her mom left her 4 children and husband and married with a baptist minister LOL
than both take off for the freeland or land of the free in 2 years moved arround 7 times
than sweet amy grows up for highschool goes to switzerland lol finish highschool there
met with her half sisters (none make it to usa i bet LOL) than got married with blind date man ow man excellent background for a writer endless insights for chinese american identity for globalization of china sooner or later
This novel turned movie is a stereotyping worthless piece if shit, Amy Tan is a self-loathing, white cock sucking sellout. She's such a disgrace to her parents and all the Chinese people. It's about White gentlemen rescuing China Dolls from their miserable existence shadowed by their Evil Asian Male counterparts. It's a perfect example of how American mainstream media is racist towards Asians.
If you're ignorant to Asian culture in general, don't bother with this, as you'll be largely misguided.
I am always leery of self -professed intellectuals who must use this kind of verbiage to try and make a point.You sound like a bigger ass-wipe than the woman your trying to insult...
@samsherwin01 People need to acknowledge that the societal norm in America yields an impression of how it is "okay" to be racist/intolerant to Asians Americans. When was the last time you saw a movie featuring an Asian male as a protagonist without the kung-fu stereotype? Dr. Fu Man Chu anyone? When was the last time you saw a sitcom on TV that pairs up an Asian male with a non-Asian female?
@kornypony I understand. I just get annoyed when people put their points across with raw crude phrases online when they can look and sound a lot smarter with a little more thought behind their words....I am a white male who WAS married to a Japanese woman. So i got a horse in this RACE too. From which ever side you want to look at this...
@samsherwin01 To be honest I couldn't care less about you and what you think of my comments. I know it takes time for people to open their mind about things. Didn't the Blacks go through all the bullshit to finally be treated like what they are---Human Beings? I blame American mainstream media (Hollywood, etc) for the racist portrayal of Asian Americans, but at the end of the day I ask myself, what can I do about it?
@samsherwin01 The One Unchanging Truth is, as we have witnessed throughout history--- Minorities are always on the losing end. In the mean while I'm glad that at least I'm free to go on Youtube and see my fellow Asian Americans represent themselves without stereotyping. On here, I get to see Asians who don't speak broken EngRish, not a villain in a kung fu flick, and who don't actually beat their wives (for what's it's worth, a disgrace of a propaganda you call a 'novel' aka The Joy Luck Club)
@samsherwin01 I was not going to say anything until I read the "obligatory" statement about not belonging to the race of people you are speaking about then qualifying yourself via just knowing or marrying a person from a different race. I am African America and from a VERY multicultural family that includes Asians born here and in Asia. We would NEVER speak on any authority about another race, it does not matter if you married into it or not, it is not your racial experience or culture.
@samsherwin01 There is no way to understand just how silly and insensitive to have said "I am a white male who WAS married to a Japanese woman..." That means NOTHING, that is such an colonial/imperial out-dated thing to say. There is NO way I could tell my Asian/Black cousin who to feel, why they should feel it blah blah blah just because we are related ( and that is by blood not paper work). How insulting, how narrow, if you, everything is not in need of white validation , get over yourself.
@samsherwin01 To quote Imari Bari ( very famous poet): "It all depends on the skin that you're living in..." You simply can not validate or invalidate the racial experience of a person outside of your own race, it is utter silliness to presume you speak with authority about another persons racial experience and/feeling regarding how they react, I hate to say it but it sounds ancient and superior and disrespectful. You know the White Male experience, that is all you know with authority.
@kimrabb How very cool you have this grand insight into my narrow whiteness....Be nice if i had a clue as to what the hell your blabing about....But please be my guest.
She is so lovely... I adore her accent. It's like a unique blend of chinese poetic sinning-like poem with English words. Could listen to her whole day long.
This movie means a lot to m. My father can be a jerk like Lin Xiao was in the film. I have to admit that as an oriental, MANY of the things in the film are realistic.
@EdmundoMD Good point taken there. In the UK, the British still used Orientals to distinguish East and Southeast Asians from the Indian subcontinent. Asians are referred to those from the Indian subcontinent in the UK. So I suppose East and Southeast Asian would be more specific and useful.
Is Kaori momoi the one that talks about jewish mah jong and chinese mah jong? I totally think she is becuase I recognize her voice from Memoirs of a Geisha, but I'm not sure. ._.U
I wish Disney would make another movie about Asia. Wanna know who they'll get to do the voices. Maybe the love story of Taj Majal or the War of Mactan.
please post some clips from the girls when they were young...like Waverly running away from her mother after she beat Bobby Fisher or when June refused to practice playing the piano.
if you have read the book then you would have known that its not a racist remark in anyway. if you really have so mucch problem with it then why don't you go take it up with the writer herself or perhaps with the american people instead of being such a smart aleck? i dont see any other people making noise about jews being on the media. its not like they dont make digs at chinese people or muslims so i dont see what you have to gripe about.
