Added: 2 years ago
From: brittle13
Views: 230,243
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (4,909)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • what a rotten old cunt...

    what was the fucking stern gang but terrorists that killed the british and arab villagers.

    death was to easy for this satanic witch.

  • Well much of what she said about palestinians could be said of jews!

  • @IDriveCorporation ofcourse, especially zionists.

  • That host is wearing a toupee.

  • Do a seach on "Jeffrey Sachs Toronto Library" on YouTube, click on Part 2 starting at 2:49, Jeffrey Sachs bitch-slaps Ayn Rand and her philosophy completely. She was a hateful, bitter and lonely woman. While married, she had an affair with Nathaniel Branden (also married) and 20 years younger. When he ditched her for a younger woman, she had a vendetta against him which lasted until the day she died. I would have loved to see Professor Chomsky or the late Edward Said debate her.

  • @fairdose Whats lovely about you liberal numbnuts is that you aren't intelligent enough to actually debate a point of the right, and because your beliefs do not hold up to scrutiny, you attack the personal character of your opponent. I expect that we will see the Obama admin use this to try and maintain power.

  • Ayn in this interviews is the same mentality that israel peoples hold in value today

    about the islam peoples. her jew instincts came out.

  • She was a bitter old hater who cared about nothing and no one but herself. Trying to hold her up as any kind of moral compass just means you'll be lost forever.

  • Ayn Rand is a racist, and "Atlas Shrugged" is nothing more than a fairy tale.

  • The question is: Did one group of people from column A evict another group of Column B out of their homes based on old literature/claims which science can for the most part disprove. The answer is yes.. On any other planet people would understand why this is wrong. I don't fall for this Arabs are savages crap because their tech is less advanced. Isn't killing people then pissing on their dead bodies savage? Agent orange in Vietnam savage? Killing civies in Nam savage? Nazis had good tech.

  • Nazi Germany was highly developed with technology.

    Did that made them more civilized?

  • @TheGolfdaily

    Excellent point!

    I know it's simple to refute Rand in general, but very well done!

    I'm almost ashamed I didn't come up with it myself as I was listening. I was thinking more in terms of arguing about the assumption that technology is always a value, which is debateable, but difficult to attack in our modern culture which currently relies so heavily on technology. I'd argue that our fetish towards technology is also putting us at risk towards our ultimate demise.

  • @SBRslacker00 Really.. you want to trade our status of technology against what - sitting in the desert sand, the savannah floor, dancing around camp fires, practicing voodoo copulation rituals ? Drop your silly exotism attitude, it's good for nothing.

    Technology is a benchmark for civilisation, like it or not. It's the one thing that makes us masters of our environment. We don't travel a day to get fresh water, we're not hungry, we're not cold, our wives don't die at childbirth.

  • @sooperfukker

    'Technology is a benchmark for civilisation'

    Based on what? Populism?  Elitism? Naziism? Please tell me.

    There are tons of false dichotomies hidden in your assumptions. If I offer a critique of technology, it means that I want women dying in childbirth? Really? The same goes for the rest of what you've written, it's a straw man attack pure and simple. Answer me this: Is it possible to integrate technology into a sustainable cultural diversity as a species?

  • @SBRslacker00 Based on : Success.

    The better our technology is, the more control we have over our environment. And it's complemented by our ability to control ourselves, i.e. through medicine.

    As I said: Technology is not enough to form a civilised society, its use can indeed produce disadvantages - which have to be countered by BETTER technology (e.g. environmental issues), but WITHOUT technology, a society is going nowhere.

  • @sooperfukker

    "The better our technology is, the more control we have over our environment"

    You are right, with greater technology, we can create Eden-like Earth. OR,,, we can blow up the planet many times over with more than 30,000 nuclear bombs which we posses.

    Now tell me, which way do you think we are heading right now??

  • @TheGolfdaily Both. Our efforts are split up with achieving great things and at the same time fighting back the cavemen hordes who still reside among us. Who we let remain among us. They will have to make a choice soon: Come along or go down history. We can't keep on wasting our time and resources on them.

  • @sooperfukker

    What is lacking in this small planet is; Love and respect for the others. Even for the cavemen.

  • @TheGolfdaily You know, in a vaccuum, that might be valid. But somehow, that feeling of compassion or sympathy gets lost when you see them hoarding in the streets, yelling nasty things about this and that great "satan" and how we all should die and rot in hell. That spoils it a bit, don't you think ?

  • @SBRslacker00 "Is it possible to integrate technology into a sustainable cultural diversity as a species"

    ^

    What do you mean by that? Integrate technology into diversity ???

