I think that this song accompanied with the video is a whole lot better than trent realizes. I remember watching the video which was the first time I had heard song also and being completely blown away. The feeling and colour of the song/videos mood was definitely a high point of the 90's. Even though it was directly written for Lost Highway it is still undeniably well written. Be proud Trent.
Haha, I know exactly what he means about him being a character as opposed to himself. It's like "Trent Reznor Starring as the handsomer version of Lord Archibald Craven" in the melodramatic story of the loss of his wife before The Secret Garden...and anyway, I really like this story, and the video really is sort of like a poem, and it shows that Trent has great confidence in Romanek and is willing to go out on a limb, though he did express hesitance, I would too, if I ceased to be me.
Im very glad he did this song and video, as this introduced me to NIN in the first place. I love this video and it makes me a bit sad he isn;t so keen, but sometimes things leave a bad taste in you're mouth if its a bad time. Love closer too.
wow this is one of my favorite videos and songs of Reznors, but im glad that he admits that its all a bit OTT and theatrical. Its refreshing to hear a rock star isn't so absorbed with all the BS.
this entire era for trent was a bit odd - he felt very missportraid (is that a word) by warner bros. i'm glad that he seperated from them otherwise we might not even have him today
Absolutely brilliant Trent. Testing your boundaries is excellent - feeling outside of your self is what this video is about, perfection in its own element. You videos speak to me on so many levels. Closer is stunning to me also.
Yes, it is you in the video, just maybe a little more exposed than you may like. Ciao.
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
Trent does the blowhard egotist thing in the commentary where he asks himself questions and answers them: "Is it an interesting thing to do? Yes. Will it be well done? Yes. But is it the right thing for *me* to do?" ...At least, he's rarely like this in other interviews.
I used to love this video and song so I'm a bit surprised to hear that he didn't like this song...matter of fact this song to me was better than Closer. The video to me was just Bram Stroker Dracula and I used to love that flick. I used to be pretty twisted back then.
i've always wondered, the three other fellows in the video, "playing" the intro to the song, and then again at the end, are they, possibly, Danny, Charlie, and Chris?
well, beside all that what he felt during creation of this song and video.. i like it both very much. to me, it's one of the best nin songs. like lyrics very much, and music too, especially drum and bass sound.. and end ofcourse. it reminds me of something. and someone.. i'm glad he made that song, cause it's more than a song to me.
It's interesting how he refers to this as being as far out of himself as he's been...and also describes the time as a rather dark one; perhaps it's a good representation of how lost he was feeling at the time.
*blush* Aw, thanks. I've felt that way before; you don't really know who you are, so you're willing to go along with whatever idea of what you should be pops up first...it made sense to me.
I never liked this because of the false goth image he has here. I'm happy he said the same. It's not him. Beautifully fimed vid, but just nooot how I want to see Trent. Soooo good he has the same opinion as me.
Trent I love you to pieces dude, But please shut the hell up this song is awesome beyond comprimise. No matter how much you try and disown it, your a fucking goth ball to the nth degree. what normal musician sings about as gruesome grotesque shit as you? NO ONE. Your awesome acept it, move on.
I can understand where trent is coming from here. but. Like he said, he agreed to to a song for the movie, so he shouldn't worry about the personal side too much. We all like it don't we ?
I don't understand why alternative music artist try to put up a anti-capitalist stance, yet they're rich and powerful - he just needs to admit he left his "comfort zone" in the making of this video for monetary gain (nothing wrong with that!?).
This is my favorite NIN video - his image WAS in fact gothic; I don't know what trent is talking about here!??? You have to be theatrical at times - he was just fucked up at the time most-likely.
I love this song. Trent is a genius.
ryne5 2 years ago 2
That video, and that song, murders every current so-called "musical artists" with AWESOMAGE bullets. And then it became an orz dirge for them.
Somebody should find Trent and tell him that his hard work paid off way more than he believes.
