesome fundamentalism in an extra ordinary way!
butawaisbut 3 months ago
the movie is a fantastic experience...wish we could come up another freedom movement from all sorts of fundamentalism...
kablachoda 4 months ago
Man start religion thing and woman has to suffer !!
excellenceisme 5 months ago
Excellent movie tolerance and world wide brotherhood.
aw005796 1 year ago
WOW WOW WOW !!! IS IT A MOVIE MADE BY PAKISTANI ? EVERY MUZLIM IN HINDUSTAN SHOULD WATCH THIS MOVIE ..AND DECIDE OF THEIR STATE IN HINDUSTAN AS COMPARED TO THEIR COUNTERPARTS IN PAKI ! JAI HIND !!!
hindubangu 1 year ago
Looking at the state of Pakistan now and especially after watching this movie, I feel our elders have failed us. When these extremists were spreading hate in the name of religion and Zia's armies were taking many of the youngsters away, why on earth weren't they trying to protect their generations from such deliberate hatred and misrepresentation of their religion. Why did they stay silent so now their next generations are suffering. Hopefully we wont fail our next generations and do something!
xcessdenied 1 year ago
I am a Pakistani - My forefathers were Sikh. And I am proud of my Heritage just like my Family. No one can pull an inch off my Heritage. Sikh were,are and will remain Our Brothers. Insh'Allah
Umar4720 1 year ago 3
I could barely hold the lump in my throat when Veero took that plunge. A very amazing movie with a message for all of us.
thephilosopherkartik 1 year ago
Menuh teek na laga veero/ayeshka keh mowth
naimhaquesheikh 1 year ago
ye 5 sajdo wali konsi namaz hai?
APPYGREEN1 1 year ago
religious fundamentalism is a threat to human emotions, this threat is more severe when religion becomes official, pakistan need to rethink its position in this 21 century
rishi25mgs 1 year ago 2
@rishi25mgs ditto
arepha 1 year ago
Thank you and God bless you for letting us see this remarkable film. This film carries a vital message which you have shared with us.
jasiddiqi 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
what a wonderful movie....and Molvis they always have been try to make us fool in the name of islam...this is bad luck of Pakistan.....Pakistan has not been in good hands...ever!....I salute Kiron Kher for her performance and we would like to thank her for choosing this film and she worked for Pakistan...and I would like also to thank the director Miss Sabiha Sumar for making such a significant movie...and for delivering great message for our nation through this film.
MrNihadahmad 1 year ago
what a wonderful movie....and Molvis they always have been try to make us fool in the name of islam...this is bad luck of Pakistan.....Pakistan has not been in good hands...ever!....I salute Kiron Kher for her performance and we would like to thank her for choosing this film and she worked for Pakistan...and I would like also to thank the director Miss Sabiha Sumar for making such a significant movie...and for delivering great message for our nation through this film.
MrNihadahmad 1 year ago 3
what a wonderful movie....and Molvis they always have been try to make us fool in the name of islam...this is bad luck of Pakistan.....Pakistan has not been in good hands...ever!....I salute Kiron Kher for her performance and we would like to thank her for choosing this film and she worked for Pakistan...and I would like also to thank the director Miss Sabiha Sumar for making such a significant movie...and for delivering great message for our nation through this film.
MrNihadahmad 1 year ago
Wow, thank you so much for uploading this movie.
KurtobaZ 1 year ago
jo apni maa da na ho sakya oho kise mazhab da kive ho sakda hai.pakistani loka ch kai change lok vi hunn par jo islam dharam hai ohdi galat varto kaaran ajj pakistan di eh halat hai.islam nu tyag ke vekho rabb milega.change karma naal te maa payo di seva naal
TIgeracademy 1 year ago
who is mr saleem khan today
mskitana2001 2 years ago
wow wowowwowoowow what a movie what a movie really waht a movie i dont know what to say just a wounderful movie you know no matter what religion you keep but humanity is biggest religion which i feel told us this great movie nice
tariq7274 2 years ago
GROSS STUPIDITY! whole movie was referred to out of context in both conceptual and literal meaning.
