A Scene From Closer

[MsMagicstore]

Why isn't love enough?

[chiflynex]

Oh, I can't tell you how much I cried in this scene. The bad thing is that this shit happens in real life =/

[mensahcarrelle]

He actually left the lovely natalie for Julia "Horseface" Roberts?!?What a jerk!

[Ironman374]

Even as a male, I relate heavily to Natalie throughout this film. It was a huge shock to me in this scene when she said, "No one will ever love you as much as I do" and "Why isn't love enough". I said those exact words to my ex fiancee of 3 years when she left me for another guy, but without the emotional breakdown. This scene might be my favorite. Her love is clearly so strong for him. Sitting up on the couch with that charming, sleepy, innocent look on her face. "What?" What an angel.

[jalgjalg]

Odi et amo

[olyviax]

i feel exactly like alice right now.. she's amazing.

[pixelb0xer]

like poetry...

[94Taraa]

because nothing last forever..........The End

[GYPSYQUEEN5050]

:( I thought it was so sad when she said "I bore you"

[veggierobi]

that is exactly where I am at. I played the very same scene last night, but it was not fiction...:-(

[maemae808]

love is never enough. sad.

[Elcristoph]

@maemae808 becouse love isnt always being happy, I was in love and we broke up a few days ago, although I did love her all she did was cause me pain. especialy when she said she loved me a week before we broke up..

[plalelal]

@Elcristoph You did the right thing. Love has to go both ways.

[atrukis]

this movie makes me cry, this scene is so sad, awesome movie, why isnt love enough??, i ask myself the same

[stacyl118]

God this is what I'm going through right now.  And I was engaged to this guy as well. Two years we were happy together. At least I thought so. I lived this scene a week ago. I will never get over this.

[veggierobi]

hi stacy, i am in the same situation, too. 2 years and a half. It's tragical, but i am sure we will get over this, although it hurts so much...a hug from someone who understands you very well...

[stacyl118]

@veggierobi,

Thanks Robbie. Big hug!

Keep your head up. I don't know if you're a guy or a girl, but keep in mind if you ended up marrying the person the situation could be even worse! You would have ended up with a divorce and much more devastated.

[wildangel20]

i love this movieeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeee­eeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeee­ee.its my love sotry.

[maccaslove]

"no one will ever love you as much as i do"

that part really gets me! i think every one has said that to someone they love that theyre about to lose.

[highwind8124]

Okay, Natalie Portman is actually acting well in this movie. Why the hell didn't she do that at any point in Star Wars?

[eversmot]

Umm.. because it's Star Wars? Terrible script, terrible actors, can't really do anything with that.

[DarlingMsM]

Because Star Wars was POORLY WRITTEN AND DIRECTED.

[nadiag80]

He broke her heart!!!

[xia0fan]

omg! she loved him more than anything:((

[carmelidis]

this is the most beautiful scene in the movie

[newbie22]

exactly what i was thinking, he is a fuckin idoit for leaving her.

[joeymed2009]

yeah this is a good Fing scene......natalie portman is the shit....... he is a homo for dumping her for fucking pathetic julia roberts

[Despina343]

I think every love dies at this one point: when you realize that just loving someone is not enough...

[kendrawhisp]

her love doesnt die here.

[dRuss8706]

god she's incredible in this scene.

so is he.

[reesters]

omg :(

[awdfechelon]

y isnt love enough?....just felt like saying it....i feel her....

its beautiful...

+a.w.d.f+

[RaimundoGuzman]

Nice last phrase to remark... very true... life is unfair sometimes

[jlafferty23]

this movie was good.

but i found it kind of werid.

who did he really love?

[limellexX]

..that's what the movie is all about..

[TEASEME0022]

Damn ... an almost word for word scene from my life ... I was Alice ... It sucked.

[ludaswifey101]

Jude Law is hot!

[chezzababy20]

I feel sooo sorry for her in this scene.....

[totallyoggioni]

natalie shocks me

[aline1015]

sad

[BeiBa]

i love that scene, amazing...

i was just like her =(

[noramohammed]

my fav scene

[paddedpencil]

in the intro, is that is different version of "the blower's daughter" or just the original?

[sarynaechelon]

i love this movie....

[pinkligers14]

natalie portman is amazing

[suga1920]

I love this film..

[ladydiangie]

God! ="( poor Alice!

[carmelidis]

i love everyhing about this movie but jude's acting, espcly in his last scene....

[carmelidis]

PETRI; TO EIDES AYTO;

[LLEBNAX]

I'm really proud of natalie for doing a role like this...something different and it made her vulnerable but she tried it and it worked out so well. Trying something new was great and its one of her values that i love. A truly exceptional actress!

[gal4600]

natalie portman is like the graetest acter ever!!!

she is so good at this movie she should have won the oscar at this!!!!

[Sweetdee985]

I love the last scene of the movie but i dont seem too find it

[tessiebearkid]

16second intro = unnecessary.

[rumneet]

I loved this film, every scence was so intense and all my favourite actors were in it.

[blackhamster39]

OMg.. actually good part of the film.. the rest was a bit to much i thought (also watched it with my parents.. BAD IDEA lol)

[seanasimpson]

you know, Natalie Portman was the only one who I thought did a good job in this movie. The story was good, but Julia Roberts was terrible.

[hinessa]

agreed. jude law and his pouty faces sucked too

[patbus23]

i totally agree. the way that julia roberts acted in this film was mediocre. i really did not expect that from her.

[eltonmgs2]

totally disagree

julia was blasé, as needed for composition

[chibisyoko]

Julia was suppose to have that personality. How was her performance terrible?