Really, in my opinion, the best rendition of this song are (females) Sarah Brightman and Tarja Turunen. Best guy versions are the 2004 movie singer because he added a bit of edginess that none of the other phantoms had (a bit of roughness that I guess is more of a scream) and the other phantom that is awesome is the Japanese bariton/bass singer. This is great too, but nothing compares to those four singer's rendition of this song!
Yes it it different, hearing it in Chinese. But it's good! :D I love their voices and how the video was made. So I think you should enjoy it rather than pick out all the things that you don't like about it. But if you really don't like it then that's ok too. :)
amazing song! amazing vocal! i started to you know him just few months ago.but after study on him i became his fan. he is my first and only idol in my life. he is really a special talent singer that is written into Asian history especially Chinese contemperary history. I can say there won't be another Fei Xiang(Kris Phillips) in the next 100 years.
@moniequa Not necessarily true. Depends who speaks it. Taiwanese accented Mandarin sounds much much less palatable than the standard HK cantonese. Both languages are actually very singable and can sound great in song. Cantonese in particular sounds very good in choral music, it actually shares a lot of phonemes with germanic languages. Here's an example of a pop song: watch?v=VYGect5mDFQ&feature=search
@jazcastillo I make one for you. zhu hua: si shui hai si meng xing ,si meng si zhen. zhe mi li hu han sheng ,chan dong wo xin. shi you lin hai shi shui,zai wo shen pang. zhe ye ban mei ying ge sheng bu ting de,xiang wo hu han. fei xiang: zhi you zai meng yan zhong,ni wo gong ming. zhe li hun ye wei yang,ni bu su xing. liu ni cui ruo xin ling ,zai wo shen pang. zhe ye ban mei ying ge sheng buting de,xiang ni hu han.
@jazcastillo zhu hua: ni shi jin gu you lin ,wei ye er sheng. wo wei ni huo bai zhou. fei xiang: su wo xin sheng tegether: wo de lin hun he ni,ge sheng xiang lian. zhe ye ban mei ying ge sheng bu ting de ,xiang ni(wo) hu huan. zhu hua: ni ting zhe ye ban mei ying ge sheng. zhe mi li ye ban mei ying ge sheng. feixiang: zai meng yan zhong de ni ,ke ceng yi wen. si hun si ren mei ying. zhu hua: ye jia ye zhen.
@jazcastillo together : xuan huo zai mi gong li ,hun po xiang chan zhe ye ban mei ying ge sheng bu ting de,xiang ni(wo) hu huan. fei xiang: (say) chang! tian shi de ge sheng. zhu hua: zhe mi li ye ban mei ying ge sheng,a~ fei xiang: (say) chang! wei wo chang! chang! ni wei wo er sheng! wei wo chang! are you learning Chinese?:)
@yuanxiaoyi I wish i could speak chinesse hehehe, but it's not so easy hehe.... sorry i did not answer before, i had not seen your answer.. thank you so much for the lyric,.... is it Mandarin or cantonesse?... than you again... i hope i coul learn a little with this XD
Which English version? The original Michael Crawford/Sarah Brightman recording or the movie version? I think these two are better singers than the ones on those recordings.
The handsome man is Chinese-US mix blood. I'm his fans from young age. now he is already 50 years old but still extremly handsome. You can add my msn vivien423@hotmail.com if you are also a oprea fans..
i like chinese version thaught i prefer english version but i dont think this's just another copy coz it gives some special effect while its in chinese and it is kinda softer more delicate and original is more tender and scary at the times
Chinese is actually a better language for this song. I wish I knew how to pronounce it. I don't think that Zhu Hua is actually singing the high part though. But you can't blame her, it goes up to the third E above middle C, most people can't hit it.
I wish I could speak Chinese, this is Mandarin Chinese, yes? There is a teacher near me who speaks it fluently, her native language...I wonder if she tutors...
For some reason pretty much every asian & european mixed person is hot, or better than average, look fei xiang (obviously) and kristen kruek!! I think it's that the best of both are brought together; delicate white people features and slender asian body. Need more eurasian celebs!!!
