@RachelLeatherman Maybe they like the song/performance, but it's the quality of the upload that they disliked....just an opinion...I don't have a prob with it, but some people dislike for that reason.
I appreciate the track the most when both Waters and Gilmour do their respective vocals. Waters: " Hello..is there anybody in there....ok just a little pin prick" Gilmour: "There is no pain ..you are receding...". Some effect of these lines and of the track isn't there when either one is absent. What a pity! This was probably their last show together.
i ha never heared a live performing as fresh and as good ,every time you hear it you feel that you hear it for the first time,as you all said guys this is the real Music,,david gllimour ofcourse have a unique amazing Voice , irreplacable Band.
Waters teamed with Gilmour and the other band to write this song. Greatest Floyd song ever in my opinion. Gilmour is a better singer than Waters. My favorite band PERIOD
I think he is. When people name guitar greats, they usually name Eddie Van Halen, Jimi Hendrix, etc etc. There are a few that list him, but people tend to forget his name with the other greats. They also forget that he was far more influential, in that he along with the rest of the band, created an all new guitar sound, that is still used today (The Mars Volta).
I veri Pink Floyd non esisteranno più. Con la morte di Wright sono diventati una entità,non sono più una band.Sono nel Nirvana della musica.E l'ultimo solo qui è mostruoso;Gilmour e la band ci hanno messo tutto ciò che potevano in questa performance
Seeing them all together gets me teary too. There are a lot of great bands out there, past and present, but none of them moved me as much as Pink Floyd. Thanks guys from the bottom of my heart
david contributed a lot to Pink Floyd, He is a man with low profile eventhough that He is just a replacement to original floyd (syd barret RIP) but he really loved the group by continuing it even in the absence of Roger Waters, but we can't denied it that in the absence of waters the band ain't no longer played the same old stuff like animals, ummagumma because it comes from the psychedelic imagination of WATERS. I really love this band
i like gilmour because of his low profile attitude unlike others there who are boastful. Gilmour is the best guitarist of all time. simple man with a wonderful talent.
NO that is the best guitar solo ever! I have played the guitar for over 30 years and Dave Gilmour can say more with the guitar than anyone living or dead. He make the guitar sing as no one else can. He is the man.
this is the song the people that voted for him sing. Thats because us free folks got to comfortable with our own thing...now I have to support them while they sing this wonderful song.
Richard,ricordati che resterai sempre nel mio cuore e in quello di tutti quelli come me a cui hai cambiato la vita con la tua musica.... Grazie per tutto quello che hai fatto con questi ragazzi... Non ti dimenticheremo mai... Riposa in pace lassù nell'olimpo dei miti e delizia gli angeli con i tuoi dolci accordi...
ah ! right, did you know that Gilmour said once in an interview that the only thing that would make him feel bad/sad about his career is that he always dream to be on the quarter ? And those guys were friends 'till these days, u can see many videos of Gilmour playing on McCartney stuff.? ;)
I think floyd n' beatles are the best bands on earth. By the way, SOYCD,Echoes, WYWH are FAR away better than Yellow Submarine. but, A Day in the Life, I want you, while my guitar gently weeps,Yer Blues and many other beatles songs are FAR away better than some final cut stuff,or AMLOR stuff. Some jackass still think that the beatles are just those yeah's & yesterday. That style was just good, but the forward to revolver just blow the music meaning.
I'm 51 years old,a big Floyd fan,have all their albums,but I must say I really didn't like anything on "The Final Cut".Which one's Pink? David Gilmour of course!
i'm 14 years old,a big floyd fan, i have most of there albums but i also didnt like anything on the final cut except maybe "when the tigers broke free" .Which one's pink? that would be syd barret
For me Roger Waters is Pink, at least in the The Wall film, Pink as played by Geldof was a character created by Waters with strong links to his own life. Apart from that Waters was the creative force behind virtually all Floyds best works
ha ha ha the beatles? for deth people is good because they fortunatly can't hear nothing.uncompereble with the floyds.if you put the beatles to some babies to listen they will cry at once for the horror they hear.
