Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (426)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • Guys, this was (I think) the first time she ever sing live. It was years ago and she has improved a lot. You guys should think about how much effort has she put on her work before saying she's terrible. Love you, Sel!

  • This wasn't one of her really good performances but that doesn't mean she can't sing

  • I think Selena Gomez is a very talented singer, this just wasn't her best performance.. I still love Sel tho!!! #NoH8

  • what does t mean by private concert?

  • miley and demi are a whole lot better then that fame whore , sorry if i offend anybody , but its true lol . but kudos its her first concert duhh

  • omg x(

  • selenas mic is low,,,so she should still be able to sing louder so it wouldnt matter?/

  • SELENA IS THE BEST THIS IS HER FIRST CONCERT CHILL OUT GOSHH

  • @otheriKiley dis is not her first concert she did other concerts before duhh

  • Comment removed

  • @cherrygirl47100 Look at her singing lessons video, she DOES can sing the fast part, don't you talk if you DON't Know, thank you...

  • @Msjazie59 she cant sing da high notes nd the singing lessons r differant she should not do da sngs she is doing now she should do low notes nd u could her onstage shes awful da mic is low cuz den dey wont hear voice its a trick

  • oh holy shit! she sucks! big time!!

  • selena is the hottest. thats all i have to say

  • Ya anyone comparing Selena to Miley just because of the shorts is retarded. Selena isn't emulating stripper pole moves and pretending to make out with girls on stage. *sigh* what i wouldn't give to see her live... probably never happen tho. Too many things going on for her to do a coast to coast tour. :'(

  • Ya anyone comparing Selena to Miley just because of the shorts is retarded. Selena isn't emulating stripper pole moves and pretending to make out with girls on stage.

  • OH GOD ITS SO BAD!

  • @HelpThePeoplePlease it was her first concert now shes better than most people in this business sure shes not perfect but are you selling out stadiums habing gold records, number one hits, best new artist on your record company. I DONT THINK SOOO

  • haha I was At mirandas cosgroves first concert

  • Where the world only sees talent, I see heart. Maybe she's not the best singer in the entire world (though I happen to like her voice), but she's entitled to be able to hold a show and to sing if she wants. She has an amazing heart, and even more she's thanked God for what she's got and that will bear so much fruit. :] God Bless Selena Gomez for having integrity and doing what she loves most while still maintaining an image that people like my sister can look up to.

  • Selena Gomez may get away with selling her CDs to little girls, but i doubt she can transition to entertaining adults. She can't sing and her stage performances are awkward and painful to watch.

  • @MileyXCyrusX123 your still a bitch. understand?

  • Okay, Miley Is Better Then Selena, But Demi Is The BEST .. xD

  • @xXDDemiFan no miley is better than demi

  • @HelpThePeoplePlease NO Demi Is SOO MUCH Better.. Demi Is The Best!

  • @xXDDemiFan I say Demi is Better than Miley, But SELENA is THE BEST!!!!!!!!!!!

  • thank god the mic is low its a trick they use because she sucks if u notice they did a acoustic version of round and round on mtv the other day and they had 2 guitars going wayyy 2 loud so u cudnt hear how awful she sounded she has gotten some nice stage presence though

  • selena iisss wayyyyyyyy better than miley. she just started and look where she got . and beforee youu judgee can you ppl singg. pshhh... would you even sing in front of a lot of ppl...diddnt tt think soooo!! so stfu!

  • Opps didn't finish it

  • Everyone here who is on the "Miley is 100 times better than Selena" or "Selena is way better than Miley" teams you guys need some facts:

    Number -

  • uh, no sh!t miley has better vocals shes been singing since she was 12! Selena has only been doing this for a couple of years! Get over it! She is great and has improved so much!

  • @MileyXCyrusX123 thats my point! duhh:P

  • this little girl cant sing!!!!!!realise that!!!!!!!!miley is ten times better than her!!!!!!!!!stop saying bullshit like selena is better than miley..this is not true!!!!selena is a loser in comparison to miley!!!!!!!!if u cant realise that,keep your fucking opinion for yourself!!!!

  • @billaras21aek Her voice improved, why don't you lay off the weed for a while and stop dreaming about Miley Cyrus in your bed. Miley is HORRIBLE, shes the one that can't sing.

