I'm not saying that it's bad; if you like the singer, I would really like this. I just don't. If I want it, I would listen to Springstreen. The comp isn't wrong, their voices are very similar. The song itself though, this one at least, is very good.
the song is about great american poet John Berryman who comitted a suicide by jumping from the Washington Avenue Bridge ..."We all come down and drown in the Mississippi River." I love this lyrics...
Saw these guys a week ago in Brooklyn, and I have listened to Stay Positive and Boys and Girls in America about eighteen times each since then. I like this song so much that I get bummed out when it ends. Just awesome.
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
ah, now i understand why a guy write in another clip about bruce springsteen... its this typical sound of springsteen and all this other faceless songs from american artists in the early eighties..
Nah, Hold Steady isn't about the music anyway, it's about the story. Start from Lifter Puller, and then work forward, the music is just a container to get the stories into the space. Springsteen is a musician, Finn is a musical novelist. Big difference.
I love all the gratuitous Twin Cities references. They remind me of a great year, baseball, and my apartment right on the Mississippi River. Jeez, I actually miss Minnesota..
This band is like Elvis Costello leading the E Street band in the 70's -in the best way imaginable. Great CD, also has some Thin Lizzy tunes influence on one tune.
The Hold Steady are the most exciting band in the world today..ive been a buyer in the music biz for 3 decades..and these guys remind of the excitement of the punk days! THE BELFAST GYPSY
"loved the golden gofers but hated all the drawn out winters." this song makes me think of tavern life in the upper midwest. twincies, milwaukee, chicago. makin the winter trips to your corner bar.
The hold steady are good because the songs they write seem to be about themselves. They write songs that seem to be about partying in minneapolis when they were teenagers. They sound like a bunch of suburban dads trying to rekindle thier youth by making a band. Which is why they're so cool.
Davey there are plenty of other terrible bands to rant on.. this is american rock and roll... not some interpol bullshit... all though i like interpol. you get me?
boys and girls in america is definitely my favorite album of the past year and definitely one of my top favorite albums ever...i really don't understand why they arent more well known either.
saw them in carlisle last week, small club, about 150 people there...why are these guys not global superstars? I love the signature weird double-time handclapping thing, and the way he sings the previous line into the audience away from the mic so all you hear is nothing but see him mouthing the words! amazing gig. A stripped down version of E Street band from 1975. amazing.
Pfft, buck up. You can't change art because of events that happened after it. I went over that bridge shortly before that happened, and I know it could have easily been me in one of those cars, but there's no way that I feel awkward or odd about a lyric.
I'm not saying that it's bad; if you like the singer, I would really like this. I just don't. If I want it, I would listen to Springstreen. The comp isn't wrong, their voices are very similar. The song itself though, this one at least, is very good.
KingPong92 2 years ago
any way to get the piano music for this song?
Mamandishj 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
please let me know if you ever find it
dubassaves 2 years ago
He was drunk and exhausted, but he was critically acclaimed and respected...
bsweinkauf 2 years ago 2
really 4 real i am not trying to be a dick but damn this is weird shit
bigrog45324 2 years ago
So much of this band output is about drugs. I think it keeps them from being as popular as they should be. I love them though.
ignatzly 2 years ago
@ignatzly I doubt that drugs have anything to do with it. There are alot of hoops that you have to jump through to become popular...
Defying89gravity 2 years ago
the song is about great american poet John Berryman who comitted a suicide by jumping from the Washington Avenue Bridge ..."We all come down and drown in the Mississippi River." I love this lyrics...
XYZTanya 2 years ago 4
Comment removed
bytwilight13 2 years ago
ahhh love this song.:) amaaazzzziiinnngg.:)
hallciara22 2 years ago
She was a really cool kisser and she wasn't all that strict of a Christian.
rrr8891 2 years ago 2
tis song remind me of my youth i love this song
Hold Steady Forever
d0naldisc00l12345 2 years ago 3
lmao best video ever
dubassaves 2 years ago
A lot of Springsteen similarity. A bit overhyped, but not bad(?).
sweetttina666 2 years ago
Saw these guys a week ago in Brooklyn, and I have listened to Stay Positive and Boys and Girls in America about eighteen times each since then. I like this song so much that I get bummed out when it ends. Just awesome.
sebastian1121 2 years ago
it's so good. I saw them in concert twice. I might see em a third time.
Conquistador76 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
ah, now i understand why a guy write in another clip about bruce springsteen... its this typical sound of springsteen and all this other faceless songs from american artists in the early eighties..