David Gilmour is an exemplary musician. His timing, his tone, his simple authority on stage with regards to the music are second to none. I saw Pink Floyd's Pulse tour in 1994 (unfortunately without Waters) and it was a a PURE example of production perfection. Waters is a great lyricist and offers some musical cues too, and Gilmour is a great musician and offers his own lyrical cues that cannot be forgotten. I only wish to see both together again as their artistic union is unparalleled.
you cant compare early beatles stuff with pink floyd tho,i prefer pink floyd, but you shud be comparing them with the white album and sgt peppers,not the early gay lord crap
Best, well it depends what's s best for ya. Beatles is commercial music. Pink Floyd has nothing of commercial in their music. Lyrics, well, the Floyd is a very different thing. You can't compare " I wanna hold your hands" with "And if the band you're in starts playing different tunes, I'll see you in the dark side of the moon"
pink floyd's music is probably the most satisfying music i've ever listened too.. my ears feel.. full. The beatles were great and are respected but I honestly believe that floyd has them, beyond any reach or leap.. their music is so in depth that it is almost always beyond words.
Simply Amazing Awesome ....Electrifying....Wish Roger Waters joins Pink Floyd back again and once again there will be another Dark Side Of The Moon by them.
Hei guys! The most important is the music from them!!! These guys are good togheter!! It is enough!!! Remember: ... divide we fall, togheter we stand!
a tu abuelo le encanta succionar jugos orgánicos de aparatos reproductores masculinos, y es tan bueno haciendolo que te heredó los genes, y tu continuas su labor, roliberio de mamahuevo
There are people that I think should be given a second life. These guys are now 60 and you can see they still have sooo many things to give and add to music today. They are simple outstanding. Perfect! I hoped they live for another 100 years!
I was watching this on the BBC unfold and I was constantly going "Will they, won't they?" and then they played that epic Bm chord and I was on cloud nine.
THIS is what music was invented for! This is THE reason Live 8 was a success! This IS music! Nearly cried when I watched them perform together for the first time in my lifetime! Its just amazing. =D
Pink Floyd, may you settle your differences and return to give us the music that we know and love so much. It was worth crying when they did this performance. I am 13 and am totally transfixed by the phenomenon that is Pink Floyd. May they never be forgotten.
I was there! I went out to London just to see this. And let me tell you, this was the highlight of the show. I cried when they started Breathe, and the atmosphere was electric the whole time they were playing.
la suerte de los que pudieron estar ahi..!!! :D tremendo tema!! tremenda banda!
xpozo 4 days ago
Can you feel this like me?
BecomingTheBull2 2 weeks ago
what a lucky git i am,i was there,6th time ive seen them,and as always,awesome
CornishCockney 4 weeks ago
<3
foxxcofe16 1 month ago
Even Chuck Norris is in awe when he hears this
LikingTrains12345678 1 month ago
Awesum
ayotteted 1 month ago
Who is the ass hat that disliked this thing?
RachelLeatherman 1 month ago
@RachelLeatherman Maybe they like the song/performance, but it's the quality of the upload that they disliked....just an opinion...I don't have a prob with it, but some people dislike for that reason.
wondrinminstrel 1 month ago
that's the way a Rock band sounds, during David's solo is like 'ok boys let's go to work'. Pink Floyd, we are so lucky to witness this.
firulais1967 1 month ago
1 idiot think what justin bieber make's good Music
HecktorMedina 2 months ago 2
I would have loved to have been there!!!
Deathsbreed 3 months ago
The best guitar solos in the world!!! (right next to the guitar solo of "brothers in arms" by dire straits).
Deathsbreed 3 months ago
obviously one guy never heard of a guitar.. what a no talent nerd.. who would DISlike this lmao
Scapers091 3 months ago
what do you say? comments? wtf do I say?!
apothead 3 months ago
David Gilmour Is A LEGEND!
tgd345 3 months ago
Gilmour=Real Guitar Hero
crookhunter 1 year ago
See that children? That's how you play a guitar.
VanDoodah 1 year ago 5
@VanDoodah and y did u point it directly to the children as if all children lack talent?
AnthonyTheChaptini 1 year ago
@AnthonyTheChaptini Because most are obsessed with shredding.
