Personally I don't like Annette singing the old Nightwish songs, the it's just hard to hear her sing it compared to Tarja's voice. I like Annette and Nightwish's new stuff but the old stuff should stay undisturbed ( just my opinion not her for an argument)
Is it me or sounds like a little girl singing about things she does not know? ._. I am used to TARJAS MATURE and awesome voice, Excuse me but I take my leave at 1:25
@RufftyViteazu Oh, I'm sorry. I thought you were an English/American person who never bothered to learn the language properly. It really annoys me when that happens. Had I known you were not in fact English/American, I would not have said something so disrespectful :)
live recordings do no justice to what you actually hear when you are there at the show, i've seen nightwish with both Tarja and Anette and both were excellent shows, I love the new nightwish stuff with anette just as i love the old stuff with tarja, and beside if they wanted to replace tarja with someone that can sing like her but actually better then they should of got Floor Jansen who is probably the best female voice in metal ever
@Sweewolf Floor was still in after forever back then, but yes with her voice nightwish could have had so many directions to go because floor sings great in normal voice and opera. Shes like the best of anette and tarja.
@farrelleto this is far from torture.I listened to all their songs, old and new and its is just a different voicenTrue, I am more used to tarja and i incline slightly to her version but anette is a kick-ass singer and she does an axcellent job.Bottom line- no need to be so hars dude.
annettes voice is too childish and as if she has her nose pinched... =( still idk why i actually like this version as much as the original... anyways, tarja rules!! XD
@chimecho6 maybe because its easier to understand the lyrics? lol the good thing about anette singing the old songs is that she makes the lyrics a lot easier to understand XD
I like Tarja's version better- Anettes voice just doesn't go well with this song. But Anette's still good! I love her voice in songs like Escapist, but not this song. :I
i prefer tarja's version, anette's voice just sounds a lil too young for it and a bit weak compared to tarja, but then again they are two different singers. no offence to anyone who prefers this version, anette is sill awesome
@Lost4815162342ish вам орфография говно
Apoccalypce2 2 days ago
Comment removed
Apoccalypce2 2 days ago
10000% anette
MrTakito96 1 week ago
1000% Tarja
ernesto281416 3 weeks ago
I like Tarja's version better too, except the bridge part, Annette pull that part off so amazingly surprising
VirgeVelve 1 month ago
I think my eyes just bled.
Randseed2 1 month ago
I love Anette's singing but this song with Anette is... HORRIBLE!
TajemnaTemnota 2 months ago
En el estribillo estan matando a algun gatito!!???
tarjanightwish1 2 months ago
I like her singing of this song. There are some she is terrible at (like The Siren). But this is not one of them.
Ashleymjy 2 months ago
Personally I don't like Annette singing the old Nightwish songs, the it's just hard to hear her sing it compared to Tarja's voice. I like Annette and Nightwish's new stuff but the old stuff should stay undisturbed ( just my opinion not her for an argument)
MultiNess01 3 months ago 4
I can't stand Anette's voice. She has a good voice but doesn't fit Nightwish style for me unless i use mute sound.
lenoirrichelieu 3 months ago
q pedooooooooooo??? parece q canta belinda... q horror
rubiiola 3 months ago
I prefer Tarja's original version, but I think also Anette is doing a great job here.
ROMANTIKILLER2 3 months ago
Annette's gotta have the most beautiful female voice in metal... Mind you I still like Tarja. Nightwish rules \m/
crofold 3 months ago
Is it me or sounds like a little girl singing about things she does not know? ._. I am used to TARJAS MATURE and awesome voice, Excuse me but I take my leave at 1:25
YamiMegami 4 months ago
awfull... anette is good singer, but tarja is better. NW's old songs are not for her, but the new songs are great :)
maijasii 4 months ago
not anette's best song
LehmannDaHero 5 months ago
Original version:152 likes, 0 dislikes
Anette's version: 32 likes, 16 dislikes.
3.octomber.2011 17:36.
RufftyViteazu 5 months ago
@RufftyViteazu
Views original version: 21 624
Views Anette's version: 7 580
Doum92 4 months ago
@Doum92 to -> 22190 in one day
joko554 4 months ago
@RufftyViteazu *October (with a capital letter and no m) :)
MrDajx 3 months ago
@MrDajx Sorry, I'm a slave to my native language(in which october is octombrie) :)
RufftyViteazu 3 months ago
@RufftyViteazu Oh, I'm sorry. I thought you were an English/American person who never bothered to learn the language properly. It really annoys me when that happens. Had I known you were not in fact English/American, I would not have said something so disrespectful :)
MrDajx 3 months ago
@MrDajx Cheers!