    Selena is amazing. She's 10x better than Miley Gay Cyrus.

  • @xMellyAnnex u are so funny...i dont know if selena has improved,but her voice still sucks....miley's voice is amazing...selena will never become as good as miley...miley is 100 times better...selena is a talentless singer...just realise that...and miley is gay?hahahaha that shows that u are completely idiot!!!!!

  • @billaras21aek and if you dont like her keep YOUR fucking opinion to YOURself. You realize that you are on HER video righT? fuck off.

  • she sucks

  • @rsaber11 no she doesnt

  • @MileyXCyrusX123 ii saiid she better singing in a recording studio

    not live STUPIID get ur facts straight

  • @MileyXCyrusX123 haha well then dontt tell me shiit that i knoee aint true

    keep ur opinion to urself

  • @MileyXCyrusX123 thats ur opinion

    which idc

    i just believe in my own

    n u wont change it

  • @MileyXCyrusX123 yeah uh hu

    u dont knoee fo shoo

  • @MileyXCyrusX123 haha well to me i just think that

    idk know for sure

    nobody does

    its what i think

  • To me, She is better off just singing in the recording studio and not doing live concerts, or she would just stick to acting:)

  • @MileyXCyrusX123 haha if they don't sing well

    they wouldn't be known for shiit

  • Comment removed

  • well at least she is better than miley to me..

  • Who is "cyrus" , answer !!

  • @MileyXCyrusX123 you , really , you are irrecoverable , leave me alone with your stupid comment !!

  • @MileyXCyrusX123 Miley is your friend , ok , Cyrus is your dog ???

  • @MileyXCyrusX123 of course , really a friend ? oh my god you are hopeless !!

  • @MileyXCyrusX123 Oh shut up please ! you are just Bit**

    Don't say "Selena can't sing " because you haven't real view !

  • I think she can't her her self sing, so her singing isn't as good as it can be.

  • Selena is good. and @O3SuNsHiN3O you don't even know if it is supposed to be a high pitch song. Also I bet you sound worse! So shut the hell up!

  • @Fuzzybunnys100 No her voice is flat...unless she's trying not to sing in the same key as the rest of the song, if that's the case then thumbs up!

    I could forgive her horrible singing if she at least had some better stage presence.

  • @MileyXCyrusX123 you don't what are a singer or what , is not miley cyrus go see a live of her !! You are stupid

  • what song is this ?

  • @peacegirl98nadia its called: "as a blonde"

  • Wow she sucks, she just stick to acting, you cant even hit a note tight, i mean you cant even sing your first single falling down, you disappoint me selena and i dont get y your fans are still cheering for you

  • I love her voice. I love the style of it. I love how its sort of low but when she hits high notes i really like how she keeps it steady

  • @MileyXCyrusX123

    I am not even going to argue with you. You are not worth my precious time.

    The only thing I'm going to say is that no matter what you(or other) think she is still very famous and she she sells lots of CD.

    BYE! (:

  • @MileyXCyrusX123

    Yes, she is not the best singer and she is not good as Miley but she sings well. Plus, this performance is like 1 year old she's improved since then. bye!

  • @MileyXCyrusX123 okay im gunna say this one thing, there was a person recording this. which means it might be a bad camera. im also gunna say this... why the freak are we arguing on youtube. i dont even know you. this conversation obviously isnt changing anything, so im gunna say okay just so this pointless conversation can be over

  • @MileyXCyrusX123 Okay, Your situation is different than Selenas in this video. And what you are saying really depends on a couple of things about you being in All-City a while back, how long was a while back, how old were you? it depends. Were there Screaming Fans, a small stage, loud drums and guitars? I know you can say whatever you want, I didnt say you couldnt, i said its not fair. Case Closed

  • @MileyXCyrusX123 Can you sing live? Can you sing? I dont think its fair to say that someone cant do something unless you legit say "I think so and so cant do this" as an opinion. Have you tried singing on a small stage witha bunch of screaming fans, and drums and a guitar in your ear so that you basically cant even hear yourself singing. Cuz if ya have, let me know. Just because you cant hear her, doesnt mean she cant sing. You gotta think about the other variables in the situation.

