2005 新秀鍾舒曼2

[rainkwok]

其實我覺得sherman好令 又唱得~

[000231846597]

Stylistic singing but needs a suitable song~

[davicking]

我覺得sherman個人好real, 又靚又好有自己ge style, support!!

[jamelokai]

Sherman個人唔識講野, 又俾Joey壓住, 上年有首"給自己的信"人氣旺咗, 已經好好, 起英皇嘅女歌手要好係難d....

[s045604]

o個時泳兒個名唔系泳兒 叫陳家欣(好刺系)

[koloyao]

總之冇同老細搞搞關係~就唔洗旨意紅~~

[judithmysty]

真係睇得出佢而家係用過功..

有進步!

[1975hk]

3 rd class singer ,may be lower

[hunbabe01]

佢短頭髮令好多.

[MrDylanlau]

難聽到 .......... 牛咁聲

[apple12074]

唱到好似high左野咁=.=

[6wingCkwan]

俾r&b sherman好嗎 eeg!!!

[rainkwok]

sherman好有自己風格.

[Czization]

佢呢首唱得真系好好聽-3-

但系件3怪怪地a0a

[pangmandy2]

泳兒好d啦-,-

[edwincyy]

Sherman 其實唱功好勁, 不過唱腔比較唔同, 台風差佐d=.=" 我覺得佢係一上台就好緊張果D。

泳兒唱功都勁但唔夠Sherman所以第二, &泳兒把聲岩唱流行歌多D, 咬字又清D, 又囉9A ,出道時冇咩新人, SO 泳兒紅D。 係我都會捧泳兒先, 不過我兩個都鍾意! SHERMAN 如果形象(唔好戴nosering)/台風好d 就會紅啦!

[kafkaleung]

老實講.. 同王菲原唱比.. 差九條街....

[manpig0922]

我唔明點解泳兒紅d..

我覺得sherman而家d歌冇得發揮囉!!!

[ilikefarenheit]

@manpig0922 唔夠商業化..食唔到大眾口味

[lowing119]

其實佢唱歌都幾好聽...

不過好似總係紅唔起咁....

[chan2005123]

係囉!明明係佢攞第一名,點解第二既泳兒紅過佢!?

[doraemonbon]

佢唱歌真係ok 嫁!

係差d 運!

[jasline7eo]

sound pollution!!

[killcuteq00]

佢個時個樣同佢ah妹2+個樣好似-3-

[csyfong]

當年係電視睇呢個比賽，我都覺得佢係咁多個參賽者中比較shar­p的...同埋又幾有個性.不過佢呢類唱腔香港人未必會鍾意

將佢同王菲比根本冇意義, 因為兩者既聲底同風格根本唔同. superwoman 呢首歌太多人唱過啦, 唔通個個都要唱到好似王菲咁先叫好?

[MrKeane111]

佢個外型好過泳兒

唱歌特別d

但略欠星味...而且未有代表作

泳兒都無

[szewing1996]

佢隻手做咩

[kib820]

too short.

[leomessifans]

this is hurting my ears.. everybody should listen to faye's version .. just by hitting all the notes doesn't mean it's a good performance

[Aznproz]

there s no way you can compare them both, one is WELL EXPERIENCED and one is just NEW to singing for like 3 , 4 years?? so yea..... there cant be comparisons between them both... xD

[momokorobo]

她现在不比泳儿出名。。。

[3024700]

no, this abused my ears!

[chadthediary]

佢冇樣咩，我覺得佢有喎，不過係唔係咁有星味lor

佢唱歌真係唔錯，希望佢可以成功啦

[color681]

Sherman肯定唔識好似泳兒禁招呼楊生la..如果唔係點解­捧泳兒多過佢..

[tszchun821]

佢把聲係唔錯嫁!!

佢個陣已經好緊張,,把聲唔夠放,,,

你地可以聽下佢而家唱歌!!

真係好左好多!!!!!=]

加油呀!!!shersher!!!

