These two sound so great together. Two extraordinary voices. Martina has sang Kelly's part on this song with Reba before and is just as phenomenal as Kelly is here.
Also....just because your from Texas doesn't mean that you listen to just country...I listen to everything from cher to kiss to Papa roach to Reba to Willie Nelson, and I'm from Texas.
Woah Woah Woah....it doesn't matter what genre dude who said Martina is better....now...don't get me wrong...mm is amazing....but Kelly clearly has a stronger voice....and she songs the vocals pretty damn close to the way Linda Davis does....
@FranFan4Life Martina can and has sang Linda Davis part on this song with Reba and has done it phenomenally. But as you see Martina is singing Reba's part with Kelly so of course she's not going to try and over sing Kelly, because that's not the part.
Y'all seem to forget: Kelly is from Texas, so she was raised on this shit. She may be pop or whatever genre you wish to use, but she has the vocals for this! We're all raised on various genres, it's whatever your range can do+damn can she sure do it!!!
@cptheone1 errr ummm ... carrie is the better of the two? Martina one of the best voices of all time? so hang on which one is better? oh and by the way anyone who thinks by mentioning Carrie here or comparing these two's performance to someone elses, is wasting their time ... here to watch these two amazing female singers honor another amazing female singer ... FREAKEN AMAZING PERFOMANCE ...
Martina McBride is the better singer of the two. Kelly "embellishes" too much. Martina sings and doesn't have to do that. Still, it's a beautiful deut.
@seaniebouy well you have to give kelly a break because Martina sings country, kelly's pop, kellys singing way out of her genre,,,they both have good voices. it probably be the other way around if martina was singing pop.
Kelly is definitely sick during this performance. Her voice cracks a bit, and you can tell she braces herself for the climax of the song, but still manages to pull off the note. I admire singers who will sing, sick or not. :)
@Daneyule actually this is what her voice has become. Reguardless of sickness, she no longer has a bright bubbly voice like she did at 19. She's matured. And in this performance, her part was perfect for her voice. both songs in this show she had to perform were perfect for her. not everyone's gonna hit the key notes in a song perfectly everytime they sing it. And sometimes I think she purshes herself beyond her limits. But she still manages to save herself everytime.
reba and martina are my two top fav artists of all time, so to have martina sing a reba song is super awesome! kelly is an amazing singer as well! i just rly rly wish reba and martina would record a duet! there is "On My Own" featuring martina, trisha yearwood and i think one other person. but i'd like one just reba and martina!
Oh how I wish Kelly would do a country album! She is already the best there is, but she would see more success than she could ever possibly imagine!!!
Ahhhhhhh! This is an AMAZING cover! They did such wonderful justice honoring Reba. Both of them have such beautiful tone and they just complement each other so well. I just keep repeating this video!
@kc1rockqueen you are so right. carrie underwood is such a barbie doll wanna be and only sing one genre of music. kelly clarkson, one in many millions of talent.
This duet proves that Kelly Clarkson is a rare talent - I think outsang the great Martina McBride in this duet . Kelly can hit notes that only a few can .
@ashlynswt Whoa! You know Carrie is the best in Country (Out of the American Idol Country singers). Kelly is just became a country singer ; probably because Talented pop singers don't sell much anymore because of the whole auto-tune mess.
@LoboAscuridad As much as i wanna just fist pump you for being real about the auto tune thing.. sadly some country singers use it too. It's not just exclusive to pop singers.
@ashlynswt this is not at you actually, I just could not find the comment button anywhere on here....I just have to put in my two cents to what I have read so far. Kelly gets a bad rap because she was on Idol, and because she is "pop" the genre of music is not important, its the quality of someones voice. she is in the same league as Whitney Houston and Celine Dion...as well as Martina McBride....Kelly will always be remembered for her amazing vocals, not her genre
I of course love the original but I also like this one because martina sounds almost exactly like reba and I love how kelly says " does he love you" at the end of the courus
Kelly and Martina did a stunning job. Kelly can sing any genre of music. She is super talented in every way. Her duet with Jason Aldean "Don't You Wanna Stay" is amazingly great!!!
