Added: 3 years ago
From: HogwartsHonorRoll
Views: 19,911
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (186)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • This was so amazing! Ag, it made me cry, though. I just recently watched The Stolen Earth/Journey's End and I still haven't recovered. IT'S JUST TOO SAD. I probably missed large parts of it, because I was too busy crying. But really, this video was fantastic. When the Doctor is running towards Rose, and he looks so happy and he's sprinting towards her, and he hasn't looked that happy since Rose left, and then that stupid Dalek shows up. Waaah. </3

  • Love it love it love it!

    Dr/Rose forever! <3

  • OH MY GOD, you ripped my heart out...I'm crying. This is fantastic. Ahhh....I can't go over how sweet and wonderful he looks when he starts running toward her...so eager to hold her. Gah!

  • Honestly, I cried for the last 2 episodes of Season 2 and the last 2 of Season 4... I miss Billie and David :'(

  • I was just wondering if anyone had thought to make a vid for this song. It's so perfect for these two. Brilliant editing.  You had me crying.

  • That was beautiful I cried XD

  • Wow! What a great song choice! I realised how perfect it was when the doctor turned round towards Rose and i got shivers! omg and now i'm basically crying AGAIN for the hundred-thousand-billionth time over the doctor and rose! great job, your videos are all great!

  • This song as alway made me sad but you made it even sadder

  • Oh. My. God.

    *favorites* immediately.

    I am in LOVE with this video.

    *goes off to cry for the thousandth time over the tragical-ness of ten and rose*

  • Every time I see the look of happiness on the Doctor's face when he's running to Rose makes my heart break...

  • Aww Thats Cute :P

    Love the Song too (:

  • made me cry :) love you guys

  • he didnt die though until 2010 new years day MISS YOUUU DAVIDDD LOVEE YOUUU

  • Love it

    Rose is the girl he loves

  • ...This vid has seriously pulled some heartstrings. O_Q Ten/Rose...

  • I think the people who made the new series always knew Rose was coming back but they wouldnt let the doctor stay with her. The Doctor has a curse. All his companions come and go and he has to stay behind, Unaging, Unchanging, stuck in time. I think the only thing that doesnt leave him is the TARDIS

  • This is truly the embodiement of Doctor/Rose cuteness. I LOVE all the flashbacks and I think they're wonderfully edited and gloriously heartbreaking and- and- Ach! This is wonderful.

  • I love Rose and at first hated Rtd but now I see he has done us such a HUGE favour in putting Rose with 10.5. There was no WAY that she could have stayed with him forever, she would have shriveled and he would be stuck on the slow path= bad tv. admit it. However, now rose and 10.5 r together we can have lovely fantasies about them doing lovely things like having kids and getting married and just loving each other. I know 10 is upset but rose was gonna leave at some point so its best this way....

  • i always cry when i watch doomsday, and journeys end. After every time I watch it, I just wanna scream, 'Just let them get together for god's sakes!' I feel so sorry for the Dr. All his companions move on and he is stuck with nobody again. Where or when is his happy ending? But once the happy ending for him comes, the end of dr. who comes. *SOB* why is the world so cruel!

  • YEah they put Orse with the clone, becuase Steven Moffatt hates Rose! he said, "just dump the clingy girlfriend with the clone"

    How Sad!

  • Beautiful video! The music is awesome, and the way you matched the clips really made this a superb video. Keep up the awesome work!

    5 stars/favorited

    Li Li

  • absolutely brilliant!!

    Thankfully, I just watched the finale (yes, just- we finished it about a week ago!) or I would be really mad!

    Amazing!

  • im not a huge rose fan (donna's my fave) but this video is beautiful! being the horrible fan that i am i watched this BEFORE id seen the full episode, and the way it ended with him almost dying made me cry with nervousness. of course i also cried because this was amazing, of course. he he.

  • The best part of this video is that it came out on my birthday... *sob* I cry every time I watch that episode...