VanDoodah 1 year ago
I love this song
megakac 1 year ago
excellent!
recoverysoon 1 year ago 2
mason took his headphones off to hear the solo :))
Esperu2008 1 year ago 3
tears
midnightwiththestars 1 year ago
FUCKIN' AMAZING SOLOOOOOO!!!!!!!!!!!!!
JusticieroDeLaMuerte 1 year ago 2
Awesome. David gilmour, guitar genius. Enough said.
FrankieM1974 1 year ago 2
Grazie di tutto quello che mi avete dato e avete dato con la vostra musica divina
MrRedrum91 1 year ago
Great to see them together again! Thanks for the upload!
Peart2112 1 year ago
I appreciate the track the most when both Waters and Gilmour do their respective vocals. Waters: " Hello..is there anybody in there....ok just a little pin prick" Gilmour: "There is no pain ..you are receding...". Some effect of these lines and of the track isn't there when either one is absent. What a pity! This was probably their last show together.
abirphukan 1 year ago
i ha never heared a live performing as fresh and as good ,every time you hear it you feel that you hear it for the first time,as you all said guys this is the real Music,,david gllimour ofcourse have a unique amazing Voice , irreplacable Band.
hopemaker2005 2 years ago 2
Take a good look. Listen closely. This is music.
HKAdmin 2 years ago 8
BANDS THESE DAYS DONT COME CLOSE
SOUNDCHASERX 2 years ago 8
Waters teamed with Gilmour and the other band to write this song. Greatest Floyd song ever in my opinion. Gilmour is a better singer than Waters. My favorite band PERIOD
annuitcoeptus 2 years ago
Pink Floyd is the best band of all time. No question in my mind. I got to see them live on the Division Bell tour. Absolutely amazing
annuitcoeptus 2 years ago 4
Most amazing solo ever :'( I always burst into tears
all3gra 2 years ago 2
I know what you mean. This is what music is all about
annuitcoeptus 2 years ago
MAN
ya just dont want this to finish
0MoD 2 years ago
I think he is. When people name guitar greats, they usually name Eddie Van Halen, Jimi Hendrix, etc etc. There are a few that list him, but people tend to forget his name with the other greats. They also forget that he was far more influential, in that he along with the rest of the band, created an all new guitar sound, that is still used today (The Mars Volta).
GeneralKenobiSIYE 2 years ago
'there is no pain, you are receding," not bad for two guys who hadn't spoken in over 15 years.
houstonveer 2 years ago
j'ADORE LA DANSEUSE
oxfordeddie 2 years ago
Gods.
grandpaegg 2 years ago 4
That's still the world's best guitar solo, and probably always will be. :)
Yownanymous 2 years ago 44
Comment removed
changilwick 2 years ago
@Yownanymous I hear these solo every time my phone ring....and every time is an emotion. thanx god for give us David
elettrolanzo 1 month ago
@Yownanymous Stairway to Heaven: Excuse me? xD
VicenteNewsted 1 month ago
I veri Pink Floyd non esisteranno più. Con la morte di Wright sono diventati una entità,non sono più una band.Sono nel Nirvana della musica.E l'ultimo solo qui è mostruoso;Gilmour e la band ci hanno messo tutto ciò che potevano in questa performance
gillanaro 2 years ago 2
ø¤º°¨„ø¤º°¨°º¤ø„¸¨°º¤ø„¸¸„ º¤ø„¸
¨°º¤ø„ ¸ PINK FLOYD FOREVERº¤ø„¸
¸„ø¤º°¨¸„ø¤º „¸¨°º¤ø„¸¸„ ¸„ø¤º from ITALY
silvio372 2 years ago 5
fantastic
frankfurtpalsterrass 2 years ago 3
yeah i have to admit, when i see the guys back together , and having a blast , i choke back the tears,
0MoD 2 years ago 23
ragazzi qua si sfiora il divino!
maxedmax 2 years ago
è il divino.