Correction, she simply uses "Jewish Mahjong" as a metaphor if you read the book more closely. It simply symbolizes how the chinese have to work harder (Chinese Mahjong- think harder, strategies) to earn a living in the world, it's their traditional values. Jewish Mahjong symbolizes how the Americans live life like a game. They don't have to work as hard or they don't follow the same values the Chinese cherish. (which is to work hard and thus, you succeed ) They take life seriously.
Np, I apologize, I simply thought you assume June, the woman in the movie, was making anti-semitic remarks. But, I hope my comment clears any other confusion in the times to come. Haha.
hmmm. i'm assuming you're talkin about sameerah. either way, sameerah's got it all wrong. what's the point of reading/watching something if your only purpose is to find fault with it?
@blackiponki Suggestions? What can I do about it? Take it up with who? Who will listen? What are you talking about "Jews on the media"? You've got to be kidding right? MGM, AOL Times Warner, Disney, Universal Studios, Viacom, NEWS corp., ABC, NBC, CBS, Turner Broadcasting System, CNN, MTV..... They PWN the media for Buddha's sakes. Have some common sense.....
Did u read the book? Or at least watch part of the movie b/c that reference was in the book as well. It was talking about how the two games are different as in thinking wise. It has nothing to do with jews(just their game.)so you don't have to get all offended by that. You should be upset by the fact that all the daughters except Jing(the one who was narating.) end up with white guys and have crappy marriages.
Actually, it is with the white guys that they are happy. It was with Asian guys that they were unhappy.
One of the white guys was a jerk, but proved to be a good man after all in the end. That marriage lasted because he, finally, opened his heart to his wife.
One of the women later was involved with a good Asian man after a bad marriage to an Asian man (who was a prick up the ass).
her mom left her 4 children and husband and married with a baptist minister LOL
than both take off for the freeland or land of the free in 2 years moved arround 7 times
than sweet amy grows up for highschool goes to switzerland lol finish highschool there
met with her half sisters (none make it to usa i bet LOL) than got married with blind date man ow man excellent background for a writer endless insights for chinese american identity for globalization of china sooner or later
artregeous 1 month ago
Comment removed
artregeous 1 month ago
I wanna see this movie!
chloebella17 1 month ago
Hey...the voice is Mulan's isn't it..♥ so beautiful
martinluva6 3 months ago 3
This novel turned movie is a stereotyping worthless piece if shit, Amy Tan is a self-loathing, white cock sucking sellout. She's such a disgrace to her parents and all the Chinese people. It's about White gentlemen rescuing China Dolls from their miserable existence shadowed by their Evil Asian Male counterparts. It's a perfect example of how American mainstream media is racist towards Asians.
If you're ignorant to Asian culture in general, don't bother with this, as you'll be largely misguided.
kornypony 8 months ago
@kornypony
I am always leery of self -professed intellectuals who must use this kind of verbiage to try and make a point.You sound like a bigger ass-wipe than the woman your trying to insult...
samsherwin01 5 months ago
@samsherwin01 People need to acknowledge that the societal norm in America yields an impression of how it is "okay" to be racist/intolerant to Asians Americans. When was the last time you saw a movie featuring an Asian male as a protagonist without the kung-fu stereotype? Dr. Fu Man Chu anyone? When was the last time you saw a sitcom on TV that pairs up an Asian male with a non-Asian female?
kornypony 5 months ago
@samsherwin01 btw I never once claimed to be an "intellectual," don't know where you got that idea from.
I'm just an average Asian guy, telling it as it is.
kornypony 5 months ago
@kornypony I understand. I just get annoyed when people put their points across with raw crude phrases online when they can look and sound a lot smarter with a little more thought behind their words....I am a white male who WAS married to a Japanese woman. So i got a horse in this RACE too. From which ever side you want to look at this...
samsherwin01 5 months ago
@samsherwin01 To be honest I couldn't care less about you and what you think of my comments. I know it takes time for people to open their mind about things. Didn't the Blacks go through all the bullshit to finally be treated like what they are---Human Beings? I blame American mainstream media (Hollywood, etc) for the racist portrayal of Asian Americans, but at the end of the day I ask myself, what can I do about it?
kornypony 5 months ago
@samsherwin01 The One Unchanging Truth is, as we have witnessed throughout history--- Minorities are always on the losing end. In the mean while I'm glad that at least I'm free to go on Youtube and see my fellow Asian Americans represent themselves without stereotyping. On here, I get to see Asians who don't speak broken EngRish, not a villain in a kung fu flick, and who don't actually beat their wives (for what's it's worth, a disgrace of a propaganda you call a 'novel' aka The Joy Luck Club)
kornypony 5 months ago
@samsherwin01 I was not going to say anything until I read the "obligatory" statement about not belonging to the race of people you are speaking about then qualifying yourself via just knowing or marrying a person from a different race. I am African America and from a VERY multicultural family that includes Asians born here and in Asia. We would NEVER speak on any authority about another race, it does not matter if you married into it or not, it is not your racial experience or culture.