我喜歡英文多D= =
lamrainng 1 week ago
Really, in my opinion, the best rendition of this song are (females) Sarah Brightman and Tarja Turunen. Best guy versions are the 2004 movie singer because he added a bit of edginess that none of the other phantoms had (a bit of roughness that I guess is more of a scream) and the other phantom that is awesome is the Japanese bariton/bass singer. This is great too, but nothing compares to those four singer's rendition of this song!
angelicbaby92 1 week ago
@angelicbaby92 Gerard Butler wasnt bad for someone that dont sing alot.
gitrdone1691 3 days ago
中文的音節氛太開了....
東西方的語言習慣不同
唱出來的歌當然也不同
weihsu71 1 week ago
Our high school music class students sang the song, we sing the school's art students good too! Haha, singing the Chinese version
qiguanweiyang 2 weeks ago
This has been flagged as spam show
费翔从来不会写自己的歌或唱自己的歌,只会翻唱又翻唱。更可恶的是到后来所有的人都以为他是原唱,那些先人所唱出的好歌到后来都成了他的代表作。
johnsonhong1978 3 weeks ago
Yes it it different, hearing it in Chinese. But it's good! :D I love their voices and how the video was made. So I think you should enjoy it rather than pick out all the things that you don't like about it. But if you really don't like it then that's ok too. :)
Allday232 4 weeks ago
The lyrics is good !!
cheimak 1 month ago
xie xie!
geoffpeterstrio 2 months ago
很好!我觉得这电影很有意思。
MMegaminx 2 months ago
I don't like the song with Chiese .
我英文很爛
算了 打中文吧
中文版我真的非常不喜歡 感覺完全不對了
打的比喻 如果有首歌change Italian into Spanish 那feel will be idoneous
所以囉~
English & Chinese 發音方式is different 唱起來感覺is different , too .
把the song change English into Chinese is terrible !
ritalovespili 2 months ago
@ritalovespili 翻译成中文是很困难的。因为发音咬字的变化会把原来的感觉改变,连口型都会变。
luoellenluo 1 month ago
Helt underbart rar version fantomen. Finns hela versionen av operan nånstans att få tag på???
SPLINTER581 3 months ago
@SPLINTER581 english please?
luoellenluo 1 month ago
amazing song! amazing vocal! i started to you know him just few months ago.but after study on him i became his fan. he is my first and only idol in my life. he is really a special talent singer that is written into Asian history especially Chinese contemperary history. I can say there won't be another Fei Xiang(Kris Phillips) in the next 100 years.
luoellenluo 3 months ago
Comment removed
luoellenluo 3 months ago
And Kris has never been in this show because....? Seriously, someone needs to get on that.
emilygracey 4 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
我有轉在至fb上,你可以告訴我在哪裡找到的嗎?我想下載
swallow0915 4 months ago
Although it sounds a little...different? being sung in Chinese, I do have to say that their voices are amazing. :D
carihigs 4 months ago
This song sounds good in every language, but in chinese is simply amazing!! Love it :)
madamoiselleJuliet 5 months ago
這樣也可以唷!
WinSmart000 6 months ago
omg, his voice is just amazing O.o So powerful and sexy
HeartXXBlack 6 months ago in playlist Phantom of The Opera
@HeartXXBlack yes.he's a sexy man.
luoellenluo 1 month ago
費翔表現的比女歌手還魅....
village283 6 months ago 4
@village283 ......有另一个现场版,更魅
luoellenluo 1 month ago
older asian sing dance gaga must see
waggietoo 6 months ago
beautiful... absolutely beautiful, captured the phantom's spirit and essence
FruityDC 7 months ago
good song!
huangqiaoling72 7 months ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Chinese phantom?
very bad,really BAD!!!
pegasisx 7 months ago
wow...This song is Universal. no matter what language, i still hear its words.
The Phantom of the Oooooperaaaaaaaa!