HolgerHelfert 2 years ago
u suck
hermanlisucks2 2 years ago 2
Nah, Hold Steady isn't about the music anyway, it's about the story. Start from Lifter Puller, and then work forward, the music is just a container to get the stories into the space. Springsteen is a musician, Finn is a musical novelist. Big difference.
mikewofsey 2 years ago
mikewofsey, I agree except I find Srpingsteen more of a celebrity than a musician now. Finn is possessed of an epic mind...for real.
martianshoes 2 years ago
these guys are so much fun.
KCVROCKS2008 2 years ago
craig is fucking adorable lol.
WFPLiaison 2 years ago
love the opening line.
jerryloupenguin 2 years ago 3
how can you not? such a great book...
and I love how the bassist is reading the Dream Songs, seeing as this song is like a giant John Berryman tribute
allgreatmusic 2 years ago
i love the RUSH shirt
fragmaster1500 2 years ago
I love all the gratuitous Twin Cities references. They remind me of a great year, baseball, and my apartment right on the Mississippi River. Jeez, I actually miss Minnesota..
bsweinkauf 2 years ago 5
How could you not? I work right on Washington, I can walk across the street and talk to the river.
TaylorFedt 2 years ago
I love the reference to Jack Kerouac.
Conquistador76 2 years ago 2
This has been flagged as spam show
such a cool song
poppstar123 2 years ago
"i don't understand why we can just get these dubbed" CLASSIC!
Gweedoe 2 years ago
Absolutuely a great song, I can really connect with it. Also, what a great video it all seems to culminate in something almost better than sex
Joekickass3000 2 years ago
love
mattego16 2 years ago
ahaha
thats one of the best videos cause its not a load of sh** like all other vids
Merrrcredi 3 years ago
This band is like Elvis Costello leading the E Street band in the 70's -in the best way imaginable. Great CD, also has some Thin Lizzy tunes influence on one tune.
PatioG 3 years ago 8
Absolutley!! great critic!!
domsewell 3 years ago 3
OMG this is this the most exciting band i have seen since ATDI
domsewell 3 years ago 2
the music is really good, but the leadsinger sucks... sry xD
sleepiebrown 3 years ago
you must be high...really really high
BVisionProductions 2 years ago 2
The Hold Steady are the most exciting band in the world today..ive been a buyer in the music biz for 3 decades..and these guys remind of the excitement of the punk days! THE BELFAST GYPSY
calexicofan 3 years ago
"loved the golden gofers but hated all the drawn out winters." this song makes me think of tavern life in the upper midwest. twincies, milwaukee, chicago. makin the winter trips to your corner bar.
Vincelambargo 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
i didnt know hitler played piano
thecomplete10 3 years ago
I'll kill you.
OnePieceSanjiRobin 3 years ago
i agree, totally justified... franz is a god among men
jimboshizz 3 years ago
LOL
DavySolaris 3 years ago
AHAHAHAHAHAHAHA
fhyd 3 years ago
MARIO!!!
ford939 3 years ago
this band is one of the only ones that are original and fucking rule :D:D:D:D:D:D
9ish 3 years ago
The hold steady are good because the songs they write seem to be about themselves. They write songs that seem to be about partying in minneapolis when they were teenagers. They sound like a bunch of suburban dads trying to rekindle thier youth by making a band. Which is why they're so cool.
theanalyticalkid 3 years ago 2
Cool songs cool band I want to hang out with these guys. And that other song about the cutters is even better
noticeeverything 3 years ago 4
On the road!
LIBREtoujours 3 years ago
kerouac ftw
mcgrathy101 3 years ago
im stuck between station =P
hitlerdawg12345 3 years ago
"I don't understand why we can't get these dubbed"...because you're the Hold Steady, man!
doublebassed 3 years ago 3
i heart the hold steady!!!!!
egnarbutterlump 3 years ago
i heart the hold steady!!!!!
egnarbutterlump 3 years ago
This song is 100% rock. No more rock can fit into this song! Good work Hold Steady!
ovresmot 3 years ago 6
This comment has received too many negative votes show
wt about the first 30 seconds where theres no rock? and ur saying that u cant put any rock into the part withought rock?
PoofsandBiggsinc 3 years ago
What a band. I saw them supporting the countings crow at Liverpool and they were awesome.
rainking157 3 years ago 3
Sounds like a different mix than the album version.
rad1030 3 years ago
This is quite possibly the best song written this decade. My God, how did these guys get so awesome?