Hectotane 2 years ago 3
I think that this song accompanied with the video is a whole lot better than trent realizes. I remember watching the video which was the first time I had heard song also and being completely blown away. The feeling and colour of the song/videos mood was definitely a high point of the 90's. Even though it was directly written for Lost Highway it is still undeniably well written. Be proud Trent.
molfie 2 years ago 4
I hate that the embed code is removed...
fuzzylilhippiechick 2 years ago 2
my least favorite song by trent
danny510x 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
SO
play it live as your self
unprofessional attitude and lack of respect for the fans.
jrfps 2 years ago
Comment removed
jrfps 2 years ago
Haha, I know exactly what he means about him being a character as opposed to himself. It's like "Trent Reznor Starring as the handsomer version of Lord Archibald Craven" in the melodramatic story of the loss of his wife before The Secret Garden...and anyway, I really like this story, and the video really is sort of like a poem, and it shows that Trent has great confidence in Romanek and is willing to go out on a limb, though he did express hesitance, I would too, if I ceased to be me.
Dakryn 2 years ago 3
Im very glad he did this song and video, as this introduced me to NIN in the first place. I love this video and it makes me a bit sad he isn;t so keen, but sometimes things leave a bad taste in you're mouth if its a bad time. Love closer too.
whiterabbitbitch 2 years ago 2
wow this is one of my favorite videos and songs of Reznors, but im glad that he admits that its all a bit OTT and theatrical. Its refreshing to hear a rock star isn't so absorbed with all the BS.
kittox2ya 2 years ago 3
Ah, this makes me kinda sad that Trent doesn't like this song
sleepyoni 3 years ago 11
this entire era for trent was a bit odd - he felt very missportraid (is that a word) by warner bros. i'm glad that he seperated from them otherwise we might not even have him today
Rane909 3 years ago 2
One of my favorite NIN songs and Vids, so glad you did it all things considered Trent!
georgey714lost 3 years ago 4
But Trent! You make such a hot vampire!
arsenicandearlgrey 3 years ago 11
This has been flagged as spam show
When is Trent Reznor not in a dark time in his life?
Zanalee 3 years ago
Right now.
skater120790 3 years ago 5
yeah pretty much. he seems happy as hell now.
dysthymia7 3 years ago 4
This has been flagged as spam show
When you are?
empty216 3 years ago 2
Beautiful video. I love it when Trent's wet.
midnightblackrose 3 years ago 5
Absolutely brilliant Trent. Testing your boundaries is excellent - feeling outside of your self is what this video is about, perfection in its own element. You videos speak to me on so many levels. Closer is stunning to me also.
Yes, it is you in the video, just maybe a little more exposed than you may like. Ciao.
skinnieminnie123 3 years ago 4
This comment has received too many negative votes show
You know he's not reading this right? Just sayin....
SimonRivas 3 years ago
which movie is he talking about in the beginning?
michmerhuizen 3 years ago
Lost Highway
akempwill 3 years ago 5
This is still my all time fav video
sailordragon 3 years ago 5
i just love it, its like a dahli painting
hammerslittlehorror 3 years ago 5
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Trent does the blowhard egotist thing in the commentary where he asks himself questions and answers them: "Is it an interesting thing to do? Yes. Will it be well done? Yes. But is it the right thing for *me* to do?" ...At least, he's rarely like this in other interviews.
Down10 3 years ago
He asks himself this because Trent is very serious about his art, and his stuff is self-expression. It's an artist thing, not an egotist thing.
niteskunk 3 years ago 16
Doesn't being an artist mean being egotistical (sometimes at least)?
hiriwabosi 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
i just don't like this song.... i don't know why.. i just don't like it
justkershaw 3 years ago
I used to love this video and song so I'm a bit surprised to hear that he didn't like this song...matter of fact this song to me was better than Closer. The video to me was just Bram Stroker Dracula and I used to love that flick. I used to be pretty twisted back then.
kookoo78 3 years ago 2
I do love this video and this song,,,but he def. sucked the emotion outta this..I still love you T.R.
gothicmaiden666999 4 years ago 5
prolly sucked his grandmother died he had drug and alcohol problems he was pissed with manson for some reason? Trent is amazing
jrquilty 4 years ago 3
sweet
thanks for poating this :)
panic0 4 years ago
i've always wondered, the three other fellows in the video, "playing" the intro to the song, and then again at the end, are they, possibly, Danny, Charlie, and Chris?
asamorris 4 years ago
I'm not sure, but one of them DEFINATELY looks like Charlie.
arsenicandearlgrey 4 years ago
I'm sure it's Danny and Chris.
skylar337 4 years ago 2
danny is on the far right im pretty sure.
as for the other 2 im lost
redvsbluefanman 4 years ago
Dahny is the one at the far right, Charlie is in the middle and Chris at the far left.