  • *sobs* Gosh i'm so pathetic.....I loved this sooooooo much. Most people think I am incredibly sad. I cried at the end of the last episode of series 2, during the last two episodes of Series 4 and at the end when the Doctor and Rose got together but also when Donna couldn't remember him.....*cries* I think I'll watch it again....

  • Nah, you're not pathetic.

    That's a natural reaction.

    I still cry every time I watch "Doomsday", "Stolen Earth", and "Journey's End".

  • @ImADrWhoAddict Saw this video twice befre moving on. (I also cried in the end of series 2...It was a good cry.) Had to wait for a couple of days before moving on with season three. Was emotionally spent.. So you're not alone ;)

  • *sobs*

  • same! whenever it's a sad moment, I cry- also when jenny *died* in his arms. and the master. so sad! david plays the character so well, you really believe he is heartbroken!

    *gets tissue out again*

    another superb video :)

  • and just for once.....the universe let rose and the doctor be together.....again....time and space never about cared about the effects , it just let them be...

    Thats going in y novel of these two....great video

  • how do you get the clips of them? i always wondered :-((

    Nice vid Btw :-))

    xx

  • oh my goodness, i literally am sobbing right now xD

    amazing. <3

  • Comment removed

  • Ok, so you may have noticed that I'm working my way backwards through your videos, hence the thousand comments I'm leaving (sorry :P).

    Of course, this is no exception, it was so beautiful - and the editing! You have a gift, my friend.

  • I don't object to your thousands of comments ;)

    But I fear for you if you're working your way backwards, as some of my superold stuff is GHASTLY horrible.

    XD

    Thanks very much :)

  • This made me cry. I loved it.

  • it was soo good and the song suited sooo well

    well done xD

  • omg! just wanted to say your videos are amazing! the amount of times i've watched them is worrying! Please keep on making great videos!

    I too was naive enough to think this time they would actually get together...

    and this video always gets me!

    xxxx

  • Thank you very much :)

    Really, you have no idea what that means, just to know that someone really enjoys these things :)

    It's what keeps me posting ;)

  • @HogwartsHonorRoll both your video ruby and the scene was beautifully done just the bit when the doctor sees rose again and his face (0:53) and then when they run to each other is brillaint its just those pesky bloody daleks that get in the way of good things!

  • Made me cry. Amazing. ;]

  • WOW!!!

    this was one of the first great doctor videos i saw. thankz for being awesome

  • Oh wow :D

    Thank you very much :D

    I'm really glad you enjoyed it :)

  • i don't lie about doctor who, and i don't compliment lightly.

    You totally love you like a sibling!!!

  • Cheers :D

    Really :DD

  • I LOVE THIS SONG!! :D thanks for making such a great vid once again <3 and the song fits so well with the dr and rose :)

  • That part where the Doctor starts running towards Rose combined witht he cresendo of the song gets me every time.

  • Whats the song right at the end?

  • it says on the ending credits

  • almost lover :)

  • wow i really can't stop watching your videos they just inspier me to cotinue making my vids infact ur vids are the reason i started making vids so thx

  • Rose rocks I like the bit with her gun and in the stolen earth that part was so funny!

  • Your very welcome =D

  • If i was writing about Rose and the....End i would have that massive denial attack too as i love her so much.

    WHY DO YOU MAKE SUCH GOOD VIDEOS!?!

    Are you insistent on making me cry?

    *Break down*

    Sob Sob

    *Gets grip...well sort of*

    Sorry but videos like this always make me cry especially yours as you always show them just right in the way that reminds verryone of why they love the ten/Rose relationship.

    Another great video

  • Ohhhh!!

    Thanks very much :DDD

  • im sorry for the comment i did 2 weeks ago i was acting like a jerk THIS IS A AWESOME VIDEO!!!!! 5 star and favorite

  • as if lol im doin thousand miles 1 now nd i was gunna do tht bit to tht song exsactly lik tht

  • beautiful reeli good its strange but im finfing tht most others tht make d.w fanvids know and like all the same songs as me, its wierd!! lol tht had nothing to do with anything but i love the video song n the credits song too lol, n its a reeli good video xx

  • well she might've liked tht song so buzz off.

