@lilyonsan would have to agree with poms1955. This piece was written in the classical period meaning, which ultimately meant the player (while staying close to the tempo) was not restrained to a strict metronomic beat. Pine's interpretation of the piece I think accurately captures the "humor" of the piece, reflecting the depth that is Wieniawski and the professionalism required to perform this piece to the nth degree.
This is so amazing.She plays with such passion and emotion.My daughter is preparing this for her first year exams in the summer 2012 and if she played it 100th as well i would be well pleased.Thank you for giving me so much pleasure as this was a piece i had never heard before.
My only problem with this is that she doesn't seem to follow any concept of tempo with this. That's really only necessary when you have a cadenza or another part without the orchestra. By playing it this way, it seems to me that the movement loses a bit of it's direction and seems to wander on. Now if that's personal input from the player than I guess I really can't argue with her but in my opinion it's poor taste. Other than that her sound is very good and intonation and tone blend really well.
@Lilyonsan I have to disagree with your comments.This piece is perfectly in Tempo with Rubato where required.The piece does meander about and that is how it is written.If you listen to other famous players playing it, it sounds identical (except for their own interpretation of course)I would say her counting and rhthyms are spot on.It is a beautiful and passionate piece and I just adore her interpretation of it.
@poms1955 That's your opinion and I shall respect it. But as for me, I still say that there are many better players and that I don't much care for this version.
I mentioned to my teacher I was amazed at your playing of this piece, and he responded "Rachel Barton Pine? She's one of the best violinists around today."
i enjoy some of the phrasing that she does! probably one of the best versions on youtube. but by far my favorite version of this piece is by joshua bell
Now lets just say that Rachel is the bomb with this piece. She is my girl, I am telling yall man she got it goin on with this wieniawski concerto. I know we probably got some haters in the crowd but people like yall she throw shade to. Rachel girl, these haters that ever come your way aint nothin but some excess rosin off that bow of yours. dust them off flip that hair and keep going girl. Because you are phenomenal.
Woah so the last part, I thought it was awesome that you took those two breaths! It really gives the audience a sense of relief, not that it gets too intense or whatever, but just it makes me feel that there is clarity. And again I really think you have done a Wonderfull Spicatto. That part is really something to brag about haha cuz it takes quite some effort. I got it almost right away, but it is still not as perfect as yours and I practiced a lot =)
WOW. That was the first thing I thought at your entrance. The first F that you played was AMAZING!!!! It was like magic!! Your vibrato is APPALLING and like I LOVE the phrasing, your interpretation of it is totally awesome, and finally, that was a VERY well done and smooth Spicatto =)
This is amazing! I'm playing this piece currently, and for some reason it's very hard for me to get the right sound. Do you have any tips? Or about practicing in general?
i am playing this piece right now and first i didnt know how i should play it. you made it so understandable and imaginable. thankyou so much for such a beautiful music...
I concur that Rachel is a marvelous world class violinist, but
doubt that she (or any truly world class violinist) would claim to be the world's best. As long as Anna Sophie Mutter, Gil Shaham and many other incredible artists perform, there isn't (no should be) any "world's best".
OOPS...mquinnmg, you caught me doing one of my pet peeves...absolute comparisons where they either do not exist or are not warranted... mea culpa... I think what i was trying to say is that she is one of the violinists who I admire and enjoy the most. You are absolutely, 100% right... :)
It's funny to see that you have a chinrest over the tailpiece, because I have it too. And my friends say always that I have a stupid chinrest. Now I can say that I am not the only one!!!