MrShaun42088 7 months ago in playlist Phantom of the Opera songs, AMV & more
我比較想聽英文的
e89665 8 months ago
@e89665 他有唱过英文的。10年前。
luoellenluo 1 month ago
这首歌非常漂亮啊!谢谢你上载这个视频。我听过汉语版 :-)
longname25 8 months ago
if you don't like the video, then why the heck would you watch it... -.-
ShinyJewels04 9 months ago 2
怎麼覺得中文的聽起來怪怪的XDDD 我還是習慣聽英文版的!!
費翔扮魅影應該會很帥唷~~~
a30214 9 months ago 3
我覺得 費翔 若扮成魅影也蠻好看
saintways 10 months ago
英文版比較好聽~我不喜歡朱樺的高音 莎拉布萊曼比較好聽 [我在說廢話嗎?她女高音ㄟ!]
我有點疑問 請問一下下 費翔眼睛本來就是藍色的嗎??
shannihorng 10 months ago
@shannihorng
他是台美混血的
Winnie1001100 9 months ago
@shannihorng 費翔是台美混血~~ 所以眼睛是藍色是正常的XDDDD
a30214 9 months ago
@a30214 可是棕色眼睛是显性形状;照理来说费翔的儿子才有50%可能是蓝色眼睛IF他娶了一个蓝眼睛女人。
wssylvia 9 months ago
英文版比較好聽~我不喜歡朱樺的高音 莎拉布萊曼比較好聽 [我在說廢話嗎?她女高音ㄟ!]
shannihorng 10 months ago 2
好怪的說...我都習慣聽英文的..
wpy1998 11 months ago
@wpy1998 的確很怪... 我習慣英文的!
a30214 9 months ago
24 people are just jealous of this epic-ness
Sakura2580 11 months ago 11
很不错吧
你们的谁。。。 唱得比他们好?
哈哈哈!
jorgeac19 1 year ago 2
轉貼囉 讚:)
lea8073 1 year ago
sounds weird, but beautiful. love chinese!!!!!
kavtoM 1 year ago
i love the guys voice...deep and hot...ahhhaa
zakuraziong 1 year ago
嗯~"~
最後那句:唱,為我唱
還是英文的比較有感覺@O@
icexnana 1 year ago
費翔是繼原唱之後我最喜歡的, 很厚的歌聲!!! :)
felixwty2003 1 year ago 3
我覺得還是用英文唱比較有FU~
a30214 1 year ago
我覺得費翔唱的有到位...........
lovesure 1 year ago 2
雞皮疙瘩了..
jacky761321 1 year ago
不錯喔!
比想像中好很多耶!
很難得可以翻唱得那麼好,
歌詞意境也有到喔!!
00980009801 1 year ago
今天剛看DVD~好看
joylin666 1 year ago
害我想到九孔模仿的XD
J41302059 1 year ago 2
That's not the phantom! He doesn't even have a mask!!! -:[
Hyunju87 1 year ago
@Hyunju87 So? He's hot. >:3
CursedBlackRose 1 year ago 3
this one is very nice. I like the expression in their voices. too bad there's no better audio quality
Cielosta 1 year ago
Does anyone else notice that our phantom here has no mask?
Darknecia 1 year ago 26
I so want this song for my iPod!
SMSProductions1 1 year ago 4
When I was about the switch to other video, Kris' voice came out
And I stay till the end
HeartLocker 1 year ago
中英文版好夾,都一樣有意思,有深度,好!!
hohopui3 1 year ago
英文版和中文版好夾,都一樣有意思,有深度!
hohopui3 1 year ago
男的唱很好
女生的部份沒男生好
metak321 1 year ago
It's amazing in Chinese. What a nice language.