  • k just asking

    jeez louise

    (what the hell did i do

  • Brilliant song to amazing clips. Well done. (Y)

  • omg such a good video....and well pretty much the best song ever for the doctor and rose. great work x

  • The song was perfect...

    Btw, i would have ripped that Dalek apart with my bare hands for ruining what would have been a happy moment!

  • i know!! cant they just hug??

  • Love it ..perfect song for them x x

  • perfect song for them!!!

  • nice video!

  • Beautiful. Absolutely beautiful.

    Crap. You've got me in tears over here.

  • *tear* Cute vid, great song.

    Doctor and Rose forever!

    =D

  • fantastic cover of the reunion. i can't wait to see what you do with the finale it was amazing. gj.

  • Omg, that made me sob so much... almost more than when I watched it in the episode itself!! Great job, though! You really summed the nearly most tear-jerking moment in the history of everything XD

  • aww *sniff* beautiful vid X3

  • You know, I didn't find it an happy ending.

    Actually, I think it's utterly depressive.

    I want Rose to be together with the REAL doctor, and I know it just fits in this way. But I can't be happy about it! All the good reasons that there are for that Rose chose the 'fake' doctor just simply ain't enough.

    I know he's not really dead, but, I just want Rose and the doctor (the first) to be together.

    And they can dump the other guy in that other dimension.

    Oh, and Donna ought to get her memory back

  • Exactly how I feel too

  • I think of it...well, did you see Confidential?

    The way Billie described it, as like in Beauty and the Beast, where Belle kissed the Beast and he turns into a man...

    ...you're really happy that she's got the human version, but you're upset that she hasn't got the "Beast" anymore.

    Billie summed it up nicely for me, to be honest. I'm happy that she got the Doctor, but not so much because he's not -the- Doctor.

  • :D Glad to know that I'm not the only one :)

  • Ok, i was the first to comment on this video and I've watched it every day since then :D

    I also commented again saying its in my playlist but I want to comment one more time.

    Okay, you are a youtube LEGEND

    Enough said ;)

  • Ohhh!!

    You are bloody brilliant, you know that?

    You've officially made me a very happy person, DoctorWhoDave :)

    Cheers :D

  • Oh I'm stupid

    I wasn't the first to comment Lol

    Anyway, I'm 100% sure that I told you a while ago that I had started making a doctor/rose vid to this song but I can't see the comment here, I dno, maybe it was a P.M *Shrugs*

    Anyway, I finally got round to finishing it yesterday :D But don't want to upload it until I've made sure again that you're ok with it

    Thanks

  • Of course you can!!

    ...sorry for the delayed responce on that one, I've been on a family holiday to New Hampshire and once again find my attention commanded by my neice, Carris.

  • Thanks :D

    Really? Cool. Did you have a good time?

  • Not a problem :D

    Yeah, I had a pretty good time. Got to see a lot of people I haven't seen in ages, went to the beach a bit, and marveled at the fact that the entire family actually managed to have a little get-together, as it's very rare for all of us to do anything together as a big group.

  • That's great :)

  • Love the video, and love the song! I was very happy that Rose got her happy ending in the end, but I felt so sad for the Doctor! I mean, he still loves her, and now he has been replaced! That would be terrible! I'm sure he would be happy for her though! :D Great video once again, very well-edited, 5 stars! :D

  • Great Video!

    Makes me want to cry.

    At the finally I was glad they were together but I would prefer the real real doctor to be with her.

  • i know!! thats exaclty what i thought!

  • AWESUM VID!! I MEAN IT!!!! i luv this pair, and the show!! i cried at the season 4 finale!!

  • Same here!

    I was in floods of tears, lol a sight for sore eyes :)

  • lolz,

    well, she is technaclly WITH him, and theyll grow old with each other :D and that makes me happy

    but a part of me wants to say shes not with the REAL doctor, ya know?