  • @SBRslacker00 O Btw.. for your false strawman: Tell it to those who actually mean it. Tell it to those who think our technological advancements is of the devil and nothing which isn't prewritten in the scripture can therefor be not true. That's the radical alternative these people offer and I hope you know who I'm talking about here. It's not me, it's not you, it is - them.

  • @sooperfukker

    'Tell it to those who actually mean it.'

    Who? Who are you talking about? Are their names? I have not encountered who/whatever it is that you are talking about. Please clarify. Better yet, link me to a YouTube video of someone with this kind of rhetoric. I've never heard anyone giving the kind of claims which you seem to be railing against. Again, you've put up a straw man, exactly because you don't give the facts of what in the heck you are speaking against.

  • @SBRslacker00

    Who tell what? That science is a heretic invention?

    There you go : watch?v=7j9Ja6bZDh4

    Or did you mean those who want to conquer Europe?

    watch?v=5xRmKTD96po

    watch?v=dRxwa008Nxg

    /watch?v=95GxhqjHZ3E

    /watch?v=AET991yFCY8

    Why do I even have to provide links? Youtube is filled with that sort of stuff. You could easily find hundreds,if not thousands of videos in instant which deal with these topics.

  • @SBRslacker00 [2] While research and technology aren't sufficient for progress of a society, they're still indespensable. Those who master technology, rule this planet. And soon more.

    We don't know how many years it will take till we colonise space, but it will happen.Mankind has a brilliant future ahead if it manages to eliminate the dangerous elements of backwardsness within it.

    Sword swinging, bearded savages, longing for blood and gore, won't be a part of that fellowship.

  • @TheGolfdaily Judging a country for 15 years of history - forgetting everything that was before and came after ? That's a bit idiotic, isn't it ?

    Germany was well developed even BEFORE it became the 3rd reich. To be precise, between about 1820 and 1930, Germany was a high ground for scientific research and engineering. Most scientific literature was published in the german language, because it was the common language within the scientific community.

  • She kind of sounds like,,,,,,,,, Nazi?

  • Comment removed

  • Comment removed

  • dizzy old cunt

  • Straight forward, she says that a secular state is ideal. Those who can make you believe in absurdities can make you commit atrocities. So who gives a fuck if someone offends your dogmatic ritualistic churches or mosques. If you can't accept objective truth then you are frightened of the truth.

  • wait wait. so she calls palestinians primitive savages, and then calls them out for being racist?? what a hypocritical cunt

  • @inertiatic123 I know it's easy to align with the many people for or against Ayn Ran, but if you learn one thing from her, it should be her preaching of Reason as the ultimate source of virtue. so, look at her statements with reason and you find that she explains that she hates them for their use of force and violence, not for race. And of course she wouldn't mean every Arab or of arab descent, but those extremists who use force on others. Use some common sense, and dignity of language, please

  • @aWinkler2010 yet israel has been using force and violence agaisnt the palestinians for decades. are they not the aggressors? not to mention israel has been relying on handouts from the US since its inception, its laughable to think theyd be nearly as advanced if not for them. using her logic, the US has the right to invade any country they want. theyre the most technologically advanced right? who cares about anybody else, theyre just fucking savages.

    ill say it again, shes a hypocritical cunt

  • Comment removed

  • jewish piece of shit, like rhe rest of the jewish rats

  • @ghandi2011 Wow Hitler posing as Ghandi.

  • @ghandi2011 Why dont you die of gonarhea and burn in hell you racist bastard

  • RIP Ayn. I miss you :'(

  • @urdisturbing No, I think the absolute opposite.

  • "...those SAVAGES who are RACIST..."

    well then.

  • What a blot in the name of libertarian! Liberty & natural rights to life, liberty & property are for EVERYONE, just because SOME Arabs or whoever commit heinous crimes does NOT mean that numerous others who've NOT impinged on our right to life, liberty & property. Those who'd bomb & kill so called "savages" are just as savage. People & cultures everywhere are different so just let them live in their countries & let us live in ours, violence only begets more violence.

  • She despises terrorism....does she despise the actions of the IDL in pr 48 israel? Terrorism has been done by Jews and Arabs in the quest to control that little piece of land

  • Alisa Rosenbaum for the jews? What an unexpected turn.

  • The jewess Rand is promoting libertarian hyper individualism for the goyim, but at the same time wants to make sure that the goy in the US is supporting the ethnostate Israel. All under the cover that Israel is "advanced" and doesnt use "terrorism".

    As always, its a jew looking out for whats "good for the jews".

  • Brrrr.

  • Just an ignorant and biased fool. Not a shred of warmth in her. Sad.

  • Israel commits genocide these days. I wonder how she would have felt about that ?

    Oh I guess if it's not on the news it doesn't happen ...