[Strangerimissyou]

其實佢係得嫁

唱腔都幾得

但...唉

同樣問題啦

靚咪紅得起囉

[michelleyuk1989]

sherman唱功真係好好,只不過係太黑,但未至於唔靚ge~

不如諗下英皇點解要捧泳兒先仲好啦~諗下啦~泳兒唔靚得好多咋,­right?

[davidhalifax]

amazing how she has progressed in just a couple years ...

[chanwww111]

唔錯

把鼙有金屬FEEL

[aaaake1]

鍾舒曼唔係冇實力冇樣冇身材

只係差d運氣

如果有1首好歌 1定會好似阿kay咁

跑左出黎左一姐 哈哈

[rorogia]

如果个个唱得好似王菲gam,王菲要收山咯~

痴线~!!

sherman 加油!

[coreyduck]

衣家既鐘舒漫真係好掂~又靚唱得又好~不過可惜丫~出左第3隻碟­都好似唔係好爆出呢咁~ 不過我覺得佢實力係穩固既, wait and see ~

[lanqmui19]

her voice is very soul power.. haha but her version of the song....no me gusta.

[kathyfky0605]

雖然她的聲音不是很棒很出色那種！

這首歌其實要很夠氣！不易唱=.=，加油！

[bape1003]

佢唱得幾好!!幾有特色!! 唱得好聽唔一定要雞仔聲

[koikoi1992]

sammi's one is better, lik of course right? hah but anyway! i think sherman actually did a relatively good rendition of this song already :D

[macaugarlei]

uhh i think she sings better than sammi..

[macaugarlei]

for this song..

[snapywrist]

i trade my wrenchfor your kid.

[michelle7798]

sherman唱得好正*v*

[acb55555]

佢讀緊書?

[nes0726]

what the hell is this?

[shuktuen]

TOO BAD! HOW CAN SHE GOT NO.1...

[waterlo2003]

唱得好。。難聽。。。

[diulasing422]

你食屎啦.....你唔上去唱??

[chubbycheer]

LMAO nice one

[yanyi12]

阿菲唱得有感覺多好多,

佢唱得好誇張...

[KK1213him]

嘩

你不如再拎勁d黎比...

如果佢唱得好過阿菲一早拎晒所以獎啦-0-

唔該唔好用咁高標準黎對一個新人啦...

唔係個個一出就咁勁既

[z18508]

I think she's singing sammi's cover of superwoman

[luvdrama001]

her voice is kinda low...

(in my opinion)

[vicwly]

her movement is kind of awkward( spell check).. but her voice is stronger than most of the female singer in hong kong

[ijoz23]

so STRANGE,,

are she one of the candidate from 2005??

[ctz1993]

如果台風好d就好

郁身郁勢好怪

[Chungchile]

爛有 feel, 但其實唔掂... ...

[sinsing46]

目前为止没听过谁唱王菲这首歌是好听的，除了林忆莲

要挑战王菲，那是找死吧。

[loveerica313]

honestly, it was a bad song choice for her and the arrangement she did was definitely not suitable for this song. i just think this song in particular is too difficult to sing at a competition. if you are gonna sing this song, at least do as well, if not better, as faye. but i must admit, sherman's style is unique. ill give her credit for that.

[rachelRachel1121]

Sherman把聲好型

[rachelRachel1121]

Sherman把聲好型

[heidiloveso]

佢唱歌實在太有實力了~~~

努力呀sherman

[shirleywuwu]

我覺得佢唱得好過原裝版本

[elainelv]

唔係掛。

[macaugarlei]

loL so funny

[rorogia]

太好听了~~好听过泳儿~~

sherman的声音很独特....够爆发力!!

泳儿用假声多过真声音唱~~

sherman加油~~

[shirleywuwu]

我都覺=]

呢d聲底好難搵

可能joey都唔夠佢咁厚

佢又未學過唱歌..

有呢種聲..

而家好多歌手都唱唔出呢種power出黎

[guwamu]

I THINK SO TOO.

[him118]

衰在個頭大

[sharpv903sh]

但係胸大

[noraacmw]

lol...be nice...she is nervous

[tse2546]

but i think it is good indeed!

[your6rannie]

what's the name of this song?