RufftyViteazu 3 months ago
yet another classic anette butchers
skimbap 5 months ago
I've got to say something to Tuomas - You disappointed us with your choice -.-''
wishmasteour 6 months ago
WTF! where's the epic solo?
CernobylAftermath 6 months ago 2
This has been flagged as spam show
Meh, this is crap.
Nightwish died when Tarja left.
Nerezza1 7 months ago
Is a 15 year old singing ? :P
Pracer7 7 months ago 4
Tarja was a bitch. U wanna troll? I have proof :]
IceColdBlueSpike 7 months ago
@IceColdBlueSpike fuck you
SunHoneyLily 7 months ago
@SunHoneyLily lol u mad?
IceColdBlueSpike 7 months ago
live recordings do no justice to what you actually hear when you are there at the show, i've seen nightwish with both Tarja and Anette and both were excellent shows, I love the new nightwish stuff with anette just as i love the old stuff with tarja, and beside if they wanted to replace tarja with someone that can sing like her but actually better then they should of got Floor Jansen who is probably the best female voice in metal ever
Ginnungagap418 7 months ago
@Ginnungagap418 Finally someone who agrees, After Forever was amazing
megadeth628 7 months ago
@Ginnungagap418 Good point. But Anette's voice is still too poppy.
And about Floor .... Yes, she could have been a a fine replacement or not. I guess we'll never know, will we?
Sweewolf 6 months ago
@Sweewolf Floor was still in after forever back then, but yes with her voice nightwish could have had so many directions to go because floor sings great in normal voice and opera. Shes like the best of anette and tarja.
RawrItsJuul 5 months ago
Why is the quality so fucking horrible.
Watchingg 9 months ago 6
is it just me or does the quality sound muffled?
skellyme 9 months ago
My problem with this version isn't so much Anette's voice, but where is the solo?
MetalSmasherGaming 10 months ago 4
Annetta should NOT be singing a song done by Tarja. It's not her style, and isn't performed well enough to be considered comparable.
CollateralMuse 10 months ago
SHIT!! Tarja come back please, save us from that torture!!
farrelleto 10 months ago
@farrelleto this is far from torture.I listened to all their songs, old and new and its is just a different voicenTrue, I am more used to tarja and i incline slightly to her version but anette is a kick-ass singer and she does an axcellent job.Bottom line- no need to be so hars dude.
SuperGodlike101 9 months ago
@scenessweet you know this is a very hard song to sing but she sang it pretty good lets see you singing that song <_<
Nightwish581 1 year ago 2
annettes voice is too childish and as if she has her nose pinched... =( still idk why i actually like this version as much as the original... anyways, tarja rules!! XD
chimecho6 1 year ago
@chimecho6 maybe because its easier to understand the lyrics? lol the good thing about anette singing the old songs is that she makes the lyrics a lot easier to understand XD
xskullxkissesx 7 months ago 2
guyz no offence to those who like anette but her voice is so thin.....it feels like an anime intro song...
johnnyangel88 1 year ago
I think I prefer Anette's version, but both versions are good.
ItsNotSymmetrical 1 year ago
tarja is a rock-opera singer. anette is a pop singer. this song should sound evil and badass. so, i prefer tarja's.
mineMissHellsing 1 year ago
@mineMissHellsing I agree.
Sweewolf 6 months ago
To me, when annette sings this song, she has this tone in her voice that makes it sound as if she's bragging...
Darkcastle98 1 year ago
''Aff"
100000.0000.0000 Tarja
mila170877 1 year ago
High Quality? It's a high quality picture for sure...
Moonblender 1 year ago 4
ah.. :( marco should have screamed "stupidity" longer! :(
And Anette's voice doesn't fit here... sounds bad... But she still has improved very much. :)
SakuraPaula1996 1 year ago
I like Tarja's version better- Anettes voice just doesn't go well with this song. But Anette's still good! I love her voice in songs like Escapist, but not this song. :I
QnDrcla13 2 years ago 3
i prefer tarja's version, anette's voice just sounds a lil too young for it and a bit weak compared to tarja, but then again they are two different singers. no offence to anyone who prefers this version, anette is sill awesome
WalkinDisaster96 2 years ago 34
where can I download it? T_T
kiotaclaire 2 years ago
Try the youtube to mp3 converter
it´s legal, as far as I know, and the quality is still good after downloading from vid.
EndOfDeceive 2 years ago
i love anette singing this song!
barcelonaboy09 2 years ago 37
@barcelonaboy09 me too is a great singer!!!
dark7700 5 months ago