@Gale1543 That's what Taylor Swift's team say everytime she sings live. This is natural for Kelly. She is not good as a live singer. On CD she sounds great like Taylor does. Carrie, not Kelly if you search on the web, is know to be the best vocalist of any genre. Carrie is known to be pitch perfect at EVERY live show.
Wow, Reba is fabulous and I love her. However, this is the best performance of this song. Even Reba was like....Damn girl! However, why did Martina have to say AM I so stupid at 2:10. You can be country without going to THAT extent. She has the natural twang, no need to embellish more.
@truluvwaited well if you hadnt noticed, when reba or anyone else sings it they sing "AM I" the same way martina did it. she was probably just trying to do it right since shes singing it for reba. :) i thought it was awesome! LOVED IT!
WOW!! Love this! Don't get me wrong, I LOVE Reba, but Reba and Kelly never worked well together.... But this....... Is AMAZING!
TheSexySpork 1 day ago
damn Kelly looks hot
wmdude102086 2 days ago
I'd say she is very proud of her. Check out 3:21 and 3:22... Facial expressions speak louder than words there. :)
clx0388 3 days ago
Reba seems so proud of Kelly
esmercp1973 4 days ago in playlist fancy
My two favorite artists singing together. I'm in heaven, right? Thanks for posting this. I can't believe I never saw this before today.
Anonnamusly 1 week ago
3:02 - 3:22 MY FAVORITE PART! GO KELLY!! :)
jasminblane94 1 week ago
Martina one great singer. Also teenage new comer "Ashley Marie Never Fall" on You Tube.
427dynodon 1 month ago
love it i love this song
lily74149 1 month ago in playlist Liked videos
loves reba's reaction!!!! 3.01
noonethanliu 1 month ago
These two sound so great together. Two extraordinary voices. Martina has sang Kelly's part on this song with Reba before and is just as phenomenal as Kelly is here.
Sam7svu 1 month ago
total eargasm 3:13 - 3:20 WOW KELLY!!!! Even Reba mouthed WOW...
misschristine3451 1 month ago 5
Also....just because your from Texas doesn't mean that you listen to just country...I listen to everything from cher to kiss to Papa roach to Reba to Willie Nelson, and I'm from Texas.
FranFan4Life 1 month ago
Woah Woah Woah....it doesn't matter what genre dude who said Martina is better....now...don't get me wrong...mm is amazing....but Kelly clearly has a stronger voice....and she songs the vocals pretty damn close to the way Linda Davis does....
FranFan4Life 1 month ago
@FranFan4Life Martina can and has sang Linda Davis part on this song with Reba and has done it phenomenally. But as you see Martina is singing Reba's part with Kelly so of course she's not going to try and over sing Kelly, because that's not the part.
Sam7svu 1 month ago
Y'all seem to forget: Kelly is from Texas, so she was raised on this shit. She may be pop or whatever genre you wish to use, but she has the vocals for this! We're all raised on various genres, it's whatever your range can do+damn can she sure do it!!!
CadillacXLRV 1 month ago
I am so totally in love with Kelly Clarkson BUT I am pretty sure she used a blender to style her hair in this performance......