Maravilloso , Ud, toca este concierto muy lindo y con mucha alma y sentimiento, me gusta muchísimo, el sonido es realmente aterciopelado y los fraseos ,parciera que nunca terminaran!!, son hermosísimos!! Una magnífica y sincera interpretación.
that's a strange comment, and it shows possible dispassion for the romatic era. It was the custom of the day to wear the heart on one's sleeve which is an expression to be as open as possible about one's love. Remember, before this period of expression, it was common for people to have their husbands chosen for them by their parents.
you are really good. i loved your humeresque peace. i play as well. and im workin on the bach double. ive got a long way to catch up to you. four years for me so far!! great job:)
extremement musical elle met tout ce qu'il faut pour jouer cette piece tres romantique, j'aime bien les accents spontanement mis dans le jeu et j'aime ca
j'ai joue cette piece et je dois dire que c'est l'une des plus remarquables du repertoires du violon au point ou chaque fois que je ;a joue j'ai un sentiment different de la fois derniere...
Because your performance, this is one of my favorite Violin Concertos. But another top favorite is the Dvorak Violin Concerto, which is rarely performed.
Yes, the Dvorak is a gorgeous piece (even if Joachim never came around to it) ... it was given its U.S. premiere by Maud Powell, who also gave the U.S. premieres of the Tchaikovsky and Sibelius concertos!
I never knew that, about Maud Powell, that is. Say, do you play the Elgar Violin Conceto? (If you don't, you really should.) My violinist friends always say it's bit like the Dvorak in that it's much more difficult than it sounds. Although, it sounds plenty hard to me. Anyhow, I think you're great.
@RachelBartonPine It is nice to hear that someone is to give Credit to one of the first few female American Violinists. I wish I could see her statue just once to be inspired by her. If I remember correctly she gave her debut with the Mendelssohn...Amazing...
what a well articulated, robust, romantic performance, great soul and expressive power--powerhouse performance--I recently sold 85% of my CD'S, but held on to one titled Homage to Sarasate/w/Rachel Barton and Samuel Sanders, that was you, right?-- I need to listen to you more.
One of the most complete performances of the Wieniawski Second. It takes a acutely intellectual mind to bring more than a lot of violin playing to this work. She finds the heart of Wieniawski's musical message to this performance and delivers it wrapped in her luscious tone and seeming effortless technique. Barton Pine, you only get better as time goes by.
This is one of my favorite concerti. I was at one of your performances in Columbia, SC when you played the Brahms, and I really, really enjoyed your cadenza.
Lovely performance Mrs Pine!!I have admired your wonderful musicality and I was blown over with your powerful account account of the Brahms-one of the best I have heard.
That is one mother of a bowing arm !
I bet her Tchaik drowns out the orchestra !!
squeatley 1 week ago
@lilyonsan would have to agree with poms1955. This piece was written in the classical period meaning, which ultimately meant the player (while staying close to the tempo) was not restrained to a strict metronomic beat. Pine's interpretation of the piece I think accurately captures the "humor" of the piece, reflecting the depth that is Wieniawski and the professionalism required to perform this piece to the nth degree.
Stedginator 3 weeks ago
Does she sing as well? :o She looks like a vocalist lol
manjusaka92 1 month ago
This is so amazing.She plays with such passion and emotion.My daughter is preparing this for her first year exams in the summer 2012 and if she played it 100th as well i would be well pleased.Thank you for giving me so much pleasure as this was a piece i had never heard before.
poms1955 2 months ago
My only problem with this is that she doesn't seem to follow any concept of tempo with this. That's really only necessary when you have a cadenza or another part without the orchestra. By playing it this way, it seems to me that the movement loses a bit of it's direction and seems to wander on. Now if that's personal input from the player than I guess I really can't argue with her but in my opinion it's poor taste. Other than that her sound is very good and intonation and tone blend really well.
Lilyonsan 3 months ago
@Lilyonsan I have to disagree with your comments.This piece is perfectly in Tempo with Rubato where required.The piece does meander about and that is how it is written.If you listen to other famous players playing it, it sounds identical (except for their own interpretation of course)I would say her counting and rhthyms are spot on.It is a beautiful and passionate piece and I just adore her interpretation of it.
poms1955 1 month ago
@poms1955 That's your opinion and I shall respect it. But as for me, I still say that there are many better players and that I don't much care for this version.