Waste of time
ghayasbilbees 2 years ago
@ghayasbilbees Although I feel what happened in 47 is not discussed in our society, it is considered a tabboo and people are to afraid to talk about what happened. The Germans acknowledge what happened in WW2 and moved on, we havent really acknowledged what and who was responcible for what in 47
musti1231 1 year ago
Really nice film...i hated the selfish son..Islam and Quran says to respect your parents no matter what....and what he did to the girl was really bad cause you can show interest in any one as long as you are a man but for a woman to say i love him is like HELL break lose....She is bad and called names......K. Kher was wonderful...
tahiraaliawan 2 years ago 4
I had been waiting for this film for a long time.Thanks to u tube i saw it.This is Kiron Kher's master piece.The film shows the dangers of Zia(Mulla) version of Islam and today pakistan is paying the price of these obscurantist ideas.Perhaps the day they restore Jinnah"s version of the National anthem written by Jagan Nath Azad...things will begin to change for the better...or the slide towards talabization will continue which means only more misery for the women.
nasreenlone 2 years ago 4
i second ur opinion..if only more people could fathom the same as well
grewaljassu 2 years ago
Kher you are the Goddes of acting. Salam to you.
PakLovesIndia 2 years ago 5
Before Britishers, muslims were the rulers of India. Why would they need to get protected after independence? It was all about politics and power which resulted in Pakistan. If you know a bit of history, the Pakistan was demanded first time in 1942. Even at the time of partition, there we more muslims in India than in Pakistan.
sweta762 2 years ago 2
pakistan was not made for islam. it was made to protect the constitutional, cultural and social rights of a minority group in indai, namely muslims. so to say that pakistan was made for islam is fundamentally incorrect.
forever2307 2 years ago 6
agar aisee hi baat hai to aj bhi muslims ki zyada tadad India mein rehti hai.
If I take it for granted what you are saying, than would you explain why the Slogan of the Pakistan Movement was 'Pakistan ka matlab kia - La ilaha ila Allah'
ghayasbilbees 2 years ago
that was so sad...
someyakhan 2 years ago 2
a beautiful movie with a everlasting essence....thanks.....
kshis13 2 years ago
so sad..:(
vishali09 2 years ago
This movie touched my heart and soul. Well directed movie and kr kher has done terrific job, she was awesome.
ind248 3 years ago
Twisted, either the movie or my mind :S
xsdnide 3 years ago
fukin immature pakistani pricks, wont stop anywhere from embarassing themselves
Anyway excellent film, Extremely well directed, Kiron Kher did an amazing job
kohprush 3 years ago
This movie has touched my heart so deeply and I am still unable to stop thinking about it. Thank you so much for uploading this movie on Youtube. I think there is not much difference in our cultures in India and Pakistan and I pray to the almighty for the peace, development and harmony in both the countries.
mubrew123 3 years ago 17
@mubrew123 I dont think there is, Pakistanis are shown in Indian media as v dif to what they are, we have a shared history, culture, and religion isnt as big a dividng factor as we think or like to think. Certainly the time of Zia ul haq was a very changing time in Pakistani society, but i think the effects were some what grossly exaggerated in the film
musti1231 1 year ago
Guys Guys Guys!!! Stop pulling each other's legs, beliefs. Comment on the movie and concept behind it. It's a story of a woman which suffered and many like her suffered due the conflicts which we muslims have with Muslims or with Sikhs. The other message which this movie gives is to follow Quran and not some rebel or guy from a street who is willing to teach you Islam. We shall not have our own beliefs but have one belief based n QURAN. That's why QURAN was sent though 3 other books were there 2
bluntu 3 years ago 17
You forgot the Sunnat bhaijaan.
Iranali786 3 years ago
I felt extremely ,,,;( sad after watching this Movie very very sad but very very true things things happened now matter what we say do or act these things and these types of people do exits in our society I should say double minded people
SenoritaPakistan 3 years ago 4
Stop this bullshit. Indian and Pakistanis do this a lot.
