Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (216)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • Nightwish is dead.

  • No, she just doesn't fit this song.

  • just beatiful

  • I will be surprised if Anette will sing a note without ooooooooohohh....this song has lost his wonderful atmosphere.....

  • I love you Anette

  • she will never take the high notes on the old songs

  • haha the bass in their music turned on the alarm on some of the cars there downtown, it was so annoying, they didn't stop the entire show.

  • Her voice is beautiful

  • oh my god how she dared to sing that master piece, with her shitty voice oh fuck now i'm in shock she really sucks

  • @LilithMaximov lame troll... if you don't like it, gtfo don't just comment without watching the vid.

  • @Daudiu

    guees what it's so awful to watch it at the end and of course its a free world i can say whatever i want

  • @LilithMaximov NOT as long as it disturbs anyone, it's like saying i'm free to kill your family or friends. It's a free world, right?

  • @310dreamer094

    of course its free u r only expressing your feelings and thoughts whatever they r

  • She has a really sweet voice, but she really shouldn't sing the old Nightwish's songs :( it's terrible.

  • ...Right, I just lost all the respect that I had for the members of Nightwish, they shouldn't have touched this song.

  • quee wueaaa mas pencaaa !!!!!! prefierooo a tarjaa jajaj

  • Anette is a shit!

  • I wish she would've tried the last part of the song (it's my favorite), i've seen her sing other stuff, I think she could've pulled it off.

  • That guitar solo at the end gives me chills. It's very soulful!!

  • proud to be there and diss her !

  • De ce exista cazuti deastia in cap care dau dislike la clipuri? Frate, daca nu iti place du-te naibii si asculta si da thumbs up la Justin Bieber in pana mea. Nu mai f****i videorile de genu.

  • I LOVE Anette ..

    but I have a hard time listening to this :-/

  • @CaughtTheMoon79 I think the same.... there are a couple of songs that are worst sung by annette, but it's normal, the singing technique of her is totally different! I think if Nightwish continued with Tarja would have become boring like Rhapsody (of fire).

  • @SaccoN2 Like, for example, The Escapist recorded with Tarja would sound like a more symphonic copy of She Is My Sin. The guitar and rhythm are so similar.

  • Tarja is better

  • Anette has very sweet voice!!!She is amazing!!!

  • poor dead boy, anette kill every poems from the world.

    Vete a tomar por culo anete cojones, que eres la peste

  • @EOLSLAYER ARDIDO ARDIDO DE MIERDA, OYE NO T DAS ASCO PINCHE TROL PENDEJO!!

  • @NwDevotion y tu? no te vomitas encima cuando te miras al espejo? anette se ha cargado el grupo perfecto que era nightwish, cuando sepas algo de musica, pues igual lo aprecias la diferencia entre la gran tarja y la cantante normal, pero no para nightwish anette

  • @EOLSLAYER ME VOMITO SOBRE LOS PINCHES TROLES COMO TU, ERES UN ARDIDO, QUE APESAR DE Q TARJA YA SACO 2 DISCOS SIGUES INSULTANDO A UNA GRAN CANTANTE QUE ES ANETTE, NO SABES EL ESFUERZO QUE TIENE QUE HACER PARA QUE SE ESCUCHE BIEN, SI TU NO LO SABES APRECIAR ES TU PROBLEMA, LA DIFERENCIA ENTRE TARJA Y ANETTE ES MUUY GRANDE, PERO ESO QUE IMPORTA YA,DESPUES DE TANTOS AÑOS, TARJA YA TIENE SU CARRERA, POSIBLEMENTE EN ALGUNO DE SUS CONCIERTOS CANTE ESA CANCION, PARA Q DEJES DE ESTAR JODIENDO

  • Anette usually does a good job on slow songs, they suit her best. She still has to work on her high notes. I just hope she did in the break...

  • nooo lo puedo creer otra mas que echa a perder le quedan mejor las nuevas por que estas las echa a perder siempre Tarja regreeesaaaa......

  • @blondgirlsk IMPOSIBLE QUE REGRESE, LO SIENTO JEJEJEJE CON NETTIE ESTA BIEN, NETT NO ES UNA DIVA DE MIERDA ^^

  • @NwDevotion mira me vale anette que se quede cantando la nuevas canciones y que deje las que no puede cantar......... si es una gran voz pero eso nunca va a cambiar mi opinio de que Tarja canta mejor

  • @blondgirlsk

    Anette y Tarja son voces totalmente distintas y no pueden compararse porque no existe el medium. Si el grupo buscó una voz distinta a la anterior es porque, quizá, no quería otra Tarja que se sintiera suplantada y, éso, creeme que sería más ofensivo para sus fans.