Apvlia 2 years ago 3
Seeing them all together gets me teary too. There are a lot of great bands out there, past and present, but none of them moved me as much as Pink Floyd. Thanks guys from the bottom of my heart
Brrrrr43 2 years ago 7
Fuck yeah Floyd live LA 1980 The Wall was smokin good....
jimmybfan 2 years ago
never mind the voices, listen to BOTH experts on the strings , even the drummer admires it lol
0MoD 3 years ago 4
che assolo ragazzi
eddymendoza37 3 years ago 2
jop-jop
eddymendoza37 3 years ago
i love this song.. i was playin along to the song on bass and started singing rogers verses.. i really got into it especially during the outro solo
TerminatorX101 3 years ago 2
Oh god Waters voice is done !!!
jethronb 3 years ago
I thought the same too...but gilmour still has it in him
harri1955 3 years ago 3
david gilmour is last prophet...
ferhatinho 3 years ago
david contributed a lot to Pink Floyd, He is a man with low profile eventhough that He is just a replacement to original floyd (syd barret RIP) but he really loved the group by continuing it even in the absence of Roger Waters, but we can't denied it that in the absence of waters the band ain't no longer played the same old stuff like animals, ummagumma because it comes from the psychedelic imagination of WATERS. I really love this band
gpaz73 3 years ago
i like gilmour because of his low profile attitude unlike others there who are boastful. Gilmour is the best guitarist of all time. simple man with a wonderful talent.
gpaz73 3 years ago 3
sarete x sempre l orgoglio della musica mondiale.grazie pink.
batti27 3 years ago
4:35 greatest solo ever!!!
Danrod161184 3 years ago 2
NO that is the best guitar solo ever! I have played the guitar for over 30 years and Dave Gilmour can say more with the guitar than anyone living or dead. He make the guitar sing as no one else can. He is the man.
therealgunslinger 3 years ago 2
Probably the greatest guitar solo ever!!
ChanceCooper125 3 years ago 2
When I was a child, I had a fever...la forza e la leggerezza di questo brano sono uniche...
Una delle band più signifocative del secolo trascorso...
anticlimacus81 3 years ago
this should be the theme song of the Obama presidency.
MVRWC 3 years ago
haha..that is for sure!
ladycandor 3 years ago
No, it would be a shame if Pink Floyd were associated with all that shit, especially when Obama is pro abortion.
1091Floyd21 3 years ago
Oh man. You have got to be kidding!
muffler48 3 years ago
this is the song the people that voted for him sing. Thats because us free folks got to comfortable with our own thing...now I have to support them while they sing this wonderful song.
grnprn 3 years ago
thak you pink floyd this song its amazing
clixtap 3 years ago
JUST A BEAUTIFUL SONG
wutzupmyboy 3 years ago 3
Fantastic! RIP to an excellent artist
akerman79 3 years ago 4
un grande GRAZIE e un triste ADDIO
target973 3 years ago 3
lissnin' n' cryin' 4 u rick, thank you
thi3fz 3 years ago 3
Richard,ricordati che resterai sempre nel mio cuore e in quello di tutti quelli come me a cui hai cambiato la vita con la tua musica.... Grazie per tutto quello che hai fatto con questi ragazzi... Non ti dimenticheremo mai... Riposa in pace lassù nell'olimpo dei miti e delizia gli angeli con i tuoi dolci accordi...
gilmouryork 3 years ago
thank you richard for all you have don to pink floyd and music.
RIP
FORESTDONS 3 years ago 2
this is for richard !!Thanks Rick
erpenguin 3 years ago 4
It's a shame what happened to Rick Wright.
Even though all of them never spoke about a true reunion , now that will never happen...
Richard Wright.
Rest in peace.
BrunoEggert 3 years ago 3
I'm cryin, I'm really cryin...I can't explain...you wouldn't understand....
SUPERSTEREO666 3 years ago 5
this band has changed my mind...
maxarus 3 years ago 4
I love this song. I'm not a big fan of the Division Bell.
eathompson13 3 years ago
it's from The Wall, anyway.
maxarus 3 years ago 4
Will we see it again?
bluesbrother37 3 years ago 2
great gilmour
erpenguin 3 years ago
just perfect!
FloydianSinan 4 years ago
wish i were there
PFLOYD33 4 years ago 2
Oh my God!!!!!! This picture at 7:13 is really priceless!
Sifis0308 4 years ago 3
the best solo ever... lost for words
jesusgalaad 4 years ago
Comfortably song..