Syed , Rizvi , Kazmi , Naqvi , Siddiqui , Farooqi , Usmani , Khan , Pathan , Niazi , Ansari , Qureishi , Ashrafi , Chamar , Bhangi , Mirasi , Makrani , Janjua , Julaha , Darzi , Kasai , Cheema , Rajputt , Soomro , Awan , Arain.....
all these castes are basically Muslims and members of the Ummat-e-Rasool ( saws) first and foremost.
Iranali786 3 years ago 5
I am glad that my ancestors are persian muslim from Prphet family(syeds) and i love/respect all religions what ever thy ar wherevr thy r from, at the end of the day we all r human first and then religion comes...
sabee66 3 years ago
You are proud (or glad) on something you never had anything to do with! How can you be "proud" of your race and still can respect others? Thats called hypocrisy! look it up. By the way - all Pakistanis think they were descended from Persians and Arabs. You might not know that Persians and Arabs don't like Pakistanis a lot. They're actually more racist than you are. Do some research n you'll find out.
erikcartman1 3 years ago
my comments are misunderstood i didn't mean that, ERIKCARTMAN or Arepha(u shoud b prud on wat u r but respect others wats wrong wid dat)unless u might hav som thin to be ashamed on (e.g.YAZID family)but i am glad that my family/ancestors are meeting with Prophet(S.A.W)by Imam Moosa KAZIM(shajra-e-syed). .research is required by ppl having no backround,not to thos u read DAROOD in every pray.(AL-E-MUhammad (s.A.W)
sabee66 3 years ago
these things are meaningless. no one will be rewarded or punished by God based on their blood lineage. No matter how much you like to think how lucky you are, you'll be surprised to find yourself among everyone else when we all shall be judged. Put down your blood-line info manuals and your Sect-text and read Quran.
erikcartman1 3 years ago 10
This comment has received too many negative votes show
you r not telling me anything new..thankyou anyway, and btw, what if i am doin what i need to do to make my ALLAH happy then.....let him judge me
seethroughmyheart 3 years ago
oops, you are signed in from wrong id here.
arepha 3 years ago
"Persian" from prophet family? Do you have any idea what you are talking about. For god sake, cease being a racist and do some research
arepha 3 years ago 3
This comment has received too many negative votes show
u silly bugger, u need some research(read the family of IMAM after Karbala where did they go and how many son's they had (just for your knowledge) and dont copy it(lol) Imam Moosa Kazim (sevethn son) and in Kazman Iran(all Kazmi's) are from, i shuldn't tell u but just thought,u did a good effort to put this drama and btw wats ur research about urself(Sardar, Cheema,Rajput or....)
sabee66 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
sabee66 I know the history and i CONFIRM it for you. YOU DO HAVE A RESEARCH. YOU GUYS SHOULDN"T ARGUE ON THESE THINGS. I KNOW WAT U R SAYING BUT STILL
seethroughmyheart 3 years ago
luv this movie.
made me cry i wish i can have contact with that women Aysha.when i looked at her made me cry i remember something.She was a great mother...
khancute143 3 years ago 2
Our original family name is 'Janjua' and I just found out that Janjua Rajputs are actually Kshatriyas in the Hindu caste system. Most Punjabi names show our Hindu origin. I was really surprised bc I always thought I was descended from Persians.I used to look down on Hindus before, like when I heard about them venerating even cow urine. But now I can't-how can a Pakistani hate a Hindu so much when they have the blood of thousands of Hindu ancestors in their veins?
poonzor1 3 years ago 10
Very good question! I totally agree with you...it's that hatred and anger sturred up by others unfortunately :(
sohniye 3 years ago 5
dont worry mate, half of pakistan is in your position...I am glad that i am iranian decend with syed family but i love/respect all other religion or sect and dont beleive on cast system
sabee66 3 years ago
Don't worry Sabee, more than half of the Pakistanis try to prove that they are hashmi, farooqi, usmani, syed etc, migrated from Iran, Arab, Afghanistan. You are just another in the lot. But I don't see any reason to be "glad" on that. May God have mercy on you.