kimrabb 5 months ago
@samsherwin01 There is no way to understand just how silly and insensitive to have said "I am a white male who WAS married to a Japanese woman..." That means NOTHING, that is such an colonial/imperial out-dated thing to say. There is NO way I could tell my Asian/Black cousin who to feel, why they should feel it blah blah blah just because we are related ( and that is by blood not paper work). How insulting, how narrow, if you, everything is not in need of white validation , get over yourself.
kimrabb 5 months ago
@samsherwin01 To quote Imari Bari ( very famous poet): "It all depends on the skin that you're living in..." You simply can not validate or invalidate the racial experience of a person outside of your own race, it is utter silliness to presume you speak with authority about another persons racial experience and/feeling regarding how they react, I hate to say it but it sounds ancient and superior and disrespectful. You know the White Male experience, that is all you know with authority.
kimrabb 5 months ago
@kimrabb How very cool you have this grand insight into my narrow whiteness....Be nice if i had a clue as to what the hell your blabing about....But please be my guest.
samsherwin01 5 months ago
Auntie Lindo's the best!
letthemxeatcake 8 months ago
this movie make ppl cry.
Akabuena 9 months ago
She is so lovely... I adore her accent. It's like a unique blend of chinese poetic sinning-like poem with English words. Could listen to her whole day long.
Hwaigon 10 months ago 2
This book and film is one of my favorites. I just saw 'Year of the Fish' from the same producer, it's soo beautiful
alexfelix255 10 months ago
she sounds like MULAN!!! :O
gabbie363 11 months ago 4
@gabbie363 She is. :)
BeautifulLogic 11 months ago
@BeautifulLogic ...WOAH!! :O *mind blown*
gabbie363 11 months ago
PLEASE TELL ME IF YOU FOUND THIS MOVIE ONLINE WITH ENGLISH SUBTITLES. :D PLEASE
thea09marcelino 1 year ago
this movie was amazing.
livetodancexox 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
love thiis movie it is actually sad
pakaymoua94 1 year ago
I love auntie Lindo!!! She was a trip!
AggieChick0711 1 year ago 2
the yellow fever club
siliconsurf 1 year ago
Honestly, I great movie and book. Both never failed to bring me to tears.
xavierp0nce 1 year ago
This movie means a lot to m. My father can be a jerk like Lin Xiao was in the film. I have to admit that as an oriental, MANY of the things in the film are realistic.
seanakizuki 1 year ago
@seanakizuki BTW....FOR YOUR INFORMATION, WE'RE NOT ORIENTALS ANYMORE, WE'RE ASIAN....WE'RE NOT INANIMATE OBJECTS LIKE RUGS....
EdmundoMD 1 year ago
@EdmundoMD Good point taken there. In the UK, the British still used Orientals to distinguish East and Southeast Asians from the Indian subcontinent. Asians are referred to those from the Indian subcontinent in the UK. So I suppose East and Southeast Asian would be more specific and useful.
oowen2784 6 months ago
my dad told the movie would make you cry and the book is amazing. i wanna see it and read it, but i dont know if i can handle it
trini4eve9 1 year ago
can u help me out for my english class
What was the theme for this movie
qwertysingh93 1 year ago
Is Kaori momoi the one that talks about jewish mah jong and chinese mah jong? I totally think she is becuase I recognize her voice from Memoirs of a Geisha, but I'm not sure. ._.U
akissy 1 year ago
Is Mah jong like Dominoes? Or are they c ompletely from one another?
83survivor 1 year ago
@83survivor it's not dominoes, it's like a card game, you dumb ass
siliconsurf 1 year ago
mah jong is difficult, you need strategy this is true!
Calsummersishere 1 year ago
taiwanese bitches hated most of the chinese men and asian mens as well.
Cambodiot 2 years ago
well I heard that chinese men treat the woman bad because having a female child is a horrible thing in china
jamestakenawa 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
white man good asian man bad. That what this movie is about damn stupid chink bitches.
Cambodiot 2 years ago
Blame the writers, not the race.
StriderIsAragorn 2 years ago 3
I miss China. ;(
NaturVita 2 years ago
you have to keep all these all in your head...yep...that's how you play chinese mahjhong.
marlon1972 2 years ago
she looks like my mother and Tsai Chin looks like my grandmother....
salashaska223 2 years ago
the best book ever
xuefen14 2 years ago
arguebly
salashaska223 2 years ago
yes,i wanna watch it too,again!,please,tell me a playlist or a site!