4erosmith 4 years ago
Simply the best of all times!!
sandramanoel 4 years ago
one of the best solos ever!!!!!!!
stratoKeith 4 years ago 4
bellissima canzone
spank72xx 4 years ago
Why did I not go to that? ;_; I feel sad now..
ForceUser 4 years ago 3
Age-less, time-less a cornerstone. Excellent.
whirlpoolzend 4 years ago 5
ah ! right, did you know that Gilmour said once in an interview that the only thing that would make him feel bad/sad about his career is that he always dream to be on the quarter ? And those guys were friends 'till these days, u can see many videos of Gilmour playing on McCartney stuff.? ;)
whoispink 4 years ago
I think floyd n' beatles are the best bands on earth. By the way, SOYCD,Echoes, WYWH are FAR away better than Yellow Submarine. but, A Day in the Life, I want you, while my guitar gently weeps,Yer Blues and many other beatles songs are FAR away better than some final cut stuff,or AMLOR stuff. Some jackass still think that the beatles are just those yeah's & yesterday. That style was just good, but the forward to revolver just blow the music meaning.
whoispink 4 years ago
I'm 51 years old,a big Floyd fan,have all their albums,but I must say I really didn't like anything on "The Final Cut".Which one's Pink? David Gilmour of course!
otherdog59 4 years ago
pink was syd barret
kubrickfan3 3 years ago
Syd was not Pink ^_^
Stan
StanMark 3 years ago
i'm 14 years old,a big floyd fan, i have most of there albums but i also didnt like anything on the final cut except maybe "when the tigers broke free" .Which one's pink? that would be syd barret
kubrickfan3 3 years ago
PINK ANDERSON & FLOYD COUNCIL.
Two blues men from the U.S. gave young Syd Barrett a fling of divine inspiration and named a psychedelic rock band from Britain,PINK FLOYD.
Stan
StanMark 3 years ago 3
i meant metaphorically
kubrickfan3 3 years ago 2
For me Roger Waters is Pink, at least in the The Wall film, Pink as played by Geldof was a character created by Waters with strong links to his own life. Apart from that Waters was the creative force behind virtually all Floyds best works
EFCthebest 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
that black chick is like tone deaf and sucks!
donut33333 4 years ago
ha ha ha the beatles? for deth people is good because they fortunatly can't hear nothing.uncompereble with the floyds.if you put the beatles to some babies to listen they will cry at once for the horror they hear.
zlatkocro 4 years ago
David Gilmour's musicianship in Pink Floyd alone is far superior to all four Beatles put together PLUS Oasis.
That's an understatement!!!
Rabidsenses 4 years ago
man no!! haha
Oasis sux ass, please dont put them next to Floyd or Beatles.
much respect for Beatles and Floyd
opethera 4 years ago
David Gilmour is an exemplary musician. His timing, his tone, his simple authority on stage with regards to the music are second to none. I saw Pink Floyd's Pulse tour in 1994 (unfortunately without Waters) and it was a a PURE example of production perfection. Waters is a great lyricist and offers some musical cues too, and Gilmour is a great musician and offers his own lyrical cues that cannot be forgotten. I only wish to see both together again as their artistic union is unparalleled.
Rabidsenses 4 years ago 3
you cant compare early beatles stuff with pink floyd tho,i prefer pink floyd, but you shud be comparing them with the white album and sgt peppers,not the early gay lord crap
PaoloVII 4 years ago
Best, well it depends what's s best for ya. Beatles is commercial music. Pink Floyd has nothing of commercial in their music. Lyrics, well, the Floyd is a very different thing. You can't compare " I wanna hold your hands" with "And if the band you're in starts playing different tunes, I'll see you in the dark side of the moon"
RTCWMavericK 4 years ago
did you know that shine on you crazy dimond spells syd barrett's first name if you take the first letter from every other word
lloydyboy94 4 years ago
pink floyd's music is probably the most satisfying music i've ever listened too.. my ears feel.. full. The beatles were great and are respected but I honestly believe that floyd has them, beyond any reach or leap.. their music is so in depth that it is almost always beyond words.
bassman26 4 years ago 2
Floyd better than the Beatles? I hope there's a cure for tone deafness!!
duffersfan 4 years ago
Simply Amazing Awesome ....Electrifying....Wish Roger Waters joins Pink Floyd back again and once again there will be another Dark Side Of The Moon by them.
delicatethunder 4 years ago
Pink Floyd ROCKED all the poverty out of Africa!!!!
icecoldhubbas 5 years ago
If only that were true...
