@ParamoreRainbows i agree with you paramore, they have more singers and more backround music, but i dont hate plain white t's, they sang at my grandmothers funeral... so i dont hate them n all...
All Time Low's is not better. It's too fast and loud, and it doesn't fit with the melody. It also doesn't fit with the lyrics. You'd never be able to tell their version was a love song. This fits the lyrics and melody much better.
These lyrics and melody work well with a pop or r&b beat like Rihanna's, or a slow arrangement like this one. It's a whole lot more meaningful that way, imo. I don't think lyrics like "in the dark you can't see shiny cars, that's when you'll need me there" or "you had my heart" fit that well with a hard rock arrangement.
Rock doesn't suit this song. The lyrics are sweet and beautiful. Rain is a metaphor is songs for hard times, and umbrella is a metaphor for how the singer will protect the person from those hard times. It's not random.
this is good, all time low amazing cover but i think what tops it is my friend Cjay singing it. it tops all cover's he's amazing. but you guy won't know as its not posted on youtube but you can trust me when i say its breath taking x
love this cover ...
shuvilayqa 1 week ago
todas las canciones de Plain white t's sirven para ponerte melancolico :/ u.u
la5tadivision 4 months ago
nice song..... i like this version keep it up..
benhur944 11 months ago
Oh wow so many bands have covered this.. McFly, Plain White T's, All Time Low, Linkin Park. And I must say all the covers are really good X)
fridaavigilteves 1 year ago 2
@fridaavigilteves And don't forget Train! ;)
MrJettsetter 8 months ago
I like how Rihanna fucked up her own single. this version is a billion times better than the one she put out.
lissy42nerdfighter 1 year ago 3
so pretty :D
Summzer 1 year ago
i like Plain white t's and all time lows version better thann rihanna(:
SkaterGurl842 1 year ago 3
WAY FRIKIN BETTER THAN RIHANNA!!! so much sweeter and calmer, love it to death!
bubblemygum404 1 year ago
muchmuchmuch better than the original!!!!
trueartist1996 1 year ago
i liked Mcfly's cover, acoustic and live/studio versions, better
txx0xxt 2 years ago
This is good! And I agree with you scrapage, McFly's cover is AMAZING!
simpleplanloverrr 2 years ago
best one ever bettter than riannah herself
happyfeet794 2 years ago
i love theirs and Mcfly's cover of this song.
scrapage 2 years ago 3
i hate the original rhianna cover but this is brill
911brando 2 years ago 3
I prefer All Time Low's version but I do like this cover. It's sweet. :)
ParamoreRainbows 2 years ago 26
ikr i love all time low there version is better than this one =]
lilcandykool 2 years ago
yes!!!
100MetroStation 2 years ago
@ParamoreRainbows i agree with you paramore, they have more singers and more backround music, but i dont hate plain white t's, they sang at my grandmothers funeral... so i dont hate them n all...
BRSKERJayson 1 year ago
All Time Low's is not better. It's too fast and loud, and it doesn't fit with the melody. It also doesn't fit with the lyrics. You'd never be able to tell their version was a love song. This fits the lyrics and melody much better.
jmo
ilovekelly75 2 years ago
thats wat makes it so much better this way to slow and the plain white ts should just stick to there other songs
lilcandykool 2 years ago
These lyrics and melody work well with a pop or r&b beat like Rihanna's, or a slow arrangement like this one. It's a whole lot more meaningful that way, imo. I don't think lyrics like "in the dark you can't see shiny cars, that's when you'll need me there" or "you had my heart" fit that well with a hard rock arrangement.
ilovekelly75 2 years ago
@ilovekelly75 tey r the best part of hard rock covers,tho i dont think u get rock
happyfeet794 2 years ago
@happyfeet794 wtf. plain white t's arent hard rock.
talksxalotx101 1 year ago
@talksxalotx101 i know, i was adressing that they were the opposite of pop, not that they were rock, and tht i like hard rock covers of theur songs
happyfeet794 1 year ago
@ilovekelly75 OMG WTF ITS NOT A LUV SONG!!!!!!!!! ITS A RANDOM SONG LIKE YELLOW SUBMARINE
happyfeet794 2 years ago
Rock doesn't suit this song. The lyrics are sweet and beautiful. Rain is a metaphor is songs for hard times, and umbrella is a metaphor for how the singer will protect the person from those hard times. It's not random.
ilovekelly75 2 years ago 4
....i hate you
FLOPPO123456789 2 years ago
I like this version better
vietkid81 2 years ago 2
this is good, all time low amazing cover but i think what tops it is my friend Cjay singing it. it tops all cover's he's amazing. but you guy won't know as its not posted on youtube but you can trust me when i say its breath taking x
xminijordanx 2 years ago
I hate Rihanna and all her song but with plain white T'S the song be very beautiful
catcheur1997 2 years ago 28
all time low does it better
givemesometots 2 years ago 4
This comment has received too many negative votes show
this is Rihanna's song the plain white t's are song steallers
wizardoflegos 2 years ago
everibody noes its rhiannas song.. its called a cover... this song is coverd by a number of bands...
juhui2 2 years ago 3
its called a Cover.
johnnyjohn911 2 years ago 2
its a cover idiot !
freakiiiKittiii 2 years ago 2
Its called a cover, idiot.
JVPavko 2 years ago 2
This comment has received too many negative votes show
hmmm. this isnt that good. its pretty boring
trunkybigsnake 2 years ago
Awesome cover!
But thaVsha115:
It doesn't matter whether you *intend* to infringe copyright. You either infringe it or you don't.
Idiot.
mikeyburns319 2 years ago
wow if u dont like it then dont fucking listen to it u fucking stupid ppl
ponemon101 2 years ago
even i can sing better
aznwnolife 2 years ago
all time low, vanilla sky, linkin park, pw 'ts, mcfly! all is singing this pretty shitty song xD
xMiCHiiRU 2 years ago
toll toll toll :'D x3
x3salax3 2 years ago
love it. ♥
M0NEYH0NEY 2 years ago
i like all time low and rhiannas better.0
rosilletta123 2 years ago
Everyones singing this rhianna plain white ts and all time low or atleast thats all i know of
rosilletta123 2 years ago
lol and theres Mcfly and linkin Park and Marie Digby and mandy moore lol soo pretty much everyone.
livexthexlife192 2 years ago
chris brown wont do anything lol
vacoreon 3 years ago
they shouldnt sing this song. chris brown might kick there ass
thebooye 3 years ago
lol he kicked rihanna's ass instead...
PUNKxXD 2 years ago 4
i love plain white t's better!!
RoseTintedLaugh 3 years ago
fiko fmz manu ^^ y love
willianbanca 3 years ago
great:) this is with Vanilla sky and all time low the best cover:D
SunnyGirlie1992 3 years ago 3
love it !!!
twilightlover12343 3 years ago
i love this version way better then when Rihanna sings it!
crazedoutfan 3 years ago 3
hm..i like this version way better than the original. although i do like it when All Time Low sings it too
boobear81 3 years ago
no all time low cover is better man lol but i like this band 2
kodak619 3 years ago
the best umbrella.. rihana sucks :D
ayonbgd 3 years ago 2
where i can get this song?
enmibolsillo 3 years ago
Makes me like the song! I can't stand the Rihanna version or any others for that matter. They make this good! Thanks for the post =)
RowenaLupin 3 years ago
Love it !!
DareThisDevil 3 years ago
i know you guys may have already herd this but i dont like this not your style but you still did a great job so idk lol
laterr
scrapper4lifee 3 years ago