Rheems1 2 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Kelly Clarkson the old and the new is still awesome to watch!! Thumbs up if watching this in 2012 !!!!
shmikeyz69 2 months ago 2
R u kidding me...Carrie is the better singer of the two and its not even close..Martina is another story, she has one of the best voices of all time
cptheone1 2 months ago
Comment removed
shmikeyz69 2 months ago
Comment removed
shmikeyz69 2 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@cptheone1 errr ummm ... carrie is the better of the two? Martina one of the best voices of all time? so hang on which one is better? oh and by the way anyone who thinks by mentioning Carrie here or comparing these two's performance to someone elses, is wasting their time ... here to watch these two amazing female singers honor another amazing female singer ... FREAKEN AMAZING PERFOMANCE ...
shmikeyz69 2 months ago
Martina McBride is the better singer of the two. Kelly "embellishes" too much. Martina sings and doesn't have to do that. Still, it's a beautiful deut.
seaniebouy 2 months ago
@seaniebouy well you have to give kelly a break because Martina sings country, kelly's pop, kellys singing way out of her genre,,,they both have good voices. it probably be the other way around if martina was singing pop.
JessicaGTaylor101 2 months ago
both great talents!!
BigEasyMale 2 months ago
some part of me kinda wonders what this would have been like if it was Trisha Yearwood and Kelly....
wmdude102086 3 months ago
este dueto me recuerda al de Mariah y Whitney!
imaddicted2youkellyc 3 months ago
Kelly is definitely sick during this performance. Her voice cracks a bit, and you can tell she braces herself for the climax of the song, but still manages to pull off the note. I admire singers who will sing, sick or not. :)
Daneyule 3 months ago in playlist Daneyule's favorites 3
@Daneyule actually this is what her voice has become. Reguardless of sickness, she no longer has a bright bubbly voice like she did at 19. She's matured. And in this performance, her part was perfect for her voice. both songs in this show she had to perform were perfect for her. not everyone's gonna hit the key notes in a song perfectly everytime they sing it. And sometimes I think she purshes herself beyond her limits. But she still manages to save herself everytime.
Funnypandalonies 3 months ago
and kelly does sound kind of hoarse. gotta love her!
ebysien 3 months ago 2
I hate to say this but kelly outshined martina like its nobodies business!! damn that girl can sing
zacloverdancer1995 4 months ago 3
Kelly's vocals at 'and I, I have nothing to gain'..... kill me everytime. LOVE.
arielliax 4 months ago
this shows she is the only american idol
whazupsuckafish 4 months ago 2
reba and martina are my two top fav artists of all time, so to have martina sing a reba song is super awesome! kelly is an amazing singer as well! i just rly rly wish reba and martina would record a duet! there is "On My Own" featuring martina, trisha yearwood and i think one other person. but i'd like one just reba and martina!
livingmirror888 5 months ago
Oh how I wish Kelly would do a country album! She is already the best there is, but she would see more success than she could ever possibly imagine!!!
Kattx07 5 months ago
please kelly do some more country, you have an amazing voice for that and so much more
birdysoendergaard 5 months ago
AMAZING. They need to put this on itunes.
cookiemonster8001 6 months ago 19
goosebumps every time I see these ladies performing this song, it's amazing!
12cowwoman 6 months ago 3
what a combanition there voices go toghrter so nicely
ddattrz1225 6 months ago
Lindsey0212 I busted out laughing when I heard that part ahh!!!
chabon3357 7 months ago
Amazing >.< !!
angelcandypoprock 7 months ago
Kelly awesome as ALWAYS!!!!!!!
jorjasara 7 months ago
WOW they have such great harmony!!!
nikki102589 7 months ago
This has got to be my favorite version, two VERY talented ladies here singing tribute to ANOTHER talented lady! :-)
Sam7svu 7 months ago
Wow, it's really hard to do the original of this song justice, but this performance really achieves that! Amazing cover by two amazing singers!
lollypop2414 7 months ago
1:02-1:06 totally sounds like Kelly says "I have his nuts"
lindsey0212 7 months ago 4
speechless....
SommerK12 7 months ago
Amazing! OMG, they are great!
hewellynt 7 months ago
Ahhhhhhh! This is an AMAZING cover! They did such wonderful justice honoring Reba. Both of them have such beautiful tone and they just complement each other so well. I just keep repeating this video!