Imp1981 1 year ago
@Imp1981, Mandarin sounds a lot nicer than cantonese.
moniequa 1 year ago
@moniequa Not necessarily true. Depends who speaks it. Taiwanese accented Mandarin sounds much much less palatable than the standard HK cantonese. Both languages are actually very singable and can sound great in song. Cantonese in particular sounds very good in choral music, it actually shares a lot of phonemes with germanic languages. Here's an example of a pop song: watch?v=VYGect5mDFQ&feature=search
gariadara 1 year ago
Wow that's really good! I'm so glad the Phantom sounds so good <3
liarakon 1 year ago
I think they're both great but they're more pop than operatic. But either way, they did an excellent job!
musicalphantom2010 1 year ago
Anyone know how can I find the pinyin lyrics for this song??? please let me know... thanks..
jazcastillo 1 year ago
yuanxiaoyi 1 year ago
yuanxiaoyi 1 year ago
yuanxiaoyi 1 year ago
@yuanxiaoyi I wish i could speak chinesse hehehe, but it's not so easy hehe.... sorry i did not answer before, i had not seen your answer.. thank you so much for the lyric,.... is it Mandarin or cantonesse?... than you again... i hope i coul learn a little with this XD
jazcastillo 4 months ago
@jazcastillo It's Mandarin.
luoellenluo 1 month ago
Is this part of a whole movie, or did they just do this one song? I would love to find the whole movie if there is one.
straightarrow372 1 year ago
LET THE HAMMER FALL FROM FLORIDA
iratelyblank 1 year ago
我来自美国。 我讲英语。 这是美丽的。 人员是非常有天才的!
121klin 1 year ago 2
@121klin 谢谢,特地用中文发言:)
yuanxiaoyi 1 year ago
hinese, japanuse, catonese it thesame it sucks!
rokardy01 1 year ago
@rokardy01 So does Spanish
yuanxiaoyi 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
I really like this song by Kris! share with thanks!
jchiu20 1 year ago
I really like this song by Kris! share with thanks!
jchiu20 1 year ago
shan780520 大大,小弟轉貼在我們社群喔
mymagadsl 1 year ago
Troi oi, hay qua!!!
"OMG, it sounds so good !!" in Vietnamese !!!
imagoodgirl18 1 year ago
I love this... it's so beautiful in so many ways! And Kris Phillips is quite a handsome guy.
JennieRose8 1 year ago
為甚麼歌劇魅影變成『夜半魅影』?
Phantom7849 1 year ago
我超喜歡,借我轉貼,謝謝您
joannhsu1 1 year ago
I like them both. Can I use it for my movie clip?(not business stuff, just for myself)
zhipuqian 1 year ago
@zhipuqian It's OK.
shan780520 1 year ago
Thank you very much. 超愛這出劇,還有無其他幾首的中文版?
zhipuqian 1 year ago
沒有
qqq137qqq 1 year ago
我比較喜歡聽英文的= =
ritalovespili 1 year ago
the voice of them are quite well but i still prefer english version...as the english version is the original one
ngtszyu 1 year ago
Which English version? The original Michael Crawford/Sarah Brightman recording or the movie version? I think these two are better singers than the ones on those recordings.
EuphrasieF 1 year ago
*.* !!!
jejjy92 1 year ago
this song is wonderful ^^ I love chinese
Cette chanson est magnifique, j'aime le chinois
TheCoquigirl 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
這樣精典曲子.被唱成這樣真是污辱了安得德魯偉柏才華.慘不忍睹..
fab7a777 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
丹田不夠力...結尾沒有膨湃激昂感染力 無法把現場群眾情緒導引到高點..我這破嗓唱得都比你這病死豬唱法 好太多了 哈哈!!
fab7a777 2 years ago
Kris' Chinese version is just as good as the English one.
Angelah2528 2 years ago
@Angelah2528 no way... Sarah's is way better...
EarThChen 1 year ago
I didn't know Chinese language is so nice! Greetings from Poland !
megi345 2 years ago 41
This has been flagged as spam show
@megi345
The handsome man is Chinese-US mix blood. I'm his fans from young age. now he is already 50 years old but still extremly handsome. You can add my msn vivien423@hotmail.com if you are also a oprea fans..