  • I love her work, but I disagree with her one sided, blinkered view on terrorism and the Israel problem. I wonder if her views would of changed in recent years and if she would admit that any form of violence towards citizens, weather Israeli or Palestinian is classed as an act of terrorism. When palestinian extremists launch missiles or anything they can towards Israel, it is an act of terrorism but so is sending U.S. made apache gunships into Gaza against settlements.

  • @orbazel I think all of her views were shaped in the context of the more prominent social issues which she was exposed to when she was younger, and she lacked the pragmatism to update them.

  • @orbazel Probably not. Though Zionism is a Jewish nationalist movement, based upon the socialist model, it was still a Western ideology. Based upon her Hegel-like statements to justify the Anglo-Americans' seizure of Native American lands in the United States, Rand's philosophy is a kind of "normative Occidentalism", and the "savages" of the world must make way for a Euro-centric concept of progress and industrialization.

  • Bloody Jewess and libertarian sect member

  • If cared at all about women's rights you would agree with her about the middle east. Jewish women actually have rights.

  • @Draanor That's like saying if I cared about ending poverty I would agree with North Korea because in North Korea everyone has the right to food, housing, and medical care. Womens right has nothing to do with the Israeli-Palestinian conflict.

  • @Draanor /watch?v=Yq8twVXl4GI

  • @newjack31622 So there are extremist Jews is that what you're showing me? Just like those crazy Baptists in the South, there are crazies in every group. Conservative Muslims believe in Sharia Law which is more than a small group of crazies and is a little bit nastier than a poor little girl getting spat upon. Derp.

  • @Draanor Oh, you're one of those ridiculous, gullible ass "Sharia law!" dupes huh? Say no more. Derp indeed dumb fuck.

  • @newjack31622 Oh my a wikipedia page on Sharia Law. Looks completely blown out of proportion. Go and be a bigot somewhere else. I'm sure there's a neo-nazi movement you can join.

  • @Draanor Are you kidding me you naive little douche? Screaming about Sharia Law is basically like waving a giant sign proclaiming yourself to be a bigot who watches too much tv. Give me a break you fucking hick retard. And "nazi"? Thats sort of like waving a white flag saying you have no argument when you play that card, especially considering the only racism came from the hick talking about "Sharia".

  • @newjack31622 I apologize for comparing your anti Jew philosophies to that of the Nazis of old and suggested that you would find good company with the Neo-Nazis. I wasn't screaming about Sharia Law but in my case of women's rights, JEWS ARE MUCH MORE NICE TO WOMEN THAN MUSLIMS COULD EVER PRETEND TO BE. SHARIA LAW IS THE REASON WHY THE MUSLIMS CANNOT TREAT WOMEN RESPECTFULLY. That's screaming. I'll remember to talk slower next time for your malformed brain.

  • Nothing "anti jew" about me you simplistic ass, but its clear you are a racist and anti-arab/muslim tool who watches too much tv like the gullible fucking hick you clearly are. Now stop with the caps lock you overly emotional hypocritical dickbag, it only proves Ive won. Oh and just a tip you racist clown, "sharia" means 10 different things to 10 different muslims, its not a uniform term that means the same thing to all of them, it has a shifting meaning. You fell for fear monger spin.

  • Nothing "anti jew" about me you simplistic ass, but its clear you are a racist and anti-arab/muslim tool who watches too much tv like the gullible fucking hick you clearly are. Now stop with the caps lock you overly emotional hypocritical dickbag, it only proves Ive won. Oh and just a tip you racist clown, "sharia" means 10 different things to 10 different muslims, its not a uniform term that means the same thing to all of them, it has a shifting meaning. You fell for fear monger spin.

  • Read & consider; The Chinese military/government has dehumanized, decimated, disrespected, & murdered 100s of thousands of Buddhist monks, over the yrs. The Chinese gov./military occupies Tibet & surrounding lands & murders protesters in large #s. Why havent the monks burned Cinese embassies, bombed Chinese neighborhoods, cut off Chinese civ's heads? Because Buddhism is inherently peaceful. Islam is not inherently peaceful. Look at the track record, people.

  • Wow she definitely doesn't sound racist does she.

  • @macspud28 Calling arabs "almost primitive savages"? No, of course not. That's not racist at all. At least in her mind, because she was so convinced that everything she said was a fact.

  • @SepherStar This immigrant russian woman single-handedly invented the GOP world view. It looks like she also invented that fair and balanced reporting I keep hearing about.

  • @drankin2112 I always wondered how republican ideology and democratic ideology became flipped.

  • DEAR RON PAUL- Watch this and STFU

  • @owizewon Ron Paul clearly disagrees with her on this one.