[sweetogal]

==""...err..I dun get how Vincy lost to her. I heard her go off a couple of times, and she sang like really low; so doesn't really bring out the challenge of this song.

[luisme719]

singing low doesnt mean is bad.... Everyone has their best key on certain songs.

Music = comfortable to listen

I think it is a better attitude to complete the song with 100% self-assurance than to raise a key or 2 to bet on yourself that it might sound better if you hit that one or two high notes. Its all for the goods of the audiences.

[sweetogal]

Yea, i know. I didn't say singing low is bad. Everyone has different style.

But I felt that like..it won't better to sing in the actual range for a singing contest;; to actual show the judges your skill and stuff? And the song doesn't sound as good low.

[luisme719]

depends~

Like... if i song such as one night in beijing... you have to sing in falsetto if you use your real voice... you wont much point... but thats pretty mucht the only exception

[luisme719]

but i do agree with you... Vincy was better at the final....

[alexalysaa]

indeed her sky is similar to the orginal version superman.....

[sharpv903sh]

D CUP...

[borisdmhk]

D cup

[wongyion2001]

王菲的歌一樣都難唱..見參賽者都唱得很辛苦

[KFH69]

she's got such a bad voice

and she tries so hard to sing like christina

which she obviously cant

so

screw her

[egmled]

she is beautiful!!!

[sinsing46]

Actually this was the FAYE WONG Classic Canto song, ai...I think no body can sing this song well among the chinese artist nowsaday, even Sandy lam & Sammi Cheng last time sang this song, but sounds weird, the Sammi cheng version was the worse...

[taipeisnow]

uh i think this key is guy 's key so she sounded low and unclear. its gary tsao's superwomen.

[anncookies]

singer*

[anncookies]

both vincy and sherman are good singers. whats special about sherman was that she has her own unique style of singing..something different from a lot of sings and i think thats what scored her a lot of point during the contest. it might be because her own unique style appealed to the judges then. anyway..i respect people's opinions though..everyone prefers something different

[cha0s19]

from this performance, i seriously dont think she is better than vincy

[chocolatechipyz]

Wow! i can't believe she won ! I thought that Vincy would win for sure ! Vincy sings so much better than Sherman ! Her ( Sherman ) voice isn't that clear and i dun like her singing style

[hihidomdom]

i think she is good wor

[ZeroZeta]

she sings very poorly... and she actually won? =_=

[Koringkas]

honestly....no good~!....maybe she should not choose this difficult faye's song...

[spikelau]

好過好多而家既歌星, 起碼識得用真聲上高音

夠厚, 我一d 都唔覺得難聽喎..

咪帶偏見睇人啦...

[gundaman02]

Agree

[siumini]

佢把聲一D都唔好聽

[yncy323]

champion?!

[sammikoo]

she is tooooo nervous, too artificial lah

[julyoften]

泳兒唱duck好聼D

*but i know she is improving now

[ybsin]

如果係朋友, 我會話佢唱得好, 但如果係歌星, 我就唔想打開電視見到佢.

[KARY031116]

佢D唱法..似X-TINA BOR..=.=

[gymnastics2006]

yes, but more people accept britney singing more

[bethni]

i think shes getting better..

but i dont like the way she sings as the notes go higher

[alterna816]

was she the winner of the sun sau contest?

[BarleyTea1]

Yes, she was.

[Kidder15dude]

omg her voice from then compare to now... she is way better

[life1992]

Its alright. Though thats not how Sammi Cheng sang it.

[ChibiZaku]

shes ugly and cant sing sawlee to say =/

[jennisterrrs]

hmm. kinda sound like kay tse. :x

i think she's okay, though.

[mwongmwong]

Forgive her, she is improving.

[fqtva7h]

1:33 - 40 . So exgagerate. Can sing, but it is annoying.

[ss1cl]

Her voice is so deep

[ss1cl]

Her voice is so low.

[EvaxTvxQ]

ew she sucks.

[zhousilai]

she so ugly

[aznballerfoshow]

she kinda sucks.

[wallacefung]

佢d動作真係好核突