Iskitim 3 years ago 5
a great rockandroll band from the new era!!
alfaropsy 3 years ago 3
Just when I almost gave up hope on contempary American Rock !
careerkuts 3 years ago 7
These are rocking live!!! they played in our town in stoke - on- trent and are fucknig amazing!!!
hornykate666 4 years ago
dude the vid was great and somewhat funny but ive been playing this song over and over on my guitar and playing it with my ipod
zombehkiller23 4 years ago
awesome song
georgeartista1304 4 years ago
man i nusaually listen to country but this is a great band and a amazing saong..CASE IH
trials199 4 years ago
The Boss #2
theminusscalekid 4 years ago 2
I love this band. Separation Sunday and Boys And Girls in America are two of my all-time favorite CDs. And this is a great song.
bluessister1 4 years ago 3
davey solaris must listen to emo.
rhythmislife 4 years ago 3
This comment has received too many negative votes show
i don't like these guys at all. not sure where their appeal is.
does the singer actually play guitar ever or just mime? i've seen them on tv 2 or 3 times, nothing ever seems to come out of his amp.
DavySolaris 4 years ago
Davey there are plenty of other terrible bands to rant on.. this is american rock and roll... not some interpol bullshit... all though i like interpol. you get me?
poppycan 4 years ago 2
dude, who cares if he just mimes? they guy's got a killer voice, let him play around with a guitar if he wants.
ben030103 4 years ago
boys and girls in america is definitely my favorite album of the past year and definitely one of my top favorite albums ever...i really don't understand why they arent more well known either.
jorgie122 4 years ago
saw them in carlisle last week, small club, about 150 people there...why are these guys not global superstars? I love the signature weird double-time handclapping thing, and the way he sings the previous line into the audience away from the mic so all you hear is nothing but see him mouthing the words! amazing gig. A stripped down version of E Street band from 1975. amazing.
colintshirt 4 years ago
I agree! You can blame it on the music industry! They have lost touch! These guys are Springsteen, Elvis costello & Joe cocker all wrapped up in one!
41special 4 years ago
this guy actualy puts meaning in his song instead of pointless shouting
BLINX663 4 years ago
saw this band at T in the Park and they were majik
WAAAAAAAAAAAY 4 years ago
Dance Craig, dance.
ForSafetyReasons 4 years ago
Could they be any hotter.
As for the song and video, awesome.
ForSafetyReasons 4 years ago
that line about falling into the Mississippi river seems kind of odd now.
jwhittlejr 4 years ago
Yeah.. Originally its a reference to John Berryman, the poet who committed suicide by jumping off the Washington Avenue bridge 2 down from the I35W.
theonion's article two years ago "State Of Minnesota Too Polite To Ask For Federal Funding" Is pretty awkward too.
dietpoison 4 years ago
Pfft, buck up. You can't change art because of events that happened after it. I went over that bridge shortly before that happened, and I know it could have easily been me in one of those cars, but there's no way that I feel awkward or odd about a lyric.
poolfiend 4 years ago
I can't wait to see The Hold Steady at Lollapalooza this year!
primesweatsuger 4 years ago
Amazing band, amazing song, can't wait to see them at leeds fest.
tomdudzitom 4 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
gay
tehnubster69 4 years ago
Who? You?
jb2jean 4 years ago 2
yea they are pretty happy ppl
smawson 4 years ago
have they got an official youtube profile. They were awesome at oxegen!
Chewabacca 4 years ago
The drummer's wearing a Rush - Hemispheres World Tour 1978 t-shirt!!! AWESOME!
Flamesfan7 4 years ago 2
Love this song
thanks
unitedssupport 4 years ago
Wasn't Mr Finn originally in the replacements?
jacobarthurpalmer 4 years ago
No, though he was in Lifter Puller for a few years.
kidkidass 4 years ago
Can't wait to see them at Summer Sundae in August
oldcolonyfire 4 years ago
Love it.
ForSafetyReasons 4 years ago
they remind me of Husker Du and earily soul alysm!!! the new era of rock and roll...
enchain 4 years ago
Well, they are from Minneapolis, eh?
Dmfdoug 4 years ago
No, you dumbass. They're from New York.
Dmfdoug 4 years ago
Apparently you're the dumbass. Craig Finn is originally from Minnesota.
johnjviola 4 years ago
Some of the members are orignally from Minnesota
crogger456 4 years ago
Thats true. There from the twin cities, if you ever listened to the lyrics they talk about it a lot.
Frozensquirrel 4 years ago
the singer reminds me of randy newman...
Codackussell 4 years ago
rock is dead
rest in peace
RecordCity 4 years ago
long live paper!
vagrantrecords 4 years ago
and scissors!!!
Frozensquirrel 4 years ago
hhehehe... the ending makes sense... could you imagine, the old recording methods, oh my... this is one of my favorites on this album :)
piadox 4 years ago
The future of rock and roll
jla999 4 years ago
It seems the future is, once again, the past.
Good song though.
chipboardchrist 4 years ago
awesome. just plain awesome.
deltawlf 4 years ago
amazing song/band/video
TheChance34 4 years ago
good song
Imsocool1004 4 years ago