  • OMG!OMG! I thot the xact same, so in a way Its Bittersweet!

    But i cried the most for Donna...i mean come on, tht was just shocking!

  • i know!! she cant even remember a thing, but if she does, *BOOF* there her head goes.. lol

    i felt sorry for her when she had that thing on her back and stuff, that would be so freakin SCARRYY!! and donna, thats what she wanted to do the most, is 2 be with the doctor, and explore the worlds. i wonder who the NEW assistant will be... O.o

  • I know for defo...the new assistant can't top Rose or Donna...

    Don't u think its strange tht the women who want to be with him forever (Rose and Donna actually say it) are ripped away from him, its a cruel world out there.

    I mean Rose and The Doctor where couple material and Donna and The Doctor where Best friends, (i nevr liked Martha...lol)

    But man...i could strangle Russel T Davies sometimes :|..och well! :)

  • i know! i always just felt srry for donna (that weird creature on her back and she wanted to be with the doctor) i liked rose the best and i liked martha. i thought it wuz funny, cuz the doctor would keeping bringing up the subject of rose when martha was the new assistant

    Rose and the 10th doctor will lways be a couple to me (cause they technacly r now, and that makes me happy. not like rose was gonna live for ever, so she got a human doctor)

  • I think somewhere out there, someone's created the Book of Doctor Who Law, which must be followed when writing Doctor Who nowadays (since I don't know about the old days so much), that says that the Doctor has to be miserable all the time and anyone who makes him happy must be forcably taken away from him.

    *sigh*

    And Rose...I'm really happy that she finally got her happy ending, as I always thought that she was such a tragic character. But the Doctor's had his heart broken all over again.

  • Yupperz bout that book. and i liked that she did gets her, but yes, the doctor had his heart broken again :((

  • Yep i know waht you mean....both of the women who wanted to be with him forever were ripped away from him! :'(

  • :(( poor doctor!!

    i heard his daughter might be the new assistant.. O.o

  • No!...i don't think it'll be rite :(

    I want Donna AND Rose back and then we'll have a nice big happy family. XD!

  • xD!!

    that would be soo awesome tho

  • It's possible.

    I mean, they keep trying for new dynamics, and Father/Daughter would certainly be a new one.

    I mean, it wouldn't give the shippers out there much to go for, but it'd be interesting.

    I mean, we've had the romance, the unrequited romance, and the best friends...who knows what's next?

  • LOL, my thought's exactly!! Those two are so awesome!

  • I still want to cry!! Lol. But this was a good vid

  • amazing video !!!!! yet again !!!!!!

  • AWES0ME

  • amazing video!

  • wow such a great vid :)

  • OMG that was so good!

    XD

  • wow its brill im going crazy because of the wait

  • that was beautiful

  • amazing video. the timing was excellent. just... amazing. loved it.

  • Excellant video, really moving that one :-)

  • To hogwartshonourrole:

    have you seen the second episode of stolen earth??

    message back x

  • Hasn't aired yet.

    But I shall watch it on tv when it does :D

  • i cant wait theirs only like 2 hours and 20 minutes to go !! xD

  • OMG, *Gobsmackededness*

  • This video is so perfect <33. Captured the moment amazingly.

    I totally bawled my eyes out in the episode when he turned around and saw her and the music was beautiful and GAAAAHHHH. Cried like a baby XD.

  • really good!

    where has the middle of that song gone?!

    aaa! can't wait for Journey's End, but i'm going to miss it!! noooo! :( :( :( :(

    aaa! i'm just going to cry now!

    oh well, i'll just have to watch it on iplayer after! :D

    such a good vid! as always

  • Thanks very much :D

    ...the middle of the song?

    It went on holiday ;)

    Nah, I just couldn't take working with so much Doctor/Rose so soon after "Stolen Earth". I would have ended up a wreck by the time I finished.

  • lol!

    fair enough! i dpn't know how i'll cope when i atempt a Stolen Earth/Journey's End vid!

    aaa! preparing myself for hysterical tears and i pick out a song!!