  • @MileyXCyrusX123 haha yeah you just know that im probably right

  • her mic should be lower

  • SELENA GOMEZ CANT SING!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!1

  • @superstarnikki98 Because you can ??

  • @MileyXCyrusX123 its a freakin small stage, shes practically standing in front of the drums, and you dont know, maybe the person recording this has bad sound quality on there camera.

  • hola? retirate ¬¬

  • @MileyXCyrusX123 yea who's concerts? selena's?

  • haters she can sing duh!!! do u hear her? yes!!! if u hear her live shes great!!! i know u cant hear her voice in this video well hello thats because the band is playing really loud and she is trying to make her voice loud its hard!!! she miley and demi arent the best singers in the world noone are but their voice are great no matter what u say they're great!!! and miley shes totally good at singing but when she wears really short shorts she moves her hips so sexy i dont like it....

  • @MileyXCyrusX123 its that band shes trying to make her voice loud so people can hear her sing but its hard you try singing with a loud music and u have to really sing loud can u do that? i cant and my voice is loud but when u play the drums and the guitars u dont hear urself singing....

  • yes here outfit is so cute

  • Whoever says Selena can't sing is an idiot. You don't know how to listen to music. I am not going to compare, but just think. Can you say that she sucks, have you ever heard her sing in real life. I HAVE.

  • @MusicLoverRA123 true that!!!!! SELENA CAN SING!!!! 

  • People dont say anything about selena wearing shorts because she wears a decent top, miley likes to get half naked, and also selena acts in a way that is appropriate for her record label, disney, she has disney fans. :) I prefer Selena Gomez personally, :) she was awsome in London :D

  • Oh and btw to all you people some disney singers don't actually sing am not sure if she does not sing but just to let ya now but selena she is pretty and has a great voice i think she does sing

  • u cant really understand her!

  • OMG

  • which is d song shes singing???nd wow,her outfit is really cute

  • she sings bad her voice is fake dumb shits

  • honestly i cant hear a thing shes singing

  • u cant hear her very well but if u went to an actual consert like live and u hear her shell sound really good

  • she has nothing unige about her voice ! also , she justt started tuh sinq after demi & miely . weird . .. .

  • Love her

  • @685ashley me 2

  • why does she sing? i know, thats beocuse she doesn't know that she can't sing, when miley and demi started to sing, she started too, but she can't sing, she has just one normol song: natturally, i don't know what could she do, if there was no naturally

  • @miley7606 wtf???

    she is the best teen actress in the world!!!!

    so i don't get your point.

    selena can beat demi amd miley in acting!!!!

    and fyi i like selena's album better than demi and miley.

  • @miley7606 girl or dude she can sing!!! selena was on tv and was singing before demi and yea so what if miley can sing too? they're both great singers!! I wanna hear u sing and i bet selena sounds wayyy better than u. and hello!! she wanted a singing career not just because demi and miley sings too!!

  • @sweetchicks211 what/ you think selena is a great singer? no, it's not so and you know this too, and you don't know my singing, why are you saying that/ and even i can't sing, i'm not standing on the stage behind thousend of people, singing and calling me a singer as selena. let's say the true, selena can't sing, you can't say that just becouse you like her.

  • @miley7606 why are u saying that selena cant sing? did u hear her voice before? if yes can u hear her voice? her voice is good and miley's voice is good too and so is demi's yea i like those singers cause they're great at singing And acting if selena's voice wasnt good enough and why is she singing on stage and fans are screaming her name?

  • @miley7606 she's on stage beouse she is actress and she was famous before, people come to her cocerts becouse they just love her, they don't think that she's great singer, they just want to be so, her voice isn't good, her voice is very weak and maked in computer

  • @miley7606 okay first of all, she obviouisly can sing because you cant become famous just because your a good actor. you really cant. you have to be a well rounded person as in you have to be able to be good t other stuff, like guitar or dancing or piano or something. if you dont like her singing end of story, u dont have to like her, but leave this space for people who like her. if u dont like her dont watch her videos or dont comment on them its that simple

  • @kushayah25 okay, you say you cant become famous just because your a good actress. of coirse you can, if it's so, how are johny depp, anjelina jolly and others so famous, they'r not actrors right? and i'll say that selena didn't becoume more popular than before when she started to sing, when she sang her popularity didn't grow up, she's famous beouse she's actress, singing didn't do something good in her career, becouse people didn't like her singing, so you can't say that.