  • @blondgirlsk y tu superaloooooo, Tarja no volverá a Nightwish NUNCA!!! si no te gusta Anette, no la veas y ya, pero eso de que la echó a perder, perdoname pero Anette cantó muy dulcemente, muy bien afinada y con una gran emoción.

    Ya dejen de clamar por el regreso de Tarja, un volcán arrojará caramelos en vez de lava antes de que Tarja regrese a la banda. Podría haber otra vocalista, pero Tarja jamás volverá a NW

  • @GrissyPink7y9 mira puede ser que nunca regrese pero eso no quita de que anette eche a perder las canciones es cierto tiene una voz muy bonita pero que se quede cantanto las canciones que estan echas para ella y no tratar de cantar las que estan echas para una cantante de operaaaaaaaa

  • @blondgirlsk y cuando en su vida es q Tarja ha cantado opera?? JAMAS!! canta música d cámara q es MUUUY DISTINTO, tiene entrenamieno d canto clásico, pero ella no canta y nunca ha cantado ópera, no podría, su técnica no es tan buena, y para la ópera, lo siento, pero ella, no puede con una ópera en forma, no está capacitada para ello, ella misma lo ha dicho. Escoge tus palabras, sería mejor si dices "cantante lírica" o "tipo ópera" ya q en 1 la defines y en la otra das referencia ;)

  • ASCO! Esta canción era una de mis favoritas, y tenía la esperanza de que Anette no la matara... pero como va, anette al parecer matará muchas más canciones :(

  • @DaniiXXDD y si odias a Anette, ¿para qué ves sus actuaciones? Por otro lado, mientras ella esté en NW ella puede cantar la canción de ellos que se le venga en gana, y finalmente las adapta a sus posibilidades vocales, y es mejor una versión diferente y no una copia de Tarja

  • I never thought that our Anette can sing that song but I wasn't true Anette live very well without an opera voice . Go Anette! GO Nightwish !!

  • yes, its beautifull. But I like this song by Tarja more :)

  • Anette Olzon killed this song!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • Wow she butchered that one

  • frate..nu zic ca suna rau..:|

    da o prefer pe Tarja:).

  • cool :3 me caia mal Tarja. xD

    mucho ego en una persona.

  • surprisingly Annette does a great job of this song

  • "Everything a wish, fooo-oor the NIII-III-IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII­IIIIIIIIGHT!" :D

  • My ears, my ears!!!! O.o

    Couldn't care less if you call me, Anette-hater, (which surprisingly I'm not)

    but For The Love of God!!!! Go sing the new songs, but (again For The Love Of God) let the old songs rest in peace!! *happily enough Tarja still sings old nightwish songs on her concerts!* >.<

  • "So much more I wanted to give to the ones who love me

    I`m sorry"

    it dosent matter who shing this, or all the nightwish's songs, this music make me feel full up in this empty word.

    Tuomas genio, he will make wonderful things with the anettes voice, like before with tarja, you will see.

    and for all the tarjas fans, Fuck you!!! all you are like dogs with rabies, all the nw's song are of tuomas, and he is the only person who can say what is the way of his songs, not you.

  • Боже.как ужас...Аннет на мыло!!!!!!!дайте мне Тарью!!! =*(

    какой кошмар*упал со стула*

  • She isn't like tarja bt it's still great :). Happy i was there. Sad they aren't showing up this year at artmania :( ..

  • No Tarja, no Nightwish.

    This is not very good, going from a first rate band to a second rate band.

    She also misses notes all the time singing offkey, this sucks ass

  • @Bjoler80 HAHAH if it dont where fore tuomas in the lat 90s there wouldent been an nightt\wish at all he was the one starting nightwish not tarja and if tuomas has too leave nightwish one day i think the whole band would split ! and the guy ho writes the nightwish music is tuomas at least moste off the music the put on an album and tarja wasnt the hole band she was a singer in it and that makes a person ho sings only that it is only band member ho plays the instruments

  • @Bjoler80 Guy= =

    Antte just chang fews key and putch to match her voice .Antte is a amazing person.

    All of us are watching she is improving everyday,And shut ur mother fuckin mouth and open ur mind to listen this wonderful song.

  • putting to death me is unsimple ))) I will be removed))) and this rat for the spoiled wonderful song to put to death necessarily) and pomedlennee !

  • Nightwish dead !