  • I've commented on this before..and faved :) but I just wanted to let you know, this is this weeks video in my video of the week playlist :D

  • Ohhh!!

    Cheers, Dave :D

    *cyberhug*

  • XD

    *Cyberlaugh but it sounds like Crazy Dalek Caan's laugh in the stolen earth*

    ....

    sorry, i'm hyper and going mad (just like Caan) from the wait for journey's end :P

  • Ahhhhhhhhhhhhhhh talk about good. This video deffiently made my heart stop. I'm still going crazy with that heart wrenching cliffhanger and your clip refreshed the anguish I felt at the end of last weeks ep. Completeltley brilliant caught all the emotion of their reunion.

  • Ohhh cheers :D

  • *sniff* love it =]

  • SEVERAL dead fish.

    I mean, right then? It could have waited ten seconds or so, you would have thought even a dalek had some sense of delicacy about reunions.

    Tsssh.

    Still, I love love love your video :) (as always) especially how you timed it when he's turning round.

    And that scene is WONDERFUL.

  • Glad someone other than my couisn Sapphire finds it appropriate to smack RTD with nothing other than dead fish.

    Stupid Daleks. They ruin everything.

    Thanks very much :D

  • OH!!! I'M SOBBING NOW!!! but it was absolutely brilliant as are you btw for making such amazing vids with perfectly fitting songs, both of which i love.

    oh dear i'm terribly a wreck for saturday. I'm absolutely devestated (although slightly thrilled) by their almost perfect reunion, and even more so by the cliffhanger ending! poor doctor and rose! they never get a break!

  • Same exact reaction to "Stolen Earth". It's been driving me -mad-!

    And thank you sooo much :D

  • this is brilliant. perfect timing and jst brill well done! =D

  • *shocked* I Love this!! I hope the doctor Ok...I think he damaged like...and then the TARDIS doesnt work properly :(:( Omg I love this about Ten and rose

  • *gasps* that was really amazing. made me cry, stolen earth+doomsday and then this next episode are bound to be the episodes that garentee i will cry.

  • I love your videos! Many do touch people a lot, many of your Doctor/Rose ones end up with my crying, I think you rock and RTD as well.

  • Ohhh thanks!

    I am soo honoured ;D

  • It's nice to see others apart from me putting Stolen Earth bits into their vids so quickly XD

    i just hope he isn't really regenerating... ;-(

  • right vid

    i cried at doomsday episode and i cried at the stolen earth episode

    so o think i will cry for years when i see the next episode

  • that was a great video!!

    i can't wait for saturday to come!! i must watch doctor who! :D

  • AHHH.

    I think you're channeling some RTD, miss.

    because THAT made me cry.

    ALMOST LOVER = <3

  • NOOO!

    I can't channel that heartless man!

    I've always had nothing but respect and the highest regard for RTD, but after "Stolen Earth", I have the intense desire to smack him with a dead fish.

    ...

    Still, he's my absolute hero, regardless ;)

    Cheers :D

  • No, don't be so hard on RTD. It would have been way too sappy to have their romantic reunion in the middle of all the chaos. There is still one hour left of storyline. Rose/10 WILL have their moment.

    By the way, this video is absolutely brilliant. You are so darn talented.

  • I agree.

    Don't worry Ruby, it's a good thing. I rarely cry over ficction, so you and RTD making me cry = Win.

  • OMG you guys are all way too amazing :D

    Thanks soooo sooo much :D

    *is forever indebted to my amazing subscribers*

  • YAY

    rose is back

    OMG the reunion was so sweet

    Stupid dalek

  • HogwartsHonorRoll, you never cease to amaze me. :) Just when I thought this song had been done to death, you go and make this. It's brilliant! How you find the time to make so many videos is beyond me, but I speak for many people when I say I'm glad you do! XD

    Saturday CANNOT come soon enough!

    xx

  • Oh wow!

    That is possibly the most flattering comment I have ever recieved in my nearly two years on this acount and the year on my previous one.