Lilyonsan 1 month ago
such beautiful, warm playing.
kylamatsuura 4 months ago
This is what i call God given virtuosity that can simply pierce hearts.....what a terrific player.........
yesyesyes310 7 months ago
I mentioned to my teacher I was amazed at your playing of this piece, and he responded "Rachel Barton Pine? She's one of the best violinists around today."
careinn10 8 months ago
Bravo!
geoffroymb 8 months ago
i enjoy some of the phrasing that she does! probably one of the best versions on youtube. but by far my favorite version of this piece is by joshua bell
ATielker 9 months ago
My god, fabulous intonation.
Caramellatta 10 months ago
So warmly played;A Great Performance!!
poicpi
82224561 10 months ago
Your bow control is incredible. You are my new hero.
asdfkathleen 1 year ago
her dress... 0-0
mrsmileyface 1 year ago
who would dislike this this was an awesome performence
villapizza46 1 year ago
Now lets just say that Rachel is the bomb with this piece. She is my girl, I am telling yall man she got it goin on with this wieniawski concerto. I know we probably got some haters in the crowd but people like yall she throw shade to. Rachel girl, these haters that ever come your way aint nothin but some excess rosin off that bow of yours. dust them off flip that hair and keep going girl. Because you are phenomenal.
YNGVIRTUOSOVIOLIST 1 year ago
Woah so the last part, I thought it was awesome that you took those two breaths! It really gives the audience a sense of relief, not that it gets too intense or whatever, but just it makes me feel that there is clarity. And again I really think you have done a Wonderfull Spicatto. That part is really something to brag about haha cuz it takes quite some effort. I got it almost right away, but it is still not as perfect as yours and I practiced a lot =)
I have learned a lot from you thanks!
musicmaniac489 1 year ago
WOW. That was the first thing I thought at your entrance. The first F that you played was AMAZING!!!! It was like magic!! Your vibrato is APPALLING and like I LOVE the phrasing, your interpretation of it is totally awesome, and finally, that was a VERY well done and smooth Spicatto =)
Thank you for the wonderful video!
musicmaniac489 1 year ago
It is rare that someone today "moves" me and you did a good job.
tonyromachavo 1 year ago
This is amazing! I'm playing this piece currently, and for some reason it's very hard for me to get the right sound. Do you have any tips? Or about practicing in general?
xxViolinrocksxx 1 year ago
Amazingly wonderful....
DrLuu1972 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
this is very gay to watch
huntercross14 1 year ago
i am playing this piece right now and first i didnt know how i should play it. you made it so understandable and imaginable. thankyou so much for such a beautiful music...
this is one of my favourite too...
khushy1990 1 year ago
wow it sounds beautiful, but the violinist moves like a rockstar lol.
lee4ivy 1 year ago
its very good but i still prefer shahams recording of this concerto
zander09401 2 years ago
it's very good, but the performance by Rabin seems to be on a different level.
potatoesaugratin 2 years ago
@potatoesaugratin Totally agree.
TheViolinCase 2 years ago
Certified Intergalactic! Superb virtuosity! Love you, Rachel Barton Pine!
Dogaradodia 2 years ago
Simply amazing
Instas 2 years ago
Rachel is quite simply the finest living violinist.
bckm54 2 years ago 5
I concur that Rachel is a marvelous world class violinist, but
doubt that she (or any truly world class violinist) would claim to be the world's best. As long as Anna Sophie Mutter, Gil Shaham and many other incredible artists perform, there isn't (no should be) any "world's best".
mquinnmg 2 years ago 2
OOPS...mquinnmg, you caught me doing one of my pet peeves...absolute comparisons where they either do not exist or are not warranted... mea culpa... I think what i was trying to say is that she is one of the violinists who I admire and enjoy the most. You are absolutely, 100% right... :)
bckm54 2 years ago
im glad you didn't mention joshua belle hehe
SpoonsForks 2 years ago
Ah, a woman.