  • @myshisnica you dead

  • 4.24 - 4.30 is it just me or does it sound like 'walking in the air'?

  • @ValuriDeNisip Sounds like that to me, as well...

  • WTH IS SHE WEARING!!!!!!!!! ug, ugly outfit, horrbile voice.

  • ce faceau acolo marco si cu celalat??? au mers la o tigara??:))

  • uah, this is just disgusting.

  • I think even Rob Schneider could sing this one better.....

  • sooo awsome the solo at the end, much better then the old i think:D

  • @fixmixazterix yeah that solo it's great

  • Toumas ever say about this song that he never like the end of this precious song but... this version is son beautyful

  • what ? bad !

  • va du un mic sfat:MAI DAT-O IN PIZDA MASII DE TREABA...SI GANDITI-VA CA SUCCESUL SI MUZICA DE CALITATE EXISTA SI FARA TARJA...INVATATI SA TRAITI PREZENTUL NU TRECUTUL SI LASATI-O PE TARJA UNDE E!CEI CARE NU AU INCREDERE IN NOUA SOLISTA POT SA ISI IA GANDUL DE LA SINTAGMA"FAN ADEVARAT".UN FAN NU JUDECA UN FAN ASCULTA SI SE BUCURA ALATURI DE EI...

  • Damn' you're right winter96storm !

  • empu!

  • @Asinity1984 - Tarjaholic lol! i like it =) anette can sing in sync with the mood and theme of the song, whoever brings the night and sahara are good examples. She doesn't just stand behind the mic singing in th same tone of voice.

  • Excellent vocals!!!

  • less vocal, more voice. thanks.

  • And one more thing:

    I don't understand why the last part of the song is literally removed from it. Why doesn't she try to sing the operatic vocals that were meant to be there? No comment. :)

  • It was removed by Tuomas long before Anette joined. He didn't like the end, even when Tarja sung it. 

    Quit being a Tarjaholic, nobody is forcing you to watch videos with Anette. Stop being so petty.

  • Tuomas said he removed it because he actually never loved this part :)

  • @Escapistdreamer maybe he is lying...i dont think he doesnt love that part..i think he is really attached to this song...and i believe he removed it because Anette definitely cant sing that part..

  • @Nat71208 then why did they skip that part when they performed it on the once-tour?? because i guess Tarja can sing it...

  • @Endaemondidas: Your post is 5 months old, but anyway... NW did not do the last part even with TARJA on 2004 when they performed Dead boy´s poem too... So there is some "trying" from Anette to you... ;) IMO this sounds more like a beautiful ballad without the last part.

  • nush de ce zice lumea ca Anette nu poate canta melodiile vechi

    in opinia mea ea canta foarte frumos mel din Century Child , Once si chiar si Dead Boy's Poem a avut mai mult sentiment ca niciodata :D

    a fost un concert pe cinste ^^

  • Awful... -_-;; It's not supposed to be that fast...

  • intr'adevar Anette nu o va intrece pe Tarja niciodata...dar am vazut un comment in care scria ca Anette e o curva , nu jtiu ce va face sa credeti ca Tarja era cheie de biserica :D...incepuse sa fie prea lacoma si se gandea numai la viitorul ei,s'a indepartat pre mult de ceilalti membri din trupa , asa cum i'a scris si Tuomas Holopainen in scrisoarea de adio(pe care sper ca ati citit'o:D) .Cu tot respectu'...fan Nightwish!!! \m/ :*

  • @scripcatudor ..chiar te iei dupa tot ce se scrie?[in ceea ce o priveste pe tarja] priveste realitatea...in interviuri...de fiecare data cand se intalneste cu fanii dupa concert..cum pot nw sa spuna ca o interesau doar banii?!!! cand am citit scrisoarea si eu am crezut..dar faptele dovedesc altceva

  • cat sunt eu de fan...pe asta chiar n-o suport...

  • pfff...fratilor, realitatea e ca nu ar fi trebuit sa se-ntample asa...adica tarja..etc...asta dupa parerea mea arata ca o curva...si se-nbraca ca unax(

  • fratioare eram in primu rand calare pe gard .....cred ca imi vad si ceasu cand dau roacherii din maini

  • thoamne ba oamenilor tarja a plecat. obisnuiti-va cu asta de dracu ma enervati deja cu tampeniile astea ce plm nu va convine nu mai ascultati melodiile de la nightwish si gata in plm ca ma futeti deja la creieri

  • Si tu, Daudiu, obisnuieste-te sa scrii normal, ca poate si tu ''futi lumea la creieri''!