  • @owizewon Ron Paul is not on Arabs' side. He just wants to leave Israel deal with its problems. and the israelis have frankly proved that they can.

    facebook . cm /photo.php?fbid=19092010766468­5&set=pu.118409901582373&type=­1&theater#!/photo.php?fbid=190­920107664685&set=pu.1184099015­82373&type=1&permPage=1

  • @owizewon from Jews for Ron Paul group. facebook . cm /photo.php?fbid=19092010766468­5&set=pu.118409901582373&type=­1

  • This woman is a Cretan.

  • fucking old monster talking about savageness

  • ahhhh... man, well shes correct on like everything else

  • Donahue is a very intelligent guy!

  • She is misinformed, obviously she doesn't know much about the atrocities committed by the US and Israel. They are no better than the Arabs.

  • She just lost every bit of respect I had for her.

  • Besides, her position doesn't correspond with her other position on non-interventionism. Although one can agree that the level of development might have differ between Israel and Arab countries in the beg. of 1980, the level of economical developmnet can't be justification of military aggression. It's a short-legged argument. Why? Who should be the judge ( eg. for me Germany is better developed than France). Why attack Arabs and not Mongolians, Chinese, Soviets, Vietnamese etc. in 1970-1980s

  • The Jewish Legion, a group primarily of Zionist volunteers, assisted in the British conquest of Palestine in 1917. Arab opposition to British rule and Jewish immigration led to the 1920 Palestine riots and the formation of a Jewish militia known as the Haganah. The population of the area at this time was predominantly Arab and Muslim, with Jews accounting for about 11% of the population. See more about Zionist terror in Wikipedia: "Zionist political violence". Ayn Rand is historically selective.

  • Rand's Zionism puts a sever limit to her intellect. If she could've freed herself from this construct she might've been able to put the pieces of the puzzle together more objectively. Taking cock as Rockefeller's mistress probably did quite a bit to instill that worldview I'm sure.

  • @Broooose Speaking from personal experience?

  • GoodVibezin says:

    The only one retarded is you. You know how to string a few words together, but that’s about it. As far as being intelligent you provide no facts whatsoever. You’re simply projecting your own fallacies.

    There are no Christians around here criticizing me, just jews like yourself. You call me a racist but you jews simply aren’t human, you’re pigs. You love your money more than you love human nature.

    Someday the world will understand why the jews created Hitler.-GoodVibezin google.

  • Rand's descriptions of the Arabs is hardly gratuitous.

    Israel gets a five billion dollar CPU factory/research facility from Intel while 440,000,000 Arabs in 22 countries can't even attract a factory to sew doll clothes.

    Israeli agricultural exports fill the shelves of European markets but 440.000,000 Arabs in 22 countries all on the same basic latitude as Israel, TOGETHER cannot meet Israeli agricultural exports this way.

    Pointing this out isn't gratuitous or racist; denying it is.

  • @SatchmoSings Really? Ever been to Kuwait, Dubai??? Israel was built from breed of settlers educated in different countries and largely benefited from the mixture of relative multiethnicity combined with adhesive power of Judaism. The area settled by Jews is much more convenient to live and prosper than rest of the Sub-Saharan region, and that's evident when one studies 2500 years of the history of civilization there. Also, would be fair to mind the colonial history of Arab countries.

  • @SatchmoSings You might be missing the fact that Israel receives a great deal of support from western countries due to its geopolitical importance. Israel is basically a military outpost of the US and Europe. It gets jobs, money, military hardware and training, and a hell of a lot of international aid, etc, etc. You're also missing that the autocracies hobbling innovation in the middle east have generally had the blessing of the west.

  • @trniquet :You're largely correct, except for you last stament; you're blaming lack of development on neo-Colonialism and by the same token, you've also accepted Israel's embracing of hi-tech and advancement is also to the approval and blessing of The West

    China is an autocratic country that was raped over for well over a century but now look at China; you don't want to accept the fact that the Arab world is not interested in progress and the new regimes of the Arab Spring are similar

  • Thumbs up to Phil Donuhue.

    Thumbs down to Ayn Rand.

  • Civalized. 

  • Ugly Jew Bitch

  • Comment removed

  • @BornToDie90 When this "ugly Jew bitch" was 50 years old, she started in fucking this dude half her age; he was a pretty good-looking man and this lasted for over 13 years.

    Lets's see what you look like when you're in YOUR 70s; you probably look like shit now anyway . . .

  • @SatchmoSings its not about her age.. its about that disgusting jewishness that she posseses.. she was even uglier in her 30s... like all jews... and was she fucking a man half her age? wow. shocking, an uber-rich jew fucking a gigolo.. congrats on her

  • @BornToDie90 Fucking a gigolo? Hardly.

    You know as much about this as you know about anything else, which is, of course, obviously less than nothing and that also includes your overall non-understanding of women in general, even Jewish ones.