ladyEulaelie 2 years ago 3
magnificent
themusicdr 2 years ago
DOnna di singolare bruttezza.... :S brava, anzi bravissima....ma proprio brutta... :S
grandecoglion 2 years ago
ma come si fa a lasciare un commento del genere? il nickname che ti sei scelto e' proprio adatto.
formaggioneone 2 years ago 2
già! XD anke il tuo nn è male comunque XD...
grandecoglion 2 years ago
La Brutta sei tu, Signora Grandecoglion. Non ti vergogni?
assindiastignani 2 years ago
neanke un po'... :D
grandecoglion 2 years ago
Che brava!
assindiastignani 2 years ago
i am learning this piece at the moment... and what can I say about this performance? she makes it look so easy, Utterly superb!
ViolinSpaz 2 years ago 3
Excellent. A superb performance by Ms Pine. What more can I say?
lxz1111 2 years ago 3
Bravo - Bravo, bravissimo !
dalmarkpl 2 years ago
Rachel gives fantastic expression to this evergreen work. A shame that the orchestra were not together!
3mikewright3 2 years ago 3
A very interesting interpretation. Well done.
BurkeSorenson 2 years ago 3
An absolutely beautiful performance
54spiritedwill54 3 years ago 3
Remarkable is status quo for you Rachel.
Thanks so much for sharing these wonderful videos with us...they are very much appreciated!
OriginalMoonbeam 3 years ago 2
her dress..so big..
asilelis4 3 years ago
she is my friend on face book
YNGVIRTUOSOVIOLIST 3 years ago
Certified Intergalactic! The best live performance of Wieniawski's Concerto #2 ever caught on camera. Bravissima, Rachel! I'm forever your fan.
Dogaradodia 3 years ago
I wonder if she was rushing a little some areas....Hmmmm... Oh well she is great though
angelachae 3 years ago
wasn't she rushing a little in some areas???
angelachae 3 years ago
Is really fantastic...
FangirlN1 3 years ago 2
Truly one of the masters of our time! By the way how do you like Jans violins?
thekingthut 3 years ago
Brava! Very well done!
It's funny to see that you have a chinrest over the tailpiece, because I have it too. And my friends say always that I have a stupid chinrest. Now I can say that I am not the only one!!!
wubbie12 3 years ago
whats wrong with the orchestra? they're out of tune and not following the soloist!
jnewburger 3 years ago 3
Beautiful playing! Would it be at all possible to upload the 3rd movement? Even if you can't thank you for these great recordings
lachnessmonster1 3 years ago
I love the passion in your playing. Its like you are telling a story^^
gbritaney 3 years ago 3
I have the shudders this is so good
fiddlinmatt 3 years ago 2
Magnífica técnica e interpretación, sin duda ¡genial!
manoloff1110 3 years ago
Hi! you're very good ! This piece is difficult, what level is it? I play violin and I want play this piece
thanks
katheex93 3 years ago
it´s a really high level;)
Bene8989 3 years ago 2
Rachel Barton SALUDOS DESDE VENEZUELA NOSE SI ME ENTIENDES PERO ERES LA MEJOR YO ESTUDIO ESCUCHANDO TU MUSICA.......EXITO!!!!!!!
raymondunder 3 years ago
Brava!!!
violinorosso 3 years ago
this orchestra really sucks; rachel is too good to play with this low a level orchestra
th0ma5laxc 3 years ago
Maravilloso , Ud, toca este concierto muy lindo y con mucha alma y sentimiento, me gusta muchísimo, el sonido es realmente aterciopelado y los fraseos ,parciera que nunca terminaran!!, son hermosísimos!! Una magnífica y sincera interpretación.
Felicitaciones
climmenestras 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
I still can't understand how in a piece every note would like to say something
melomansarasatiste 4 years ago
that's a strange comment, and it shows possible dispassion for the romatic era. It was the custom of the day to wear the heart on one's sleeve which is an expression to be as open as possible about one's love. Remember, before this period of expression, it was common for people to have their husbands chosen for them by their parents.
violdick 3 years ago 3
wonderful phrasing. you certainly did Wieniawski justice by playing this concerto. congragulations!