  • Amazing quality. Some songs just be created for Tarja. Anette brings the new experience but it isn't quite feel like it.

    btw, what's the heck is she wearing

  • Awful, totally out of tune, there's no emotion.This song can be sung only by Tarja

  • I find a lot of emotion.

  • outch.

  • Anette is perfect!

  • @Wironf  r u drug or something???

  • @LilithMaximov No. Are You? If you don't like Anette, don't listen. Grown up and get a life.

  • @Wironf guess what I have a life to enjoy with beautiful things not with shits like her yes it was a mistae that i found this more that i've seen but that she believes a great singer fuck she sucks n u like her u must be an emo that's the only reason

  • It's*

  • It isn't the only part of the lyrics she or marco had changed. She probably changed it as an homage to tuomas. The lyrics are not NAILED, people, they can change a word or two, after all it's their band not ours.

  • And it is as if Tarja was SO perfect with her stage performances... Only Anette could make mistakes, no one else...

  • x,D good joke

  • Haven't you noticed that Tarja has misspelled lyrics too? Watch Lowlands 2005 Ghost Love Score. She mumbles!

  • eram in primul rand chiar in fata lui tuomas =p~ si am un sfert din prosopul lui \:D/

  • A fost super anyway ANETTE ROCKS indiferent de ce cred unii

    Intreba-se cineva cand s-au aruncat ratzele.... dupa ce s-au intors pe scena si marco a cantat "poker face", apoi au dat ratzele si dupaia au cantat I wish i had an angel. Deci la sfarsitul concertului(:

  • this is amazing

  • this music is beautiful and the voice is even more of Anette! xD

  • OK from now on, dont ever go to a nw gig!!! but you know, as I can see you have an internet access which means u have access to 100000 of nW lives videos with ANETTE.. So Why Didnt you just watch one of them to see if you like it??? OMG and by the way Anette is literally perfect!

  • Really lovely performance. Thanks for posting!

  • vocea lui anette, fara nici o suparare, se potriveste ca nuca in perete, nu are nici o treaba cu mesajul si tonalitatea melodiei, mult prea cristalin te duce cu gandul la o melodie pop...mai are de exersat

  • I really hope Anette gets to record this song in the studio!! She puts so much power & Spirit into it!!

  • Anette is awsome in some songs Tarja didn't pull off live. Tarja's great, but Anette is too. Dont get why people still argue about it, nothing you guys can do about it anyway.

  • And Anette ruins Dead Boy's Poem...

    I am really sad aboyt that...

  • How she ruins it? With her soft, emotional and beautiful voice?

  • hahaha

    don't make me laugh!

    what do u know about ruinning songs if u listen to evanesence (that's really sad)

    Evanescense sucks!

    NW forever!

  • evanescence sucks?!?!?! are you idiot? oh come on... if you don't like it you don't have to say they suck... amy lee rocks.....nw rocks.. 8-|.. dumbass

  • bai bai. ce dracu. nu se compara nw cu evanescence. nu au nimic special aia frate. au niste riffuri gen linkin park, ffs.

    subtitilate...

  • well evanescence doesn't suck in my opinion Nw is far better and anette (and tarja) are much better live then Amy lee

  • Epic solo-ul lui Emmpu! walking in the air spre sfarsit, nu?

  • Asa e ;).

  • Annette can't be better than Tarja because they are different! they can't be compared!

    Annette isn't better than Tarja and Tarja isn't better than Annette

  • apropo... stie careva pe la ce melodiile am aruncat ratele pe scena? adica... intre ce melodii? dupa tpatp cumva? :-?

  • Inainte de WIHAA, dupa...dupa ce o fi fost inainte de WIHAA. Gasesti si videou' pe undeva :)

  • hm mersi. si ce a fost inainte de wihaa? 8-}

  • gasit, dark chest of wonders :D

  • ok glady, atunci noi eram la 1 metru de tuomas. happy? :))

  • foarte tare a fost. la nightwish cel putin..erai "beat" de muzica lor

  • ur so boring with insulting anette for no reason.

  • this was a funny comment! xD Good to know you can actually understand and feel what Marco and Emppu feel :p

  • how de fuck do u n no, der bored wit her singing!!! ur jus makin ridiculous assumptions jus coz dey arent hopping around full of de joys of spring in a song that isnt hugely guitar based doesnt mean they dislike her singing!!