  • @miley7606 what im saying is that they have to be "well" at something else.Like I said they need to be well rounded.Johnn Depp and Angelina Jolee or however u spell her last name are GREAT actors so they dont need anything else to put out in the world. they are all set.they might great at something else we just dont know unless your a obsessed stalker fan(theres nothing wrong with that to those of you who are) Selena Gomez of course isnt the best actor in the world but she has singing to cover

  • @kushayah25 i'm saying that singing didn't do something in selena's career, becouse as singer she didn't make progress, the only reason why she's a famous person, is that she's good actress, everybody knows she can't sing good, becouse very many people can sing as her, so she didn't become more populer with singing. and i think people love her becouse she has good personality and good appearance()but i don't think she's pretty, she has baby face)

  • @miley7606 okay, now that you explained it better i see what you are saying. i see your point. Although, I see that a lot of people like her singing, so maybe its just that Selena has a unique way of singing and not a lot of people like it. I still dont think that anyone should say she cant sing because all you have to say is that you dont like her singing.I do agree with you on the fact that she didng become any more popular than she already was when she was acting.

  • @kushayah25 okay finally we got eacheder's point

  • selena can not sing sorry but thats real!! she has a normal voice and that is for me boring!!

  • @MsHATESELENAGOMEZ omg

    i love ur user and i afree

  • Wow! You were so close to her!

    I SO wanna meet her one day!!

  • ok she can't sing.....

  • this is just a glorified version if came back as a blong put a diffrent lipstick on oh its so orginal pls im not a hater i love selena and miley but seriously music label u need to wake up this song is garbage she can sing better and so can miley if u let them and not use commercial junk huh whos with me!

  • She has no power in her voice....at all.

  • sucker, she cant sing

  • for those who can't tell the difference between bands like the so called "Miley" vs "Sel's band" then you're all idiots. Miley is a singer and Selena is part of band. get it or are you all still slow? are your brains not fully functional? Having ID10T Errors? "IDIOT" lol ok enough teaching the young minds about bands, musicians and such. for most are just easy to manipulate as we can see through the media stream.

  • Wow her voice sucks here. Sorry for all fans ( I like her too but this is not her best performance)

  • she can't sing

  • i'm jealous of her legssss! ugh she is super pretty

  • amazing, the mic just needs to be louder, love the outfit.

    why does everyone compare her to miley cyrus, they are nothing alike the only thing that they have in common is disney channel. maybe she doesnt get critised as much as miley beause selena is nicer and doesn't do as much crazy stuff.

    i do like miley btw

  • weird??????????

    she got the worst voise ever

  • @miley5759 why??do u have the best voice in the world??

  • She sings AMAZING for a first concert! I love the outfit. And yes, maybe they should make the mic louder but she sings and dances good. I really, really want to be on her concert :)) She's adorable <3

  • thats not even close to singin. thats a weird somewhat evil chanting. with a band.

  • SELENA, PLEASE, STOOOOP!!!!!!!

  • she did not to well on ellen....she doesnt do well in signing anywhere

  • mmmmm she does not had a great voice... BUT watever!! guys, leave me alone.. this is my oponion.. MINE!! ok??? ¬¬

  • that was awsome i really wanna go to a selena gomez concert!!!!!!!!!!(:

  • Fantabulous!! Piece of cake, had found the entire album for free download at DownloadMusic[DOTT]im, take away the slashes and you are to good to go..

  • omg her outfit is sooooo kute

  • @1285sandra her mic is low thats why her voice is all messed up

  • i want that selena make a show in brazil

  • Kay, well, everyone shut up about the shorts. These shorts aren't skin tight on Selena- like Miley's are on her. Besides, Selena doesn't dance on ice cream carts in a furry vest showing her bra through her shirt.

  • at least miley can sing x

  • shes good at singing live! shes hardly even experienced!! leave.her.alone.

  • SHe looKS SO PREttY !!

  • Only because Miley looks like a tramp in her shorts and Selena doesnt.

