Tibet in 49 Seconds - Karsh Kale Interview

[Rhizomio]

Also, if Tibet wasn't annexed by the PLA, the Tibetans would be under Indian or Russian administration. If the Indians had gone in Tibet would still be in abominable poverty, if the Russians had taken over the theocracy would've suffered a similar fate.

We don't live in a world of happy happy fairies. Politics is real.

[MissingVoices77]

Chinese politics for real???

They are one enormous lie!

Ooh please study history and learn about the brutality of the Chinese occupation, there is no excuse for that and the harrasment keeps continuing. You just do not want to see the truth of the Human Rights abuses, Tibet reminds us on the lack of morality we have.

And BTW Tibetans under Indian rule happy and prosper. Also the Tibetans under Chinese rule have the right to be happy.

[MissingVoices77]

Part 1

You could not imagine what it was like for the Tibetans to be occupied by a brutal Chinese regime, You had no idea about the lies of the CCP, no idea about the immense suffering that China successfully tries to hide. If Russia had taken Tibet, Tibet would also have suffered under Stalin, but Tibet would then now already for 20 years be a free country. If India Had Taken Tibet, Tibet would have gained autonomy and cultural and human rights would have been respected.

[MissingVoices77]

Part 2

Even economy would have flourished, like now in India. India is a stable country, China not. China looks stable from the outside,

but the inside is held together by the repressive force of the PLA and the police. I China remains unable to make peace with itself

it will blast!

[Rhizomio]

You've got your head in the sand. And you display the typical double standards of the 'Free TIbet' Brigade, that you consider the death of a Han soldier humourous, yet present yourself as being righteous over the Tibet issue.

I call you out as a hypocrite. I read you as having your mind in a box. The comparison stands, or are you unaware of the spate of violent attacks on Han by Tibetans?

I guess you're a passionate believer in the authenticity of the Nobel Peace Prize too?

I

[Rhizomio]

You're hopelessly deceived if you maintain faith in 'democracy'. It's awfully fashionable to plug some hole in ones identity with some Free Tibet stance, but what do you think the result of DL reclaiming power be? Free and fair elections? No. It'd mean a US military base on the Himalayan plateaux and several high profile mineral extraction contracts going to mostly US and possibly some EU multinationals. And the peasants would once again get to indenture their offspring to their god-king.

[Rhizomio]

Who the hell is Karsh Kale? Big knives and automatic weapons aren't uncommon in Tibet. A couple of weeks ago a group of Tibetans walked past an army barracks and shot a Chinese soldier in the head in Chongqing. If that was Belfast it'd be all over the news. Really peaceful.

[MissingVoices77]

Time to forget your preconceived ideas,

and learn about the sad story of Tibet,

I mean without the CCP propaganda!

[Rhizomio]

I appreciate and respect your view on this matter, however you show a misconception regarding the nature of Chinese politics: it is not a system of legislature rather than one of human relationships, and as such is flawed by definition, however the alternative is totally dehumanised society. Also, although democracy as it is used in Western propaganda is lacking in China, Chinese politicians are demogogues on most issues. If you think that if the CCP lost power all would change, think again.

[MissingVoices77]

CCP might have brought some materialistic prosperity to a few hundred million Chinese, they have the heritage of the biggest murder in human history and the still bring damage to China, the Chinese and the countries they occupy.

If the CCP would stop to exits and democracy would have given a chance a new and brighter future would appear for the Chinese, truthfulness will win of the lies, humanity will win of brutality, love would win of hostility.