Violin11tango 9 months ago
what a fantastic video. love the design
Cielosta 2 years ago 3
i like chinese version thaught i prefer english version but i dont think this's just another copy coz it gives some special effect while its in chinese and it is kinda softer more delicate and original is more tender and scary at the times
anyway i like them both very much!!!
xianjinmei7 2 years ago 5
Just a copy version.I prefer in english.
mcwdrew 2 years ago
her voice was beautiful and his voice was great as well but his voice can never compare with how sexy gerard butler's voice NEVER!!
SesshysLady 2 years ago 4
EEEK~
His voice is so sexy for Chinese. X////X
animesweetness6 2 years ago 2
Korean along with this version are my favourite versions of all..
I love the video in this one aswell. <3
HattuSama 2 years ago
Brilliant, an outstanding Asian performance
Tiernarr 2 years ago
雖然和英文的味道不同
我還是喜歡
我也找了很久 終於看到你貼出來
我轉貼囉
多謝呢
sm2661s 2 years ago 4
O-O wow this is amazing!!!
chibimonster123 2 years ago 2
kris philips is just half chinese/ taiwaese right?
KoreanVisualKei 2 years ago
He's half Chinese and Half American
BPFanatico 2 years ago 4
I think this is better than the english version.
tam705618 2 years ago 5
there are many english versions, which one? :)
xvaall 2 years ago
唱的還不錯 不過我覺得 這首歌 用英文來唱 比較能感覺到其中的味道
ckkkkkkkkk 2 years ago 28
他也有唱過英文版的呀:)
shan780520 2 years ago
@ckkkkkkkkk 个人觉得中文的翻译很成功,意境超越英文原版。
borawang008 11 months ago 4
tres belle version de la chanson!
jorjafox88 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
沒唱歌劇金屬可惜 當然最好是東方的
h9e4av 2 years ago
i want to know keris"s blog, who can tell me? 谁能告诉我费翔的博客,facebook,myspace ,youtube,twitter
diorchanellee 2 years ago
Please, someone knows where can i get piying lyrics of this song?? I would like to know how pronunce it.... thanks everyone!!
jazcastillo 2 years ago
Chinese is actually a better language for this song. I wish I knew how to pronounce it. I don't think that Zhu Hua is actually singing the high part though. But you can't blame her, it goes up to the third E above middle C, most people can't hit it.
SopranoOfTheNight 2 years ago
朱樺最后的花腔耍得很漂亮,如果唱得更入戲就更完美了
Season110 2 years ago
@Season110 莎拉的原版才叫完美~~ 不过朱桦也是很好很好的歌唱家
EarThChen 1 year ago
費翔很棒;>
emii0325 2 years ago 4
The chinese phantom is SO HOT!
*fangirl scream*
Apocalypticabitter 2 years ago 4
男主角在愛恨表現不錯(因為他看的到女主角)~但女主角在入戲方面有點不夠~入歌應該是有點茫茫然的唱法~而最後的連續阿音 ~最後的高音是很重要~因為是看到水銀燈掉下來~忽然嚇到的唱法~她的唱法有點太制式的聲樂唱法~不夠入戲
a2318940 2 years ago 3
Comment removed
itcymon 2 years ago
蠻不錯滴
可惜女生低聲音感覺有點太過於低沉哩
wen781366 2 years ago
Kris Philip rocks. He's a pro who sings on broadway.
phasmaserica 2 years ago 2
I wish I could speak Chinese, this is Mandarin Chinese, yes? There is a teacher near me who speaks it fluently, her native language...I wonder if she tutors...
alchemistra 2 years ago 2
高音部份很很很厲害`!
karenyau91106 2 years ago 2
啧,翻译得不错呀!有味。费翔成长了好多,哈哈。
dustguest101 2 years ago 4
Totall agree with you!. I thought the Chinese translated lyrics would be weird, but it is actually elegant and match the melody well.
linyihsian 2 years ago 4
me too! this one is nice
minato6115 2 years ago 2
magnifike
jorjafox88 2 years ago
wonder if vitas does the ending part of the high pitches would be so powerful
limpei1 2 years ago 2
the best
byoncarwen 2 years ago
nice
bloom7733 2 years ago
i agree with tsli1234! :) look Brandon Lee for example :)))
zitazerg 2 years ago
BEAUTIFUL!!!