arepha 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
if ESA(aw) was glad to be UMATI from MUHAMMAD(S.A.W), i think there is a big reason to be happy to be from his family, dont worry u wont understand these things...u might know ppl who r proving/claiming, but ALhamdulillah, come to my Great Great Grand father shrine and you will find out, like i said dont worry u wont understand this, i just said that , forget it
sabee66 3 years ago
@arepha I could ideally start naming out ayaat of quran and ahadees which speak on this subject, sufficient to say is these examples: no matter how good your lineage it will not save you from the fire, whether its being the son of a nabi (e.g Lot (AS)), the wife of one (Lot and Nuh (A.S)) or the Prophet (SAW)'s mother. And people from the worst of households, the wife of pharoah (the person promised the worst punishment in the hellfire) being of the 4 women who perfected thier faith
musti1231 1 year ago
Comment removed
drgarga 2 years ago
Well, in most cases, ALL the blood they have are from the Hindu ancestors - for Hinduism was around when Islam wasnt around here but your Hinfu ancestors where still somewhere in the Rajasthan-Punjab area.
So much for being "two nations"
drgarga 2 years ago
Remarkable movie. Hats off to Sabiha Sumar for adding life to our memories and thank you Arepha for sharing it with us.
lilzlizzy 3 years ago
Comment removed
drgarga 2 years ago
wow! this movie worth to see, i am proud of this movie, Islam is not a religion of Hate, but some people are using it for there own ideas and cause. May Allah give a right path to muslims and every body.
Thanks for posting this lovely movie.
3987234 3 years ago
Lovely movie . Thank you.
nafrid4 3 years ago
Arepha, thank you for posting this movie. I was speachless at the end.
Engior 3 years ago
I am glad you liked it
arepha 3 years ago
much better than the over-hyped 'Khuda ke liye'.Shows the self-hate that Islam induces among the converts.Not only that,the mulsim are always suspicious of the new converts.Read the book 'The other side of Silence' by Urvashi Butalia to know more about the hate faced by the Hindus/Sikhs who were converted muslims by force.
bongbuster1 3 years ago
Islam doesn't induce any self-hatred amongst the converts. As a matter of fact no religion does that. Its the minority of people who strive on the fear induced in public and this clergy system exists in all communities. Also, this is the story of both sides.
arepha 3 years ago
Yes it does.Just observe the number of neo converts to Islam being involved in terrorism related activities like Dhiren Bharot..The hatred of the son of the main protagonist once he finds out that his mother was a non-muslim is so telling.I have read a few such personal accounts in Butalia's book.The complete denial of the present day malaysians/pakistanis of their Hindu past is an example of the self hate.Same is true for the Bangladeshis which were Buddhist.
bongbuster1 3 years ago
HOw can a Muslim remember his Hindu past? A hindu has a set place in society, he has a caste: for a muslim to hold on to his Hindu past (which in all likelihood got mixed up wiht several other caste groups within Hinduism and other races from outside hindu fold over the centuries) would be to hold on to Hindu casteism. Islam's effect in India has been the breakdown of castes with each generation. hinduism's effect has been to further subdivide people into castes over the centuries.
Sameena111 3 years ago
A Hindu who converts to Muslim remembers his or her Hindu past just like a son or daughter remembers their parents life. Trying to erase the life and thinking that the belief of your own forefathers and your own blood was something inferior than what you believe in, is really hating one's own blood.This is what is called self-hate. If a modern Hindu denies his/her non-Vedic past, it is similar self-hate.
drgarga 2 years ago 3
very true and its a travesty of fate that even hindus dont understand their vedic past
pallavrnt 2 years ago
Gr8 Efforts....very strong expressions by artists.
nice background music...thnxs for subtitles...my punjabi is not so good...