  • @SatchmoSings my conclusion is based on simpla facts... ugly old jew + money + young lover= ugly old jew using money for young lover

  • @BornToDie90 Your conclusion is based on your own Jew-hating fantasies; even the wife of the 25 year old that Rand was fucking was able to do a splendid bio of Rand based on facts and not her anger over what her husband did to her; you're really that sick . .. and ignorant too since this was also the basis for a movie about Rand.

  • @SatchmoSings jew hating and logic.. not that the two are separate

  • @BornToDie90 lol, calling jewish women ugly is a stretch. For every ugly jew like Ayn Rand or Golda Meir, there's kosher cuties like Natalie Portman, Mila Kunis, Lisa Edelstein, Gina Gershon, need I go on? Srsly, if you're gonna go after teh j00z there's more consistent stuff to catch them on than the way their women look.

  • @Kle7777 very few exceptions... i really think that every goo-looking jew out there is already a celebrity

  • FUCKING JEWS!! I FKING HATE ALL U FUCKING KIKES!!! YES I DO, IM RACIST ONLY TOWARDS YOU AND IM PROUD OF IT, I HAVE EVERY GOOD REASON TO HATE YOU AND ALWAYS WILL! BURN IN HELL U SONS OF SATAN! HITLER SHOULD HAVE KILLED YOU ALL!

  • As someone who actually like Ayn Rand's philosophies...even I had to give this video a dislike.

  • @emilylouisechurchos makes you feel dirty for liking (or in my case, liked) her philosophy, doesn't it? I know it does for me. Ayn Rand once stated racism is collectivism in its ugliest form. I still agree with that statement, and it made me realise Ayn Rand was a hypocrite..

  • Zionism = Colonialism

    Colonialism = Theft

  • Why doesn't she speak normal English even though she had lived in the US since she was 21?

  • @Kle7777 What the hell is normal English?

  • @MrRipperSkillz Well, y'know, not sounding like she's fresh-off-the-boat from Russia, not sounding like a shrill-voiced woman who has yet to shake the Russian/Yiddish accent of the language she spoke back in Russia. This video was made in 1979, a whopping. This means for 58 years she barely made an effort to make herself intelligeble.

  • @Kle7777 Rand's command of the English language is superb; it's certainly much better than even the above-average shithead that posts on "Youtube."

    Yes, she has a heavy accent but her English is most excellent.

  • @SatchmoSings Your's is also most excellent.

  • @GoodVibezin Thank you.

    Words are important to me; I try to be precise and when I write I also keep in mind that the reader has none of the other "contextuals" that would come with a face-to-face conversation or even a telephone call; the reader can only figure out what I'm saying purely from the printed word and little else. (My homepage here on "Youtube" does, of course, supply other "contextuals" about me.)

  • The middle east is not "most complicated". There are many details in the politics, but the basics are quite simple.

    There is one side that wants an absolute judenrein territory and will not stop its aggression until the jews are all dead or far away.

    On very few occasions in history was it as clear as in this conflict who the good guys and who the bad guys are.

    Ancient Greece against Persia, Rome against Carthage, England vs. France, etc. not remotely as clear as this case.

  • If you speak against Islam you are a hero. If you speak against the Jews you are a NAZI. Superb logic !!

  • Didn't the israelis bomb and use terrorist tactics so much that they drove the british out. Just think about that for a moment.

  • WOW this woman is highly despicable.

  • disgusting woman. Using the muslim terorist card and calling others racist. Israel is the biggest terror state ever.Ayn rand is not objective.

  • This video shows that Ayn Rand is ignorant of history. Have you ever heard of the words algebra, zenith, nadir and zero? They're Arabic words. The concept of "zero" came to Europe from Islamic Spain. In Islamic Spain Jews (and Christians) did not have equality with Muslims, but they were free to practice their religion and engage in commerce. For Jews it was considered a Golden Age. Contrast this to their treatment under the Visigoths and the Spanish Inquisition after the Reconquest.

  • "Hate Hate Hate!! Fear Fear Fear!!" - SatchmoSings

  • @urdisturbing This is quite obvious from your profile, since you refuse to use the old format which gives a much better "fleshing out" of who, or in your case, what you are.

    Indeed, I automatically assume hate, anger, fear and shame when a "Youtuber" refuses to show even a brief sketch of who and what he is and you're absolutely no surprise this way.

    My profile can and does give folks a much better handle about ME; I'm not a furtive snitch like some people are.

  • @SatchmoSings Do you have anything intelligent to say? Or are you like most youtube users, and only here to hurt people?

  • @urdisturbing Oh? You can't take the personal criticism of the double standard of hiding who you are when I don't?