PQleyR 4 years ago
i wish someday they realize that they should reunite. We REALLY miss the classic lineup...
KaragouniS13 4 years ago
No they didn't.
markdr123 4 years ago
AMAZING !!! AMAZING!!!! AMAZING!!! Pink Floyd will live forever in our minds, no other band has done what they've done. The Best....
T.P.
tportillo 5 years ago
Hei guys! The most important is the music from them!!! These guys are good togheter!! It is enough!!! Remember: ... divide we fall, togheter we stand!
frantecar 5 years ago
Thanks for uploading.
Pink Floyd were an amazing band.
Few bands will be talked about once this century has past.
and they are one of them.
bezerker4828 5 years ago
simply the best.. cant wait to see waters at the mgm in las vegas!
aao83 5 years ago
You right...I saw Rogers concert in June 2006 in Israel and it was an awesome show !!!
StanMark 5 years ago
CojonUUUUUdos!con perdón
foxtiefirst 5 years ago
Dude....keep smoking shit.
jimmywrangles 5 years ago
incredible
samthemanisthebest 5 years ago
America invented Rock and Roll... Britain perfected it
cyclonedrums 5 years ago
David Gilmour is better singer than Roger.
torrance7 5 years ago
you'r a retard
bookfloor 5 years ago
a tu abuelo le encanta succionar jugos orgánicos de aparatos reproductores masculinos, y es tan bueno haciendolo que te heredó los genes, y tu continuas su labor, roliberio de mamahuevo
torrance7 4 years ago
omg...most amazing song ever from the most amazing band....this is the type of stuff that will be talked about 1000 years from now
gayatri91192 5 years ago
Dude, stop smoking shit.
EternalLifeForYou 5 years ago
like the old times
Zaul2410 5 years ago
thank you
billyfionamcm 5 years ago
There are people that I think should be given a second life. These guys are now 60 and you can see they still have sooo many things to give and add to music today. They are simple outstanding. Perfect! I hoped they live for another 100 years!
arg0nauta 5 years ago
Wow~ Couldnt stop watching this one...well done!
Sueski2 5 years ago
simply wonderful... the best band of the world!
betankurt 5 years ago
I saw that guitar before... over 80's jojo (mi ingles es malardo jojo)
wandusky 5 years ago
roger is having such a good time.. why dont they tour once more!!
dwr6075 5 years ago
Thanks Guys for your Comments ;-)
StanMark 5 years ago
totally spine tingling
03090221 5 years ago
I was watching this on the BBC unfold and I was constantly going "Will they, won't they?" and then they played that epic Bm chord and I was on cloud nine.
WouterJ 5 years ago
I was totally the same
telecasterthommy 4 years ago
2 words,awe-some.
zombieleader 5 years ago
and legendary again ...
bigmachine 5 years ago
THIS is what music was invented for! This is THE reason Live 8 was a success! This IS music! Nearly cried when I watched them perform together for the first time in my lifetime! Its just amazing. =D
gabjam 5 years ago
Divinissime...
guipsycho 5 years ago
Pink Floyd, may you settle your differences and return to give us the music that we know and love so much. It was worth crying when they did this performance. I am 13 and am totally transfixed by the phenomenon that is Pink Floyd. May they never be forgotten.
Yours,
cdgw
cdgw 5 years ago
I was there! I went out to London just to see this. And let me tell you, this was the highlight of the show. I cried when they started Breathe, and the atmosphere was electric the whole time they were playing.
gtrmu 5 years ago
greatest rock song ever written, and greatest solo, its above everything
spikezula 5 years ago 2
PWNAGE!
FootballFan13 5 years ago
It's good to see them once and for all!
thuynganc 5 years ago 2
pink floyd thats it
rockdier 5 years ago
brilliant!
duckie1313 5 years ago