I donno whether it could change somebody's heart...but i am pretty sure, it will make you think onces again abt ur stand for religion.
friend2love4ever 4 years ago 3
Gr8 Efforts....very strong expressions by artists.
nice background music...thnxs for subtitles...my punjabi is not so good...
I donno whether it could change somebody's heart...but i am pretty sure, it will make you think onces again abt ur stand for religion.
friend2love4ever 4 years ago 2
o bhai...ay keri namaz ay....jiss wich chhay chhay sajday ho reh ney...subhan teri Qudrat... :D
kaych686 4 years ago
saw this film today with an english and a brazilian friend and they were totally shocked by this amazing film. Humanity has no language, country, colour or religion
GARRYKINGLIVE 4 years ago 3
wow ! thats great
arepha 4 years ago
great movie. Humanity is what makes us humans.
sssandhu78 4 years ago
Good Movie but full of exaggeration......
ManuosAjnabi 4 years ago
what do you think is exaggeration in the movie ? :)
arepha 4 years ago
truth is often an exaggeration of reality
GARRYKINGLIVE 4 years ago
saw this amazing film one night on channel 4. Myself and an english friend. We were rivetted by teh end and were almost in shock at the final scene. My friend was old enough to know of the partition and he had tears in his eyes. what a film.
matt6565655 4 years ago 4
It,s AWESOME and unbelievable ACTING!!!GREAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAT wofk
nydesiking 4 years ago 4
really good movie,acting was excellent scenes awesome thanks
erina916 4 years ago 3
Amazing movie and I applaud everyone associated with it. Bravo!
Schazaad 4 years ago 3
over all a very good story and true, Islam is not to hate or kill others its meaning are to love humanity in any way. These extremist terroist are killing not only Pakistan but Islam, and the main persons responsable are General Zia and the Saudi's who know nothing about Islam. All you have to look in to the love given by our Prophet Mohammed who shold nothing but peace and love never started any fight first
tremasi 4 years ago 3
i totally agress with you. prophet muhammad (pbuh) never waged war against anyone, all the wars in his time were in defense. it was after when he passed away that some of his companions took it the wrong way, his message was love and peace and you can prove your point with force!Awesome effort with t his film
zarak111 4 years ago 2
I meant you can NEVER prove your point with force.
zarak111 4 years ago
great work!... its true one follows certain relegion to be a good person and have a personality that attracts other people towards you instead of being someone who scares others away
muffu85 4 years ago
see theyy made fun of sikhs in the movies 4-5 times,which i personally did not like, but on the other hand i know that the movie is not abt making fun of sikhs,but it is about sending some great message,and i got that, its humanity, but i would have liked it more if there wouldnt be any thing in the movie making fun of sikhs
niralam 4 years ago
I see where you're coming from...but this movie is based on the true story of many people of that time. The movie wasn't made to make fun of Sikhs, but rather to show that there are people of that sort. I know you would like this movie more if they didn't, but wouldn't we all? Life would be so much better. Sadly, you'll find people like that today too...Muslims were also discriminated against as well. Basically this movie depicts the reality of those years.
sohniye 3 years ago
excellent movie
love it
thanks for uploding
Jalilm123 4 years ago 3
we need to be huma beings first, not muslim not sikhs
niralam 4 years ago 4
You are right
arepha 4 years ago
great movie, thank you so much. what religion make you animal i am so sad to say it
phulghari 4 years ago
Every religion came as revolution to free people but sadly, with passage of time religion becomes property of a few clercs who rule people on the name of religion. It happened to every religion from hinduism to Islam. I am muslim but I think Sikhism is latest, so it's less authoritative yet.
arepha 4 years ago
lol acha
nangamujra 4 years ago
G8 movie arepha thks for uploading it .Iwas born in 1949 so i dont have any personal memories of the 1947 riots but what i have heard of them they were gory and we can not but hang our head in shame whatever we are Hindu Muslim or Sikh . Pinjar and Train to Pakistan are equally good movies on similar subjects
jssidhoo 2 years ago
pretty good directed and acted movie!
fammy23 4 years ago