    I personally find nothing hurtful in that; you should have, instead, either filled me on a bit of your "contextual" or at least justified your hiding this info.

    You're angry that I've challenged your beliefs and I've made quite a few points that, in going over our thread, you've refused to answer; your sense of shame is sorely misplaced.

  • @urdistrubing I'm done arguing with you.

  • @556deltawolf Quite the lowlife @urdisturbing is, isn't he?

    He's not bright; has absolutely NO capacity for analogies, let alone critical thinking; is obviously obsessed with Jews rather than with any sense of justice, world-wide; he's just too lazy and dumb to at least put up a few other videos to "throw us off the scent" this way but at least he's honest this way.

  • @SatchmoSings Everything that you said is true. I'm a stoned hippi living in the same bedroom since i was 12. That doesn't change the fact that everything I've said is true and you haven't said a single intelligent thing this entire conversation.

    Zionism = Colonialism

    Colonialism = Theft

    I'm going to repeat that until you say something which contradicts it.

  • @urdisturbing Everything you've said is a Jew-hating and Jew-baiting lie that just reeks of the usual double-standards that are applied to Israel and are at best, ignored elsewhere or at least tacitly if not outrightly approved of.

    And you're also a racist regarding Arabs; you give them no credit for their own decisions; everything is they do is purely under the umbrella of neo-colonialism; you can't accept the choices they make so you pin the blame on their choices elsewhere.

  • @SatchmoSings I'm saying that all Arabs don't deserve to be punished for the actions of a few, and Palestinians don't deserve to be punished the crimes of the Nazis. I think judging someone by there race is primitive and malicious; all people are individuals. I also think Nationalism is a mental illness, as it causes people to take credit for accomplishments that they had nothing to do with and hate people that they have never met.

    Zionism = Colonialism

    Colonialism = Theft

  • @urdisturbing 01. The Palestinians weren't punished for the crimes of the Nazis; you've obviously never looked at a map nor the demographics of the 1948 partition and while the Arabs had a state that was virtually "Jew-free," the Jews had "their own state" that was 45% Arab.

    Jews have ALWAYS had a presence in Palestine and in various censuses taken during Ottoman times showed strong majorities (if not pluralities) in much of Ottoman Palestine.

  • @urdisturbing 02. Jews have to have our own state for a matter of personal safety; we did try to share with the Arabs but the Arabs, both within what was the Mandate and outside of it found this intolerable and obviously, you do too.

    Oh, and by the way, 68% of the Arabs who fled what is today Israel never once saw an Israeli soldier; you obviously don't consider the Arabs making war on Israel to be Colonialism and theft but your idea of "Justice."

  • @SatchmoSings More lies. I never condoned Arab violence towards Israel and I even said it hurt their cause.

    I pointed out the fact that Palestinians were never given the right of self-government by the British, but you justified this by saying that all Arabs are evil because of what happened 1300 years ago, proving that you have no interest in giving them basic human rights.

    Zionism = Colonialism

    Colonialism = Theft

  • @urdisturbing Palestinians WERE given the right of self-government; the UN partition made for TWO states in the region so your claim this way is a LIE.

    Where do you come up with this shit?

    The US, Canada, Australia and NZ have all given their indigenous peoples the same rights as the conquering whitey; when are the Arab countries going to do the same such as letting Copts repair their churches without Arab Muslims telling them no?

  • @SatchmoSings Do you still think what happened in 637 is relevant today? If so, you are really making a serious error, and it needs to be rectified. Otherwise, Arabs will never have a hope for fair treatment from people like you.

    Once again, your argument is that there are lots of evil people in the world, so Israel can be as evil as it wants. I think thats stupid.

    Jews don't deserve Israel any more than Mennonites deserve Germany.

    Zionism = Colonialism

    Colonialism = Theft

  • @urdisturbing You're the one that is making the serious error; you obviously support the subjugation of Berbers, Copts, Nubians, Phoencians, Assyrians and Chaldeans by Arab Muslims and furthermore once the people of Egypt, now totally free of any sort of your claimed neo-Colonialism, will, of course, chose a stricter Islamist government that will make things even worse for the Coptic minority.

    I know, for a fact, that when this happens you'll still be complaining about Zionism.

  • @SatchmoSings People should always be more focused on their own faults then on the faults of others, so I want to make sure that MY government doesn't support any Pariah states. This includes Israel, Iran, and Zimbabwe amongst others.

    So, what exactly is your definition of an Aggressive War? If Europe colonizing and enslaving Americans, with periods of blatant genocide, wasn't aggressive, what exactly is?

  • @urdisturbing As I've already pointed out, I have no idea what country is "your" country because you're afraid to show it on your profile; there is no contextual here; for all I know you're from North Korea.