Nanotekx 4 years ago 6
lovely!!!!!!!
Where did u studied?
CuciucGriga 4 years ago
An absolutely beautiful performance
cchamp27 4 years ago 2
you are really good. i loved your humeresque peace. i play as well. and im workin on the bach double. ive got a long way to catch up to you. four years for me so far!! great job:)
sportsfan1937 4 years ago
anyone that spells piece that way ....probably doesn't have that much musical experience!
gwyn15 3 years ago
anyone who comments on someone's choice of spelling is a real bitch.
sportsfan1937 3 years ago 10
@sportsfan1937 asdaf
zZzPBZzZZ 1 month ago
BRRRRRRRRAAAAAAAAAAVVVVVVOOOOOOOOO™™™©‘ìï
zZzPBZzZZ 1 month ago 2
extremement musical elle met tout ce qu'il faut pour jouer cette piece tres romantique, j'aime bien les accents spontanement mis dans le jeu et j'aime ca
j'ai joue cette piece et je dois dire que c'est l'une des plus remarquables du repertoires du violon au point ou chaque fois que je ;a joue j'ai un sentiment different de la fois derniere...
melomansarasatiste 4 years ago 2
Wonderful performance.
dandan321 4 years ago 2
Because your performance, this is one of my favorite Violin Concertos. But another top favorite is the Dvorak Violin Concerto, which is rarely performed.
shapirojoe 4 years ago 7
Yes, the Dvorak is a gorgeous piece (even if Joachim never came around to it) ... it was given its U.S. premiere by Maud Powell, who also gave the U.S. premieres of the Tchaikovsky and Sibelius concertos!
RachelBartonPine 4 years ago
I never knew that, about Maud Powell, that is. Say, do you play the Elgar Violin Conceto? (If you don't, you really should.) My violinist friends always say it's bit like the Dvorak in that it's much more difficult than it sounds. Although, it sounds plenty hard to me. Anyhow, I think you're great.
assindiastignani 2 years ago
@RachelBartonPine It is nice to hear that someone is to give Credit to one of the first few female American Violinists. I wish I could see her statue just once to be inspired by her. If I remember correctly she gave her debut with the Mendelssohn...Amazing...
grihdalli 9 months ago
BRAVO!!!!!!!!
Beautiful, elegant performance of one of my fav. concertos.
Ms. Pine, you've done it justice- hope to see more clips of yours soon.
2ndAveLine 4 years ago 3
what a well articulated, robust, romantic performance, great soul and expressive power--powerhouse performance--I recently sold 85% of my CD'S, but held on to one titled Homage to Sarasate/w/Rachel Barton and Samuel Sanders, that was you, right?-- I need to listen to you more.
gawgul 4 years ago
i liked your playing, wonderful sounding fiddle also
scottbos68 4 years ago
Spectacular!!!!
ViolinCyndee 4 years ago
One of the most complete performances of the Wieniawski Second. It takes a acutely intellectual mind to bring more than a lot of violin playing to this work. She finds the heart of Wieniawski's musical message to this performance and delivers it wrapped in her luscious tone and seeming effortless technique. Barton Pine, you only get better as time goes by.
Hachechulo 4 years ago
This is one of my favorite concerti. I was at one of your performances in Columbia, SC when you played the Brahms, and I really, really enjoyed your cadenza.
ztefieh 4 years ago
I love this performance, great. It is really close to my own concept of this concerto.
Laruuu 4 years ago 2
Really nice performance.
liviern3 4 years ago 2
Lovely performance Mrs Pine!!I have admired your wonderful musicality and I was blown over with your powerful account account of the Brahms-one of the best I have heard.
Brava!!
Alessia
alned676 4 years ago 2