Capucacuru 3 years ago
You can watch the whole movie @ Youku [dot] com, though it might take some time to load.
Replace [dot] with .
Psystud7 3 years ago
lots of thanks!
Capucacuru 3 years ago
anyone know a playlist where i can watch this whole movie on youtube? :)
artistictalent 3 years ago
Best film ever.
lusitanoemdublin07 3 years ago
Mulan's voice
paxinomnipopulo 3 years ago 3
someone in my english class said that when we watched this haha i think you're right
JalousYet 3 years ago
you're right about it... it is Mulan's voice...
shaundy2006 3 years ago
I wish Disney would make another movie about Asia. Wanna know who they'll get to do the voices. Maybe the love story of Taj Majal or the War of Mactan.
paxinomnipopulo 3 years ago
The actress of June is the one who dubbed Mulan.
HingYok 3 years ago
does any one no where i can find da hole movie??? if so plz plzplz plz plz plz tel me!
wackerscrackers 3 years ago
the book is so raw, im just radiant in the face that i am watching the movie rite now
stazzylove456 3 years ago 11
please post some clips from the girls when they were young...like Waverly running away from her mother after she beat Bobby Fisher or when June refused to practice playing the piano.
Tenor5274 4 years ago
少数几部让我感动的电影
she cannot speak Chinese or overseas young generation cannot sadly?
kidshaoss 4 years ago
this reminds me of my family.. very much... amazing..
sabrinavsginc 4 years ago 2
shes very pretty!
MitsuomiKun 4 years ago 2
yeah i know :)
FamilyGuyRockz2009 4 years ago
if you have read the book then you would have known that its not a racist remark in anyway. if you really have so mucch problem with it then why don't you go take it up with the writer herself or perhaps with the american people instead of being such a smart aleck? i dont see any other people making noise about jews being on the media. its not like they dont make digs at chinese people or muslims so i dont see what you have to gripe about.
blackiponki 4 years ago 11
ive read it and i agree with u :)
FamilyGuyRockz2009 4 years ago
blackiponki- I think you misread her message- she was making anti- semitic remarks, not complaining about anti-semitism!
ginsengbambi 3 years ago
Correction, she simply uses "Jewish Mahjong" as a metaphor if you read the book more closely. It simply symbolizes how the chinese have to work harder (Chinese Mahjong- think harder, strategies) to earn a living in the world, it's their traditional values. Jewish Mahjong symbolizes how the Americans live life like a game. They don't have to work as hard or they don't follow the same values the Chinese cherish. (which is to work hard and thus, you succeed ) They take life seriously.
XAbsolute0X 3 years ago
I was replying to someone else's comments, not saying anything about the video
ginsengbambi 3 years ago
Np, I apologize, I simply thought you assume June, the woman in the movie, was making anti-semitic remarks. But, I hope my comment clears any other confusion in the times to come. Haha.
XAbsolute0X 3 years ago
i agree
chocowomanpowerwork 3 years ago
hmmm. i'm assuming you're talkin about sameerah. either way, sameerah's got it all wrong. what's the point of reading/watching something if your only purpose is to find fault with it?
blackiponki 3 years ago
@blackiponki Suggestions? What can I do about it? Take it up with who? Who will listen? What are you talking about "Jews on the media"? You've got to be kidding right? MGM, AOL Times Warner, Disney, Universal Studios, Viacom, NEWS corp., ABC, NBC, CBS, Turner Broadcasting System, CNN, MTV..... They PWN the media for Buddha's sakes. Have some common sense.....
kornypony 5 months ago
i'm studying the book for Literature. Any idea where I can get notes on its characterization and stuff?
sakuwa 4 years ago
yeah empress is right, even so you shouldn't get so offended. ignorance is everywhere and we can't do anything about it.
HumpbackYen 4 years ago
Did u read the book? Or at least watch part of the movie b/c that reference was in the book as well. It was talking about how the two games are different as in thinking wise. It has nothing to do with jews(just their game.)so you don't have to get all offended by that. You should be upset by the fact that all the daughters except Jing(the one who was narating.) end up with white guys and have crappy marriages.
EmpressofthisWorld 4 years ago 6
@EmpressofthisWorld
Actually, it is with the white guys that they are happy. It was with Asian guys that they were unhappy.
One of the white guys was a jerk, but proved to be a good man after all in the end. That marriage lasted because he, finally, opened his heart to his wife.
One of the women later was involved with a good Asian man after a bad marriage to an Asian man (who was a prick up the ass).
dakotagerman1 1 year ago
PLEASE can u upload the whole movie!
im dying to see it!
cheenu10 4 years ago 3
please upload more the movie call joy luck club movie i mean all of it the part please ok thank.
asiangirl77777 4 years ago