  • short short on selena so the fans r saying selena can wear em but miley cant WELL THATS FUCKED UP

  • It is...Miley and Selena both look fine in short-shorts

  • i know and i reallt needed to hear tht

  • i think she´s getting better and better....she sounds very great at the ellen show...good job sel!!

  • yeah thats right :) or her performance at new year

  • yes that was a great performance =)

  • she looks so beautiful :)

  • i love selena 2 deathh but here's just what i thinkk;

    she had a really big fan base when she was just

    an actor. her singing isn't that great but because

    of that fan base she didn't really lose that much

    like "attention" i guess. but personally i think her

    voice could use a little workk...i give her guts for trying though!(:

  • @xoxSeLeNaLoVeRxox i think i am with you her fan base would give her guts for trying and after that concert she did amazing i mean on ellen was wonderful the same on the new year performance and i think selena would never lose a fan if she became the same and didnot change

  • Wonder why she didn't sing this at Anaheim. She sounds great.

  • heheh your soo lucky you could go! lol..i love her outfit!! shes awesome<33

  • 0:06 0:09 the way she moves meakes look pretty

  • no its live wehn she goes for the big blonde shes like bloonde! instead of BLOOONDE! lol

  • wow shes great! But shes sweating really badly

  • yeah ive performed on stage. you sweat A LOT. cuz of nerves, and the lights are REALLY strong produce A LOT of heat. also you're dancing around. thats why shes sweating....

  • her band is playing horrible!!! like really!!! it sounds like they are just banging on stuff! and u can barely hear Selena Gomez!!

  • Yeah, hear voice isn't loud enough...

  • I think it's because it's her first concert and she doesn't wanna make a mistake and also it's a private concert so it must be pretty small so you wouldn't wanna belt out and make everyone deaf (:

  • its cuz its a small theatre so if its really loud then the feedback will be horrid

  • WTF YO? hahahah

  • she's like demi when she preforms,

  • No duh. It's the same song.

  • u cant really hear what shes saying i give this a booo!!!

  • Comment removed

  • did u seriously go see her in concert?! haha wow.

  • I was pesimist about her album because I don't really like falling down! But I listened to it and I like most of the song!

  • to TheATZEN2

    Selena is new to singing so she will get tired. plus to me it sounded like miley was tired. wait i forgot thats her normal ugly voice

  • Shes a good performers :]

    Its weird how shes wearing really short shorts too, but she doesn't get crap about it like miley does.

  • Well, its probably because she has a cleaner record than Miley, so people let her off on this. Anyways, Miley has her own supporters, she's alot more experienced that Selena in singing.

  • @PleaseSupportMiley

    oh plz miley is way better than this moron

  • @sisy111 Well yes I obviously no that, that would be why my name is PleaseSupportMILEY

  • @PleaseSupportMiley I know, I hate it...It's like, her outfit is the same as what Miley wears, yet everybody's like "I love her!" "she can sing so good!" when you can actually hear Miley when she sings.

  • @PleaseSupportMiley yea but her ass isnt hanging out

  • @PleaseSupportMiley its because Miley has other bad incidents like the supposed photos she sent to her boyfriend and because o the photo shoot where she wore nothing but she was covered in sheets. I agree with youthough thats still no one says anything about Selena

  • shes dying there

    so sad..

  • to galaxygirls1

    Miley sung 18 songs and she wasn't tired at all!!

    She jumped and whatever :DD

    she is a better entertainer

    !!!

  • Comment removed

  • naw bra this song is not good

    idk y ppl listen 2 dis

    u no wut i meen yea!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!­!!!!

    im out peeeace

    thx 4 taking the time nd reading dis comment...

    wait ur still reading ok stop, stop!

    ok now its not funny! can u stop reading this message

    omg ur still reading

    wow u need a life no offence but stop

    that wus a prank message!!!!! lol :0 thx!

  • she cant sing!!!!!!!!!!!

    demi sings better

  • all you people just shut up and if you don't like her singing,,,,.... stop listening to her!!!!! DUH!!!!

  • SORY BUT THIS IS A DUMB SONG SO I POSTED SUMB COMMENTS O WELL ITS JUST ME U NO by the way poop is goog

  • why even comment if u dont like it? please stop hating selena!