    Thank you sooo much!

  • Lol. No probs. :)

  • Oh yes, i cryed at the run up. It was so emotional. Cryed today about it as well. Really good video, keep up the good work. :)

  • omg i fecking cried!!!!

  • How did this not show up on my subs? *smashes YT* This is amazing! Straight to the faves! The editing tuning with the beat was a nice touch! ;) I never would have thought of this song for this scene. Good idea!

  • I actually came across it by accident, to be honest.

    I was rewatching the reunion scene, to torture myself, and I was working on a video to that song anyway and it started playing randomly in the background and I was like

    :O

    Cheers :D

  • Ok big mistake of mine or youtubes for not showing this vid in my subscriptions I was wondering when you were gonna make a Doctor & Rose reunion vid ^^ this is AMAZING! i so love this song and it bring tears to my eyes AGAIN! with that scene of them running to each other T_T damn DALEK! lol anyway 5/5 this is totally awsome!

  • waouh so beautiful you mede me dry again 5 stars

  • Someone should do that almost lover song to that. But still great video! Captures the emotion perfectly! =D

  • Brilliant. Perfect. Fantastic.

  • devastatingly beautiful, as usual.

    i'll admit, i cried.

    I HATE THAT DALEK!!

  • OH MY GOD

    1. this is a brilliant vid :D

    2. WHY DID I WATCH THIS?? we only JUST started getting the eps over here last week! im sooooo stupid...

    3. and, omg, i nearly died wif happiness wen i saw the doctor's face wen he saw rose. seriously, i was completely ecstatic.

    AND THEN MR DALEK CAME ALONG...

    damnit. im gonna hav to wait, like, months 2 get to that ep.

    *dies*

    but, like i said, GREAT vid! 5 stars ;D

  • Yeah.

    "Oh My God" sums up "Stolen Earth" rather nicely.

    Want to go on an international Dalek Extermination Tour?

    ...I think using "Extermination" in the title would make things all the more ironic.

    The "DET" for short.

    DET:"Hello, we're going to exterminate some Daleks."

    DALEK: "EXTERMIN-"

    DET: "Ermm. No. Exterminate yourself!"

    DALEK: *implodes*

    ....*Ruby needs to get her brain checked out*

  • lmfao.

    That would be awesome.

  • I love this video....it is going on my favourites list....

  • It seems I haven't stopped crying since I saw 'The Stolen Earth' WTF is up with that? RTD you magnificent bastard you! Give them (and us) a taste of happiness and then you exterminate it away!!!

    Great video anyway. *goes back to sobbing*

  • As long as I'm not the only one who is still crying about it several days later.

    Because I've gotten to the point that I can't even watch the happiest of Doctor/Rose videos without collapsing into a puddle of tears.

  • *cries* *wails* oh that killed me, like episode does EVERY TIME, oh I LOVE it!!!!!!

  • This part of the episode always makes me cry as well. That song really seems to fit those two so well.

  • wowowow, that was amazing!! GREAT!!

  • Just remember Ruby David isn't leaving! You can stop crying now! THIS SO IS SO PERFECT FOR ROSE AND THE DOCTOR! I love the moment where the Doctor turns around and sees Rose and then starts running in slow motion. I almost started crying at the end of this :(Great job. 5/5 and favorited!

  • hehe stolen earth is one of the best dw episodes , i love this song and it goes perfectly with them ^.^ good work!

    Keep it up!

    Pygmypuff20

    xx

  • excellent.

  • Absolutly brilliant! You have a really good talent for these videos. It's fantastic! 5 Stars! *****

  • i still cry when ever i watch the stolen earth so sad the end i love *david* but the doctor and rose are back together *yeesss* love your video.

  • I love this song and I love the Doctor and I absolutely love your talent for music videos. I can ignore Rose getting the Doctor killed again to enjoy the rest of it.

  • amazing!!!fantastic your work ;)

  • great vid u kno the ep is 65 mins long its longer than the longest chrimbo special!