  • God ! You are so right :)) I was there and I was disspointed

  • Anette is the BEST singer for Nightwish :) She sings really fantastic :)

  • eu eram in dreptul lui tuomas chiar in fata, langa boxa. a sunat totul mai bun sau mai putin bun, dar a fost bine pentru toti pana la urma. :D

  • I don't know how people can doubt her talent, it just blows my mind. Obviously, they seem to dwell on her older, not so great performances. Her new persona is so much better, both in vocalist and performer. I'm glad she rose above all of her critics :)

  • 100 % agreed

  • I can't believe it!

    She is better vicalist than Tarja? xaxaxaxaa

    OMFG :P

  • Maybe I'm reading playtagwithasemi's comment wrong... But WERE does he/she bring up Tarja????

    From what I read in it, he/she states that he/she feels that Anette has grown as a performer and as a vocalist since her first shows... Has got nothing to do with Tarja....

  • nobody said she was better than tarja

    prick

  • anyway, u like evanescence so u cannot speak.

    in case u don't realize, i'm bashing the band u like just like u just bashed anette

    lovely, no? =)

  • I cannot speak?

    I don't think so!!

    I'm just telling that Anette isn't a good vocalist ;)

    On the other hand Tarja is the best ever ;)

  • Annette IS a good vocalist!

    and on the other hand, Tarja isn't the best ever..

    Tarja has the low operatic vocal range, while Annette has a HIGH range vocal..

    Ahh!! and annette is so much better than Amy Lee from Evaneshit! ;)

  • You know nothing abut music ;)

    Anette isn't a good vocalist, she can't sing right at the concerts!

    And GOD Tarja is a lyrical soprano with studies on music, Anette Olzon is nothing...

    Amy Lee isn't just a vocalist, she is composer too!

  • Ahem, Anette has studied singing too, even classical singing. She stopped it because it was changing her voice and she did not want that.

    When Tarja was in Nightwish she was just the singer. Nothing more. And she sings different in studio and in live concert. I prefer her studio singing because her live singing is horrible IN MY OPINION.

  • Tarja singing horrible live??? LOL

    *going to listen Passion and the Opera*

    Tarja was THE voice of nightwish! Noone can replace her...

  • I guess u missed the part 'in my opinion' :D

    I already told you, you listen to Evanescence so you have no right to give your opinion about Nightwish, which is 1000X better than Shitescence.

    The way you are bashing Anette without point, I am bashing Shitescence. This is the way you stupid 'haters' make real fans feel when you bash Anette. STOP IT.

  • She WAS the voice, but JUST the voice. Fortunately Tuomas is the SOUL.

    Now Anette is the voice. She took her OWN place in the band, not Tarja's. Tarja LOST her place when she was kicked out.

    Summa summarum: NO-ONE has been replaced.

  • many people think tarja sang bad live. i am one of them. she simply ...sang. she had no feeling. just vibration of the vocal cords. that's why i prefer Anette. she makes you feel something.

  • De cat timp asculti Nightwish ?

  • de prin 2004... a inceput cu fratemeu invatand sa cante moondance la pian :)

    mai, o stiati pe anette - daca stiati ca nu va place, de ce ati mai dat 120 ron pe bilet? ...

  • Nu te inteleg :-?? ai ascultat-o si pe Tarja , cum poti sa suporti noua voce? Nu te macina ca Nightwish s-a terminat ? sau poate nu stii sa apreciezi.. sincer l-as fi preferat doar pe Marco vocal

  • imi place pentru ca sunt deschisa la schimbari...nimic in lumea asta nu e batut in cuie...azi traiesti maine mori, azi tarja maine anette... prima data cand am auzit-o a fost un soc. dupa aceea, mi-a intrat treptat in inima. face la fel de mult parte din NW pentru mine ca si tarja... Si trebuie sa recunoastem ca ea chiar canta frumos, doar diferit fata de tarja... foarte diferit...dar de cand diferenta e un defect?

    pece...:) si la cat mai multe artmania...

  • Ce sa zic :-?? unele schimbari nu sunt bune :)) oricum, cel mai bine au cantat My Dying Bride

  • @Morphine435 DE ACORD!

  • eu am dat 90 fratioare:)) ....oricum mie mi-a placut concertu

  • Tarja was brilliant live on songs from the first three albums. On CC & Once songs, however, she was unable to replicate the sound she produced in the studio. Does she still sound OK? Yeah, usually; the woman's voice is spectacular anyway. But I still cringe when I hear her howling through "Ever Dream" live.

    Oh, and Anette DID replace her. Just FYI.

  • That is a little thing called YOUR opinion. So it's not a fact. Accept Tarjas gone, and listen to her solo or old songs if you don't like Anettes voice.