YoYoRaeRae 8 months ago
duets are great if each complements the other. martina and kelly just did that
dcoffeegirl 8 months ago
Both are great vocalist. Martina does a great job sounding like Reba and of course Kelly is just Kelly and GREAT ! ! !
Engineer245 8 months ago
Reba looks so happy!
SmallTownCityDreams 8 months ago
Martina is beautiful , love her songs
TheHellnextdoor 9 months ago
Wow the song is actually nice, i almost hated it when i heard carrie sing it, it wasn't painful to listen to this time!
TheHellnextdoor 9 months ago
Carrie Underwood sucks and is so annoying. I hate her voice. Kelly has the greatest voice of the generation. Kelly Clarkson is simply amazing!!!
kc1rockqueen 9 months ago
@kc1rockqueen you are so right. carrie underwood is such a barbie doll wanna be and only sing one genre of music. kelly clarkson, one in many millions of talent.
mountainrain100 1 month ago
love the part where reba was laughing where martina and kelly were walking towards each other . love all of them
dcoffeegirl 9 months ago
Kelly Clarkson is the best! Great Vocals! :D
nickr18ful 9 months ago
who cares about carrie underwood? duh. KELLY CLARKSON IS THE BEST! :D
nickr18ful 9 months ago
Does anyone have the recent performance at the Hall of Fame for Reba last night?
kc1rockqueen 9 months ago
I love the way they had Reba laughing... having fun with the song! 2:53 - 3:00
trina19751 9 months ago
I love the way they had Reba laughing... having fun with the song!
trina19751 9 months ago
This duet proves that Kelly Clarkson is a rare talent - I think outsang the great Martina McBride in this duet . Kelly can hit notes that only a few can .
doogleandalix 10 months ago 3
@doogleandalix she had the flashier parts, I think its a waste of time to say anyone outsang anyone here.
Rosannasfriend 3 months ago
@Rosannasfriend Both are superior talents but in this particular duet, I prefer Kelly - to each his own, I guess.
doogleandalix 3 months ago
ha ha Carrie who?
ashlynswt 10 months ago 16
@ashlynswt Whoa! You know Carrie is the best in Country (Out of the American Idol Country singers). Kelly is just became a country singer ; probably because Talented pop singers don't sell much anymore because of the whole auto-tune mess.
LoboAscuridad 2 months ago
@LoboAscuridad Kelly is a MUCH better singer than Carrie. Much more versatile. When Carrie has hit songs in pop and country, come talk to us.
ezelder 2 months ago
@ezelder Yes Kelly is a better singer than Carrie, I know. Forget it.
LoboAscuridad 2 months ago
@LoboAscuridad As much as i wanna just fist pump you for being real about the auto tune thing.. sadly some country singers use it too. It's not just exclusive to pop singers.
gilbertgonzalezjr 2 months ago
@gilbertgonzalezjr What country singers use auto-tune???
I don't think I heard one yet. Or maybe they are using it very sneaky. I don't know.
Tell me who.
LoboAscuridad 2 months ago
Comment removed
shmikeyz69 2 months ago
@ashlynswt this is not at you actually, I just could not find the comment button anywhere on here....I just have to put in my two cents to what I have read so far. Kelly gets a bad rap because she was on Idol, and because she is "pop" the genre of music is not important, its the quality of someones voice. she is in the same league as Whitney Houston and Celine Dion...as well as Martina McBride....Kelly will always be remembered for her amazing vocals, not her genre
shlook77 1 month ago
@ashlynswt Carrie Underwood
RebaFan4Forever 1 month ago
Wow...does it get any better than this???
cherylsalo 10 months ago 2
Love Kelly Clarkson, her dress is pretty too! But i think Her and Reba are definetely better together, instead Martina! :)
MegaSmiley03 10 months ago
Love kelly in this performance she did really good! But i still like Reba better with her.
MegaSmiley03 11 months ago
LOVE LOVE LOVE this version! And i love the look on Reba's face when Kelly hits the high note...classic
cmarko1982 11 months ago
3:14 gives me chills everytime I hear it .