    Arabs conquering much of The Middle East and North Africa, with its blatant genocide, is a good definition of aggression; you obviously don't consider Arab countries to be pariah states but you do consider Israel to be one, the one state in the ME where Arabs have real rights.

  • @SatchmoSings I'm from Canada, and my profile says so.

    The Palestinians never conquered North Africa. That happened hundreds of years ago.

    The homeland of Palestinians is Palestine, reason being they had lived their for generations. The homeland of European and American Jews is America and Europe for the same reason.

    Zionism = Colonialism

    Colonialism = Theft

  • @urdisturbing Jews have lived continuously in Palestine and more Jews lived in Jerusalem in the mid-to late 1800s than Arabs have.

    I see how you insist that the homeland for European Jewry is Europe; I take this to mean you're in favor of The Holocaust; Jews must be subjected to whatever Europe wants for us.

    Arabism = Colonialism

    Colonialism = Theft

  • @SatchmoSings My god, you are an incredible liar. Absolutely nothing you say about me is true. Not one thing. You make outrageous accusations of heineous crimes and don't provide a single quote or reasonable piece of evidence to back them up. You are incredibly paranoid for assuming that every single person who is against war must be a Nazi.

    Don't worry, I'm not judging all Jews based on you.  That would be a dick move.

  • @urdisturbing Every single person that is against Jews is a Nazi and you do judge Jews based on me because most Jews do agree with me; I don't need your lies; this is precisely why you talk about Israel as you do; half of the world's Jewry lives there and this is precisely how you feel about them.

  • @SatchmoSings If you admit that Colonialism = Theft, then you admit that Zionism = Theft. Check-mate, you loose.

    Just because I don't want anyone to steal in the name of nationalism doesn't mean I hate Jews.

    Happy NewYear, you fascist pig.

  • @urdisturbing It's great how you don't agree that rounding up Jews and putting us into gas chambers doesn't count for anything evil and, in fact, you are in favor of it because if more Jews had been killed there would have been no survivors to populate Israel.

    Happy New Year, you neo-Nazi you!

  • @SatchmoSings Thats right, condemning war is the same thing as endorsing the holocaust. You are so stupid its not funny. Go see a shrink.

    Everyone who sees your comments is going to know for sure that Zionism is a mental illness.

  • @SatchmoSings The colonization of the new world was extremely unethical, so by drawing comparisons you are condemning your own movement. Also, I think Jews demanding a home land in Palestine makes about as much sense as Native Americans demanding a homeland in Miami.

  • @urdisturbing American Indians DO have their own homelands in various parts of the United States & while American Indians may not have a homeland specifically in Miami, I'm sure they do in other parts of Florida.

    If you ever go to an "Indian Homeland" I'd appreciate if you pick up a few cartons of cigarettes for a friend of mine; since this is "homeland" for many Indians they don't have to subject smokes to the same taxes that Uncle Sam and various state and local governments do.

  • @urdistrubing Do you know how hypocritical you sound right now? You argue against the forcing of Palestians and Natives Americans to move yet you apporve of making the Jews leave Israel! You know what, you're right! Maybe to end racial discrimination, all the African Americans should move back to Africa. All the white people should go back to Europe and the Asians go back to whatever Asian nation they came from. Dude, that kind of attitude FUELS rascism and hate. Not solve it.

  • @556deltawolf I don't think the Jews should be forced to leave Israel. I apoligize for leading you to believe that.

    I think the best solution is a two-party state but I think Israel has made a clear choice of expansion over security, meaning they aren't really interested in peace. I think Zionism in general is misguided and I resent it that I am accused of racism every time I stand up against it.

  • @urdisturbing Jews have to have our own home because racists like you want us to live as minorities elsewhere so we can be killed, much to your pleasure.

    And while you/'re at it, I see you obviously approve of Berbers, Copts, Nubians, Phoenicians, Assyrians and Chaldeans living as minorities amongst Arabs; you also obviously feel that this is something "healthy" for these minorities, particularly with the rise of Islamism.

    @556deltawolf

  • @SatchmoSings

    Zionism = Colonialism

    Colonialism = Theft

    Which part of this equation don't you understand? The best hope for world peace (which is essential, now that humans have nukes) is to say that nobody is allowed to steal from anyone.

  • @urdisturbing I'm glad to hear that you believe that not stealing from anyone will make for world peace.

    That said, tell me when Poland is going to give back what they stole from the 8.5 million Germans they threw out after WWII or the Czechs that did the same with 2.5 million Germans after this war.

    Since you only seem concerned with Jews this way, there is something very odious, if not actually neoNazi-like in your observations.

  • @urdisturbing "Expansion over security?"