ritacea 2 years ago
superbe musique que s'est agréable la grande merci de ce moment de douceur saphault
saphault 2 years ago
For some reason pretty much every asian & european mixed person is hot, or better than average, look fei xiang (obviously) and kristen kruek!! I think it's that the best of both are brought together; delicate white people features and slender asian body. Need more eurasian celebs!!!
tsli1234 2 years ago 2
费翔就是帅,那个女的唱的也很好。
blueswilder 2 years ago
great !
wiwbib 3 years ago
Wow, I just watched Phantom in LA... I like this Chinese version very much!
shazbots 3 years ago 2
为啥,费翔的中文这么好。
shanaling 3 years ago
WOW the man sings good!
the woman not bad;)
littlemei 3 years ago 2
He's definitely a better singer than Gerry.
LuigiGodzillaGirl 2 years ago
I would like to hear Jacky Chang and Zhang qing fang singging
asvoriapenxil 3 years ago
Kris Phillips費翔 is so handsome.
rebacca036 3 years ago
the lyrics r soooooooo different
chochang229 3 years ago
I love this song.
erzhs 3 years ago
Fei Xiang is excellent
marksun18 3 years ago 3
Hi. I come from Germany and was the first German Translated for the movie so well found
Oh man, to me, a shower on the back!
That is so nice:)
I have the video a few months (or a year?) Seen ... and then no longer be found.
But now it was before my eyes:)
Thank you, that you've uploaded!
19aqua95 3 years ago
how can it be possible that the phantom isn't wearing the MASK???
Hanueberalles 3 years ago 6
Watch the Dario Argento version. The Phantom in that film has no deformity, and he wears a nasty wig
LuigiGodzillaGirl 2 years ago
Excellent !
PL1044 3 years ago 3
the lyrics are completely different than the original.....
phantomgurl71494 3 years ago
its ok but the lyric suck
sas997 3 years ago
!!! Wspaniałe, muzyka mówi sama za siebie, w jakim by języku nie był śpiewany ten kawałek, zawsze jest świetny.
hooren 3 years ago
zgadzam się ;)
Issobelle17 2 years ago
好彩我味死...
yy2lloveyou 3 years ago
Wow....that was the best one I've heard so far. And the music video wasn't bad either :D
Simba92 3 years ago 2
Ok, this I believe is definetly the best version of the phantom of the opera, and I've heard it in all the other languages.
Kris Philips is very handsome.
secretlyinspired17 3 years ago 3
Is this Mandarin Chinese? Or is it Cantonese?
ExplodingBacon 3 years ago
It's Chinese,not Cantonese.
shan780520 3 years ago
Cantonese is a branch of spoken Chinese. I'm not stupid.
ExplodingBacon 3 years ago
Mandarin Chinese
shan780520 3 years ago
我轉貼去了
感謝你
jimmy3251053 3 years ago
love it! kris is so hot!
natalie32abcd 3 years ago
The girl is astonishingly suitable to play Christine. She has a good voice, innocent, sweet look and did I say she had a good voice?
CoolMapleStore 3 years ago 6
男:在梦魇中的你
可曾疑问假魂似人魅影
女:也假也真
合:旋惑在迷宫里魂魄相缠
这夜半魅影歌声
不停地向你呼唤
女:这迷离夜半魅影歌声
lmgwyxg 3 years ago
我把歌詞po到資訊好了
謝謝你@@..
shan780520 3 years ago
不客气,呵呵
lmgwyxg 3 years ago
lmgwyxg 3 years ago
歌名:歌剧魅影
歌手:费翔
专辑:百老汇经典辑
女:似睡还似乎醒似梦似真
这迷离呼唤声颤动我心
是幽灵还是谁在我身畔
这夜半魅影歌声
不停地向我呼唤
lmgwyxg 3 years ago