DownwardSpiral84 4 years ago
personally, i love this song and vid.
i've written songs that i don't relate to, also.
when you hear it, it's like...
wtf was i thinking?
but it sort of throws other emotions out there.
awesome commentary.
Xx12Evanescence12xX 4 years ago 3
I agree because I thought the same thing what he is saying about himself, I saw him as a character and not something that was part of him.
TobiasCamery 4 years ago 7
well, beside all that what he felt during creation of this song and video.. i like it both very much. to me, it's one of the best nin songs. like lyrics very much, and music too, especially drum and bass sound.. and end ofcourse. it reminds me of something. and someone.. i'm glad he made that song, cause it's more than a song to me.
tainted4m 4 years ago
It's interesting how he refers to this as being as far out of himself as he's been...and also describes the time as a rather dark one; perhaps it's a good representation of how lost he was feeling at the time.
arsenicandearlgrey 4 years ago
that's pretty good how you picked that up.
antbrman 4 years ago
*blush* Aw, thanks. I've felt that way before; you don't really know who you are, so you're willing to go along with whatever idea of what you should be pops up first...it made sense to me.
arsenicandearlgrey 4 years ago
I never liked this because of the false goth image he has here. I'm happy he said the same. It's not him. Beautifully fimed vid, but just nooot how I want to see Trent. Soooo good he has the same opinion as me.
Must love.
ninworm 4 years ago
where'd you get this?
diddlingdoom 4 years ago
He looks like Severus Snape
Gonk 4 years ago 4
I know, and that's why I fell in love with Snape, because I'm in love with Trent Reznor. :-) HOTNESSSSSSSS
poorleno22 4 years ago
*gasp* It was KIND OF the other way around for me. :D
ratexla 4 years ago
lol they are both hot to me...but since i knew about trent before he'll always be my one true love. lol
poorleno22 4 years ago
Trent I love you to pieces dude, But please shut the hell up this song is awesome beyond comprimise. No matter how much you try and disown it, your a fucking goth ball to the nth degree. what normal musician sings about as gruesome grotesque shit as you? NO ONE. Your awesome acept it, move on.
much love,
Alex
AlexMurdoch87 4 years ago 3
I can understand where trent is coming from here. but. Like he said, he agreed to to a song for the movie, so he shouldn't worry about the personal side too much. We all like it don't we ?
SloppyCheeseFinger 4 years ago
I don't understand why alternative music artist try to put up a anti-capitalist stance, yet they're rich and powerful - he just needs to admit he left his "comfort zone" in the making of this video for monetary gain (nothing wrong with that!?).
ifranqui58 4 years ago
This is my favorite NIN video - his image WAS in fact gothic; I don't know what trent is talking about here!??? You have to be theatrical at times - he was just fucked up at the time most-likely.
ifranqui58 4 years ago
Sorry, you're saying Reznor is gothic? :| Urrm-k?
scorpiusdiamond 4 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
trent can't do commentaries
pkinasevych 4 years ago
wow...he's so insightful...
commentaries like this get trent a lot of respect in my book.
Caitlin4eva 4 years ago
NIN should release more experimental stuff like this between albums. I really like it.
666Nukes 4 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
where is your god now?
spec400 3 years ago
i mean you echronorian,u fuckin sissy
czr9inchNail 4 years ago
quit wachting nin videos, you bitch made n'sync loving shit pusher.
czr9inchNail 4 years ago
His soul, his heart...
Hmmm
kabukicallgirl 4 years ago
While he brings up alot of good points, this is one of the greatest music videos of all time and an ultimite classic.
JackRussellTerrier2 4 years ago
...lol...
leave him alone...
he's one of those people who doesn't like to watch himself of tv
bobtreelover 4 years ago
This is great, what an eye opening insight into Trent...
HandyAndy888 4 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
trent is such a pussy
somerset219 4 years ago
wow where did u get this? thanks for posting.
luketoddhunter 4 years ago
fuck u hes at leas 10000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000 times the man yull ever even dream of being u dick head.
7p666 4 years ago
cry home to ya mama!!
echronorian 4 years ago