    Yes, you are correct; it must have been a mistake to return Sinai to Egypt and it was also wrong to give Gaza over to Hamas, especially after Hamas thanked Israel with over 6000 rounds.

    A two party state would be even worse for the Jews of Israel than what has happened to South Africa in the wake of the end of Apartheid; The Union of South Africa is now the rape and AIDS capital of the world

  • @urdistrubing You could argue that people are "one family" but guess what, we are not! Were social animals yes, but we are still animals. Humans cannot be forced to get along we each other hell the argument were having right now is a prime example. I'm sorry but I personally find the idea that humans are "one family" a complete violation of human nature. I'm sorry.

  • @556deltawolf With that "One Family" thing I was arguing against nationalism. I consider Nationalism to be a mental illness, as it only causes people to take credit for accomplishments that they had nothing to do with and to hate people that they have never met. Pretty of everything that you are has been determined by things outside of yourself, so claiming superiority because of your God-given gifts is childish and arrogant.

  • @urdistrubing There are people who still want the jews dead. Have you ever heard the president of Iran talk? That guy is crazy! Second of all the Palestians are free. If they want to be treated better, instead of following Ghandi, they should the follow the works of Booker T. Washington and improve their lives, stop supporting the extremists who take lives, and stop trashing Israel. In time, the Israelis will then accept them as fellow men rather than terrorists.

  • @556deltawolf Did you know that the president of Iran was the best hope for democracy in the middle east before the CIA assasinated him?  If America wants to end terrorism, the best thing it can do is stop committing it.

    If the Israelis don't want to get bombed the best thing they can do is go home. By "Home" I mean Europe and America.

  • @urdisturbing How dare you compare US relations with Native Americans to genocides! Now granted, we did horrible things to the Native Americans but we never commited acts of genocide. The definition of genocide is "the deliberate and systematic destruction, in whole or in part, of an ethnic, racial, religious, or national group" Did we kill Native Americans in the past? Yes we did I'll admit that but it wasn't deliberate!

  • @urdisturbing Ayn Rand did not defend William Edward Hickman she was more fascinated for who he was. She was more interested in why he chose to kill and why he came to that decision and there is nothing wrong with that. One of the best way to prevent crime is too understand the criminal mind.

  • @urdistrubing Just because someone forces you to move out of your homeland does not grant you the right to kill and murder innocent people like all those extremist do. In fact, she's Rand is right about the extremists being unwilling to change. You are a complete hypocrite to say that Rand "supports" murderers yet you yourself are voicing support to people who resort to violence and terrorism just to get a political point across. People like you disgust me!

  • @556deltawolf The Golden Rule is my moral premise - and for that reason I am condemning of all violence and aggression.

    Every time Israel has expanded, it took things by force and then afterwords demanded that its enemies negotiate and act reasonably. This is the strategy that all imperial powers use.  If the Palestinians were led by Gandhi they would probably be free by now - violence has certainly hurt their cause - but Israel does NOT have the right to act innocent.

  • @urdisturbing When a nation starts a war and loses, the defending victor gets to dictate the peace; that's the way it's been throughout history.

    That is, of course, unless that nation is Israel; Israel, according to you, MUST be the sole exception to this.

    I must assume you make this odious exception, solely for Israel, because you hate Jews; if I'm wrong, you can explain it to me.

    @556deltawolf

  • @SatchmoSings You keep using a false analogy. Palestine is the homeland of Palestinians, Western imperial powers are the invaders. Of course, you think arabs don't have a right to self-government because of what happened 1400 years ago, a position which I find mind-boggling stupid. The only other option is to say that boths sides are defenders, which of course is absurd.

    Zionism = Colonialism

    Colonialism = Theft

    What don't you understand about that?

  • @urdisturbing You're the one with the false analogy; Palestinians are ARABS and Arabs come from (Saudi) Arabia; they arrived in the region in 638 AD on their way westward to conquer as far away as what is today, Mauritania; any Berber, Copt, Nubian, Phoencian, Assyrian and Chaldean can tell you this.

    When will the Arabs leave so all these indigenous peoples of North Africa and The Middle East can all have their land back free of the Colonialism and Theft of the Arab?

  • @SatchmoSings Jews are Arabs and Arabs are Jews it's only religion that fucks everybody up. Part of a study published in the Proceedings of the National Academy of Science "They may have their differences but Jews and Arabs share a common genetic heritage that stretches back thousands of years.

    The striking similarities in their biology have just been revealed in a study of over 1,300 men in almost 30 countries worldwide."

  • @davijeph I looked up that quote and the news story that went along with it; you're presenting it in the most simplistic of terms when the real story is much more complex. (BBC News).

    Yes, Jews and Arabs have some DNA in common and they also have a lot that isn't which you conviently left out so don't hand me bullshine that I can confirm for myself.