Julesb2183 11 months ago 2
I of course love the original but I also like this one because martina sounds almost exactly like reba and I love how kelly says " does he love you" at the end of the courus
chicha65 11 months ago
LOVE ITTTTTTTTTTT...............
danishaDK 1 year ago
Unbelievable.
blahhduhhx3 1 year ago
Hahaha!
REBA!!!!
clearcrimson 1 year ago
It puts a smile on my face every time they start walking toward each other. Both trying their hardest to stay in character and not smile. Cute. :)
Sam7svu 1 year ago
Martina always stunning & classy! Fantastic duet by these lovely ladies!
Sam7svu 1 year ago
Wow! Kelly C. blows the roof off the place with her mad vocals!
djintheatl 1 year ago 4
Kelly and Martina did a stunning job. Kelly can sing any genre of music. She is super talented in every way. Her duet with Jason Aldean "Don't You Wanna Stay" is amazingly great!!!
MsDottie09 1 year ago 3
do we love Martina and Kelly? Yes...
lthalial 1 year ago 2
I think Kelly was sick during this performance. She sounds very hoarse but she still nailed it! love her!
Gale1543 1 year ago 2
@Gale1543 That's what Taylor Swift's team say everytime she sings live. This is natural for Kelly. She is not good as a live singer. On CD she sounds great like Taylor does. Carrie, not Kelly if you search on the web, is know to be the best vocalist of any genre. Carrie is known to be pitch perfect at EVERY live show.
IdolofCarrie 1 year ago
@IdolofCarrie carrie has had many not so good performances, many artists do
bro0klyn0riginal 1 year ago
@Gale1543 she still sounds good though :p
DontEverGiveUpHope 1 year ago
this was awesome.
mysticangel17 1 year ago
I have the answer to their question: he doesn't love either one of you!!!!
MeredithOD 1 year ago
Wow, Reba is fabulous and I love her. However, this is the best performance of this song. Even Reba was like....Damn girl! However, why did Martina have to say AM I so stupid at 2:10. You can be country without going to THAT extent. She has the natural twang, no need to embellish more.
truluvwaited 1 year ago
@truluvwaited well if you hadnt noticed, when reba or anyone else sings it they sing "AM I" the same way martina did it. she was probably just trying to do it right since shes singing it for reba. :) i thought it was awesome! LOVED IT!
Victoria016 1 year ago
@Victoria016 I agree, I thought it was amazing. Martina is amazing every time!
truluvwaited 1 year ago
@truluvwaited sure is :)
Victoria016 1 year ago
3:12 - 3:20
The BEST!
BleedingxSoul88 1 year ago 69
@BleedingxSoul88 AGREED! (:
DontEverGiveUpHope 1 year ago
Martina & Reba are the two greatest country singers ever :) love them!
Victoria016 1 year ago
Did you see Reba's face? She was like DAMMMMNNNN =]
angiexmarie1 1 year ago 3
@angiexmarie1 She looks so proud!
blahhduhhx3 1 year ago
live...
nikky02000 1 year ago
Good version of this song
georgehavens281 1 year ago
Two great vocalist right there,beautiful performance!
lullabyali 1 year ago 4
i wish kelly would do a country album :( she is so great and omg if her and martina did a duet on it..... ahhhh this is just WOW
KCfan008 1 year ago 4
"WOW" !!! This is some MAJOR singing folks. ABSOLUTLY FANTASTIC!! "WHEW" You want to talk about SIMPLICITY OF EXCELLENCE? Well, here it is.
bwbourn1 1 year ago 3
This is an unbelievable performance!!!
ecwelder09 1 year ago 48
These to do and Absolute Fabulous job on this song...I can listen to them sing it over and over again....Great job....
89FireRescue 1 year ago 6
they both sings the song good and i like how Martina McBride looks like she is mad about it
cjpm1234 1 year ago 7